- Joined
- Mar 14, 2019
- Messages
- 8,428
- Reaction score
- 9,788
Everything you say is true. Selfish to me is building a 200 person WL to maybe pull 20 or 30 people from, if that, without letting any of the people know where they stand unless and until they receive a call. Adcoms can and do do it, solely for their convenience, because they want to have maximum flexibility when the time comes.I am not sure if selfish is the right word here especially since there are no less comfortable alternatives that could help applicants feel better but still not have major issues with recruiting students to form a class before the start of an academic year.
Adcoms members are humans as well and they have limited resources (time for example). They can't make offer to let's say 100 people for 100 spots and wait and see how many declines and start interviewing again. They might really not be able to fill their class and the while process will be a lot more protracted (and applicants will suffer more). To call then selfish means there should be another option that inconveniences them but still gives you a reasonably similar results and I say there are none other than what they are currently doing.
I get it, and don't blame them, but it's not really necessary. They do it because they can. And people with good options don't typically allow themselves to be placed in limbo and used in that way, so, at the end of the day, it's people with no better options being jerked around by people who do it because they can.
UCF does it the right way, with total transparency. Everyone knows exactly where they stand, even the 100 or so people in the bottom third who are there if UCF needs them, even though UCF knows beyond a reasonable doubt that they won't. There is no reason all schools cannot be so transparent, other than they don't have to and it would be more work for them.
Last edited: