FTF's Worst Idea Yet (Game Over)

[JustPaws]

---

Members don't see this ad.

You are voting for alissa for her posts...

Yes, prior to the momentum building

 

[Ms Procrastinator]

I’m more inclined to discuss MsP’s choice. Green grocer isn’t that terrible.. you basically send vegetables every night. Useful? No but are any of the other roles useful? Something must’ve been super tempting to her to pick something else. For this reason, I think I’ll start with

yeet MsP

I do agree with your analysis. I have a hard time believing Pippy would choose vanilla townie over a not-so-awful mafia role. Perhaps she was offered something better and even more sinister? I think it’s very possible for her to pick something 3P over mafia though

thoughts on MsP? I think MsP is kinda in the same boat as puppy in regards to she likes, or at least doesn’t mind being scum.

Really... hm. I just figured that since green grocer wasn’t the worst role she must’ve discarded it for something more interesting. That’s why I’m yeeting her to find out. Though I’m open to flipping to Pippy if that’s the way the votes are heading.

Yeet Alissa. These posts are giving me scum feel

 

[PippyPony]

Yes, prior to the momentum building

"Momentum" = two votes?

 

[PippyPony]

Well now 3 I guess

 

[alissa14]

But a lover is always on your team and is always assigned

(...I think?)

Spoiler: Mafiascum role description

Idk how it would work in this game tbh. If all lover roles would be linked or not or if they’d all die simultaneously or only in pairs. To my understanding this game is messed up and anything is possible

 

[JustPaws]

In the meantime

Yeet paws

For yeeting alissa and then saying cray was being opportunistic for the same vote

In the meantime

Yeet paws

For yeeting alissa and then saying cray was being opportunistic for the same vote

Opportunistic was what cray called someone else. I just laughed at the coincidence

 

[Dr. ForgotToFlush]

fyi i continuously update the spreadsheet i linked in the day opening post with the votes, as I see them
if im out the house i'll let you guys know

 

[JustPaws]

"Momentum" = two votes?

No, multiple people discussing her

 

[alissa14]

It’s extremely frustrating to discard a role that dies early by mechanics only to be on the track to die early anyways

 

[JustPaws]

No, multiple people discussing her

@pippypthe cray vote happened while I was reading other people discussing her after I had voted for her

 

[PippyPony]

Opportunistic was what cray called someone else. I just laughed at the coincidence

I saw. This doesn't answer my question about why her vote was opportunistic when it's the same vote you are on.

 

[Animal Midwife]

Also I didn’t get a full role description of the lover. It makes more sense that you wouldn’t pick this role if it meant a teammate also died. I just assumed it meant another player would die

It does mean the latter. Literally every possible lover outside of that discarded role is village.

 

[JustPaws]

I saw. This doesn't answer my question about why her vote was opportunistic when it's the same vote you are on.

I never called her opportunistic. I just quoted it cuz the timing was funny. You are working really hard to misinterpret my posts this game

 

[alissa14]

It does mean the latter. Literally every possible lover outside of that discarded role is village.

How did I not notice this now I feel like pip was just trying to further put more sus on me to get me misyeeted AGAIN. I hate when people take advantage of me being an easy misyeet. It makes me feel crappy about how I play. She didn’t even bother calling out you when you brought it up first.

 

[Animal Midwife]

Regardless of whether Pippy misinterpreted her role or not, it still doesn't say anything about what she chose instead.

 

[alissa14]

Regardless of whether Pippy misinterpreted her role or not, it still doesn't say anything about what she chose instead.

So now you’re saying it’s NAI when at first you said it was suspicious? It’s nice that you’re trying to leave me hanging out to dry.

 

[PippyPony]

It does mean the latter. Literally every possible lover outside of that discarded role is village.

Is this an assumption or fact? I don't understand how I'm supposed to have known that based on the description

Because if I could have picked to be a wolf who would automatically take down a villager, then heck yes I would have picked that role.

 

[Animal Midwife]

So now you’re saying it’s NAI when at first you said it was suspicious? It’s nice that you’re trying to leave me hanging out to dry.

No, I'm saying her saying she didn't understand has no weight on my original stance. You can not know what one role means and still understand what another does.

Regardless, how is this me leaving you out to dry?

 

[Animal Midwife]

Is this an assumption or fact? I don't understand how I'm supposed to have known that based on the description

Because if I could have picked to be a wolf who would automatically take down a villager, then heck yes I would have picked that role.

That's how lovers always work though. It's an individual ability, not a factional one. And for this game it's still not applicable to wolves. Only mafia and villagers can be lovers.

 

[PippyPony]

How did I not notice this now I feel like pip was just trying to further put more sus on me to get me misyeeted AGAIN. I hate when people take advantage of me being an easy misyeet. It makes me feel crappy about how I play. She didn’t even bother calling out you when you brought it up first.

I am yeeting paws, not you

 

[PippyPony]

I never called her opportunistic. I just quoted it cuz the timing was funny. You are working really hard to misinterpret my posts this game

Why was the timing funny?

 

[alissa14]

No, I'm saying her saying she didn't understand has no weight on my original stance. You can not know what one role means and still understand what another does.

Regardless, how is this me leaving you out to dry?

Oh ok I understand.

and it’s because I thought you were now saying pip discarding the role was NAI. And I felt like it made me look dumb for agreeing with you right away.

Idk why I’m extra sensitive today omg

 

[alissa14]

Yeet Alissa. These posts are giving me scum feel

Any other thoughts or are you just gonna agree with what paws and cray are saying about me and leave?

 

[JustPaws]

Why was the timing funny?

Because I found the cray post about opportunity, posted, then went back and then cray had voted. It was funny to me

 

[PippyPony]

I never called her opportunistic. I just quoted it cuz the timing was funny. You are working really hard to misinterpret my posts this game

I'm not trying to misinterpret your posts, I just don't understand why you're uncomfortable with someone voting with you. It's weird to vote for someone and then jump on the first person who votes with you.

Like if someone votes for you right now, I wouldn't be mad about it

 

[PippyPony]

Because I found the cray post about opportunity, posted, then went back and then cray had voted. It was funny to me

Ok well that explanation seems kinda sketch

 

[JustPaws]

I'm not trying to misinterpret your posts, I just don't understand why you're uncomfortable with someone voting with you. It's weird to vote for someone and then jump on the first person who votes with you.

Like if someone votes for you right now, I wouldn't be mad about it

Show me where I said I was uncomfortable or jumped on cray. It was a stupid in the moment comment lol. If I was uncomfortable wouldn't I have unlynched? Or like voted cray or something?

 

[JustPaws]

Ok well that explanation seems kinda sketch

Ok barely millenial 😉

 

[BobLoblaw78]

Ok well that explanation seems kinda sketch

By all means, don't think I am protecting someone that is sketchy, but iirc, Cray said I was being opportunistic to jump on a vote this early. Then Cray jumped on a vote early!!!!!! LOL. It was very funny (and almost seemed intentional that he did it that shortly after he called me out for it).

 

[WildZoo]

Yeet pip

Haven't read all posts because I lost my spot, but feel like she's being twisty in the ones I have read

 

[PippyPony]

Love it when I get called twisty twice in a row for my actual logic -- while someone is admitting they are missing context

@WildZoo please point out the posts

 

[PippyPony]

Show me where I said I was uncomfortable or jumped on cray. It was a stupid in the moment comment lol. If I was uncomfortable wouldn't I have unlynched? Or like voted cray or something?

I don't know, would you?

 

[PippyPony]

Ok barely millenial 😉

If you ever come to my house, I'm not offering you any of my crystal light 😛

 

[WildZoo]

Love it when I get called twisty twice in a row for my actual logic -- while someone is admitting they are missing context

@WildZoo please point out the posts

The conversation you're currently having with paws, and what I read of the one with alissa.

I don't have to read all the posts to get a ping - actually I'm often more accurate when I don't

 

[PippyPony]

The conversation you're currently having with paws, and what I read of the one with alissa.

I don't have to read all the posts to get a ping - actually I'm often more accurate when I don't

Then how can you say something is being twisted? Like what is being twisted, specifically?

 

[PippyPony]

Follow up question: how do you feel about paws' posts so far?

 

[Dr. ForgotToFlush]

im going out for pizza
occupy yourselves in the meanwhile

 

[JustPaws]

I don't know, would you?

Lol I guess that's a fair point haha

 

[JustPaws]

If you ever come to my house, I'm not offering you any of my crystal light 😛

Keep your old lady drink lol

 

[PippyPony]

@WildZoo I feel like you shouldn't have to go digging for an answer to that question

 

[JustPaws]

Love it when I get called twisty twice in a row for my actual logic -- while someone is admitting they are missing context

@WildZoo please point out the posts

How come you get to ask WZ to show you posts but you didn't show me mine?

 

[Animal Midwife]

@Ms Procrastinator I still expect you to come back and talk some more this cycle.

 

[Animal Midwife]

Also how are you feeling about the thread @Zenge142? Haven't heard from you in a while.

 

[Aprilthearab]

I'm not willing to put my vote on AM or Chaos today for aforementioned reasons.

Alissa is sounding wolfy but she always sounds wolfy D1. I'm not eager to put my vote there today because she is an easy D1 misyeet. I will definitely consider it once I have more than 12 hours to get a feel for her, particularly because her D1 posts in the previous two games where she was village had more of a lighthearted feel behind them than these do. I guess game after game of D1 sus could do that to you - I know it has to me. Subtle tone difference but not enough to make me override the D1 pass I'm giving her.

 

[PippyPony]

How come you get to ask WZ to show you posts but you didn't show me mine?

Because it's a different argument...? She's specifically implying that I'm deliberately twisting your words around, but she also said she didn't read a bunch of things yet. I don't see how that particular argument can be made without context. The whole point is that there is context.

 

[PippyPony]

And now she's MIA, which feels like she's going back to do a line-by-line recon

 

[Zenge142]

Feels opportunistic

I don’t care for this. She’s saying Bob voting for Chaos is opportunistic but it’s literally the first vote on Chaos.

I also don’t like that she’s attacking Bob for voting for Chaos when Chaos is voting for her. It feels like she’s trying to curry favor with the person voting to yeet her.

Yeet Cray

 

[PippyPony]

And now she's MIA, which feels like she's going back to do a line-by-line recon

Can we edit posts? ^That's a typo and supposed to say retcon

 

[PippyPony]

I don’t care for this. She’s saying Bob voting for Chaos is opportunistic but it’s literally the first vote on Chaos.

I also don’t like that she’s attacking Bob for voting for Chaos when Chaos is voting for her. It feels like she’s trying to curry favor with the person voting to yeet her.

Yeet Cray

Don't love that this popped up right after AM asked you where you were

You appear to have been following the thread based on post likes

 

[Zenge142]

Also how are you feeling about the thread @Zenge142? Haven't heard from you in a while.

Been busy today, just got home and caught up. Currently yeeting cray for reasons stated but there’s not a ton on the thread that’s pinging me. Don’t care for the Alissa vote. I think she’s easy to misyeet, especially D1.

Still trying to reconcile all the possible roles and what might be out there, but I’ll keep my thoughts on that to myself since it’s just wild speculation.

I’m having to look up a bunch of them. I will say I’m very surprised at Sunny’s discarded role, since it seems like, who ever kills her, wolves or village, gets severely punished for it by losing a cycle. Makes me wonder what she picked instead.