- Joined
- Jan 23, 2016
- Messages
- 34,402
- Reaction score
- 42,141
Unlynch Jil
Lynch Kara
I don't know what to think anymore.
Lynch Kara
I don't know what to think anymore.
Another tie? If ny goes and is a wolf, that should still give villagers another day, right? I really do feel like the one basics game where dvmd totally set me up to be lynched and wolves won. If AM is a wolf, she played a really good game imo, but from our pm, I suspect her slightly less. Good luck villagers. LIS has got to go next.
unlynch jil, lynch nyanko
Unlynch Jil
Lynch Kara
I don't know what to think anymore.
I'd rather do a 3-way and increase the chances of snagging a wolf tbh.
Don't you sass me. I will delete the roster and make you read it.So who were the wolves. Way too much of a tl;dr without any red names to indicate who was wolf easily.
Don't you sass me. I will delete the roster and make you read it.
Grumble.@WildZoo I was telling the truth when I said shelter didn't have any tutelage from me. I pretty much left her to the villagers and let her do the rest. I did think it was funny we both ended up wolves after she had just shadowed me
Gonna enjoy bringing up this game when people **** talk me trying to lynch quiet players next time, lol.
Idk, that would have led to MJ and filly lynches too Think it was partly our fault though (maybe not yours, you been dead awhile, but village in general). Focused so much on the groups where wolves were killing, it was very easy for ny and kara to just kind of float along while we killed off all the original Descartes peeps and then went after the ones on Hatari.Gonna enjoy bringing up this game when people **** talk me trying to lynch quiet players next time, lol.
Oooo..... it was Devyn that played that tear-jerking "you're such a mean bastard" move on me, not Kaydubs. I think. I didn't fall for it, but she sure made me feel like crap. I felt like she was a little over the line, but.... it's WW.... the line is mobile.
And by me lynch you... you mean you lynch me, right?But you didn't try to lynch quiet players... you tried to lynch me...
Idk, that would have led to MJ and filly lynches too Think it was partly our fault though (maybe not yours, you been dead awhile, but village in general). Focused so much on the groups where wolves were killing, it was very easy for ny and kara to just kind of float along while we killed off all the original Descartes peeps and then went after the ones on Hatari.
And by me lynch you... you mean you lynch me, right?
I literally didn't lynch you lol. I mentioned you were sketching me out, actually went and looked at past games to figure out why, and then was dead by the time I saw you'd turned around and lynched me for it.I was just returning the favor.
Oh so it's all @SummerTheLynx's fault? As usualNot using the gate keeper really hurt village this game. They needed to spread out and when someone most people had issues with was on a planet not with a power villager, that power should have been offered up for the GateKeeper to use for a night. I purposefully built in not knowing if the Gate Keeper was village, but based on how everyone's abilities were used, it would likely have been easy enough to figure out.
Key is still to use posts and votes though to find wolves. I felt like people were really lax here in not making Jil accountable for her votes and timing. There didn't seem to be much questioning in general and making people give thoughts on who they thought was wolfy and why. Too much on trying to find easy ways out by what being they were and mechanics. I purposefully only had a single seer that was affiliation and even used alternating with other powers to make people play a traditional game still in wolf hunting.
Gonna enjoy bringing up this game when people **** talk me trying to lynch quiet players next time, lol.
Not using the gate keeper really hurt village this game. They needed to spread out and when someone most people had issues with was on a planet not with a power villager, that power should have been offered up for the GateKeeper to use for a night. I purposefully built in not knowing if the Gate Keeper was village, but based on how everyone's abilities were used, it would likely have been easy enough to figure out.
Key is still to use posts and votes though to find wolves. I felt like people were really lax here in not making Jil accountable for her votes and timing. There didn't seem to be much questioning in general and making people give thoughts on who they thought was wolfy and why. Too much on trying to find easy ways out by what being they were and mechanics. I purposefully only had a single seer that was affiliation and even used alternating with other powers to make people play a traditional game still in wolf hunting.
He was so remarkably close as usual for all the wrong reasons, then he died and you all marched into the sea. lolOh so it's all @SummerTheLynx's fault? As usual
He was so remarkably close as usual for all the wrong reasons, then he died and you all marched into the sea. lol
yeah, no cigars had this go round. Very lucky even that shelter barely got lynched. hahaUnfortunately, 'close' doesn't help when it means you're still lynching villagers.
That, and I just think they're a hell of a lot less fun than people who actually engage. And @Filly Bay knows I mean that with the most love possible, lol.I'm sorta kinda with you.
I think our reasons are different (but I'm not really sure?), but I feel like quiet players are just ... a risk.
First off, there's no real good way to assess them (aside from seering, but people WAY over-value seering).
Second off, even if they are villagers they aren't contributing aside from being a number, so if you DO have some reason to think they're a wolf, lynching them and being wrong costs incrementally less than going after someone very active who turns out to be a villager.
I mean, in the end, I think you go after the people you really think are wolves - regardless of 'quiet' - but ... I'm kinda with ya about giving a little more "wolf" weight to people who are quiet. Not trying to put words in your mouth, though; that may not be how you mean it.
Except Nyanko and STL. They should always be lynched mid-game. Always. Said it before, and I'll keep preaching it. Always always always make sure they don't survive to end game. DocE, too.
Well I marched into my own personal hell of confusion and paranoia, still managed to get to the right conclusion but was so unsure of everything that I definitely didn't push it hard enough lolHe was so remarkably close as usual for all the wrong reasons, then he died and you all marched into the sea. lol
That, and I just think they're a hell of a lot less fun than people who actually engage. And @Filly Bay knows I mean that with the most love possible, lol.
And of course I lynch people I think are wolves... but if I'm really not feeling anyone in particular, our players who just sit back and minimally engage are always fair game.