CWWem's HoWWiday ExtWWavangza (mafia game thread)

[Zenge142]

Advertisement - Members don't see this ad

She reminds me of the apop I just wolfed with. Admitting it could be confbias of getting that up close look

What specifically reminds you of it?

 

[WildZoo]

can’t ignore wz and spurs!

Sure you can, just hit the "ignore" button

 

[Zenge142]

GTH pls

Village probably

 

[WildZoo]

Village probably

So the pocketing is working. Noted.

 

[fruitsalad]

foiling

unyeet katie
yeet genny

@Clem J @alissa14

 

[WildZoo]

foiling

unyeet katie
yeet genny

@Clem J @alissa14

Foil?? Share with the class pls

 

[katiemcat]

Katie can you talk about this more?

I don’t really remember you talking the vote being “because of SAR’s Sleep Vote” at the time, and I know I was the one who originally raised the issue about the sleep vote

Vote sleep

It's a Christmas miracle!

@Clem J @alissa14

If we sleep D1 we gain no info…. No…?

OR IS THAT WHAT THEY WANT

Unvote @GoSpursGo

Vote @SARdoghandler

@Clem J

NO SLEEP

I really don't like that SAR suggested a Sleep vote. She knows better. Voting is the power we have as villagers. That's going to really bother me.

I literally brought this up way before you bud……

Is this really methodical village zenge ..?

 

[fruitsalad]

Foil?? Share with the class pls

thinking apop, genny, PSV

 

[GoSpursGo]

Disagree from the perspective of my own mind being a skittery anxious wolfling

I could be wrong! From the outside looking in, you’re looking kind of skitters and hopping in a few different directions

What specifically reminds you of it?

I’m not sure my process is super sound, because it’s somewhat result oriented. But basically getting sus early in game, then managing to deflect the sus elsewhere. I would need to go back and really look, but my recollection is that on d3 and later she brought up some names that weren’t really on anyone else’s board like she is kind of doing with fruits here.

I also can’t remember if it was apop or beans who did a lot of solving via pair analysis last game.

I’m on my phone under a blanket contemplating a nap so I’m not able to readily verify any of this.

 

[WildZoo]

thinking apop, genny, PSV

Oh hmm. Let me...roll that around in my noggin. Is there something specific leading you that direction or legitimately just tinfoiling?

 

[genny]

Well generally me still not feeling The Genny Way™️ at this point means it's increasingly likely she's wolfing, so they're kind of the same thing?

Unless you’re the one wolfing

 

[WildZoo]

I also can’t remember if it was apop or beans who did a lot of solving via pair analysis last game.

That was beans

I don't actually recall if apop did it too, I just know beans did it a bunch. Apop had the spooky Spreadsheet.

I’m on my phone under a blanket contemplating a nap so I’m not able to readily verify any of this.

Pffft that's how I play 85% of the time, get gud

 

[fruitsalad]

Oh hmm. Let me...roll that around in my noggin. Is there something specific leading you that direction or legitimately just tinfoiling?

i’m having difficulties trying to pair katie with other people here, and it’s further complicated by the fact that genny suspects katie and lissa, and PSV pushed katie earlier, so i’m thinking katie is a misdirection

 

[WildZoo]

Unless you’re the one wolfing

Idk I think that would make it easier for me to see The Genny Way™️ hmmyes

 

[GoSpursGo]

That was beans

I don't actually recall if apop did it too, I just know beans did it a bunch. Apop had the spooky Spreadsheet.


Pffft that's how I play 85% of the time, get gud

@apoptosis09 this reminds me I had wanted to ask, did you build the spooky spreadsheet from what I dropped in wolf chat or did you make your own??

 

[genny]

i’m having difficulties trying to pair katie with other people here, and it’s further complicated by the fact that genny suspects katie and lissa, and PSV pushed katie earlier, so i’m thinking katie is a misdirection

Or… we’re right. 😱

 

[genny]

Idk I think that would make it easier for me to see The Genny Way™️ hmmyes

I’m unpocketable! Don’t even try it!

 

[GoSpursGo]

I literally brought this up way before you bud……

Is this really methodical village zenge ..?

Fwiw I also jumped almost immediately on SAR’s sleep vote, I just didn’t vote for her because of it. But zenge definitely wasn’t first.

 

[GoSpursGo]

Or… we’re right. 😱

Oh goodness is @fruitsalad about to see the Genny Way (TM)?

 

[apoptosis09]

@apoptosis09 this reminds me I had wanted to ask, did you build the spooky spreadsheet from what I dropped in wolf chat or did you make your own??

I dont remember what you dropped in wolf chat

 

[GoSpursGo]

Oh goodness is @fruitsalad about to see the Genny Way (TM)?

Nvm I misread the thread and thought Katie (ETA: not genny) was in fruits’s hypothetical pack. Thread is moving fast

I am not gud

 

[WildZoo]

I’m unpocketable! Don’t even try it!

I like a challenge If I were wolfing I would 100% keep you alive so you could choke in endgame

 

[fruitsalad]

Granted, I'm also suspicious of apop and there's clearly not a joint venture there.

How do you feel this version of apop compares with the wolf version we just played with?

mmmm
I don't have reliable reads on comparing people to how they played as my partners, because to be frank there are times I will skim my partners' posts because I know I'm unlikely to call them out on something lol. And I'm not trying to solve them.
The better question is how does this version of apop compare to previous versions of apop I've played with previously where I've actually had to solve her and found out she was village

hmm, thinking further

 

[fruitsalad]

unyeet genny
yeet apop

back on the board

@Clem J @alissa14

 

[Zenge142]

I literally brought this up way before you bud……

Well forgive me for thinking that this:

OR IS THAT WHAT THEY WANT

Didn’t sound super serious.

Also you voted for SAR because “Sleep gives us nothing”

My talking about SAR voting for sleep is a lot different. I was bothered by it because SAR knows better.

These are different things. You voted SAR because you disliked her idea. My issue with SAR was because I believed SAR would know not do vote sleep D1

NOT THE SAME THING!

 

[GoSpursGo]

Presses tally button

(to summon @WildZoo to do it for me)

 

[WildZoo]

NOT THE SAME THING!

 

[WildZoo]

Presses tally button

(to summon @WildZoo to do it for me)

 

[WildZoo]

I'm pretty sure the tally is unchanged since all that happened is fruits moved to genny and then back to apop

D2 tally

apoptosis09 ( 1 ): fruit
fruitsalad ( ):
genny ( 2 ): Spurs, Dubz
Gospursgo (1 ): Lissa
katiemcat ( 1 ): apop
Lissarae06 ( ):
potentialsheltervet ( ):
wildzoo ( ):
zenge142 ( ):
sleep ( ):

 

[fruitsalad]

i guess katie, lissa, WZ is possible but that feels really bizarre to me

 

[katiemcat]

Well forgive me for thinking that this:

Didn’t sound super serious.

Also you voted for SAR because “Sleep gives us nothing”

My talking about SAR voting for sleep is a lot different. I was bothered by it because SAR knows better.

These are different things. You voted SAR because you disliked her idea. My issue with SAR was because I believed SAR would know not do vote sleep D1

NOT THE SAME THING!

It’s actually exactly the same thing….

SAR is an experienced player. Voting for D1 sleep was undeniably a strange move and something that would benefit the wolves.

Your vote for SAR isn’t different from mine, even though it seems like you’re attempting to make it out to be for… reasons…..

 

[WildZoo]

i guess katie, lissa, WZ is possible but that feels really bizarre to me

fruit pls

 

[GoSpursGo]

I'm pretty sure the tally is unchanged since all that happened is fruits moved to genny and then back to apop

D2 tally

apoptosis09 ( 1 ): fruit
fruitsalad ( ):
genny ( 2 ): Spurs, Dubz
Gospursgo (1 ): Lissa
katiemcat ( 1 ): apop
Lissarae06 ( ):
potentialsheltervet ( ):
wildzoo ( ):
zenge142 ( ):
sleep ( ):

thank you, you saved me from trying to find an appropriate non broken gif on my phone to respond to your pic with

 

[fruitsalad]

unyeet apop
yeet katie

@Clem J @alissa14

 

[fruitsalad]

i’m split between apop and katie

 

[WildZoo]

D2 tally

apoptosis09 ( ):
fruitsalad ( ):
genny ( 2 ): Spurs, Dubz
Gospursgo (1 ): Lissa
katiemcat ( 1 ): apop, fruit
Lissarae06 ( ):
potentialsheltervet ( ):
wildzoo ( ):
zenge142 ( ):
sleep ( ):

 

[katiemcat]

unyeet apop
yeet katie

@Clem J @alissa14

Because Zenge says so…?

 

[GoSpursGo]

Sigh I kind of want to flip back to apop to keep her on the board, but I guess it’s almost consolidation o clock huh?

 

[fruitsalad]

@GoSpursGo @Zenge142 what are you thinking about apop and katie?

 

[fruitsalad]

Sigh I kind of want to flip back to apop to keep her on the board, but I guess it’s almost consolidation o clock huh?

we have <4 hours so plenty of time to discuss

 

[GoSpursGo]

Because Zenge says so…?

Katie who are you leaning towards voting?

 

[WildZoo]

Sigh I kind of want to flip back to apop to keep her on the board, but I guess it’s almost consolidation o clock huh?

I think you should do what your heart desires. We don't need to artificially consolidate this early.

 

[fruitsalad]

lissa voting spurs doesn’t look wolfy to me so i’ll be surprised if she’s a wolf

idk

the way she’s approaching this game mirrors supernatural

 

[fruitsalad]

unyeet katie
yeet apop

@Clem J @alissa14

 

[GoSpursGo]

@GoSpursGo @Zenge142 what are you thinking about apop and katie?

Apop is one of my two strongest wolf reads, so I would be willing to vote there.

I can’t fault someone for thinking Katie is sus, but I’m personally village reading her and would be unlikely to vote there unless it’s to break a tie.

 

[GoSpursGo]

I think you should do what your heart desires. We don't need to artificially consolidate this early.

I also hate waffling, lol.

i Also also should put my phone down and take a nap while the children are napping

 

[katiemcat]

Katie who are you leaning towards voting?

Earlier I would have said apop but now I’m kind of getting prickled by zenge……. I would still like the hear more from him but I’m really confused by his “investigation.” I could probably be convinced either way though.

I personally don’t think apop is ever a bad flip. Spurs to me feels really towny with his contributions - especially when I compare it to his wolfing in the games I’ve played with him. But I haven’t gotten a chance to read the good place thread as I’ve been busy yet. I think Lissa fees like she did in supernatural for me rn (village). Fruit is scaring me a little as he usually is way more investigative (if not chaotic) with his posts and usually has more fleshed out theories.

I’m going out to breakfast but I will def be able to post more than yesterday.

lissa voting spurs doesn’t look wolfy to me so i’ll be surprised if she’s a wolf

idk

the way she’s approaching this game mirrors supernatural

Hmm..

 

[WildZoo]

I also hate waffling, lol.

i Also also should put my phone down and take a nap while the children are napping

As long as you don't do it as much as fruit I think you're absolved of waffle sins 😛
But if you would like to stay on genny with me, that's cool too

 

[Zenge142]

It’s actually exactly the same thing….

SAR is an experienced player. Voting for D1 sleep was undeniably a strange move and something that would benefit the wolves.

Your vote for SAR isn’t different from mine, even though it seems like you’re attempting to make it out to be for… reasons…..

Okay, and you just immediately jumped on it like it was a smoking gun.

I struggled with it. I tried to see what the village side of the case was. I tried to talk to SAR and understand SAR’s process.

You were like “yep easy P.Z. Let’s go!” And look how it turned out.

I struggled with it.

 

[fruitsalad]

i’m starting to think 3 wolves is the worst case scenario since that feels on the higher end

so i’ll stop trying to group by 3