Already over my 5 min break limit from reading posts but....
Current reads after consulting with the voice in my head:
Wolfie
Barks, Wondering, BC, Miz
Neutral leaning wolfy
Nav, Pippy
Neutral (Unknown)
Genny, alissa, SAR
Neutral leaning village
MsP, dolphin, WZ
Village
AM, Coop
Did I show up on the neutral leaning wolf list after making one comment about one of your comments? What about the fact that I am voting for Nav?
I don't think the silencer has been playing it very village imo. Possibly extremely biased because I hate silencing but silencing the discussion drivers is not super village. I feel like a little bit of why it was so quiet yesterday was because I couldn't talk. I'm not sure how I feel about them silencing Miz. I suppose if they had both me and Miz on their wolf list it would make more sense of a villager. Welcome to my thinking out loud session -- pippy will call it wolfy
I don't know why you think I would call this wolfy when it is extremely similar to comments I made yesterday about the silencing. I do not like silencing, I think silencing vocal players handicaps the village, and I was whining all day yesterday about how it was overly quiet.
No but seriously who said last time they feel pippy would control the thread more as a wolf. I don't even care if it's true I want to remember who said that.
Are you even listening to yourself? "I don't even care if it's true"...? You don't care if you're using real evidence or not, you just want someone to jump in and agree with you that I'm the wolfiest player everrrrrr? Stop looking for validation on bad reads, because wolves are going to give it to you.
The comment I made before where I said I was annoyed and you said "wtf" was because I feel like you immediately jump on me in every single game and never revise your read based on information, especially if literally anyone else in the game thinks I'm even slightly wolfy.
And yes -- I know I
also jump on
you in early game all the time, but there is a major difference in that I'm able to use your responses to that aggressive questioning to make some situational determinations about your affiliation. Whereas you seem to want to agree with everyone who thinks I'm a wolf, even when it's wolves who are leading you around like a puppy following a bacon treat.
Nooooo
Possible Wolves
Miz, Nav, Barks, silencer (more to be added). Since I think the silencer is a wolf I'll be taking future silences with a grain of salt.
Neutral to wolfy
Pips
Village
Coops, BC, AM
I can't even:
Dubz
Neutral
Alissa
Everybody else
I don't think you can consider future silencing as evidence of being village because 1) wolves are perfectly capable of changing their behavior based on feedback and 2) it could still very well be a villager who is doing the silencing, and they therefore don't know jack about the affiliation of their targets aside from their own reads.
I didn't have you as sitting in my wolfy pile until this post, because I don't understand how "possible wolves" "neutral to wolfy" "I can't even" and "neutral" describe different categories, because they are all variations on "dunno"
However -- I felt a little better after hearing the explanations in here:
BC is a double vote and I kinda think that leans village. Coop because of PM, silence, etc. Pippy I feel like her, Nav and miz don't make that much sense when you look at NKs so far. I'm still on the miz/nav tinfoil so I'm cool with moving pippy down. I have a problem viewing the wolf pack as OG heavy given the choice of kill. I kinda think they're being picky about who they kill which makes me think there's at least two OGs there. The killerleaf kill seemed like they didn't want to go after other OGs too quickly and were avoiding killing certain people. Add that to the whole being picky about killing previous mods and the NKs thus far kinda points to at least two OGs.
Can't even for dubz means can't even bother cause she could easily be either and I wouldn't know the difference (thought I did eons ago). She could easily go to neutral.
Alissa moves to neutral because I feel she's calmed down since yesterday. It could be OG wolves telling her to chill, but I'm feeling slight better about her today.
BUT THEN...
OG (people who have played forever) compared to others like BC, wondering and alissa. I'm thinking 3-4 wolves. What do you mean which people are being avoided?! The kills aren't exactly targeting the talkative! I mean killerleaf seriously?! Heck that kill benefited village! I would have thought it village vig if it weren't so clearly wolf! Let's be honest the wolves aren't exactly targeting who they should be scared of (the present and talkative) which makes you wonder. They seem to be "silencing" the talkative if anything.
I also didn't like this post. Why so many exclamation points??!?!
But seriously this felt like an over the top comment about something that is insanely WIFOMy. You know who can explain night kill choices with any true level of accuracy? Wolves. And mods. And that is it.
Perhaps one wasn't silenced
🤔 Or the silencer doesn't know what they're doing
We know both were silenced because THEY PLACED VOTES IN PM THAT SHOWED UP IN TALLIES
And I don't know why people are having trouble with that concept
I'd go for the later, Miz and I aren't the sort of people to be able to keep our mouths shut, especially when people start insulating things about them that I would have otherwise corrected. I'm sure I could do it if necessary, like endgame. But I'm not one to plot this out in such early game. I doubt Miz would either, but if it was Nav or someone hell yeah that's be suspect. Miz is the type of wolf to be right up there with the fake claims and making you put her village and pocketing you so far you can't tell it wasn't your idea in the first place. But this isn't her style. Not saying she's not a wolf, just saying I HIGHLY doubt she'd fake a silence for... what exactly would she gain in this scenario?
For what it is worth, I agree with all of this except for the part where Coop is saying what she herself would not do as a wolf. But the Miz assessment feels valid based on my experience wolfing with her.
Why is anything due on a Sunday?
Most of our homework/take home exams are due on the weekends.
And on that note, now I'm like 35+ min over my 5 min break
