Nor'east Ski WWeekend (Basics) - Game Thread

This forum made possible through the generous support of SDN members, donors, and sponsors. Thank you.
Care to elaborate at this time?
AM, WZ, and mel aren't setting off any alarm bells yet. SOV seems fine. Snowy seems to have grown a pair, and I like it. Dolphin and Barkley seem villagery enough.

I don't like what I've heard from petmoose, grebes, or capri so far. And Pip is definitely a wolf.
 
I see why this originally caught attention. Village leans refer to how you feel about others... village leans can't be put onto another player and expect everyone to follow. So it is weird to village lean yourself because as was pointed out if you were village you'd count yourself as confirmed village or not even mention yourself.

Furthermore, I could see a noob wolf coming up with this strategy of "Oh I was a wolf last time so I'm clearly not likely to be a wolf this time"
...but?
You weren't RNG as wolf. You were subbed as a wolf, and there are no statistics for that.

HOWEVER. I don't like how obvious it seems, for D1.


D1 is random votes with a purpose of trying to find a direction to go to.

I definitely read that stats thing from cubs as a joke. I can't decide if you think he meant it or you are trying to manufacture something.

It's the lack of hedging or any reasoning for that matter. I've never seen her play like this before.

Thats right. Trying something new :kiss: If I am less hedgy as a villager = less hedgy as a wolf = mel doesn't always lynch me when I'm trying to figure out how to wolf. (yes blah blah take that as I am a wolf this game if you want, but I'm just kinda sick of being always called sketchy when I think I have good insight sometimes). And I gave reasoning for my barks vote. Coffee? is also up there now for taking the comment above as real.

And then again it might be because I'm kinda really done with this ****y day :grumpy:
 
Also just so we all know (including myself for later) the mutts lynch is eh at best. So I’m gonna not do that lol.
 
Thats right. Trying something new :kiss: If I am less hedgy as a villager = less hedgy as a wolf = mel doesn't always lynch me when I'm trying to figure out how to wolf. (yes blah blah take that as I am a wolf this game if you want, but I'm just kinda sick of being always called sketchy when I think I have good insight sometimes). And I gave reasoning for my barks vote. Coffee? is also up there now for taking the comment above as real.

And then again it might be because I'm kinda really done with this ****y day :grumpy:

Sorry about your day.

I was just curious because I have seen you less hedgy but never seen the no reasoning behind a vote before.
 
No, she wasn't in full on AM tunnel, I agree there.
Why so quick to defend?
Bc AM is like the only player I can generally remember play style. I blame her usual Pokémon avatars for it lol.
 
I definitely read that stats thing from cubs as a joke. I can't decide if you think he meant it or you are trying to manufacture something.



Thats right. Trying something new :kiss: If I am less hedgy as a villager = less hedgy as a wolf = mel doesn't always lynch me when I'm trying to figure out how to wolf. (yes blah blah take that as I am a wolf this game if you want, but I'm just kinda sick of being always called sketchy when I think I have good insight sometimes). And I gave reasoning for my barks vote. Coffee? is also up there now for taking the comment above as real.

And then again it might be because I'm kinda really done with this ****y day :grumpy:
Pretty sure he definitely meant it but if you notice my analysis came out with the result of, noob, and although I didn't explicitly say so, I intentionally did not vote there.

How about your thoughts on SOV, who was the first to comment on it, and one of the reasons I visited that particular comment, as I mentioned I was looking at what others were concerned about?
 
If you don't know, then you're not reading between the lines.
You mean her "don't Lynch a PR bit"? that just made me lol

If there is something else I am missing, feel free to tell me then.
 
AM, WZ, and mel aren't setting off any alarm bells yet. SOV seems fine. Snowy seems to have grown a pair, and I like it. Dolphin and Barkley seem villagery enough.

I don't like what I've heard from petmoose, grebes, or capri so far. And Pip is definitely a wolf.
Noted.
 
Also just so we all know (including myself for later) the mutts lynch is eh at best. So I’m gonna not do that lol.
Eh in that perhaps for a last minute waffle, I agree. Eh in that it isn't worthwhile to pursue, I disagree, and I definitely would like to see more pressure there to get her to talk.

@muttmanager new thoughts?
 
Eh in that perhaps for a last minute waffle, I agree. Eh in that it isn't worthwhile to pursue, I disagree, and I definitely would like to see more pressure there to get her to talk.

@muttmanager new thoughts?
Yeah that’s why I meant it at this time kinda thing. Bc I’d like to at least lynch someone besides cubs today. And I don’t think mutts is that person as of now. Not saying that anyone on cubs has no merit either but I’m just personally reading it as noob not wolf at this point.
 
D1 Puppy Slope Skiing Tally

Killerleaf () -
grebes () -
Mel (2) - Skilary, dolphin
AM (1) - capri
MSU () -
Capri (2) - Grebes, Bryndi
WZ (2) - killerleaf, dina
Barks (4) - Ziggy, mutts, snowy, cubs
Cubs (5) - SOV, petmoosy, MJ, genny, Barks
SOV () -
Zigjaz (1) - Mel
Sporty () -
Coffee (2) - SAR, sporty
Snowy (2) - AM, dubz
genny (1) - MSU
Mutts (1) - coffeebean

23/23 voting :heckyeah:
Cubs, you are in the lead!

Please consider sending in your night actions early!

Lynch close at 10pm Eastern (15 min remaining)

-skiing-39852.gif
 
@muttmanager I saw you liking posts. What do you have to say?

Don’t lynch me. I’m catching up now.

To coffees “reasoning”
I don’t usually use rl but I’m taking an evening class and work is s****y rn so I am not able to be as active as usual until early am or close to lynch close and the barks lynch were my strongest feels the math didn’t seem like strong reasoning to vote there but still sketchy

I saw something barks wrote so ##unlynch barks, lynch Capri##





Sent from my iPhone using SDN
 
Sorry about your day.

I was just curious because I have seen you less hedgy but never seen the no reasoning behind a vote before.

Blame my mood. Partially feels I couldn't pinpoint. And other people had already said what else I agreed was sketch about her.

Pretty sure he definitely meant it but if you notice my analysis came out with the result of, noob, and although I didn't explicitly say so, I intentionally did not vote there.

How about your thoughts on SOV, who was the first to comment on it, and one of the reasons I visited that particular comment, as I mentioned I was looking at what others were concerned about?

Really? Weird. (like noob weird/stats weird). SOV I haven't played with much. It sounded like it went over his head. Your comment off of that sounded manufactured.
 
Don’t lynch me. I’m catching up now.

To coffees “reasoning”
I don’t usually use rl but I’m taking an evening class and work is s****y rn so I am not able to be as active as usual until early am or close to lynch close and the barks lynch were my strongest feels the math didn’t seem like strong reasoning to vote there but still sketchy

I saw something barks wrote so ##unlynch barks, lynch Capri##





Sent from my iPhone using SDN
You're not in danger, I'm literally the only one on you
 
Blame my mood. Partially feels I couldn't pinpoint. And other people had already said what else I agreed was sketch about her.



Really? Weird. (like noob weird/stats weird). SOV I haven't played with much. It sounded like it went over his head. Your comment off of that sounded manufactured.
maybe it's cause I was driving

DONT FOLLOW MY EXAMPLES
 
Blame my mood. Partially feels I couldn't pinpoint. And other people had already said what else I agreed was sketch about her.

Okay, it's just this is the first time you've actually even said you suspect her.
 
Yeah, you're going on the sketch list.
Ok?? It's like y'all think I can't read or something. I read her comment, I don't necessarily believe her and I think blindly following that is naive.

And saying that if I don't know, I can't read between the lines is just??? Like, the statement was clear enough everyone could pick up on it. Idk really what you're getting at.
 
Ok?? It's like y'all think I can't read or something. I read her comment, I don't necessarily believe her and I think blindly following that is naive.

And saying that if I don't know, I can't read between the lines is just??? Like, the statement was clear enough everyone could pick up on it. Idk really what you're getting at.

Remember the probability conversation earlier? This is actually a relevant one here.
 
Are these sporty’s reasons you’re referring to? Just wondering for my own clarification I know you’re not voting there anymore.
Ye. It was mostly this comment for me
Barkley was lynched in the noob game, yes? Seems odd you have forgotten this so soon.
Which was kind of ridic in my opinion because why would zig be expected to remember who got lynched 3 or 4 games ago? It's weak though and the rest of coffee's posts haven't bothered me.
 
Ok?? It's like y'all think I can't read or something. I read her comment, I don't necessarily believe her and I think blindly following that is naive.

And saying that if I don't know, I can't read between the lines is just??? Like, the statement was clear enough everyone could pick up on it. Idk really what you're getting at.
So let's say she's lying. She doesn't die overnight, doesn't die the next few nights, continues to act sketchy as heck and we eventually lynch her as the wolf she is. What's wrong with that? There are 3 other wolves to track down in this game.
If she's telling the truth, you want to deprive the village of a PR on day 1, make the wolves' job just that much easier because they don't even have to night kill her. Or draw a giant bullseye on Barks for night kills just in case her statement got glossed over in all the day 1 activity.
Which course of action seems less harmful to village?
 
Ye. It was mostly this comment for me

Which was kind of ridic in my opinion because why would zig be expected to remember who got lynched 3 or 4 games ago? It's weak though and the rest of coffee's posts haven't bothered me.
I mean I said that because ziggy was specifically commenting that barkley wasn't defensive, barkley says "when I have ever been defensive?", and ziggy's response was "I don't know I've never seen your lynch get pushed"
 
Ye. It was mostly this comment for me

Which was kind of ridic in my opinion because why would zig be expected to remember who got lynched 3 or 4 games ago? It's weak though and the rest of coffee's posts haven't bothered me.
Ugh I was hoping you wouldn’t say this post lol. Bc I feel like you’re partially in my brain. I also was like woah I have no idea who died when in that game...
 
Ugh I was hoping you wouldn’t say this post lol. Bc I feel like you’re partially in my brain. I also was like woah I have no idea who died when in that game...
See above... it wasn't that I expected her to remember but she said essentially that she's never seen her get lynched but was making a playstyle argument.
 
Ugh I was hoping you wouldn’t say this post lol. Bc I feel like you’re partially in my brain. I also was like woah I have no idea who died when in that game...
I didn't think we were genetically close enough to mindmeld :thinking:

I mean I said that because ziggy was specifically commenting that barkley wasn't defensive, barkley says "when I have ever been defensive?", and ziggy's response was "I don't know I've never seen your lynch get pushed"
Most players are bad at remembering that kind of thing :shrug:
 
Welp, pass the Muro128. Was all excited to play this game and start learning but I guess I gotta wait another week or two. I know I’m not part of the crew yet or whatever but that’s not my fault.

I did learn one thing in game 2 at least: don’t ever make in-thread math posts and if you’re a noob don’t ever talk on D1 :hello:
 
I'm asking you a question.
Don't know what you're asking. Unless you're just implying what you were implying all of last game, idk.

So let's say she's lying. She doesn't die overnight, doesn't die the next few nights, continues to act sketchy as heck and we eventually lynch her as the wolf she is. What's wrong with that? There are 3 other wolves to track down in this game.
If she's telling the truth, you want to deprive the village of a PR on day 1, make the wolves' job just that much easier because they don't even have to night kill her. Or draw a giant bullseye on Barks for night kills just in case her statement got glossed over in all the day 1 activity.
Which course of action seems less harmful to village?
You think I drew a giant target on her? She was the one who said it. It's not like we have to act all cryptic about it. Everyone here can read.
 
Welp, pass the Muro128. Was all excited to play this game and start learning but I guess I gotta wait another week or two. I know I’m not part of the crew yet or whatever but that’s not my fault.

I did learn one thing in game 2 at least: don’t ever make in-thread math posts and if you’re a noob don’t ever talk on D1 :hello:

That's not the lesson. But ya gotta be more active around EOD. Otherwise, it may look like lurking.
 
~Please check your votes~

D1 Puppy Slope Skiing Tally


Killerleaf () -
grebes () -
Mel (2) - Skilary, dolphin
AM (1) - capri
MSU () -
Capri (3) - Grebes, Bryndi, mutts
WZ (2) - killerleaf, dina
Barks (3) - Ziggy, snowy, cubs
Cubs (5) - SOV, petmoosy, MJ, genny, Barks
SOV () -
Zigjaz (2) - Mel, dubz
Sporty () -
Coffee (2) - SAR, sporty
Snowy (1) - AM
genny (1) - MSU
Mutts (1) - coffeebean

23/23 voting :heckyeah:

Please consider sending in your night actions early!

Lynch closed

-skiing-39852.gif
 
Last edited:
Welp, pass the Muro128. Was all excited to play this game and start learning but I guess I gotta wait another week or two. I know I’m not part of the crew yet or whatever but that’s not my fault.

I did learn one thing in game 2 at least: don’t ever make in-thread math posts and if you’re a noob don’t ever talk on D1 :hello:
See this just makes me sad. Silly waste of Lynch. Wish you could stick around cubs!
 
Welp, pass the Muro128. Was all excited to play this game and start learning but I guess I gotta wait another week or two. I know I’m not part of the crew yet or whatever but that’s not my fault.

I did learn one thing in game 2 at least: don’t ever make in-thread math posts and if you’re a noob don’t ever talk on D1 :hello:

No. Do talk. Eventually everyone will get used to you. Noobs often get lynched D1 for sounding sketchy... thats just the way of the game (now you can make everyone feel bad if they want to lynch you next game D1 haha)
 
You think I drew a giant target on her? She was the one who said it. It's not like we have to act all cryptic about it. Everyone here can read.

So what are the odds of it being a bluff? And is it worth lynching? Pros and cons? Probability stuff.
 
Top