Cat's MeoWW - Game Thread

[ziggyandjazzy]

---

Members do not see this ad.

I like blue better.

Now this is just full blown wolf status. Blue is the worst color.

Now who's not reading? I said if genny is third party, and Im a wolf, who is the other one?

No you didn't. you said, word for word "Lets temporarily assume genny is 3rd party, who would your other lynch choice be and why?" I also directly quoted this above.

 

[cubsrule4e]

Now this is just full blown wolf status. Blue is the worst color.

No you didn't. you said, word for word "Lets temporarily assume genny is 3rd party, who would your other lynch choice be and why?" I also directly quoted this above.

Your OTHER LYNCH CHOICE, you are currently voting for me, friend.

 

[ziggyandjazzy]

Your OTHER LYNCH CHOICE, you are currently voting for me, friend.

village:
me, acanth, coop, capri, barks, dolpho, miz

neutral/tbd:
allie, cubs, dina, Lawpy, sporty
prob feel the worst about cubs and sporty from this list

wolfy:
genny


oh and
###contingency Lynch genny###

This hasn't changed much since no one has flipped who hasn't been in my village pile since posting this. Might feel worse about lawper then sporty tho, who knows

 

[ziggyandjazzy]

Looking at the D5 tally when genny was lynched.

I don't think much can be analyzed from that tally as genny was dead in the water no matter what, but idk

I more find it suspicious people voting for acanth, considering how ****ing suspicious genny was, and that I had been shouting from the rooftops that she was village since literally d1. who knows

 

[genny]

Now this is just full blown wolf status. Blue is the worst color.

It's my favorite color.

 

[cubsrule4e]

This hasn't changed much since no one has flipped who hasn't been in my village pile since posting this. Might feel worse about lawper then sporty tho, who knows

Re: This. Going back to D1, Acanth, in your village pile, had been going hard after Pippy thinking there was a wolf on that lynch, what if she just picked the wrong one to go after? I still think the others are village (read: i DONT buy this theory), but thats another point of contention that may be hiding a wolf, if we are trying to collaborate and discuss the validity of all the tinfoils.

Also this is absolutely hilarious to me 🤣

I don't feel good about lawp's putzing around here at the end of lynch

 

[ziggyandjazzy]

Re: This. Going back to D1, Acanth, in your village pile, had been going hard after Pippy thinking there was a wolf on that lynch, what if she just picked the wrong one to go after? I still think the others are village (read: i DONT buy this theory), but thats another point of contention that may be hiding a wolf, if we are trying to collaborate and discuss the validity of all the tinfoils.

Also this is absolutely hilarious to me 🤣

I've also said for several days that lawper is of highest suspicion to me of the people on that lynch. I mean, I welcome discussion but this just sort of feels like you're trying to throw out a bunch of possibilities and sees what sticks atm. like, back to the lacking conviction thing.

what are your actual reads?

 

[cubsrule4e]

I've also said for several days that lawper is of highest suspicion to me of the people on that lynch. I mean, I welcome discussion but this just sort of feels like you're trying to throw out a bunch of possibilities and sees what sticks atm. like, back to the lacking conviction thing.

what are your actual reads?

I would agree with that.

Here you go, I'll even do the coloring everyone likes

Genny - Wolf. Alpha vs 1x avoidance? I think as a group we decide to try this lynch again or not
Allie - All the blocking discussion, extremely quiet in the beginning but has picked up activity since her name has been thrown around more, in the middle of the genny lynch

Why do people think all of a sudden that wolves have brains smaller than a walnut?

Allie, if a wolf was blocked from doing a night kill...and they knew who the blocker was because you said it was you...

1) why do you think they would have the same blocked wolf attempt the kill again? That sounds like a good way to be caught again somehow

2) why are you alive this morning when 2 other roles -- one of whom appeared to be providing wolves with murky seering ammo -- are dead?

Dina - Definitely still suspicious on the multiple PM role thing, in the middle of the genny lynch, and I dont know.... it just seems in my mind like she fits well with genny lol. And if there's a wolf amongst the PMers and its not Dina, its probably...
Capri- But I still have the Nav info in the back of my mind from earlier which is keeping me hesitant here. Maybe this far along with no other context it doesnt even hold any weight. Strong vouches from those in the PM world, but my most likely guess at a wolf if there is one in the gossip club
Sporty - If Allie isnt a wolf, this looks pretty bad. Was in the middle of the genny pile on lynch. Throwing some Cubs shade earlier since village hasnt seemed to be getting anywhere which usually picks up some traction (and it did, at least with you) and would be a great deflection to take any acute suspicion off of her
MelCoop - When is Mel not to be under suspicious? Another member of the gossip club
Lawper - If theres a wolf on the kata lynch, this is the one Id pick. Plus I cant get over that allie putzing around comment lol
Ziggy, Dolphin
Barks

 

[ziggyandjazzy]

d7 cattitude tally
Dina (1) - capri
cubs (2) - sporty, ziggySARdust
genny (1) - cubs

voting: 4/11
Lynch close: ~6.5 hrs

 

[Lawpy]

I'm thinking but for now

Lynch Dina

 

[SportPonies]

So if youre saying you dont really have anything better right now let me ask you:

You said last night you might go back to genny today. As you said, youre one of the veterans here. Does the fact that acanth only had a one time avoidance and flipped village make you think genny is actually an alpha? I think the majority agrees she's probably a wolf, or third party at minimum if thats a thing, but would it be worth it to challenge her claim again today, or look elsewhere?

What happened that caused you to be less suspicious of allie?

I think there might be a wolf somewhere in the gossip girls group, and if theres not, then maybe Capri has been onto something with Dina? I agree with barks and others that a pair of neighbors, plus two PMers, while certainly not provable, is more likely than not to contain a wolf role.

So I get your thought in the sense that I'm not sure where to vote right now either given this scenario, but I think there's definitely a few good candidates to look into further.

I said I would go back to genny IF we flipped a wolf. We did not.

I think I may have seen this on the thread but cant remember. Do we know if pippy got to choose her PM partner, or is the neighbor role already established between two people?

No, it was preestablished.

Ooooo have fun! Yes I agree completely about the Genny thing, but I'm very wary of yet another lynch avoidance. I'm thinking alpha type thing.

I think pip said something about sporty but also something about allieh, which sporty kept bringing up and then suddenly dropped? Maybe she just didn't get around to it and I'm overthinking things.

Yes, pip said she was suspicious of me right before she died. I was also suspicious of her.... literally all game. But not enough to believe she was a wolf. Just didn’t trust her enough to move her out of neutral. Reread some of my posts and you’ll see me make comments relating to our neighbor status

I would agree with that.

Here you go, I'll even do the coloring everyone likes

Genny - Wolf. Alpha vs 1x avoidance? I think as a group we decide to try this lynch again or not
Allie - All the blocking discussion, extremely quiet in the beginning but has picked up activity since her name has been thrown around more, in the middle of the genny lynch


Dina - Definitely still suspicious on the multiple PM role thing, in the middle of the genny lynch, and I dont know.... it just seems in my mind like she fits well with genny lol. And if there's a wolf amongst the PMers and its not Dina, its probably...
Capri- But I still have the Nav info in the back of my mind from earlier which is keeping me hesitant here. Maybe this far along with no other context it doesnt even hold any weight. Strong vouches from those in the PM world, but my most likely guess at a wolf if there is one in the gossip club
Sporty - If Allie isnt a wolf, this looks pretty bad. Was in the middle of the genny pile on lynch. Throwing some Cubs shade earlier since village hasnt seemed to be getting anywhere which usually picks up some traction (and it did, at least with you) and would be a great deflection to take any acute suspicion off of her
MelCoop - When is Mel not to be under suspicious? Another member of the gossip club
Lawper - If theres a wolf on the kata lynch, this is the one Id pick. Plus I cant get over that allie putzing around comment lol
Ziggy, Dolphin
Barks

I was NOT on the genny Lynch my dude.

 

[dolphin106258]

Lynch Allie

Because why not. I am suspicious of cubs slightly but when I look at the game and in context of everyone as a whole it’s like ugh allie and genny still bother me, obviously if everyone can come to a consensus and say yes let’s try genny again then I’ll move but I’d like to have my vote on someone with mild suspicion levels until I can go back and dig up something on D1 I didn’t like.

Also @cubsrule4e why is zig not the same color as barks? How is one more village than the other?? Also it’s these tiny inconsistencies that really bother me about you atm but I’m trying really hard not to go with those feelings.

 

[cubsrule4e]

I said I would go back to genny IF we flipped a wolf. We did not.


No, it was preestablished.


Yes, pip said she was suspicious of me right before she died. I was also suspicious of her.... literally all game. But not enough to believe she was a wolf. Just didn’t trust her enough to move her out of neutral. Reread some of my posts and you’ll see me make comments relating to our neighbor status


I was NOT on the genny Lynch my dude.

So then the tally was wrong? Who did you vote for? Acanth?

 

[cubsrule4e]

Lynch Allie

Because why not. I am suspicious of cubs slightly but when I look at the game and in context of everyone as a whole it’s like ugh allie and genny still bother me, obviously if everyone can come to a consensus and say yes let’s try genny again then I’ll move but I’d like to have my vote on someone with mild suspicion levels until I can go back and dig up something on D1 I didn’t like.

Also @cubsrule4e why is zig not the same color as barks? How is one more village than the other?? Also it’s these tiny inconsistencies that really bother me about you atm but I’m trying really hard not to go with those feelings.

I have an extra village point for barks for a reason I will reveal later if it becomes necessary, but I wouldn’t read too much into that. The green people are green.

 

[ziggyandjazzy]

Holy **** I just saw a couple sloths
Also
###unlynch cubs
Lynch genny###=

 

[PippyPony]

Holy **** I just saw a couple sloths

****
Liked for spontaneous sloths
*****

 

[genny]

Holy **** I just saw a couple sloths
Also
###unlynch cubs
Lynch genny###=

2-toed or 3-toed?

 

[Barkley13]

Just curious, how many nights have happened since allie claimed blocker?

 

[Coopah]

lynch paws

I don't really have a lot of time right now but I will bite on Nav's info especially since I had feels for paws yesterday. Promise I'll have lots more time this weekend

****lynch paws *****

######lynch paws ######

For reasons, I think she should at least still be pressured

Votes Paws three days in a row

Why are your panties in such a bunch over one vote. It's clear with a little over an hour until deadline, not many people are following my vote soooo why are you so worried

Paws was blocked last night, that's one of the reasons I want her pressured

Shade for paws. It's interesting because she had been voting for paws for three days and just blocked her last night?

Interesting... If you are so important not sure why you didn't mention sooner that you were blocked

Why should someone say when their blocked? especially if they're an important role? That tells people that they have an action and couldn't use it, especially in a game where notifications are rare

Why do people think all of a sudden that wolves have brains smaller than a walnut?

Allie, if a wolf was blocked from doing a night kill...and they knew who the blocker was because you said it was you...

1) why do you think they would have the same blocked wolf attempt the kill again? That sounds like a good way to be caught again somehow

2) why are you alive this morning when 2 other roles -- one of whom appeared to be providing wolves with murky seering ammo -- are dead?

This is an excellent point by Pippy and I'm still not sure why she's alive tbh

1) I don't care if she didn't attempt the kill again, she may have had another ability that I could have blocked...that's not rocket science blocking mentality there
2) Good question and interesting that you've waited until 4pm to have that lightbulb moment

Throwing shade for a legitimate question not the best defense

I will probs be NKed but if I'm not, by all means have at it

WHY ARE YOU STILL ALIVE?
I don't care that you're sketchtastic a blocker is a serious threat to the wolves, you should be beyond dead right now. Even for some of the no kill nights where Miz was successful at protecting dolphin, why wasn't it you? I suppose you could've blocked genny but it really rubs me the wrong way.

Piss off

Then she starts to get feisty (which I'm currently reading as defensive)

I think genny is lying/bluffing and is a wolf whom when acted upon blocks that person the following night.

Unless someone else wants to admit they acted on me last night.

Then there's this stuff, which is honestly really confusing because it's the first we've heard of it in the game

I'm not sure. Either wolves have their own sort of blocking mechanism or we have a bone headed villager who doesn't trust me and wants village to lose out on the possibility of getting lucky and blocking NKs.

Then there's this comment, assuming allieh is village why on earth would she think there's ANOTHER village blocker? It makes no sense.

Overall it's too sketchtastic for me

Lynch Allieh

 

[Coopah]

Holy **** I just saw a couple sloths
Also
###unlynch cubs
Lynch genny###=

Like outside? Randomly? Wow!

 

[ziggyandjazzy]

2-toed or 3-toed?

2!

Like outside? Randomly? Wow!

Yep!! They are hanging out at the faculty air bnb


Also I will say I think it's poor logic to try to flip Allie before genny and I am side eyeing all of you for this. There is very little chance they are both wolves. Allie claimed she blocked genny, remember? So if genny flips wolf there's very little chance Allie is a wolf. If Allie is in fact a village blocker, she may be one of our last hopes to block a kill and automatically discover who a wolf is. Why should we be lynching her before genny again? Oh right, we shouldn't be.

 

[Barkley13]

This is an excellent point by Pippy and I'm still not sure why she's alive tbh

This is why I was curious about how many nights it has been

 

[Coopah]

2!

Yep!!


Also I will say I think it's poor logic to try to flip Allie before genny and I am side eyeing all of you for this. There is very little chance they are both wolves. Allie claimed she blocked genny, remember? So if genny flips wolf there's very little chance Allie is a wolf. If Allie is in fact a village blocker, she may be one of our last hopes to block a kill and automatically discover who a wolf is. Why should we be lynching her before genny again? Oh right, we shouldn't be.

I would be more than down to flip genny, as I've said before my concern is that she won't flip. If she only had one lynch avoidance why would she be acting so confident? I dunno dude maybe I'm wildly off base but especially if Genny is a wolf whose only ability is extra lives/alpha, why wouldn't allieh block her for cred?

 

[Coopah]

This is why I was curious about how many nights it has been

I just double checked she revealed D3, what day is today? I dunno, but it's been a lot

 

[Coopah]

d7 cattitude tally
Dina (1) - capri
cubs (2) - sporty, ziggySARdust
genny (1) - cubs

voting: 4/11
Lynch close: ~6.5 hrs

Apparently it's now D7

 

[allieh8607]

Votes Paws three days in a row


Shade for paws. It's interesting because she had been voting for paws for three days and just blocked her last night?

Why should someone say when their blocked? especially if they're an important role? That tells people that they have an action and couldn't use it, especially in a game where notifications are rare

This is an excellent point by Pippy and I'm still not sure why she's alive tbh

Throwing shade for a legitimate question not the best defense

WHY ARE YOU STILL ALIVE?
I don't care that you're sketchtastic a blocker is a serious threat to the wolves, you should be beyond dead right now. Even for some of the no kill nights where Miz was successful at protecting dolphin, why wasn't it you? I suppose you could've blocked genny but it really rubs me the wrong way.

Then she starts to get feisty (which I'm currently reading as defensive)

Then there's this stuff, which is honestly really confusing because it's the first we've heard of it in the game

Then there's this comment, assuming allieh is village why on earth would she think there's ANOTHER village blocker? It makes no sense.

Overall it's too sketchtastic for me

Lynch Allieh

Bravo, what a compelling case you've made

 

[ziggyandjazzy]

My little runty friend
(How could you not listen to this adorable little face?)

 

[Lawpy]

View attachment 272248
View attachment 272249
My little runty friend
(How could you not listen to this adorable little face?)

😍 kittens 😍 kittens 😍 kittens 😍

 

[capri1722]

Bravo, what a compelling case you've made

Not sure why the sarcastic tone when you're right.

 

[allieh8607]

Not sure why the sarcastic tone when you're right.

soooo, lynch me?

 

[capri1722]

soooo, lynch me?

Ask and ye shall receive 🙂
unlynch Dina
lynch Allie

 

[allieh8607]

lynch cubs

 

[ziggyandjazzy]

d7 cattitude tally
Dina (1) - lawp
cubs (2) - sporty, allie
genny (2) - cubs, ziggySARdust
allie (3) - dolph, coop, capri

allie is in the lead!
voting: 8/11
Lynch close: ~4 hrs

 

[ziggyandjazzy]

I would be more than down to flip genny, as I've said before my concern is that she won't flip.

Ok so I asked the mods if we could no Lynch. they said no

today: 11 people. 3 bad, 8 good
- ok so let's assume 3 wolves and mislynch and NK
+ tomorrow: 3 W, 6V
+ next day: 3w, 4V and lylo
- let's assume we Lynch genny today and it doesnt work, besides that the same
+ tomorrow: 3w, 7v
+ next day: 3w, 5v and mylo
but we can't do mylo so it's just as bad as lylo. this shows NO detriment to lynching genny today, if she is alpha, NKs go through, and there are 3 wolves

now let's try it out assuming there is a third party
- assume mislynches and NK go through
+ tomorrow: 2w, 6v, 1n
+ next day: 2w, 4v, 1n and mylo
- assume try to Lynch genny and it doesnt work
+ tomorrow: 2w, 7v, 1n
+ next day: 2w, 5v, 1n
+ day after: 2w, 3v, 1n


SOOO basically this shows that lynching genny, if she has a Lynch avoidance, won't be to our detriment if there are 3 wolves as we would be on the same path to end game either way

If she only had one lynch avoidance why would she be acting so confident?

WIFOM. she couldve cultivated this

I dunno dude maybe I'm wildly off base but especially if Genny is a wolf whose only ability is extra lives/alpha, why wouldn't allieh block her for cred?

this does feel wildly off base to me. you think allie would bus genny that much??
I dont think allie and genny can both be wolves but I could be wrong.
I could see one as 3rd party and 1 as a wolf but I think it is strategically smarter to try to Lynch genny today, even if it doesnt work, which I am not convinced of. lynching a village blocker who may be our last home to help find a wolf/extend the game would be awesome

 

[Lawpy]

Unlynch dina
Lynch genny

 

[dolphin106258]

Fine

Unlynch Allie
Lynch genny

 

[ziggyandjazzy]

Ok now it's freaking me out people are listening not used to this


@allieh8607 you didn't answer whether you can block tonight or no?

 

[allieh8607]

Ok now it's freaking me out people are listening not used to this


@allieh8607 you didn't answer whether you can block tonight or no?

Trying to decide if it's safer for me to keep that to myself or not

 

[Coopah]

Ok now it's freaking me out people are listening not used to this


@allieh8607 you didn't answer whether you can block tonight or no?

Freaks me out that it happened within ten minutes or so but I see no downside! Let's lynch us a wolf

Lynch Genny

as a side note I really appreciate that you broke that down, thanks 😍

 

[cubsrule4e]

Legit picture of my friends cat, Zelda. She told me “The bed was made when I left this morning” 🤣

 

[genny]

🙄
lynch genny

 

[dolphin106258]

Ok now it's freaking me out people are listening not used to this


@allieh8607 you didn't answer whether you can block tonight or no?

When you broke it down it made sense so I figured why not. I’d rather lynch my most Wolfy feel everyday and that is genny.

 

[dolphin106258]

🙄
lynch genny

 

[Coopah]

Freaks me out that it happened within ten minutes or so but I see no downside! Let's lynch us a wolf

Lynch Genny

as a side note I really appreciate that you broke that down, thanks 😍

Shoot forgot to unlynch Allieh Lynch Genny

 

[genny]

This is going to work out so well for us villagers.

 

[ziggyandjazzy]

@dolphin106258 could you list out the nights you asked your question again?
was it n2 how many wolves there are? and then what night # did you ask about conversion and # of non vil?

 

[ziggyandjazzy]

This is going to work out so well for us villagers.

"us villagers" 🙄

 

[ziggyandjazzy]

also leaving to go toading, have fun y'all

 

[genny]

today: 11 people. 3 bad, 8 good
- ok so let's assume 3 wolves and mislynch and NK
+ tomorrow: 3 W, 6V
+ next day: 3w, 4V and lylo
- let's assume we Lynch genny today and it doesnt work, besides that the same
+ tomorrow: 3w, 7v
+ next day: 3w, 5v and mylo
but we can't do mylo so it's just as bad as lylo. this shows NO detriment to lynching genny today, if she is alpha, NKs go through, and there are 3 wolves

now let's try it out assuming there is a third party
- assume mislynches and NK go through
+ tomorrow: 2w, 6v, 1n
+ next day: 2w, 4v, 1n and mylo
- assume try to Lynch genny and it doesnt work
+ tomorrow: 2w, 7v, 1n
+ next day: 2w, 5v, 1n
+ day after: 2w, 3v, 1n


SOOO basically this shows that lynching genny, if she has a Lynch avoidance, won't be to our detriment if there are 3 wolves as we would be on the same path to end game either way

So I can't believe I have to be the one to point this out to you, but if you lynch me and it doesn't work (which it won't), then the village is in a worse position than if they lynch a villager today.
See the bolded above. With 3 wolves and 5 villagers statistically there is a greater chance of lynching a villager at mylo (vs lynching a villager at lylo).
With 2 wolves and a neutral, you end up with a situation where you have to hope the neutral doesn't vote with the wolves. Do you really think neutral is going to vote with village?

 

[dolphin106258]

@dolphin106258 could you list out the nights you asked your question again?
was it n2 how many wolves there are? and then what night # did you ask about conversion and # of non vil?

N2: was how many wolves are left
N3: asked if there was a third party chaos and the question wasn’t answered
N4: asked if conversion had occurred was told to ask again at a later time
N5: how many non villagers left: got three.
N6: was night cancel