- Joined
- Oct 22, 2013
- Messages
- 25,469
- Reaction score
- 39,669
when were the no kill night(s) again?
Because at this point Mel is just enjoying throwing things onto the thread and not even making an attempt to explain themwhy AM?
Are you saying any actions against AM would have gone to someone else? Do you know who?So it looks like N2 was a no kill night. That night I know that drinks were being handed out by someone. I know that someone took AM's place. I don't know how to connect those things for you people in a meaningful way, but there's the facts of N2.
@Crayola227 i guess it doesn't matter to who but if actions against AM were redirected that night are you saying she can't be the convert if it happened n2?Are you saying any actions against AM would have gone to someone else? Do you know who?
Are you saying any actions against AM would have gone to someone else? Do you know who?
@Crayola227 i guess it doesn't matter to who but if actions against AM were redirected that night are you saying she can't be the convert if it happened n2?
Last I checked you didn't want genny lynched so idk why you are all about her and moose being lynched now.
I'm going off of posts and I will not be voting for genny. There is still a hole in this theory that she is a wolf, and it is that SAR was upgraded to be a jailer and blocker, and if the other bouncer got a similar upgrade then genny shouldn't be condemned here. It's interesting that Coop trusts this information so much, given that we still are missing a variable, and that PMing with genny did not make Coop think she was wolfy.
I will say tart has been throwing up red flags, because he voted to lynch genny yesterday with an attitude that read "oh, everyone else is lynching genny? That's what I'll do then" and tried to chalk it up to being a "grudge" that he has for her, which imo could have been something to play around with on D1, not D3. I don't like how he tries to play off the seriousness of his voting for genny, because it makes it seem like if genny did flip village, he could claim that it was just a joke vote, and not be expected to give reason or be held accountable beyond that. Village votes village all the time, but the lack of willingness to put his name on a vote, and give real reasons behind it sketches me out.
Coop is one of the other people I could vote for today actually. I find it odd to not have feels or concrete evidence on someone, and vote there anyway. What are your thoughts on Lawper?
um, sketchy timing BJ, gotta say
You can think of it this way, SAR was next on the chopping block after Moose and genny, and if I didn't want to vote for either of them then what makes the most sense?
I can't recall if the way this unfolded that your vote for SAR was in a good direction or not... namely away from tie or Moose or Genny....
We keep blaming genny and moose for where the bandwagon went yesterday, what about BJ and other late voters/switchers??
Although at this point that could be academic. The runaway train mislynch of yet another villager in a village like ours (I don't just mean this game) is hardly unusual for this bunch.
I'm a fan of bandwagon voting as both villager and wolf, and even I've been just plain shocked at the trains lately. It's frankly more disgusting than most porn I watch and that's really saying something.
But these aren't the same thing, you calling me out for switching, and saying that I was trying to shade those who were switching is two completely different things.
I went through my own posts looking for me calling out those involved in SAR's lynch, and I didn't find squat. Let me know if you do
***********~~~~~~~~
Pips is MIA and I did my first ever write-up
♪ Alllllll by myyyyseeeeeeeeeelf ♪
~~~~~~~~
~~~~~~~~
Pips is MIA and I did my first ever write-up
♪ Alllllll by myyyyseeeeeeeeeelf ♪
~~~~~~~~
I hadn't even considered the implications like that, Paws.
This is why sometimes it seems like I'm not doing amazing wolf hunting and I'm vague. I'm an ideas person. I can put out my thoughts on players and strategy and hope that others can put it together to good use.
I need to iso you, moose, and yk, and decide if I think any of you are wolfy. If I decide i think you are, I will let the thread knowI'd like to see why Paws and BJ are leaning wolf on me now.
**********************
Lol go wolves (I can't root for village after that lynch 😛 but no hard feelings ok?)
************
Still feeling Mel today?Except I'm pretty sure he quoted the wrong lyrics on purpose plus his explanations to me and Bryn only scream trolling.... I'm staying on mel and will stay on him until he's lynched.
@tartesos I don't see where you answered this. Are you still feeling coffee or sporty?do you think there is more than 1 original left and if so who are you looking at?
Oh and FYI moose I'm not sure if you were trying to prevent a kill by vanillaized me but a wolf with this much sketch wouldn't be doing the killing. If they're not alone that is. If not, all you did was stop a potential block of another night kill.
Sorry, did what I thought was necessary.
I understand that, I'm just saying that if she had any protective powers or any special ability, she can't use them.
Then votes for cray and stays there all night, even while fighting with tart and Mel.So I've kinda been half-assing this game. This is the first game where I haven't done a spreadsheet so bear with (Some people are grouped where they are based on feels).
Leaning village group
AM - seems villagery but does seem a bit quiet this game. She has been tunneling Coop which is like her so I'm leaning village on her.
Kara - I agree with most of her analyses and her play seems like she's village. She's not as "in the game" as when she's wolfing.
Coffee? - idk how Mel has her confirmed chaos, but if she's not chaos, then I think she's village. I feel the info she shared wasn't necessarily crucial but it lined up with my power at least (and seemingly a few others' powers).
Mixy - based on PMs and the mason clear, I would say village however I do agree with Mel that it is highly possible that she can be a convert.
Coop - idk, I don't believe coop is a wolf because of how much she put herself in the spotlight the past few days with the genny stuff. I'm just going based off of feels here though.
Unsure Group
Mel - so, I really like Mel's above analysis as I can agree with most of it (I'm not a convert btw) but I've been getting sketch feels from him for most of the game soooo, I'm still unsure.
Paws - she seems village but I've never played a game where she was a wolf and I'm wary of her.
Bryndi - she's engaging conversation and I like it but I don't necessarily like her voting pattern or strategy (voting late in the game).
Allie - I can never get a good read on allie and I haven't seen a lot of her tbh
LOTF - I can't really follow her logic in games so I'm always wary/paranoid of her
Sporty - Sporty is being awfully quiet which was exactly how she cruised under the radar and ended up winning the bake game. I know she was village and was rezzed but we're not 100% sure if she came back village.
Lawpy - I don't even know what's going on with you. I know you've been ill but you're leaning more wolfy for me.
Wolf Group
Cray - she's been posting mostly fluff and hasn't really contributed much to the actual game versus theory from mafia as a whole.
YK - she's been sketch this whole freaking game and I really dislike her voting patterns and timing!
Tarty - lot of fluff posts, acting like he's a noob, others saying he's a veteran, overall, I'm confused and he's gotta go soon.
For now, I'm gonna
Lynch Cray
However, I would be willing to switch to tarty or YK as well. Sorry AM, I'm not really seeing Coop. I get the lynch would probably give us some info but she's currently vanillized for the cycle including into the night.
She could have easily swayed it to tarty (who she also has on her wolf list) but instead sits on cray alone.CHECK YO VOTES for reasons
DAY 5 Official ~ End of the Night It's Goin Down ~ Lynch Tally
Coop (4) - Lawper, AM, Paws, Coffeebean
Mel (3) - Mixalot, Sporty, Cray
Cray (1) - MOOSE
Tarty (3) - yk, kara, Bryndi
Coffee? (3) - Mel, allie, tarty
14/16 voting
Tarty, you're in the lead
~the bigger they are the harder they fall~
Lynch closed
~you better move, you better dance~
@MixedAnimals77 I didn't see your contingency vote on Mel until I made the tally.Still feeling Mel today?
Where do you think you'd vote next?Meh. I'm gonna stick with my
lynch Mel
Pretty sure I've heard him lynch villagers in the past on the policy of them being unhelpful at best and a wolf at worst, and that's precisely where he's at.
I don't feel super well today so I'm probably going to be sparser than usual.
This was from BJ to Mel.
This is where my eyebrow was raised, because you are accusing Mel of not being consistent if I read right, and in this above quote to whom I don't know now that I am typing this post, you are calling someone out for voting without feels or evidence, and in the other quote above, you're criticizing Tarty's haph hazard voting. To which I say:
about the SAR vote switch you did.
My point was that you where shading people for what you see as crappy voting after you switched votes with < 15 min to close, without saying why at the time (IIRC) or really explaining later until i asked (IIRC).
I'm trying to point out that by your own words your behavior was sketchy. Then your response:
Which I didn't really find that satisfying, but that's OK. Not everyone is satisfied when I give my reasons.
Here I'm just saying that if we are going to examine some players for last min vote switching and little reasoning, we should probably examine them all.
Possibly in your comments about people's votes and genny and moose, I got mixed up if you were trying to shade people for the SAR lynch or not specifically. But you ARE shading people for certain voting behaviors. See above.
Maybe I'm mixed up that the people you were criticizing their votes, didn't have much to do with the SAR lynch. I can't ****ing recall. The point of my whole exercise here is that you are calling out people for things you yourself did.
That's not a sure fire sign of lycanthropy, that's not my point. I feel like you're acting like nothing about what you did was shady, and you're calling people out for sketchy stuff you yourself did.
Unless I goofed, these are in order.
I have had problems with Tart's voting for days, so if there was someone I was getting after on that day it was him. I know that I called him out on it after lynch close on the SAR lynch day, and voted for him the next day. I have not, however, thrown shade for last minute switches. This is the last time I will say this, I have only gone after tart and mel in terms of how they have been voting, and what I mean by that is they did not give any reasons, or their reasons (tart) were "oh everyone is voting genny now? okay let's do it". I am not going to keep repeating myself on this. If you don't like how I changed my vote for SAR last minute then fine, but try and see if there is something else that's bothering you about me, because I'm not beating this dead horse anymore.So let me ask again, the criticisms you were making about people voting when genny and Moose were top contenders, was that the SAR lynch? I took that you were criticizing those players as throwing shade on them for shady vote practices like last min vote switching for little reason, to which I pointed out what you did. You weren't just criticizing their voting practices as a matter of proper villager conduct, you were saying you could vote them. Saying that you will vote someone and not specifying a reason other than lycanthropy (yes, there are other reasons), prima facie means you think they are a wolf unless otherwise stated, in my book.
My interpretation of all this could be wrong, but the point that you were criticizing certain voting behaviors and then also did the same, stands. It could be a villager mistake.
What is not a villager mistake, is acting like I'm not trying to articulate this clearly or that I'm just shading you without attempting to make a cogent argument.
Coop was the village's top lynch choice for next time so I did what I thought was best for the village. If coop had turned out to be a wolf there may have been a secret PR we didn't know about and I thought it was best. I didn't agree that coop was a wolf but I felt that enough people who were in my village pile did think she was a wolf.What do people think about moose vanilla-zing coop? I know we weren't sure about coop, but we did know she was a blocker...
Then moose goes on to say how she doesn't even think coop is a wolf (see bold below)
Then votes for cray and stays there all night, even while fighting with tart and Mel.
She could have easily swayed it to tarty (who she also has on her wolf list) but instead sits on cray alone.
Lynch moose
Unless someone can explain to me why she isn't wolfy. I really think this is a wolf sitting on an easy non lunch to avoid voting for any of the winners. She must have felt pretty damn comfortable that a villager was going to go down without her help...
What?Coop was the village's top lynch choice for next time so I did what I thought was best for the village. If coop had turned out to be a wolf there may have been a secret PR we didn't know about and I thought it was best. I didn't agree that coop was a wolf but I felt that enough people who were in my village pile did think she was a wolf.
I think Cray is a wolf so I voted there!
I agree with coffee? that people weren't going to move on from coop until she was lynched. I disagree with that, hence why I didn't vote for coop. I don't know about tarty and while I do have him on my wolf list, I feel stronger about Cray.
So how about you place a vote instead of waiting until the end of the day?Coop was the village's top lynch choice for next time so I did what I thought was best for the village. If coop had turned out to be a wolf there may have been a secret PR we didn't know about and I thought it was best. I didn't agree that coop was a wolf but I felt that enough people who were in my village pile did think she was a wolf.
I think Cray is a wolf so I voted there!
I agree with coffee? that people weren't going to move on from coop until she was lynched. I disagree with that, hence why I didn't vote for coop. I don't know about tarty and while I do have him on my wolf list, I feel stronger about Cray.
I disagree with people not moving on until lynch hence why I didn't vote for coop. But I don't hold it against coffee for her voting for coop because certain people (*cough* AM *cough*) weren't going to move on and actually contribute to the game until coop was lynched.What?
Sorry, got sidetracked with that post and forgot toSo how about you place a vote instead of waiting until the end of the day?
Also, if cray flips village, Mel will be next on my list because, now that I think about it, he might have been a good choice for a convert.So how about you place a vote instead of waiting until the end of the day?
How many originals do you think we started with? So far we've only caught one wolf so you are definitely hunting converts a little early perhaps...Also, if cray flips village, Mel will be next on my list because, now that I think about it, he might have been a good choice for a convert.
Day 1 Lynch Tally
LoTF (1) - SAR
AM (1) - dolphin
Cray (2) - Bryndi, yk
cheezit () -
lawp (1) - coop
coop () -
karabou (1) - LoTF
allie () -
kal (2) - MOOSE, Paws
Dubz () -
Sporty (1) - DVMD
DVMD (1) - Sporty
capri (6) - Mel, AM, coffeebean, genny, dubz, lawper
Coffee (3) - allie, Mixy, cray
Tarty () -
SAR (1) - Kara
20/22 votes
Missing: tarty, capri
Day 2 Lynch Tally
Mel (1) - DVMD
craycray (2) - Tarty, MOOSE
SAR (1) - genny
Coop (1) - AM
Dubz (9) - Dolphin, lawper, Mixy, Mel, coffeebean, LotF, Kara, allieh, bryndi
Moose (3) - SAR, WZ, Coop
Coffeebean () -
YK (1) - Paws
Mixy () -
Paws (1) - YK
19/20 voting
Missing: Cray
Day 3 Lynch Tally
DVMD (1) - allie
Paws (1) - Kara
Moose (5) - Lawper, Mel, SAR, Cray, Coffee?
allie (1) - LoTF
coffee () -
Coop (1) - AM
SAR (5) - genny, MOOSE, Mixy, dolphin, bryndy
Mel () -
genny (4) - Coop, Paws, tarty, Sporty
tarty (1) - YK
19/20 voting
Missing: DVMD
Day 4 Lynch Tally
Coop (1) - AM
genny (6) - coffee, mixy, skimble/dvmd, LoTF, tarty, yk
Paws (1) - Kara
Tarty (1) - bryndi
Moose (1) - cray
Yk (4) - coop, allie, MOOSE, genny
Coffee (4) - dolphin, mel, lawpy, Paws
bryndi (1) - Sporty
19/19 voting
Day 5 Lynch Tally
Coop (4) - Lawper, AM, Paws, Coffee?
Mel (3) - Mixalot, Sporty, Cray
Cray (1) - MOOSE
Tarty (3) - yk, kara, Bryndi
Coffee? (3) - Mel, allie, tarty
14/16 voting
Missing: Coop, LOTF
I'm merely saying it in reference to Mel's read list where he lists his top 3 convert choices. That makes me think he could POTENTIALLY be one.How many originals do you think we started with? So far we've only caught one wolf so you are definitely hunting converts a little early perhaps...
@tartesos I don't see where you answered this. Are you still feeling coffee or sporty?
What are your thoughts on moose?
*********************
I think I deserve royalties every time my name comes up because holy wow
************
@tartesos I don't see where you answered this. Are you still feeling coffee or sporty?
What are your thoughts on moose?