CHOOSE YOUR OWWN III - Game Thread

[Lawpy]

---

Members do not see this ad.

Yeet Lumi

No offense, but I really don't like how you came on here demanding that a bunch of people role-reveal. In addition to claiming you're too busy to explain why you want to endanger town PRs by having a mass role-reveal on D1. That, plus the probability that you're lying about being the goo (since I cannot see any actual benefit to Wonder also lying) means you're our best bet for getting scum voted out on D1.

How are you reading chaos?

 

[Lawpy]

Well I guess I don't really know what I'm waiting for at this point
Vote lumi

Same question pls

 

[Animal Midwife]

Day 1 Yeet Tally
Stagg () -
mkg () -
O2 () -
genny () -
True () -
dubz (1) - Lumi
Chaos (4) - Lawpy, shorty, mkg, Zenge
Lumi (7) - True, Wonder, Chaos, alissa, dubz, O2, alley
mkg () -
Lawpy (1) - PSV

13/16
yeet close in ~23.5 hours

 

[Lawpy]

Also going to tag @LuminousLag

 

[Truenamer]

refrains from responding to this post

I agree, it was very difficult to not respond to that

Also, on the topic of Dubz's alignment: as far as I know, literally no one in this game is good at reading her. I in particular am terrible at it. I'm just going to happily go along with her master plan until we get some kind of evidence that we can work off of.

 

[alleycat03]

Fake Claim Zoo: Electric Googaloo,

I'm ****ing cackling now omfg

 

[alleycat03]

I agree, it was very difficult to not respond to that

Also, on the topic of Dubz's alignment: as far as I know, literally no one in this game is good at reading her. I in particular am terrible at it. I'm just going to happily go along with her master plan until we get some kind of evidence that we can work off of.

pssssst doesn't Zenge have the only Dubz reading card, which was laminated and mailed to him?

 

[WorthlessOxygen]

How are you reading chaos?

Same question pls

Not great but I'd rather flip lumi first

 

[WildZoo]

I agree, it was very difficult to not respond to that

Also, on the topic of Dubz's alignment: as far as I know, literally no one in this game is good at reading her. I in particular am terrible at it. I'm just going to happily go along with her master plan until we get some kind of evidence that we can work off of.

Inb4 Zenge angery

 

[Truenamer]

pssssst doesn't Zenge have the only Dubz reading card, which was laminated and mailed to him?

Hmmmm

@Zenge142, can you be the Dubzometer?

 

[supershorty]

I agree, it was very difficult to not respond to that

Also, on the topic of Dubz's alignment: as far as I know, literally no one in this game is good at reading her. I in particular am terrible at it. I'm just going to happily go along with her master plan until we get some kind of evidence that we can work off of.

Jesus I am intensely triggered by this post SO BADLY

You said stuff just like this when you guys were wolfing together 50% of the time. And I believe in Globe too?

twitch

 

[WildZoo]

Jesus I am intensely triggered by this post SO BADLY

Help, I can't remember if he makes his "I can't read Dubz so I'm gonna exist in her pocket" posts more as wolf or village lol

 

[WildZoo]

Also since when do I have a master plan? And why haven't I seen it??

 

[supershorty]

Help, I can't remember if he makes his "I can't read Dubz so I'm gonna exist in her pocket" posts more as wolf or village lol

I'll look into it after I have dinner.

 

[genny]

Engaged

Spoiler: how i picture lawpy

 

[WildZoo]

I'll look into it after I have dinner.

I just saw your ninja edit
concerned

 

[WorthlessOxygen]

refrains from responding to this post

I agree, it was very difficult to not respond to that

These look suspiciously like responses

 

[WildZoo]

These look suspiciously like responses

Oof, guess I'm outted

 

[genny]

Fake Claim Zoo: Electric Googaloo

i was momentarily confused about maybe missing a dubz claim

 

[supershorty]

i was momentarily confused about maybe missing a dubz claim

I mean...

I AM THE BLACK GOO

😛

 

[Viscernable]

Anybody know if there's a possible role that benefits from being voted out?

Looked for one last game when we were wondering this and couldn’t find anything. Unless I’m thinking of looking for a scum role that would be dangerous surviving for another day with that whole Zenge stumpification brouhaha. But in any case, closest I can see is:

- 1-shot townie who doesn’t want to test their luck as a survivor - disproven due to discards
- supersaint or oneshot yeetproof who has decided their death will be worth the temporary chaos and taking an extra cycle/taking out someone with them
- saulus or judas who wants the role shift. would probably just claim oneshot yeetproof or saulus
- my favourite: condemner persona non-grata. A DIY jester

 

[alleycat03]

PSV and shorty I'm feeling okay about rn, but I don't remember seeing why PSV is voting for Lawpy

I'm agreeing with a lot of Dubz's posts, but wolf!dubz is very hard to differentiate from village!dubz

Lawpy feels fine too, has some unique insight and contributions

Zenge is lurky with random thoughts, some pingy and some valid points

Alissa's posts have been a bit pingy

Chaos and Lumi are both scummy based on their fake claims

Vis feels fine right now

MKG is a bit scummy, but I know I am **** at reading her, so take that with a grain of salt

True has been kinda pingy, especially early on, so going to keep an eye on him

Nothing game related is coming to mind about WO2, but didn't see anything scummy yet from him

Wonder's alignment is contingent upon the lumi flip, but I am thinking she is pro-village based on her claim of black goo

No posts yet from Stagg

Genny has been entertaining but nothing AI yet


I think that's everyone, I'm sorry if someone wasn't memorable enough in my brain and I forgot them

 

[alleycat03]

I'll look into it after I have dinner.

shorty pls it's 9:30pm

 

[supershorty]

shorty pls it's 9:30pm

Late dinner on silks nights pls

 

[Lawpy]

Late dinner on silks nights pls

Displeased

 

[Viscernable]

Please catch up with the thread before making accusations like this? I have been very open about the three roles I got randed— Village Lover x2, and a scum role I took the PR from.

If I can’t make comments before reading all 600 posts, then I think you can read literally the very next line before getting all bent out of shape, friend

 

[Lawpy]

Chaos and Lumi are both scummy based on their fake claims

I see 🤔

 

[Lawpy]

Yeet Lumi

No offense, but I really don't like how you came on here demanding that a bunch of people role-reveal. In addition to claiming you're too busy to explain why you want to endanger town PRs by having a mass role-reveal on D1. That, plus the probability that you're lying about being the goo (since I cannot see any actual benefit to Wonder also lying) means you're our best bet for getting scum voted out on D1.

I think I feel ok about alleys from this post. Because it’s at least more insightful.

 

[alleycat03]

I see 🤔

Am I wrong??

I understand what you're saying in disagreement, but I legit don't get why wonder would risk that and not actually have the black goo aff

 

[Viscernable]

No this isn't accurate. Different affiliations have different meanings for Alpha, from looking through the list.

Spoiler

Alpha Goon (105)​

You are an Alpha Goon.

Abilities

• During the Day, you may vote for whomever you want eliminated.
• Factional Kill: The Mafia may kill one player per Night.
• Factional Communication: If there are other Mafia-aligned players, there will be a Mafia QT that can be used pre-game and during the Night.

Win Condition

• You win when all players without a Mafia wincon are wiped out and at least one Mafia-aligned player is still alive (or nothing can prevent the same).

Alpha Werewolf (112)​

You are a Alpha Werewolf.

Abilities

• During the Day, you may vote for whomever you want eliminated.
• Factional Kill: The Werewolves may kill one player per Night.
• Factional Communication: If there are other Werewolf-aligned players, there will be a Werewolf QT that can be used pre-game and during the Night.
• Alpha: You will investigate as "Not Guilty" if investigated by a Seer.

Win Condition

• You win when all players without a Werewolf wincon are wiped out and at least one Werewolf-aligned player is still alive (or nothing can prevent the same).

Nope, alpha purely means “will investigate as not guilty if investigated by a seer”, but all mafia/town/aliens/etc except werewolves and hirsute also will investigate as “not guilty” to a seer, so the ability does nothing when not attached to werewolf aff

 

[Lawpy]

Am I wrong??

I understand what you're saying in disagreement, but I legit don't get why wonder would risk that and not actually have the black goo aff

No i got the answer to my earlier question asking for your chaos read

 

[Viscernable]

I'm not entirely sure how I feel about mkg given the delay in her revealing what card she used for her aff. Felt weird in particular that she replied to alissa about how she had been planning to post it but then waited to be directly asked again before actually posting it. Made me go hmmm.

She’s an aff vampire, she can only reveal her aff card when invited in

 

[genny]

I think I feel ok about alleys from this post. Because it’s at least more insightful.

really? I thought it was over-explainy in a wolfy sort of way. just that particular post, i don't think anything else she's said has pinged me thus far.

 

[Lawpy]

really? I thought it was over-explainy in a wolfy sort of way. just that particular post, i don't think anything else she's said has pinged me thus far.

It goes beyond than just following Wondy’s claim

 

[genny]

It goes beyond than just following Wondy’s claim

yeah, kind of like "why, yes, officer, i do have a license to drive this bus"

 

[potentialsheltervet]

I have so many quotes to respond to I shall be breaking them into bite sized tidbits.

I think it's interesting that you actually thought of the discard optics, because I didn't really think of that. I just picked the role and ability I wanted from my 3 options

Me too. I only looked at the list of roles to check definitions but I had no idea what the numbers meant.

Here's the thing about D1 - I like to be right. And D1 is the hardest to analyze because there's the least to go on. So I always feel like I get more out of listening reading than I do from mud slinging and musings. Which I get isn't the most "pro village" way to approach the game per se... but if I'm not wrong about where my vote ends up at the end of the day, then I'm pretty happy. Especially when I get to pull out "ThE cUBs vOtE wAs wEiRd ZeNgEs!!! WhY wOuLd YoU sHeEp PsV?!?!?!?!" anytime I want now. 🤣

But since you sheeped me, that makes me the shepherd and therefore all my reads are law. *bangs gavel* Dismissed.

are you asking me for more shenanigans? i'm fresh out. i can give you a fakeclaim though!

Idk genny, I think we're being rate limited on the fakeclaims.

 

[potentialsheltervet]

Who doesn't peel carrots??

Freshly... me. After very firmly arguing all carrots should be peeled, I have now eaten two without peeling, just a good wash, and it's the same but less energy and no carrot bits everywhere.

Must be a delayed effect, some of those giant logs looked pretty solid.

You know shorty... I thought you were talking about dog poop here.

goolag

This is the winner.

Intriguing, why?

I mentioned it briefly but essentially I'm testing the waters on his response to me voting him and others' responses to me voting him. Admittedly I think both times I've played with Lawpy I was wolfing and knew he was village so my independent read of him is... untested. I'm not married to this vote, though Lawpy might get engaged to it. Essentially I found his response to Wonder also claiming goo to be interesting in a "hmm" sort of way.

 

[potentialsheltervet]

I've never actually eaten eggplant before

Hehehehe

Help, I can't remember if he makes his "I can't read Dubz so I'm gonna exist in her pocket" posts more as wolf or village lol

Maybe equal amounts of both? Recency bias makes me think Globe but he said similar things in StardeWW as well. LiterWWary of course doesn't count. So that would make Globe the only useful game there for wolf comparison.

 

[potentialsheltervet]

Am I wrong??

I understand what you're saying in disagreement, but I legit don't get why wonder would risk that and not actually have the black goo aff

And if none of them are goo, then there's the potential for yet another person to claim they're the real goo. Not everybody can be Dirty Dan. Sometimes you have to be Pinhead Larry.
If they were all gooning together and this was an attempt to create the world's most impressive WIFOM then I would tip my hat, but I don't think that's the case here and forcing a three way Thunderdome with your fellow scum is probably not the most effective game strategy.

 

[potentialsheltervet]

Won't the real goo player please stand up, please stand up, please stand up?

 

[WildZoo]

he said similar things in StardeWW

Did he really? That would be odd since it was only the second game we'd played together and there would have been no reason yet for him to think he couldn't read me.

Mostly I'm curious if he said such things in MarWWel which I guess means I should go look 👀

 

[supershorty]

Did he really? That would be odd since it was only the second game we'd played together and there would have been no reason yet for him to think he couldn't read me.

Mostly I'm curious if he said such things in MarWWel which I guess means I should go look 👀

I think he did say similar things in Stardeww, but I have now shoved grilled cheese in my mouth and will go peruse.

 

[supershorty]

Did he really? That would be odd since it was only the second game we'd played together and there would have been no reason yet for him to think he couldn't read me.

Mostly I'm curious if he said such things in MarWWel which I guess means I should go look 👀

Wasn't MarWWel the first game he played, though? He wouldn't really have any basis for how to read you one way or the other.

 

[WildZoo]

Wasn't MarWWel the first game he played, though? He wouldn't really have any basis for how to read you one way or the other.

No, his first game was BoWWling. MarWWel was the only other game we played together as village besides BoWWling, I think. Could be blacking out on another one.

 

[WildZoo]

Oh there was another one, it was Mountains

 

[supershorty]

Hmm, in StardeWW, at least early on, it was more hard-defending Dubz as being village than saying he couldn't read her.

Spoiler

Dubz is in my strong village lean bucket because I spent more one-on-one time with her in the last game than anyone, and her vibe is exactly the same.

Sure, but it's day one, it's literally all just vibes and feels. Just saying that I will be mildly more surprised if Dubz is a wolf than the average person.

From what I've been told, by both Dubz and others, her wolf and village play are extremely similar. So she might be neutral out of caution.

Very curious about your Dubz reasoning, she's near the top of my "probably village" list at the moment.

I've discussed my feelings about them previously, but I got to know Dubz well in deadchat last game and she hasn't given me a single non-village ping this entire game. Maybe she's just totally outclassing me, always a possibility, but I would be very surprised if she's a wolf.

And I'm pretending that I have an AM soul read until proven otherwise.

For those who didn't play this game, True/Dubz was v/w, respectively.

 

[Zenge142]

Now I just need to get you on team blue cheese

I guess this is your rebellious streak.

I think right now I feel best about Lawpy and Vis.

i agree with this.

Kinda rude to let everyone else do the work and contribute on D1 and you just reap the rewards from lurking 😛

To be clear, I’m not sheeping other peoples hard work. I’m watching for interactions to play out and get as much info as I can before coming to a decision.

pssssst doesn't Zenge have the only Dubz reading card, which was laminated and mailed to him?

Hmmmm

@Zenge142, can you be the Dubzometer?

Too early to tell.

 

[WildZoo]

I'm being kinda lazy about it but there was this from MarWWel

I cannot read dubz at all, I'm probably never going to be able to yeet her

 

[supershorty]

He made a point to village read Dubz in Globe, but I wouldn't say he really leaned into the "willing to go along with Dubz" thing the way I recall him doing in LiterWWary.

Spoiler

Lol it is almost certainly the drinks, but also, more importantly than the drinks, being pocketed so hard by Dubz affected both of us and the way that we are going into the games.

Like, she just felt so wholesome and good and protective and she was a wolf the whole freaking time

Dubz, but she was also villagey in StardeWW (but I want to belieeeeve)

AM feels exactly the same as always, though I acknowledge that I haven't played with her while she's woofin', but still

You feel normal to me <3

Fluff seems like village-Fluff, though perhaps her experience last game was enough to level her up and now she's Super Powerful Boss-Wolf Fluff (unlikely)

There's a little of it in these first 2 posts, but not laying it on thick.

He was being kind of quiet, I guess I assumed they'd go for Stoat, Dubz, or someone permavillagey like AM. Though I guess she wasn't on the genny yeet, right?

The people I see as "firm bloc" right now are just you, Fluff, Dubz, and WO2 (and obviously myself but I need to earn my way in).

I think it's risky to give AM too much credit at this point in the game, even though my gut is telling me she's village!AM. PSV is also not completely solid, so she shouldn't be in the inner blocc.

 

[genny]

To be clear, I’m not sheeping other peoples hard work. I’m watching for interactions to play out and get as much info as I can before coming to a decision.

yeah me too. i like the way you said that.