Youre acting like youre better than me, when we both had no clue, but I at least brought it up at some point. Thats all Im saying.
I'm not even trying to say that any one person is responsible for what happened.
I am saying, that shutting down discussions about what is possible in WW because "that's not possible," besides it literally just not even being how I've ever really enjoyed this game, well it's about more than what I enjoy. It's valid game strategy to consider all the angles.
And putting it all together, we've made progress. We think there are two wolves and we should look for w/w interactions even now. AM's point that an original and a convert would be OP is valid, except that village mechanics is one way that gets balanced. So now we even have an idea for when we would look for a convert, as she says, if we have a no kill night, looking for clues in the write ups, and also if the village looks OP itself as we learn about this game set up. If it feels like analyzing like we're dealing with a two person pack is leading to dead ends.
And fighting about this stuff is instructive.
I noted last game that Shorty was very active and present *except* in these types of discussions.
Wolves have to be very careful how they engage in mechanics convos meant to be hunting them down. Many get bored, or don't want to help, or leak signs of TMI, or actively try to shut down the convo, or try to steer things in weird directions.