Howdie (aka the GOAT MS1) here
This is somewhat of a controversial topic since you could ask 25 students and get 25 different responses, but I’ll go ahead and give opinion on the subject.
If you’re wanting to match into something competitive like surgery, the campus you attend is not going to make as big of a difference as you think it will. Your step 2 score is going to be the most important factor, followed by 3rd year core rotation grades (shelfs/evals), and LoRs. At least this is what I’ve been gathering through discourse w/ upperclassmen and my own personal research.
Each campus has its pros and cons. UMC is notorious for having the most difficult evals, and this will greatly impact your third year scores. This is the biggest gripe I’ve heard from nearly every single upperclassmen that has rotated through here. On the flip side, staying at UMC will allow to keep relationships formed during the first two years of school. To wit, I’ll be starting research in a couple weeks, but I’ll be unable to continue my research longitudinally as I’m moving to Amarillo for clinicals. I’ll add that I have several friends pursuing ortho who have already formed great relationships with attendings/residents here and are already cranking out pubs. Given that most of them are staying at UMC for clinicals, this could open opportunities for potential LoRs in the future. Food for thought.
Regarding Amarillo, they are opening up a surgery residency this year. I don’t know how many residents there will be and how it’ll impact “first assist” opportunities, but I want to put it out there. There will still be more one-on-one time with attendings as there are significantly less residents in Amarillo. Ditto for Odessa.
Regarding covenant? Not a clue, it’s popular though. I’ve only heard good things from students who rotate there, and they’re typically pretty happy (or as happy as an MS3 can be).
You are ultimately the deciding factor regarding what specialty you match into. You dictate your personality and test scores, so, shine wherever you end up. I’ll say this, if you are dead set on surgery, I think UMC would be an overall net positive. I think the diversity of cases you get here would allow you to see several different sub specialties w/ in surgery and give you an idea of what you’d like to explore. The burn unit here is very, very good and students who have no interest in surgery very much enjoy rotating through there.
4th year is where you do your electives and sub-Is which you can do at any campus. So, in reality, your 5 weeks of surgery (+1 week of shelf study) likely won’t make a huge dent in your academic curiosity, if that makes sense. Amarillo, Covenant, and Odessa will still give you excellent educational experiences.
My initial campus rankings were 1) UMC 2) Covenant 3) Amarillo 4) Odessa
Knowing what I know now, my rankings would be 1) Amarillo 2) Covenant 3) UMC 4) Odessa
For context I am considering anesthesia, IM, or pathology. So for me, I want to make 3rd year as easy as possible and I’m confident Amarillo is the best place for me (also the food is sooooooooooo much better there).
I hope this gives you some insight!
Edit: After reading replies above, ig it’s not that controversial. Lmao
Also hi wysdoc! Hope all is well 😀