A question...What are the pros and cons of going to USUHS versus getting a military scholarship to attend any other medical school? It seems like both require the student to commit to medical service in the military, but I'm missing the finer points of distinction. Can anyone help me on that?
I am a current 3rd year USUHS med stud. Here are some of the advantages/disadvantages of USUHS vs HPSP as I see them. ( Broken down by curriculum phase and excluding finances)
Pre-clerkship- 18mo systems based lecture/lab similar to traditional 1st and 2nd year
This is largely curriculum dependent because you are comparing USUHS to the civilian school of your choice.
Adv.-
-Early exposure to Pt care. In the first week you walk over to Walter Reed to practice your interview skills on real patients and start learning and practicing physical exams on your classmates
- Video lecture base recording system, which lets you watch lectures on your own time at the speed of your choosing
- Freedom to learn as you please. Most lectures are not mandatory meaning you can sleep late most days and even not show up to school on others. Explore the MD/DC/VA area, golf, shop, take a mental day.
Caveat: You are still held accountable to the course material for labs/OSCEs
- FTX- The field training exercise gives you early exposure to some of the unique aspects of military medicine. Also you really get to know your other classmates well and build a strong support network.
- Our Office of Student Affairs has been very responsive in listening to our feedback and tweaking the new curriculum. The Class of 2015 gave feedback stating that they did not have enough dedicated time for Step 1 studying (just less than 4weeks). OSA in response added two weeks to Class of 2016 Step ! study period bringing it up to six weeks.
Clerkship- 12 mo (traditional 3rd year)
Adv.
- Rotations at military MTFs across the country (DC, Hawaii, California, Washington, Texas)
- Exposure to residency program directors who are interested in you and who will try to recruit you to their program
- Learning the Military EMR system
Dis.
- We take back to back shelf exams over the course of our assessment weeks, which is not ideal.
- Some of the military hospitals where we rotate are low-volume so you may not get as much case exposure as you would at some civilian hospitals.
STEP 1- 6wks dedicated study period
We take STEP 1 after clerkship year. So far the class ahead of us did better than previous classes. My class has mixed opinions.
Post-Clerkship- 12 4wk electives/sub-internships +Bushmaster+B3
Adv.-
- More AD rotations than HPSP to interview programs (only 1 interview is partially funded)
- Set up electives all over the world including (Germany, Spain, Phillipines)
- Many classmates move to the locations where they matched
- Research opportunities with capstone projects
- Bushmaster- the premier FTX at USUHS and completely unique to our curriculum
Dis.-
- Most of the Post clerkship rotations are unfunded so there is lots of competition for spots in DC/VA
Cons-
- Forced to do additional military training and deal with military culture while at Medical School (this is person dependent)
- Having to wear a uniform to class
- Being forced to go to class
I'm sure other people can give you better information but from my research this is what I have seen.
USUHS generally shelters you from many aspects of being in the military and allows you to primarly focus on being a student. Yes you still do PT tests and mandatory training, but it would be extremely rare that you would have to wake up at 0430 to make a 0530 formation, for example.
Being forced to go to class isn't necessarily true. You do have mandatory labs/lectures/small groups, but for the most part showing up to lecture is optional.