Panem et Circenses - Game Thread

[WildZoo]

---

Members do not see this ad.

unlynch paws lynch mutts

 

[WildZoo]

What the hell is going on with that MsP post? Can we get an edit exception @Melchizedek because that is annoying af

 

[cubsrule4e]

Why is mutts reading village to you?

Because from what I’ve seen with her as village (I think every game I’ve played with her) when confronted or accused as wolfy this is generally the standard reaction.

 

[Ms Procrastinator]

Initially lynched AM, was very reluctant in conversing with AM, due to her questioning and game play tactics (limited answers, etc).



















Then unlynches AM to lynch Stagg, when she is called out.











Then switches vote again from Stagg to Pip, only after realizing Mutts also lynched Stagg via RNG (she didn’t like that). Only reasoning for lynching Pip, thus far, is all her fluff and doesn’t trust her (but why??)







Became defensive again, when called out for quick responses that others have already asked (didn’t really need to respond defensively IMO)







Now that the lynches are stacking up on her, she is backtracking her defensiveness











Only person who’s voting has been all over the place today…

Are you trying to play coy?







@cubsrule4e

what did he mean by profile pic may mean more that what it appears? What more can you tell us?







NAV

Seems knowledgeable in the game itself, trying to understand how SDNers play by throwing out stats and old game references. Interested to see how it plays out with them.








@SARdoghandler from what I’ve noticed seems to be a good wolf hunter (could be wrong as I have not played many games nor seen many). Seems to be defending AM’s game play, are you just looking out for her in general or believe she’s could be village?













Computer has been super slow and that took forever to round up the excessive amount of quotes lol.



So I can say where my vote is going tonight





Lynch ziggy




I left off on page 6 of the thread, so I’ll keep reading and update as needed.

[/QUOTE]
I don't understand what is happening with this post[/QUOTE]
I messed up on the quoting. I quoted what I actually meant since we can't edit.

 

[genny]

I'm confused. That second quote isn't me leaning you or AM village. I was saying the barkely and someone else yesterday all saying the routinely sketchy/hard to read people: AM, me, you, pippy as village was suspect. I dont have a read on you.
I also still think AM and Nav sound village and I thought and was correct that zig sounded village too.
My only other read was maybe vill on pippy and I'm not sure on that or if that has changed.

I think it's weird that both you and em said that I had you as sketchy but I guess maybe it wasn't clear. Why didn't you ask me about that post yesterday if you were confused by it? This sets off alarm bells for me cuz you are better than that

I never said that you said you had me as sketchy. Not sure where that comes from.

I didn't ask you about it yesterday because I didn't iso you until this morning when I was asked for an opinion about you. The way I interpreted the two quotes was that the first one had you village reading the group of players named, and the second one was calling out someone else for also village reading the same group. And like I said, I was leaning the perceived inconsistency more village.

But it was enough to make navilly change his vote, and that was interesting.

 

[Ms Procrastinator]

What the hell is going on with that MsP post? Can we get an edit exception @Melchizedek because that is annoying af

It hurts me toooooo.

 

[Melchizedek]

What the hell is going on with that MsP post? Can we get an edit exception @Melchizedek because that is annoying af

I don't understand what is happening with this post[/QUOTE]
I messed up on the quoting. I quoted what I actually meant since we can't edit.[/QUOTE]
I’ll allow it. That thing is a freaking eyesore

 

[JustPaws]

Apparently that quote infects your phone

 

[Ms Procrastinator]

Apparently that quote infects your phone

sorry🙁

 

[Doggo Labs]

What changed your mind on Paws and genny?

Some of Genny posts to me have been kind of fluffy and not actually getting village anywhere. I don't know if this is her normal style or not. If it is let me know. But something seems off and I can't place it. I've been rereading trying to find what it is, I'll let ya know if I find something concrete.

pocketed.

I feel like your avatar is judging mine.

I had that as my avatar in the past!

Paws keeps bringing up old games, I don't think there is much to it, and I don't see the point in it. It's a new game, old ones don't have much weight on the current one.

Cubs has been a wolf or chaos when joking around in the past. He's batting like 60-75% non-vill

But think of the d6 goldmine it will be

Don't remember the game just the trauma lol

 

[cubsrule4e]

Any reasoning? Have you played a game where mutts is a wolf?

No, and she seems to be acting exactly the same as other games. So that either leans her village, or it means her wolf and village metas are similar and I don’t have the game experience to tell the difference yet.

 

[emlady09]

My voting with someone who is suspected today, but wasn't really on my radar makes me wolfy? that's lame reasoning.
genny was not on my sketch list
stagg just felt wrong, but like i said i need to go read yesterday again after i catch up

Unlynch cubs
Lynch doggo
I could go barks or cubs again cuz I haven't actually liked the posts there so far.

And genny or cubs?

Well you possibly considered voting genny yesterday along with cubs, or barks. Just wanted to see what your thoughts were on it.

Lynch emlady

Started getting feels yesterday when she came on, posted one post saying she was here and asking what people wanted, and then disappearing again. Her two long posts don’t say much about her reads and seem to be asking questions, bringing up things that have already been addressed, or just commenting on things that have happened without saying thoughts on it.

I popped in real quick to let y'all know I was around yesterday. There wasn't much to go off of yesterday other than ziggy's behavior which is apparently typical and noted for future games.
Sorry i'm trying to write my thesis IRL on my only day off, also it's not typical for me to post dozens of posts or be on all day either. I work 10-12 hour days during the week, so when I'm MIA during the day now you know.
It also takes forever to go through these threads and I hate to make quick posts with out reading through to figure out wth might be going on.

Did anything happen to anyone over night? Asking because in past games people have had things happen to them (i.e. someone gets watched, someone uses an item to collect info).

 

[Barkley13]

Some of Genny posts to me have been kind of fluffy and not actually getting village anywhere. I don't know if this is her normal style or not. If it is let me know. But something seems off and I can't place it. I've been rereading trying to find what it is, I'll let ya know if I find something concrete.






Paws keeps bringing up old games, I don't think there is much to it, and I don't see the point in it. It's a new game, old ones don't have much weight on the current one.

What do you think of the analysis they have been doing?

 

[JustPaws]

I don't understand what is happening with this post[/QUOTE]
I messed up on the quoting. I quoted what I actually meant since we can't edit.[/QUOTE]
But what about that quote is why you are voting me?

 

[cubsrule4e]

Why are you allowed unlimited research on current players here from previous games, but no one is allowed to look into your playing history?

@Navilly ever going to address this?

 

[JustPaws]

I don't understand what is happening with this post

I messed up on the quoting. I quoted what I actually meant since we can't edit.[/QUOTE]
But what about that quote is why you are voting me?[/QUOTE]
@Ms Procrastinator

 

[Navilly]

@Navilly ever going to address this?

Nope, it's not game related, and I have no interest in answering it. Has no effect on my villagerness or wolfiness in this game.

 

[Animal Midwife]

D2 The People Want More Bread Unofficial Tally
Mutts (3) - AM, Lawpy, dubz
Paws (3) - Pippy, Nav, MsP
genny (1) - mutts
dubz (1) - dolphin
Stagg (1) - genny
emmy (1) - Barks

10/18 Voting
Lynch closes in ~7.5 hrs

 

[dolphin106258]

I'm not sure what you're saying here

It was a comment on something you did. Not really a question of anything. Except for the did you miss part, that was just me being snarky.

 

[Animal Midwife]

Lynch emlady

Started getting feels yesterday when she came on, posted one post saying she was here and asking what people wanted, and then disappearing again. Her two long posts don’t say much about her reads and seem to be asking questions, bringing up things that have already been addressed, or just commenting on things that have happened without saying thoughts on it.

I don't know, I was kind of liking how she's more active this game than previous ones.

 

[Barkley13]

Did anything happen to anyone over night? Asking because in past games people have had things happen to them (i.e. someone gets watched, someone uses an item to collect info).

Why does it matter to you?

 

[dolphin106258]

It was a comment on something you did. Not really a question of anything. Except for the did you miss part, that was just me being snarky.

a question OR anything. Gah I hate this.

 

[muttmanager]

There's a difference between having someone in neutral and having someone as wolf leaning. Justification of RNG is not an argument. So any other reasons why you have them as wolf leaning and not neutral?

Yea I know, which was why I made a neutral block. I’m fine with lessons as I am new but this is coming off condescending your question alone would have been fine.
Like I said im fine with him where he is for now and may look further into him once he posts more

 

[JustPaws]

And genny or cubs?

@emlady09
This quote was asking for an opinion in Genny or cubs. I wasn't including them in my own list.

Please go back and read cuz you are mischaracterizing me

 

[Navilly]

Yea I know, which was why I made a neutral block. I’m fine with lessons as I am new but this is coming off condescending your question alone would have been fine.
Like I said im fine with him where he is for now and may look further into him once he posts more

It wasn't condescending (or at least the goal wasn't condescension), it was me trying to explain a rebuttal to what you have currently provided, to help encourage you to provide more.

 

[genny]

Did anything happen to anyone over night? Asking because in past games people have had things happen to them (i.e. someone gets watched, someone uses an item to collect info).

 

[Navilly]

How many games does emlady have under their belt? Excuable comment if its only a couple/handful, less excusable if she is more experienced.

 

[JustPaws]

Did anything happen to anyone over night? Asking because in past games people have had things happen to them (i.e. someone gets watched, someone uses an item to collect info).

This is fishing big time

 

[cubsrule4e]

Nope, it's not game related, and I have no interest in answering it. Has no effect on my villagerness or wolfiness in this game.

Lol ok. You’re literally reading through previous games and applying peoples prior game play directly to how they’re playing this game.

If that’s not sketchy enough, it looks like you joined SDN solely for the purpose of playing WW?

 

[genny]

This is fishing big time

I read it more as "hey guys, look how hard I'm villaging right now!"

 

[Navilly]

Lol ok. You’re literally reading through previous games and applying peoples prior game play directly to how they’re playing this game.

If that’s not sketchy enough, it looks like you joined SDN solely for the purpose of playing WW?

Once again, you are bringing in stuff that is outside from the game, and detracting from it. If you have an issue with me, bring it to pm, this isn't the place to air out stuff.

 

[genny]

How many games does emlady have under their belt? Excuable comment if its only a couple/handful, less excusable if she is more experienced.

Very few.

 

[emlady09]

Why does it matter to you?

If something happened that could benefit the village it would be helpful to the whole class if they shared it? Considering we can't PM in this game (thanks Mel -_-), we have to have everything out in the open in order to better strategize as village. Not being able to PM puts village at a huge disadvantage for reasons just stated.

@emlady09
This quote was asking for an opinion in Genny or cubs. I wasn't including them in my own list.

Please go back and read cuz you are mischaracterizing me

Ok, thank you for clarifying that.

 

[dolphin106258]

I am & voted there and its feels from yesterday. No, I didn't pull a specific post


Yes - doggo and jboo are on my wolf leans but I would like to see more from them
I was not confident in any lynch and was fine staying on Stagg


Bc they were on the ziggy lynch as I stated yesterday i had them leaning wolfy
I was willing to give Paws time. Clearly since i put her in village-ish.
Pip- comments to ziggy about why she wasnt voting her, not voting at all but around @ lynch close,



Cute since theres not much to analyze on you.


I didnt refuse anything. I gave a whole list and am answering questions- theres enough manufactired shade you dont need to make up any more.

Historically, no one goes back and looks at my reads - Mel literally shot me and no one followed my lynch vote

Hey I am trying to give you time to respond to questions and things but when I read the thread your tone from last night to today felt distinctly different. Sorry if you don’t agree.

Some of Genny posts to me have been kind of fluffy and not actually getting village anywhere. I don't know if this is her normal style or not. If it is let me know. But something seems off and I can't place it. I've been rereading trying to find what it is, I'll let ya know if I find something concrete.






Paws keeps bringing up old games, I don't think there is much to it, and I don't see the point in it. It's a new game, old ones don't have much weight on the current one.

Nav is too but I don’t see you mentioning that?

 

[JustPaws]

Lol ok. You’re literally reading through previous games and applying peoples prior game play directly to how they’re playing this game.

If that’s not sketchy enough, it looks like you joined SDN solely for the purpose of playing WW?

I think this is a discussion that should be off this thread. We are an open community it's ok if he came just to play

 

[WildZoo]

It was a comment on something you did. Not really a question of anything. Except for the did you miss part, that was just me being snarky.

I get it was a comment, I'm not sure what your point was, or how it led to your read of me. Like I don't see what you're getting from that post.

 

[Navilly]

Very few.

Then personally, I am okay with that comment. Noob comment from a lack of exposure to varied mechanics. Agreed that if they were more experienced, than it would fall into either of the two interpretations provided.

 

[Dinashadow]

If something happened that could benefit the village it would be helpful to the whole class if they shared it? Considering we can't PM in this game (thanks Mel -_-), we have to have everything out in the open in order to better strategize as village. Not being able to PM puts village at a huge disadvantage for reasons just stated.

Yes but it also provides information to wolves especially on who is a good PR nk target

 

[emlady09]

This is my third game. 1. noobs in space, 2. lucky underwwear

 

[PippyPony]

Unlynch Paws

Lynch emlady

Have a pretty strong village read on barkbarks after just reading through the thread and like how she is pushing emlady, and that comment from emlady just made my eyebrows hit the ceiling.

 

[PippyPony]

Lol ok. You’re literally reading through previous games and applying peoples prior game play directly to how they’re playing this game.

If that’s not sketchy enough, it looks like you joined SDN solely for the purpose of playing WW?

I don't understand why you are fixated on this. Why is it sketchy that someone new to the site is doing research on how people in this game play?

It comes across as you being afraid of being examined, and given that all you have done so far is pile a weakly justified vote onto Zigzag in the middle of the pack, it is making you shoot up my wolf list like a rocket.

 

[dolphin106258]

I get it was a comment, I'm not sure what your point was, or how it led to your read of me. Like I don't see what you're getting from that post.

It felt like a completely off and unnecessary comment to make. But also if people just stop listening to ziggurat then people see yours and think oh wow Dubz making a solid comment to everyone to clean up their act. Also you found the lynch groce as you said but I think (unless I’m misremembering) that’s all you had to say until after the flip. Overall just felt SUPER off to me, and before me reading that I had you in neutral.

 

[dolphin106258]

It felt like a completely off and unnecessary comment to make. But also if people just stop listening to ziggurat then people see yours and think oh wow Dubz making a solid comment to everyone to clean up their act. Also you found the lynch groce as you said but I think (unless I’m misremembering) that’s all you had to say until after the flip. Overall just felt SUPER off to me, and before me reading that I had you in neutral.

To Zig....not ziggurat. RIP all my grammar and spelling.

 

[muttmanager]

Hey I am trying to give you time to respond to questions and things but when I read the thread your tone from last night to today felt distinctly different. Sorry if you don’t agree.

My tone changed bc I woke up and everyone on wanted to lynch me. I'm slightly calmer now & I answered all the questions

 

[PippyPony]

To Zig....not ziggurat. RIP all my grammar and spelling.

I dunno, I was kinda digging that as a new nickname for zigzag

 

[Ms Procrastinator]

I messed up on the quoting. I quoted what I actually meant since we can't edit.

But what about that quote is why you are voting me?[/QUOTE]
@Ms Procrastinator[/QUOTE]
Actually it's more about SAR and why she died. I like to look at what dead people were doing before they got killed. She didn't really do much on this thread. She just found you sus.

 

[WildZoo]

It felt like a completely off and unnecessary comment to make. But also if people just stop listening to ziggurat then people see yours and think oh wow Dubz making a solid comment to everyone to clean up their act. Also you found the lynch groce as you said but I think (unless I’m misremembering) that’s all you had to say until after the flip. Overall just felt SUPER off to me, and before me reading that I had you in neutral.

It was just a comment, because AM's votes tend to gain followers and I've seen again and again that her accuracy is not as good D1, or even before the first wolf is lynched. I was noting it as another example. You're blowing it way out of proportion. I make comments like that all the damn time.
I also switched my vote to mutts, and asked where the waffles were. I'm not going to shout from the rooftops telling people to switch on every vote I mildly disagree with. Sometimes it's better not to, if people feel less pressured to vote a certain way, the analysis is more pure.

 

[PippyPony]

I get it was a comment, I'm not sure what your point was, or how it led to your read of me. Like I don't see what you're getting from that post.

You are getting awfully defensive this game whenever anyone questions you even a teensy tiny bit. Yesterday you snapped at the newest nooblet for being presumptuous enough to drop a vote on you. Salamanders pee in your coffee or something?

 

[Animal Midwife]

I think this is a discussion that should be off this thread. We are an open community it's ok if he came just to play

tbh, that's pretty much all I do on here lol.

 

[WildZoo]

I'm raising my eyebrow at you right now @dolphin106258 because the way you're tripping over yourself to make a mountain out of a molehill right now reminds me a lot more of your wolf play than the solid village play I've come to expect from you