CHOOSE YOUR OWWN III - Game Thread

[Viscernable]

---

Members don't see this ad.

I think I’ll be off work about on time today so should be able to participate this evening

Thanks for volunteering me, past Vis

 

[alleycat03]

I’m trying to leave no stone unturned before we do this vote, but with very few posts to analyze and interact with, I’m kinda just sitting here twiddling my thumbs

 

[Viscernable]

*screams for 10 more hours, time travels back to this moment* okay now I’m ready to read things I GUESS

 

[Viscernable]

Wait does anyone have vote trackers somewhere?

 

[Animal Midwife]

Day 4 Yeet Tally
Wonder (1) - Zenge

1/4
yeet close in ~5 hours

 

[alleycat03]

Final Day 1 Yeet Tally
Stagg () -
mkg () -
O2 () -
genny (2) - dubz, alissa
True (2) - shorty, Vis
dubz (1) - Lumi
Chaos (7) - Lawpy, Zenge, True, O2, PSV, genny, mkg
Lumi (3) - Wonder, Chaos, alley
mkg () -
Lawpy () -

15/16
Missing: Stagg

Final Day 2 Yeet Tally
genny () -
Lumi () -
True (6) - Zenge, dubz, Vis, alley, genny, O2
mkg () -
dubz (1) - True

7/11
Missing: Wonder, mayo, mkg, Lumi


Final Day 3 Yeet Tally
Wonder (1) - Zenge
mayo (2) - mkg, alley
alley () -
mkg (4) - mayo, Wonder, Vis, dubz

7/7



Our remaining scum is *probably* not a wolf, so this is likely not that helpful. But seeing the colors helps me

Wait does anyone have vote trackers somewhere?

 

[alleycat03]

Wait does anyone have vote trackers somewhere?

I made that after the vote the other night. So that’s why it doesn’t have the mayo and dubz colored

 

[Viscernable]

… Wonder feels too obvious but like… I want to vote Wonder

 

[kaydubs]

Spoiler

He once used “I forgot my shoes” as an excuse for being late. Like he’d left his house barefoot, drove all the way to work, realized he was shoeless, and drove all the way home again, and was “just leaving now”.

You know, I have those moments sometimes. But they actually happen and im like oh dear

 

[genny]

You know, I have those moments sometimes. But they actually happen and im like oh dear

Same. I have forgotten my shoes and started the car. Don’t think I’ve driven anywhere though. Almost forgot my shirt once, but thankfully it was a cold day so I realized immediately.

 

[Zenge142]

… Wonder feels too obvious but like… I want to vote Wonder

Have you played with wonder before? I can’t remember if I have.

@alleycat03 have you?

 

[genny]

*********
Sorry I’ve been an absent stump the last few days. Interesting that a lot of my reads were correct. Makes me feel like maybe I’m not the worst WW player lol
*********

You’re a good player! Too many scum in the game trying to convince you you’re wrong. Usually means you’re on the right track!

 

[genny]

Have you played with wonder before? I can’t remember if I have.

@alleycat03 have you?

I have. Wonder is 100% bona fide grade A villager

 

[Zenge142]

I have. Wonder is 100% bona fide grade A villager

Do you remember what games?

 

[alleycat03]

Have you played with wonder before? I can’t remember if I have.

@alleycat03 have you?

I don’t think so? I thought she mentioned playing the last CYO game but I have no memory of her

 

[alleycat03]

Do you remember what games?

Zenge please, she’s dead edit:stumped scum

 

[alleycat03]

Have you played with wonder before? I can’t remember if I have.

@alleycat03 have you?

Wonder died N1 of CYO II so that’s probably why I don’t remember her. I haven’t found other games she’s played yet

 

[Zenge142]

Zenge please, she’s dead edit:stumped scum

I can still go look at the games. Worst she can do is tell me a game Wonder didn’t actually play.

I’m reading this thanksgiving game

WWe Be Thankful Game Thread

Opening Post Welcome to Thanksgiving 2020! Things are definitely going to be a little different this year compared to previous Turkey Days Past.... but let's not let the pandemic dash our spirits!! Remember to wash your hands and social distance appropriately. Whether we meet via Zoom or...

forums.studentdoctor.net

 

[alleycat03]

Okay she started playing in the Noob game before cartoons, the wintry wildlife one

WWintry WWildlife - 6th Annual Noob WW Game

❄❄❄❄❄❄❄❄❄❄❄❄❄❄❄❄❄❄❄❄ To appreciate the beauty of a snowflake, it is necessary to stand out in the cold. ❄❄❄❄❄❄❄❄❄❄❄❄❄❄❄❄❄❄❄❄ Winter had arrived, covering the landscape in a coating of thick, white snow. The sky was gray, clouds gathering for round two, and the seas receded in the wake of...

forums.studentdoctor.net

 

[holdthemayo]

*********
Sorry I’ve been an absent stump the last few days. Interesting that a lot of my reads were correct. Makes me feel like maybe I’m not the worst WW player lol
*********

I could forgive you accurate reads, but your absence is too much


Vote Alissa off of stump island

 

[holdthemayo]

You know, I have those moments sometimes. But they actually happen and im like oh dear

Shoes are for the weak

 

[holdthemayo]

Day 4 Yeet Tally
Wonder (1) - Zenge

1/4
yeet close in ~5 hours

AM...

What cards were used to produce my role?

 

[WonderingStudent]

Feel like it's only right for me to try for the villagers and figure out whose the last scum *knocks on wood that whoever is the last*

ISOing wasn't a ton of help

Visc: they’ve been sounding village-y but my gut for some reason says their scum
Zenge: I really don’t know why they overreacted to my posts.
Alley:

Spoiler: spoiler

was really set on a Lumi vote D1

because I don't trust anyone that lies, especially for no reason other than to "trick scum"

I can definitely understand where genny was coming from with saying that this page can be read like alley trying to push the vote away from chaos. (context:
Day 1 Yeet Tally
Stagg () -
mkg () -
O2 () -
genny (2) - dubz, alissa
True (2) - shorty, Vis
dubz (1) - Lumi
Chaos (3) - Lawpy, Zenge, True
Lumi (4) - Wonder, Chaos, O2, alley
mkg () -
Lawpy (1) - mkg

13/16
yeet close in ~3 hours
=>

Unyeet lumi
yeet chaos

WO2 tipping the vote toward Chaos
=>=>=>

I really didn't understand what Lumi was going for at first, and even now that I've research the role, I don't completely buy that they are telling the truth. If Lumi really is the bloodhood, scum are probably going to kill them soon OR Lumi leads us to a wolf/mafia/alien/whatever and we have to decide to trust them (a liar) later or not.

=>

because I don't trust anyone that lies, especially for no reason other than to "trick scum"

I was saying that lying is crappy, and while they could do it as scum or as village, I didn’t like that they lied in the first place. Hence my vote for them

In regard to votes D1 on chaos instead of vig-ing him:

That’s what I was thinking too. I really don’t understand the pile of votes on him

Even if there’s not a vig, I still believe that we should focus on Lumi first

I think lying in general as a villager is scummy unless you have a very good reason to lie, like only sharing part of your pro-village ability. Lumi trying to play 5D chess and start off the game with a giant lie did not sit well with me

To give a complete picture alley’s response to genny:

1. I wasn’t defending chaos, I wanted a vig to take him out.

2. Chaos should’ve been taken out by a vig, which is what I advocated for. NOT defending him.

3. I thought chaos could’ve been Judas, so a vig would’ve been the best choice to kill him. I said a vig should shoot him, which is not defending him.

4. Pew pew chaos not defending him

My read on Mayo was separate from just talking about his reveal. I was saying that his role reveal felt more believable than theirs. Because village hirsute is more believable than wonder’s vanilla townie and MKG’s watcher targets.

He also didn’t answer my follow up questions which is yikes.

(Personally, I don’t think “believable” is the right word but I can understand what you were going for. It would have just been as easy for me to say I was some random card and hope that someone else didn’t have it (or go for one that has a scum/village allignment thus there is 2 of them) - at least that would be less sus than being vanilla. There’s 12 vanilla cards in the game - it’s very believable that multiple players would end up with it.)

I’d rather vote today since if we wait another day cycle it’ll end up with the same misyeet and I think for my own sanity this game needs to be done. I also wouldn’t be around for yeet close on Thursday if we did that.

edit: I thought something in my head and totally mixed up words

 

[alleycat03]

Feel like it's only right for me to try for the villagers and figure out whose the last scum *knocks on wood that whoever is the last*

ISOing wasn't a ton of help

Visc: they’ve been sounding village-y but my gut for some reason says their scum
Zenge: I really don’t know why they overreacted to my posts.
Alley:

Spoiler: spoiler

was really set on a Lumi vote D1

I can definitely understand where genny was coming from with saying that this page can be read like alley trying to push the vote away from chaos. (context:
Day 1 Yeet Tally
Stagg () -
mkg () -
O2 () -
genny (2) - dubz, alissa
True (2) - shorty, Vis
dubz (1) - Lumi
Chaos (3) - Lawpy, Zenge, True
Lumi (4) - Wonder, Chaos, O2, alley
mkg () -
Lawpy (1) - mkg

13/16
yeet close in ~3 hours
=>

WO2 tipping the vote toward Chaos
=>=>=>

=>


In regard to votes D1 on chaos instead of vig-ing him:



To give a complete picture alley’s response to genny:


(Personally, I don’t think “believable” is the right word but I can understand what you were going for. It would have just been as easy for me to say I was some random card and hope that someone else didn’t have it (or go for one that has a scum/village allignment thus there is 2 of them) - at least that would be less sus than being vanilla. There’s 12 vanilla cards in the game - it’s very believable that multiple players would end up with it.)

I’d rather vote today since if we wait another day cycle it’ll end up with the same misyeet and I think for my own sanity this game needs to be done. I also wouldn’t be around for yeet close on Thursday if we did that.

edit: I thought something in my head and totally mixed up words

Anybody using the “alley defended chaos angle” is obviously scum. Idk how many times I’ve told y’all that I wanted him dead, I just didn’t want to risk activating Judas.

 

[alleycat03]

Final Day 1 Yeet Tally
Stagg () -
mkg () -
O2 () -
genny (2) - dubz, alissa
True (2) - shorty, Vis
dubz (1) - Lumi
Chaos (7) - Lawpy, Zenge, True, O2, PSV, genny, mkg
Lumi (3) - Wonder, Chaos, alley
mkg () -
Lawpy () -

15/16
Missing: Stagg

Final Day 2 Yeet Tally
genny () -
Lumi () -
True (6) - Zenge, dubz, Vis, alley, genny, O2
mkg () -
dubz (1) - True

7/11
Missing: Wonder, mayo, mkg, Lumi


Final Day 3 Yeet Tally
Wonder (1) - Zenge
mayo (2) - mkg, alley
alley () -
mkg (4) - mayo, Wonder, Vis, dubz

7/7



Our remaining scum is *probably* not a wolf, so this is likely not that helpful. But seeing the colors helps me

 

[alleycat03]

I don’t bus unless I absolutely have to. Mayo was in serious danger of being yeeted. My vote for him on D3 would be stupid to do as a packmate.

I have not voted for a wolf this game, that is true. But I said for the entirety of D1 that we needed someone to vig chaos. I would’ve just kept my mouth shut if he was a packmate. I also was heavily considering a vote for MKG. I was between her and Mayo on D3.

 

[alissa14]

I could forgive you accurate reads, but your absence is too much


Vote Alissa off of stump island

**********
Am I even obligated to play as a stump? I can’t vote. If I was fully alive I would’ve made more effort. I am aware this is anti-village but I have real life shiz to do
************

 

[alissa14]

*********
Absolutely not even caught up on thread but if I had to pick out scum based on previous reads I would lean towards zenge and wonder. But I haven’t read wonder’s recent posts to see if I could get good village vibes. I actually would lean more towards zenge over wonder if I had to choose
**********

 

[genny]

Do you remember what games?

I just admitted to forgetting my shoes, do you think I’m going to remember what games I played and with whom?

 

[alissa14]

TREESTUMP

********
This is so funny to me lol
*********

 

[alleycat03]

**********
Am I even obligated to play as a stump? I can’t vote. If I was fully alive I would’ve made more effort. I am aware this is anti-village but I have real life shiz to do
************

You’re not obligated to play as a stump and I think Mayo was making a joke. Please don’t take his comment seriously

 

[holdthemayo]

TREESTUMP

You rang

 

[holdthemayo]

**********
Am I even obligated to play as a stump? I can’t vote. If I was fully alive I would’ve made more effort. I am aware this is anti-village but I have real life shiz to do
************

You can vote on tree stump island. The main game is boring and full of trunks.

 

[alleycat03]

I appreciate wonder’s half-hearted attempt to paint me as scummy, but it obviously did nothing to convince me. @Zenge142 @Viscernable any more thoughts in these last few hours?

 

[holdthemayo]

I appreciate wonder’s half-hearted attempt to paint me as scummy, but it obviously did nothing to convince me. @Zenge142 @Viscernable any more thoughts in these last few hours?

Wonder didn’t convince you that you were scum? That’s a lot to ask…

 

[alleycat03]

Wonder didn’t convince you that you were scum? That’s a lot to ask…

Ikr? I’m absolutely shocked she couldn’t convince me to vote for myself

 

[Zenge142]

I appreciate wonder’s half-hearted attempt to paint me as scummy, but it obviously did nothing to convince me. @Zenge142 @Viscernable any more thoughts in these last few hours?

Not really. I’ve been mulling over how wrong I was about Vis on D1 of clue, but I really think she’s village here.

Wonder is the only vote that makes sense to me.

 

[Viscernable]

Have you played with wonder before? I can’t remember if I have.

@alleycat03 have you?

Yes but I can’t remember when

 

[Viscernable]

I appreciate wonder’s half-hearted attempt to paint me as scummy, but it obviously did nothing to convince me. @Zenge142 @Viscernable any more thoughts in these last few hours?

I think my brain turned off. That or it really is just that obviously Wonder

 

[Zenge142]

I think my brain turned off. That or it really is just that obviously Wonder

I just can’t get over having Mayo 2nd highest on her reads list at that point in the game.

Is it TWTBW, or is it just…exactly what it looks like?

 

[kaydubs]

Shoes are for the weak

Absolutely. If I could, I would not wear them

 

[alleycat03]

I just can’t get over having Mayo 2nd highest on her reads list at that point in the game.

Is it TWTBW, or is it just…exactly what it looks like?

Yeah, I agree that that is puzzling. I’m having a harder time figuring out the cards she used and why she claimed black goo for aff. I don’t think she’s compatible with chaos and the wolves, but I have not seen a SINGLE reason why she isn’t compatible with Mayo. And she’s ignored my questions asking her how she’s not compatible.

Vis here doesn’t feel like casino Vis. But I know I was crappy at reading her that game and it makes me anxious thinking that she’s village here, because what if I’m wrong again!? I don’t have any reasons to think she’s scum, but I’m so paranoid that I’m wrong and wonder isn’t scum.

Neither of you feel like baby animals wolf!vis and wolf!zenge. Which is good because that was a terrifying end game. I know you cannot be a wolf, and it is EXTREMELY unlikely imo that you’re mafia either.

 

[WorthlessOxygen]

I think my brain turned off.

Smh I said this as a bad thing, not a recommendation for y'all to follow suit

 

[WildZoo]

*******

*******

 

[alleycat03]

We only have 15 minutes left. I don’t foresee anything happening in the next 15 mins that’ll convince me otherwise.

Yeet wonder

 

[Animal Midwife]

Day 4 Yeet Tally
Wonder (2) - Zenge, alley

2/4
@WonderingStudent is in the lead!
Missing: @WonderingStudent @Viscernable
yeet close in ~12 minutes

 

[WonderingStudent]

I just can’t get over having Mayo 2nd highest on her reads list at that point in the game.

Is it TWTBW, or is it just…exactly what it looks like?

Well when everyone else have more posts to get sus vibes from leads to my ordered list of reads from the other day - more that everyone else just felt more sus to me. Sorry if my reads are crap but thats where I put them.

Yeah, I agree that that is puzzling. I’m having a harder time figuring out the cards she used and why she claimed black goo for aff. I don’t think she’s compatible with chaos and the wolves, but I have not seen a SINGLE reason why she isn’t compatible with Mayo. And she’s ignored my questions asking her how she’s not compatible.

Vis here doesn’t feel like casino Vis. But I know I was crappy at reading her that game and it makes me anxious thinking that she’s village here, because what if I’m wrong again!? I don’t have any reasons to think she’s scum, but I’m so paranoid that I’m wrong and wonder isn’t scum.

Neither of you feel like baby animals wolf!vis and wolf!zenge. Which is good because that was a terrifying end game. I know you cannot be a wolf, and it is EXTREMELY unlikely imo that you’re mafia either.

I forgot to respond to you about mayo since I got lost in ISOing. But, truly how can I prove that mayo - a player that barely posted isn't compatible with me or really anyone here. We don't know what faction the last scum is coming from IMO

 

[genny]

Can i interest anyone in a tie?

 

[Viscernable]

Yeet wonder

 

[Viscernable]

So did I choke