CHOOSE YOUR OWWN III - Game Thread

[Animal Midwife]

---

Members do not see this ad.

Day 2 Yeet Tally
genny (1) - dubz
Lumi (1) - True
True (2) - alley, Zenge

4/11
yeet close in ~24 hours

 

[holdthemayo]

I know wolf genny is different than village genny.

Why?

Why do you know it or why am I right?

 

[WildZoo]

Why do you know it or why am I right?

Why do you think I'm barking up the wrong tree?

 

[Zenge142]

You may be right, but it felt like I was being called out when I was pretty clear that I was struggling to catch up.

Sorry. Wasn’t meant as a call out. Just noting that I couldn’t move Stagg’s/Your slot out of the POE without seeing more.

@Zenge142 do you remember which games your nooblet played besides the noob game?

Hopefully because the nooblet doesn't 🙃

BoWWling and Globe TroWWtting

 

[holdthemayo]

Why do you think I'm barking up the wrong tree?

I learned to wolf from Genny and sporty. You probably modded those games.

 

[WildZoo]

I learned to wolf from Genny and sporty. You probably modded those games.

You're gonna have to spell it out for me a bit more. Help me see what you're seeing.

 

[WildZoo]

Okay quickly looked through Woxy's posts. I'm uncomfortable with the narrow focus tbh. Not much mention of anyone outside of chaos and Lumi so far. Even in BoWWling, where that early modkill happened, there was more broad engagement prior to that point.

Could be first time scum latching onto the obvious targets and struggling to fake reads on the rest of the roster.

 

[WorthlessOxygen]

Okay quickly looked through Woxy's posts. I'm uncomfortable with the narrow focus tbh. Not much mention of anyone outside of chaos and Lumi so far. Even in BoWWling, where that early modkill happened, there was more broad engagement prior to that point.

Could be first time scum latching onto the obvious targets and struggling to fake reads on the rest of the roster.

We had two people caught in lies on D1, I think it's reasonable to be pretty focused on yeeting at least one of them

 

[WildZoo]

We had two people caught in lies on D1, I think it's reasonable to be pretty focused on yeeting at least one of them

Sure. That doesn't mean the other players in the game cease to exist. We certainly don't only have two scum.

 

[alleycat03]

@WildZoo what’s up with the profile pic change?

 

[WildZoo]

@WildZoo what’s up with the profile pic change?

I found it while looking through BoWWling and about died laughing. I was going to put it in my signature but I like my ermine gif too much to replace it.

 

[WonderingStudent]

~Trying to give something but also recognize I am still catching up currently at page 17 ~

Most likely already mentioned but as it is majority (11 players) => do not get close to six voting one player until we are ready to end the day.

 

[WonderingStudent]

Not great but I'd rather flip lumi first

probably a moot point now but why did you rather a lumi flip before chaos

 

[WonderingStudent]

What if it turns out Wonder is scum and used the goo card for the ability

Definitely a possibility but would only be beneficial to a wincon if I got another cult card for affiliation. Target me and let me know D3 if you’re cult 😉

Interesting, wolf black goo would actually be a fun ability. Insurance against seers/trackers outting you through mutually assured destruction.

Shucks that would have been fun

Edit to specify in the first line “another” cult card for aff

 

[WonderingStudent]

Spoiler: Freyr asking for food and for these game thread pages to get shorter

Freyr asking for food and for these game thread pages to get shorter

 

[WorthlessOxygen]

probably a moot point now but why did you rather a lumi flip before chaos

At the time I was on board with the theory that chaos could be left for a potential vig. You'll read the point where I question that whole process and ultimately disagree with it.

 

[WorthlessOxygen]

Sure. That doesn't mean the other players in the game cease to exist. We certainly don't only have two scum.

I'll admit that I'm probably hyper focusing on those 2-3 players but I think it's understandable given that one already flipped wolf and my concerns about lumi haven't been addressed yet

 

[WildZoo]

I'll admit that I'm probably hyper focusing on those 2-3 players but I think it's understandable given that one already flipped wolf and my concerns about lumi haven't been addressed yet

Well, Lumi hasn't been here, and unlike a normal game where you might have to see if Lumi flips scum to decide on other people, Lumi's affiliation doesn't have much to do with anyone else's here. Even disregarding that, I don't think sitting back and waiting for the person you're voting for to flip without talking about anyone else is really in character for you

 

[genny]

I’m just a little disappointed that no one is claiming any vig shots. I was hoping for more drama I guess.

 

[WorthlessOxygen]

Well, Lumi hasn't been here, and unlike a normal game where you might have to see if Lumi flips scum to decide on other people, Lumi's affiliation doesn't have much to do with anyone else's here.

I didn't follow through with voting Lumi last night precisely because they haven't been around. Their affiliation not having much to do with anyone else is part of why I'm still interested in flipping them as I would normally be looking elsewhere after Chaos' flip.

Even disregarding that, I don't think sitting back and waiting for the person you're voting for to flip without talking about anyone else is really in character for you

Hmm I don't think I can objectively evaluate this. I'd like to know what @Zenge142 and @Truenamer think given that I've played with them a couple times

 

[WildZoo]

I didn't follow through with voting Lumi last night precisely because they haven't been around. Their affiliation not having much to do with anyone else is part of why I'm still interested in flipping them as I would normally be looking elsewhere after Chaos' flip.

Are you planning to vote for someone else if Lumi doesn't show up?

 

[WorthlessOxygen]

Are you planning to vote for someone else if Lumi doesn't show up?

Undecided but willing to. Seems like a waste of a vote if Lumi will be modkilled due to not meeting post minimums, right?

Current reads list coming

 

[WorthlessOxygen]

This is largely from this morning and will take some major tweaking with more attention to player compatibilities because right now it's way too focused on overall tones. I think I'm also letting dead villagers' reads influence it too much. Village block is dead or stumped so these are all leans.

Blue Cheese
Zenge

DubZ

Carrots, Peeled
Vis
Wonder

MayTagg

Carrots, Unpeeled
Genny
Alley


Microwaved Eggs
True
MKG
Lumi

 

[WorthlessOxygen]

I think I'm going to have a lot better chance after thinking through rough numbers/distribution of players. We've pretty much confirmed that the factions at least consist of: village, wolves, aliens. Right?

Minimum of 50% should be village per earlier discussion which leaves us with at least 8 village slots. 4 are confirmed, leaving a minimum of another 4. Does anyone know what to expect for the size of the others?

 

[genny]

I think I'm going to have a lot better chance after thinking through rough numbers/distribution of players. We've pretty much confirmed that the factions at least consist of: village, wolves, aliens. Right?

Minimum of 50% should be village per earlier discussion which leaves us with at least 8 village slots. 4 are confirmed, leaving a minimum of another 4. Does anyone know what to expect for the size of the others?

Aliens? Confirmed? Sounds like a perspective slip to me

 

[WorthlessOxygen]

Aliens? Confirmed? Sounds like a perspective slip to me

Isn't there only one faction that can stump someone?

 

[WildZoo]

Isn't there only one faction that can stump someone?

Been over this. The ability is stumping, it could be paired with any affiliation.

 

[WildZoo]

I think I'm going to have a lot better chance after thinking through rough numbers/distribution of players. We've pretty much confirmed that the factions at least consist of: village, wolves, aliens. Right?

Minimum of 50% should be village per earlier discussion which leaves us with at least 8 village slots. 4 are confirmed, leaving a minimum of another 4. Does anyone know what to expect for the size of the others?

Don't really know what to expect for sure but in previous games (which were both 14 players) there was one 3-player scum faction and one lone scum in one and one two player faction plus two lone scum in the other

 

[WorthlessOxygen]

Been over this. The ability is stumping, it could be paired with any affiliation.

 

[WildZoo]

So distributions have been
10:3:1
10:2:1:1

 

[WildZoo]

It's okay, you get it from your father 😉

 

[WildZoo]

Microwaved Eggs

Rood

 

[WildZoo]

Blue Cheese

Also I don't like being in this category, can I be Gouda?

 

[WorthlessOxygen]

Also I don't like being in this category, can I be Gouda?

Ooh so you're saying that I'm upsetting both my village leans ?

 

[Viscernable]

There's a chance their whole thing yesterday was just fancy village play, but the fact that they opened with a big lie, a bunch of weirdly strong reads on several people, then some flailing when Wonder called them out, and then just vanishing...

Idk. I feel like I've seen a decent number of wolves just sort of stop posting after they feel like they've blown it. I really hope they come back, I am open to changing my vote but wanted to get something on the board.

I mean, when outted, yeah. When have you seen a wolf stop posting instead of fighting at all when they haven’t been outted?

 

[WildZoo]

Ooh so you're saying that I'm upsetting both my village leans ?

Yes, pls fix

What has alley in your unpeeled carrots?

 

[Viscernable]

Besides the obviously MIA people, I want to see more from Alley I think, she pushed lumi hard yesterday, which I’m fine with but I don’t really remember much of anything else from her.

How do you feel about alley’s push on lumi?

 

[WorthlessOxygen]

Yes, pls fix

Spoiler

What has alley in your unpeeled carrots?

Mostly paranoia about how many people were feeling safe. I think I also mixed her and alissa up a couple times because rereading today I'm finding myself agreeing with a lot of alley's posts. I'm ready to peel her today.

 

[Viscernable]

Updated rough list:

Zenge
Wonder

Dubz
Vissy
Alley
WO2
genny

Lumi

No rating: Mayo-Stagg

I don’t remember what you’ve said about genny, why is she second lowest?

 

[Viscernable]

****************************
I can’t get scum read and yeeted for saying this now so I’m gonna say it again. Ngl getting strong village vibes from Dubz again lol
****************************

Tell me more

 

[Zenge142]

What has alley in your unpeeled carrots?

This is the kind of question I hope someone who's unfamiliar with WW stumbles in and reads.

Hmm I don't think I can objectively evaluate this. I'd like to know what @Zenge142 and @Truenamer think given that I've played with them a couple times

Even disregarding that, I don't think sitting back and waiting for the person you're voting for to flip without talking about anyone else is really in character for you

Can you highlight something you found in Globe or Bowling that gave you this impression, Dubz?

 

[Zenge142]

I'm ready to peel her today.

I do really enjoy the fun categories for your reads list. But the idea that peeling a carrot turns it into Blue Cheese is....

 

[WorthlessOxygen]

I do really enjoy the fun categories for your reads list. But the idea that peeling a carrot turns it into Blue Cheese is....

Father please peeled carrots dipped in blue cheese are prime snack material

 

[Viscernable]

**********************
Mine is looking something like

POE:
Mkg
genny
True

Squinting:
True
Lumi
Zenge
Wonder

Meh:
Mayo/Staggg
WO2

Village:
Alley
Vis
Dubz
**********************

Why squinting at Z and Wonder?

 

[WildZoo]

Father please peeled carrots dipped in blue cheese are prime snack material

Please delete this

 

[WildZoo]

This is the kind of question I hope someone who's unfamiliar with WW stumbles in and reads.

This one too

I'm ready to peel her today.

 

[WildZoo]

Can you highlight something you found in Globe or Bowling that gave you this impression, Dubz?

Hold pls, easier on computer

 

[WildZoo]

@Zenge142 BoWWling is not super helpful since I think Woxy's only vote was the initial joke vote on LaWWpy, but I'm still seeing more developed thoughts on a broader group of players than we've seen here, even just on day 1

Spoiler

Welp 5 more pages to catch up on when I get home but my thoughts from yesterday: your interaction with Mel was about the only thing that stuck out. Not sure what to make of it though as neither felt necessarily wolf or village. Other than that, most of the conversation was jokes or references to past games so I don't have much to go off of.

^directed at AM

I'm sorry, a lot of what I had quoted has already been addressed but I'm mostly caught up on today's posts.


Really not feeling great about fluff's vanillager comment, but also not sure that I'm ready to yeet over it.

Ivy was frequently absent during the noob game. As was I, and we were both village. Actually, I think the majority of the less active players were village. Not that that necessarily means much but I don't know that I'd read it wolfy now.


Got back from work and now I'm juggling laundry, cooking dinner and negotiating a raise while trying to catch up on a lot of conversation. Plus it's D1 so not the most helpful conversations. Unfortunately won't have a ton of insight today.

I have no idea what to do with any of Lawpy's comments. I don't think they're wolfy and my vote was a joke but no one is really sticking out to me as strongly wolf so I'm also not overly inclined to move it.

Just included because of what I said above with Ivy being somewhat absent in the noob game.

I read anything with unsubstantiated stats/percentages as non-serious. assumed it was D1 banter.

None of these are strong reads, I really don't have a solid grasp on anyone.

Dubz leans village but I may be just misinterpreting frequent posting.
AM feels aggressive but I guess that's normal
Stoat seems to be less analytical than in the noob game but I don't want to put too much emphasis on that today.
Truenamer leans village but only slightly, I think I like their thought process at this point.
Fluff's PR discussion makes me very uncomfy.

^these are hedgy but thoughts at least exist

Pulling Globe quotes next

 

[WildZoo]

Globe stuffs. The big thing for me here is the engagement/discussion about other options beyond the person who Woxy is directly voting for.

Spoiler

Don't people say that zenge is always lurky though?

So how is a more sober @bluestoat feeling about genny?

I don't have any strong feelings either way but 80% wolfy seems like a stretch to me. I thought your Zenge vote was odd too. Not necessarily to the point that I'd vote you for it, but definitely odd.

I'm way behind on thread so I don't know if anyone already brought this up but this feels weird to me. Almost overly threatening?

Haven't decided if it's in character yet though.

^directed at stoat

Yeet genny

I don't like PSV as the other leading wagon and while I don't completely agree with stoat's argument, I do think it's the most convincing thing I've seen so far. I'm still a couple pages behind so I may waffle shortly though

Better, yes.

^referring to how he's feeling about stoat after a little while (this was still during d1)

Was feeling better pre-PSV votes. Stoat is feeling fairly similar to our noob game. Not enough to clear but enough that I'm comfortable to say leaning village.

Early comments that maybe doubted that were while I was catching up and wanted to circle back/see what developed in the missed pages

Did you add more to this? Sheeping without adding commentary feels unexpected from you here

^directed at me, sweeping stoat's genny vote

She's my wolfiest read.

The stoat vote felt weak, backing off didn't necessarily make me feel any better, especially since she hasn't voted for anyone else yet. I feel reasonably ok about stoat and dubz for now so I'm not thinking that I'm jumping into a wolf-lead wagon.

I don't think the PSV push is necessarily a wagon or wolfy but I also don't get wolfy vibes from PSV so not interested in that.

^referring to genny in the first two lines

This seems like an unnecessarily risky time to bus, doesn't it?

^post-genny yeeting

There was almost a tie plus it's day 1. I don't know, I haven't been around long enough to see any bussing so maybe I'm wrong. But it just seems like an odd decision.

I read through the last few pages pretty quickly, sorry if you already said something about them but how are you feeling about dana and cubs?

^ Can't remember who this was directed at

Stoat, did you have other reasons for feeling Dana was wolfier today?
Edit: quotes took up more space than I realized

I'm ok with a please vote. I get why cubs and true are pinging people and they're definitely in my POE but I'm not really feeling a vote there right now.

Yeet please

Note that I'm behind at the moment, haven't ready anything that happened today. Was not feeling great about dana, violet, or cubs as of this morning.

Largely process of elimination. Not really interested in looking into anyone who was on genny's vote at this point and a few of them are solidly village for me. Your stoat vote yesterday(? game yesterday at least) and sitting on it through vote close felt like you may have been trying to avoid bussing but also avoid being a decisive vote on a village misyeet

Hmm I'd prefer to say not feeling bad. But yes.

^referring to PSV

Hmm I don't think I like the thought of waffling right now but I also think stoat has a much better read on true than I do. And I don't like how there was no alternative wagon, which makes me less confident in my please vote...

Was debating, you actually convinced me here

Still doesn't feel great. But also better than please, I think. Am thinking

^talking to samac about the Please and True wagons

Largely lack of any interest in an alternative wagon to please

^reasoning for feeling unsure about the Please wagon

 

[SportPonies]

****
I just noticed @WildZoo is using the graph I made without giving me credit
****