HoWWrses: Game Thread

Veterinary Science Graduate Programs from U. of I.
This forum made possible through the generous support of SDN members, donors, and sponsors. Thank you.
Members don't see this ad.
Lynch AM
giphy.gif
 
cubsrule4e said:
Bryndi (5) - Karabeans, meats, snowy, Lupes, coffee

Theres gotta be some Red in here somewhere, if not bryndi herself. Zigs flip makes me look a little less at kara.



Lets find out more about them then, shall we? I havent been on the bryndi sketch train at all so

Lynch Coffee

Care to join me for a third day in a row, Ski?
Click to expand...
🙄

edit

giphy.gif
 
*******************
Unofficial Day 3 Lynch Tally
Kara (3) - Stagg, Mel, Weim
capri (1) - WZ
Gwen (2) - AM, genny
WZ (2) - Snowy, meaty
Stagg (1) - SAR
coffeebean (1) - cubs
AM (1) - coffeebean

11/24
lynch close in ~7 hours
*******************
 
killerleaf said:
at this point in time, in my beady little brain:
AM and Lupin are tied for the role of Chaos--mostly for how they seem to just be stirring the pot.
Everybody else I have as "I have no freaking clue" will have to think and go back and look at a couple of things.
Click to expand...
this isn't meant mean, please don't take this as mean

this is what I would explain as being a little bit "literal"

players causing what seems like a lot of chaos, that isn't really the sign of chaos, that isn't what chaos really means in WW

"Chaos" role or affiliation means someone who is a 3rd party - they have a win condition that is separate from that of the wolves or villagers. Sometimes they can win with either team, but they usually have something that must happen for them to win - it could be getting a specific player lynched, getting themselves NK'd, getting themselves lynched, getting someone lynched and then getting themselves lynched, the list of possibilities is endless. Often, when they win, everyone else loses, but not always. What is always true is that they have some agenda that is not exactly the same as the villagers or the wolves.

I can't find my go-to article about lying and agendas, and how to glean motives and agendas from what a player says and does.

It isn't that "chaos" or 3rd party means people play erratically, or really I should define what erratic means. It doesn't mean they seem bizarre in their play or kick up kick up dust in an obvious or showy way. That may or may not happen. It's called that, because what is chaotic about their gameplay, if anything is amiss, is that upon inspection or analysis, it truly cannot be fully accounted for by a villager or wolf agenda. It's as though there is some other force at work in the game, one that doesn't make sense to be wolf or villager. If it does seem to cause "chaos," it's chaos in the sense that it can be difficult for either wolves or villagers to make sense of the play or events, when viewed with the lens of if something seems village or wolf. Or the chaos is caused as they work towards their wincon, which is not in keeping with the wolf or villager agenda.

Wolves and villagers do all kinds of stupid things that run counter to their agenda, but the motive is what you expect for each team's wincon (win condition). When you have members of both the village and wolf teams confused by a player's agenda, you can see some "crossing the aisles" of viewpoints on that player. This can cause further confusion.

Most wolves and 3rd parties are not trying to draw suspicious attention to themselves, or come off chaotic, unless that's just their gameplay or keeping to their meta, or something that is basically necessary in pursuit of their wincon or mechanics surrounding that.

Perhaps this was all the lens you meant to be using to look at AM & Lupin for coming to the conclusion that the best explanation for their gameplay is that they are NEITHER wolf nor villager, and that their actions cannot be well explained as such. If that is the case, it would be logical to consider if they are 3rd party.

Keep in mind, I probably used wrong terminology in places and have some details not quite right, and other vets will have something to say on their experiences with how chaos/3rd party roles work. The main take away, is that like with everything in WW, things might not be obvious.

Just, to be clear, chaotic players may not be a 3rd party or "chaos" player, and 3rd party players may seem to be playing quite ordinarily and fitting in.

I have not ruled out that AM or Lupin are not either villager or wolf. At this point I think their behaviour can be explained by either affiliation. I haven't seen anything in the game that I don't feel cannot be explained by wolf or villager, or that suggests there is a 3rd party acting in line with its own interests.

Lastly, the maxim, if it isn't village it must die. You don't have to figure out if they're wolves or 3rd party. You need to decide if they are village or not. It complicates things unnecessarily to introduce a 3rd category in the primary determination. It's almost a process of elimination. Determine who you think is village. Determine who you think is NOT. Kill all those people. Reassess everyone continually. You mainly go over the list of those you thought were village to see what you missed when it seems like you're missing something. There could be a 3rd party that was missed and not lynched with your "not village" category people. Right now, we're not missing something, we're missing everything. Build a village and wolf pile. Go from there.
 
Legit have been busy/sick and still have not had a chance to catch up (just had a few moments to read the last page or so but haven't read back). The low activity votes are real sweet though guys 😉
vetmedhead said:
Lynch dubz

don't like her non-response response about my questioning of her capri vote and her overall lack of solid contributions to thread when that is something I think is more typical of her gameplay imo
Click to expand...
Yeah you should know it's typical of my wolf gameplay too. Quiet dubz is not wolf dubz, it's busy dubz. For shame.

Anyway my answer was not a non-answer. My D1 vote was a feel, don't really know what other kind of explanation you wanted. I kept it the next day because I was interested to see if it went anywhere, and then obviously haven't gotten a chance to reevaluate.
 
Totally behind, out of the loop, and just ranting. I haven't slept, a lot going on, yada yada.

@Melchizedek you came out of the gate strong and won me over, but cannot rest of your laurels. I need to see you generate more solid village content besides whatever you got with Kara. If you're right, she's not the only wolf.

@Lupin21 I haven't seen what's been brought from our PM to the thread. It's concerning to me that Barkely the vig and your PM partner were the NKs, and now the village redirector. I feel like you've been a bit pockety. I also feel like you've been a bit fluffy charming. Wolfdar is going off super hard, but it's been a long time since we played and I don't know your meta to begin with. I hate coming to thread with suspicion from PM, it feels like betraying a friend, but then again that's no way to play.

I'm bored with the AM/WM vote talk. Not sure what is currently happening with AM and Stagg.

If you're voting Kara, I need to see why peeps.
 
sheltermed said:
I feel like Kara is maybe wolfy. she's pretty good at hiding behind being busy as a wolf and then sometimes coming around to give the guise of wolf hunting. I have wolfed with her before and am also her wolf pup.

I am also around 10 pages behind. sorry for not coming back last night like I said I would. catching up now.
Click to expand...
I remember wolfing with her, and she really was that busy and it wasn't faked.

So Kara being busy with work is NAI for me. I need to go do some post analysis on her. For me I feel that's the best way I can read her. Who am I kidding. That's the only way I can attempt to read anyone.
 
crayola, thank you for the information. I guess I have viewed those in the chaos role more like puppetmasters, or conductors. Subtly, or not so subtly in some cases, leading the masses to the lynches they choose...that is kinda how I see AM and Lupin (and Mel to a certain extent) playing. here's an idea...now, withdraw. do you think that is a good idea? then withdraw. A dance, of sorts. Leading, watching.

of course, a lens should be used--is this wolfy? is this village? is this how I have seen others as 3rd parties?

My idea is to watch carefully, closely. While not necessarily a prime target in the first days, should not drop off of radar.
 
Stagg737 said:
For now

Contingency Lynch Kara

I need to do some re-reads, but I had another reason I thought she was wolfy and I'd like to hear more from @Karabiner13
Click to expand...

so what is this 'other reason'?

also what are your reasons for thinking am is wolfy? It's better to share so others have a chance to evaluate their reads

personally I'm reading am village. There was an early tie between her and zigzag that sat for quite some time D1 which is why I mentioned feeling good about them. She also sounds like am

cubsrule4e said:
Bryndi (5) - Karabeans, meats, snowy, Lupes, coffee

Theres gotta be some Red in here somewhere, if not bryndi herself. Zigs flip makes me look a little less at kara.



Lets find out more about them then, shall we? I havent been on the bryndi sketch train at all so

Lynch Coffee

Care to join me for a third day in a row, Ski?
Click to expand...

so are you doing this so I'll clear you or do you believe there is a wolf between koffee and bryndy?
 
Melchizedek said:
Real life excuses are NAI, I completely agree there.

You're reducing my argument to "Kara is a wolf because she's lurking." which is not the case. As I said to VMH, your lurking could be seen as one of two things and I acknowledge that you might truly be busy. That however is not the main reason I've been on your lynch. Your voting bryndy D1 over the worst reason, and then badgering her into talking enough to look sketchy and attract votes feels exactly like what you did to me in CO to get me lynched.
Click to expand...

OK, when I wrote the post above, somehow I missed like 3 pages of posts including the one where Ziggy died.

Anyway, I see that Mel has called out other players and even switched his vote.

More importantly, he hits the nail on the head here with Kara.

Here's the thing. Last game where I thought he was a wolf, initially he made a point on SOV, I believe, that was complex and had merit. Most of Mel's proposed theories do that. But there is a tone where I feel like he is either reading more into something than is there, vs hitting the nail on the head. OK, that's not fair, I've seen him spin tinfoil, tunnel, stretch, and be wrong. So I should say is it an intentional stretch to cast more shade than is there, or is he just calling it like it is or like he thinks it is. This just has a certain accuracy, that really the issue here is that I believe what Mel is saying to be true to the point that it's not a matter of his affiliation. I said earlier that Kara's early D1 interactions and questions felt like village Kara. However, and I know I said this to Lupin, I did not like the BJ lynch justifications that came up on thread that day. That's not even a question of my lean on BJ, she's sketched me out in her own right. But I said I felt like people were using BS to jump on her and there was nothing inconsistent with her hate of the math talk yet putting her feet in it. Not simple, but human.

My memory is so bad that I can identify what took place without remembering who said what or even what was said. But yeah
 
killerleaf said:
crayola, thank you for the information. I guess I have viewed those in the chaos role more like puppetmasters, or conductors. Subtly, or not so subtly in some cases, leading the masses to the lynches they choose...that is kinda how I see AM and Lupin (and Mel to a certain extent) playing. here's an idea...now, withdraw. do you think that is a good idea? then withdraw. A dance, of sorts. Leading, watching.

of course, a lens should be used--is this wolfy? is this village? is this how I have seen others as 3rd parties?

My idea is to watch carefully, closely. While not necessarily a prime target in the first days, should not drop off of radar.
Click to expand...
often you do see powerwolves doing that, the puppetmaster or conductor thing, because they know more and their only real role in the game is informed manipulation, and that's how it feels. However, power villagers like Kara, Mel, AM, even Dubz to some extent 😛 will lead interrogations and reaction tests. Even more confusing is that sometimes a village PR can make people come off more in the know and leading. The hardest part of this game for me has been identifying when lynch leading is village or wolf.

I think your observations on these players are spot on. They are doing what you think they are doing. It's just not clear to me why yet. Except that so far Mel is working out for me, and AM just feels like AM, which is NAI in my book.
 
Karabiner13 said:
so are you doing this so I'll clear you or do you believe there is a wolf between koffee and bryndy?
Click to expand...

I believe there is a wolf somewhere in that voting block, and by voting for one of them if they do happen to flip wolf, I would think that would make you feel better about me being not afraid to go after them. So what are your up to date thoughts on the two?
 
cubsrule4e said:
I believe there is a wolf somewhere in that voting block, and by voting for one of them if they do happen to flip wolf, I would think that would make you feel better about me being not afraid to go after them. So what are your up to date thoughts on the two?
Click to expand...

working on compiling reads. Going through the whole roster to make sure I don't forget someone
 
Crayola227 said:
OK, when I wrote the post above, somehow I missed like 3 pages of posts including the one where Ziggy died.

Anyway, I see that Mel has called out other players and even switched his vote.

More importantly, he hits the nail on the head here with Kara.

Here's the thing. Last game where I thought he was a wolf, initially he made a point on SOV, I believe, that was complex and had merit. Most of Mel's proposed theories do that. But there is a tone where I feel like he is either reading more into something than is there, vs hitting the nail on the head. OK, that's not fair, I've seen him spin tinfoil, tunnel, stretch, and be wrong. So I should say is it an intentional stretch to cast more shade than is there, or is he just calling it like it is or like he thinks it is. This just has a certain accuracy, that really the issue here is that I believe what Mel is saying to be true to the point that it's not a matter of his affiliation. I said earlier that Kara's early D1 interactions and questions felt like village Kara. However, and I know I said this to Lupin, I did not like the BJ lynch justifications that came up on thread that day. That's not even a question of my lean on BJ, she's sketched me out in her own right. But I said I felt like people were using BS to jump on her and there was nothing inconsistent with her hate of the math talk yet putting her feet in it. Not simple, but human.

My memory is so bad that I can identify what took place without remembering who said what or even what was said. But yeah
Click to expand...

mel didn't switch his vote
 
##lynch SAR##
In looking at the voting record, she was on my lynch and on Moose's. She is the only person that shows on the final tally, for both lynches.
 
The Karabou Reads:
1. koffee - wolf lean?
- wolf between bryndy and koffee?
- side tracked by math D1
- defends zigzag early (first in response to shelter then ski)
- not seeing a lot of reads
2. mutts - wolf lean
- distrusts rezKL (typically rezzes are more village though)
- cray vote for not following her logic? join the club
- votes for me because felt better about moose, yet moose was in wolf reads and I was in need more info
- breaks tie so don't lost 2 villagers?
- thoughts on me now?
3. snowy - village lean
- so far seems typical hedgy snowy who is neutral on me but reading situation differently than others (I think holds the karabou reading card?)
5. skim: village lean
- agreeing with a lot
6. sar - neutral
- spreadsheet mention
- side tracked by gif discussion
- more posts
7. ski - neutral to wolf lean
- sidetracked by roster swap
- off topic posts
- minimal reads
8. dubz - cautious village lean to neutral
- need more posts
- tentative village dubz? We're agreeing in the few posts we've made?
9. am: village lean
- tie with zizag that sat D1
- gut feels
10. mel - wolf
- deja vu
- feels like wolf!mel from meat where he didn't like my logic and we were bickering, feel like we don't have as many heated exchanges when we are the same affiliation
- last time was bryndy was a wolf who I caught and he tried to discredit it (Meat)
11. dina - neutral
- more posts
12. cray - neutral to village lean?
- been glazing over her posts but seems mostly cray
- typical suspicion for me?
14. lupes - cautious village lean
- agreeing with a lot
15. cubs - wolf lean?
- if there's a wolf in bryndy or koffee possibly broke a tie away from them
16. genny - neutral
- care free as usual
- bats off stagg for wolf reads and reasons
17. vmh - wolf lean to neutral
- lynches BJ D1 for a non-existent KL vote and then switches to the reasoning but then those disappear. Current read on bryndy?
- switches to moose D2
18. msu - neutral
- 3 posts, need more
19. mj - neutral
- not enough
20. stagg - neutral to wolf
- sporty vote 30 min to deadline D1
- tried to tie me and moose
- tight lipped on what info moose or karabou flip would give
- top wolf reads?
- reluctant to share info
- either V/V or W/V with am
22. gwen - neutral
- not enough
23. KL - was night cancel now rezzed; village lean
- seems genuine in pm
24. capri - neutral
- need more; mostly short posts with few reads
26. BJ - wolf lean?
- wolf between bryndy and coffee?
- came on close to close to tie it up D1
- survived but no mention of her being involved in the tie in write-up (could just be how mods wrote it or could have escaped another way)
- those that voted and didn't like her popping in disappeared
27. weim - village lean?
- seems ok in pm despite lynching me
- on bryndy D2 when weim mentions not liking bj's end of lynch play unlike most that said that and voted elsewhere
28. karabou: village
- fear free posting, don't care what others think
- needs more posts when can
 
Karabiner13 said:
mel didn't switch his vote
Click to expand...
Its true. I didn't really.

Karabiner13 said:
The Karabou Reads:
1. koffee - wolf lean?
- wolf between bryndy and koffee?
- side tracked by math D1
- defends zigzag early (first in response to shelter then ski)
- not seeing a lot of reads
2. mutts - wolf lean
- distrusts rezKL (typically rezzes are more village though)
- cray vote for not following her logic? join the club
- votes for me because felt better about moose, yet moose was in wolf reads and I was in need more info
- breaks tie so don't lost 2 villagers?
- thoughts on me now?
3. snowy - village lean
- so far seems typical hedgy snowy who is neutral on me but reading situation differently than others (I think holds the karabou reading card?)
5. skim: village lean
- agreeing with a lot
6. sar - neutral
- spreadsheet mention
- side tracked by gif discussion
- more posts
7. ski - neutral to wolf lean
- sidetracked by roster swap
- off topic posts
- minimal reads
8. dubz - cautious village lean to neutral
- need more posts
- tentative village dubz? We're agreeing in the few posts we've made?
9. am: village lean
- tie with zizag that sat D1
- gut feels
10. mel - wolf
- deja vu
- feels like wolf!mel from meat where he didn't like my logic and we were bickering, feel like we don't have as many heated exchanges when we are the same affiliation
- last time was bryndy was a wolf who I caught and he tried to discredit it (Meat)
11. dina - neutral
- more posts
12. cray - neutral to village lean?
- been glazing over her posts but seems mostly cray
- typical suspicion for me?
14. lupes - cautious village lean
- agreeing with a lot
15. cubs - wolf lean?
- if there's a wolf in bryndy or koffee possibly broke a tie away from them
16. genny - neutral
- care free as usual
- bats off stagg for wolf reads and reasons
17. vmh - wolf lean to neutral
- lynches BJ D1 for a non-existent KL vote and then switches to the reasoning but then those disappear. Current read on bryndy?
- switches to moose D2
18. msu - neutral
- 3 posts, need more
19. mj - neutral
- not enough
20. stagg - neutral to wolf
- sporty vote 30 min to deadline D1
- tried to tie me and moose
- tight lipped on what info moose or karabou flip would give
- top wolf reads?
- reluctant to share info
- either V/V or W/V with am
22. gwen - neutral
- not enough
23. KL - was night cancel now rezzed; village lean
- seems genuine in pm
24. capri - neutral
- need more; mostly short posts with few reads
26. BJ - wolf lean?
- wolf between bryndy and coffee?
- came on close to close to tie it up D1
- survived but no mention of her being involved in the tie in write-up (could just be how mods wrote it or could have escaped another way)
- those that voted and didn't like her popping in disappeared
27. weim - village lean?
- seems ok in pm despite lynching me
- on bryndy D2 when weim mentions not liking bj's end of lynch play unlike most that said that and voted elsewhere
28. karabou: village
- fear free posting, don't care what others think
- needs more posts when can
Click to expand...
👍
I'm not LIS, you don't get village points for spewing a bunch of reads on thread under pressure. I'm pretty sure I've told newbie wolves to do exactly this when getting heat to get people off of them.
Nice try though.
 
Animal Midwife said:
No, because they weren't on my wolf leans anyway. If I reevaluate over village or neutral leans flipping village, I'm not playing right.
Click to expand...
We need a meme for when AM basically throw up her gangsta signs as she tell us all to get jacked.

I went looking for one, and this isn't it, but it still made me laugh. I mean, we are all animal loving WW addicts.
i-aint-playin-324211.jpg
 
Melchizedek said:
Its true. I didn't really.


👍
I'm not LIS, you don't get village points for spewing a bunch of reads on thread under pressure. I'm pretty sure I've told newbie wolves to do exactly this when getting heat to get people off of them.
Nice try though.
Click to expand...

:zip: :banana:

great, thanks but you need to get your blinders off

#notawolf
 
Crayola227 said:
We need a meme for when AM basically throw up her gangsta signs as she tell us all to get jacked.

I went looking for one, and this isn't it, but it still made me laugh. I mean, we are all animal loving WW addicts.
i-aint-playin-324211.jpg
Click to expand...

What does get jacked mean?
 
capri1722 said:
Could go either way I think
Click to expand...

Melchizedek said:
I know you didn't ask me, but I think village.
If it was a wolf PR then think about it. The wolves would consistently have one extra vote everyday and thats really powerful.
Click to expand...

SnowshoeDog143 said:
I would guess village. People don't usually like to lynch silenced people who can't defend themselves, so it's not a super helpful ability for the wolves.



night kill analysis is always WIFOM
Click to expand...

Do you think WZ had anything to do with it? She was the only other person on the Capri lynch with MJ.

Karabiner13 said:
@muttmanager what is your read on me?
Click to expand...
Neutral now.
 
muttmanager said:
Do you think WZ had anything to do with it? She was the only other person on the Capri lynch with MJ.


Neutral now.
Click to expand...
I don't think she'd telegraph her ability like that. Sick/busy/distracted or whatever, dubz plays better than that.

Thats all I'm going to say, I don't like where this conversation is going or the fact that you're bringing it up.
 
Crayola227 said:
OK, when I wrote the post above, somehow I missed like 3 pages of posts including the one where Ziggy died.

Anyway, I see that Mel has called out other players and even switched his vote.

More importantly, he hits the nail on the head here with Kara.

Here's the thing. Last game where I thought he was a wolf, initially he made a point on SOV, I believe, that was complex and had merit. Most of Mel's proposed theories do that. But there is a tone where I feel like he is either reading more into something than is there, vs hitting the nail on the head. OK, that's not fair, I've seen him spin tinfoil, tunnel, stretch, and be wrong. So I should say is it an intentional stretch to cast more shade than is there, or is he just calling it like it is or like he thinks it is. This just has a certain accuracy, that really the issue here is that I believe what Mel is saying to be true to the point that it's not a matter of his affiliation. I said earlier that Kara's early D1 interactions and questions felt like village Kara. However, and I know I said this to Lupin, I did not like the BJ lynch justifications that came up on thread that day. That's not even a question of my lean on BJ, she's sketched me out in her own right. But I said I felt like people were using BS to jump on her and there was nothing inconsistent with her hate of the math talk yet putting her feet in it. Not simple, but human.

My memory is so bad that I can identify what took place without remembering who said what or even what was said. But yeah
Click to expand...
oh yeah also I gave him credit for switching his vote... to Paws, the NPC, lmao. The rest of it stands, he's gone on to question other players. But yeah, my VCA skills are top notch.
 
WildZoo said:
Legit have been busy/sick and still have not had a chance to catch up (just had a few moments to read the last page or so but haven't read back). The low activity votes are real sweet though guys 😉

Yeah you should know it's typical of my wolf gameplay too. Quiet dubz is not wolf dubz, it's busy dubz. For shame.

Anyway my answer was not a non-answer. My D1 vote was a feel, don't really know what other kind of explanation you wanted. I kept it the next day because I was interested to see if it went anywhere, and then obviously haven't gotten a chance to reevaluate.
Click to expand...
I haven't caught up on thread, but want to clarify that my concern wasn't that you are quiet (figured you were busy, we all are), but rather that the posts you have made haven't had a ton of wolf hunting effort in them, which is something I generally expect to see more of from you regardless of how often you are posting
 
Melchizedek said:
I don't think she'd telegraph her ability like that. Sick/busy/distracted or whatever, dubz plays better than that.

Thats all I'm going to say, I don't like where this conversation is going or the fact that you're bringing it up.
Click to expand...
Oh I wasnt trying to fish, my bad.
This ability is confusing me, I cant grasp the purpose but I guess thats a mod post-game question
 
vetmedhead said:
I haven't caught up on thread, but want to clarify that my concern wasn't that you are quiet (figured you were busy, we all are), but rather that the posts you have made haven't had a ton of wolf hunting effort in them, which is something I generally expect to see more of from you regardless of how often you are posting
Click to expand...
Hard to wolf hunt when I haven't really been reading since D2 started dude.

Which I will be fixing now
 
*******************
Unofficial Day 3 Lynch Tally
Karabou (3) - Stagg, Mel, Weim
capri (1) - WZ
Gwen (2) - AM, genny
WZ (2) - Snowy, meaty
Stagg (1) - SAR
coffeebean (1) - cubs
AM (1) - coffeebean
SAR (1) - killer
Mel (1) - Karabou

13/24
lynch close in ~4 hours
*******************
 
You know, upon looking back through thread, covfefe is giving me a lot of feels

CoffeeQuestionMark said:
interesting considering your thoughts on me included I talked a lot about math (yes, I like math), don't like the ziggy lynch (don't see how this is a problem.. do you WANT ziggy lynched?), and I wasn't self-prezing (which was true until I was in the lead, and then I did self-prez, so again, not sure your issue here)

Do you have any updated thoughts on anyone? I see you've mentioned myself, moose, and killer (flipped village) all as sketchy, bryndi as not sketchy, and kara in response to someone else as asking a lot of questions but not saying much else.

Specifically

-what do you think of Moose being up for lynch today?
-what do you think of bryndi's move last night, and how she is not dead?
-how do you feel about my points towards Cray + followup: would you say there is potentially a wolf between kara and cray?
Click to expand...
Ignoring the part I already discussed (the aggressive defending of ziggy), the bolded reads a lot like suspicion manufacturing to me. I think any reasonable person would have considered her survival a likely part of a tie mechanic and this felt too much like trying to read into it too much for my taste

CoffeeQuestionMark said:
I FORGOT ABOUT SOMETHING





Forgot about the game but liked a post shortly after game started??

edit: I see she admitted to this later. Still keeping this in mind.
Click to expand...
Also feels like manufacturing suspicion, especially given that covfefe has also made several posts about how we shouldn't lynch quiet players
CoffeeQuestionMark said:
I am feeling better about Cray. Still not sure on Kara who has not been on all day so it's still D1 information on her.

I don't like where Ski was trying to go which seemed to be no where. She had her vote on me, claimed to be continuing thoughts on me from yesterday, but rejected every thought that I echo'd from her yesterday as her not saying it's sketch but it's just notes. So @SkiOtter if everything you said about me and everyone else yesterday WASN'T sketch, then what is?

ZJ - Lynch close write up made us aware we weren't supposed to be PMing anymore. Oops. Well, what's done is done but someone has been very actively trying to be agreeable and complimentary in PM today but not saying much on thread. Since we aren't any longer PM partners I feel that's worth sharing 😉

AM - this is day 2 of voting for somebody not posting on the thread for nearly the entire day. It concerns me. Her questions keep coming but yes, she can ask questions as a wolf just as easily. The concern is when they aren't producing wolves or answers.
Click to expand...
The bolded, again, reads as manufacturing suspicion, especially since it was D2 and kind of a reach to expect any line of questioning to have come to the fruition point of producing wolves yet (we all know we don't get answers in WW, as mods need player confusion to live)
 
Oh, and I feel more unsettled about cray today than I did yesterday. As much as I know she enjoys posting WW theory posts (and I enjoy reading them), I personally feel that she's been heavy on those in this game and lighter on reads and questioning other players. Between that and the blow up argument with zig last night it feels a little like cray is mimicking the posting habits of hers that are lighter on in-game analysis and possibly picking fights with feistier players so there's a good reason to point to regarding why her posts have been a little lacking in reads/player analysis
 
*******************
Unofficial Day 3 Lynch Tally
Karabou (3) - Stagg, Mel, Weim
capri (1) - WZ
Gwen (2) - AM, genny
WZ (1) - Snowy
Stagg (1) - SAR
coffeebean (2) - cubs, meaty
AM (1) - coffeebean
SAR (1) - killer
Mel (1) - Karabou

13/24
lynch close in ~4 hours
*******************
 
Lupin21 said:
I wanna know what @Skimble thinks today. capri and stagg are both on my suspect list still, so interested to see where she has landed after the last couple days.
Click to expand...
I just got on the train home and I’m just looking at posts I was tagged right now. I’m on page 17... so... if someone wants to give me the TLDR, I’d really appreciate it. I pm’d dolphin this morning asking if she would possibly help me out with that, but I don’t see that she replied yet.
 
Skimble said:
I just got on the train home and I’m just looking at posts I was tagged right now. I’m on page 17... so... if someone wants to give me the TLDR, I’d really appreciate it. I pm’d dolphin this morning asking if she would possibly help me out with that, but I don’t see that she replied yet.
Click to expand...
I think dolphin died last night so you may want to try whoever your other PM partner is
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

Similar threads

Animal Midwife
Death Nommy - Game Thread
83 84 85 86 87
Replies
4K
Views
51K
Animal Midwife
Animal Midwife
WildZoo
  • Poll Poll
Mission ImpoWWssible Game Thread
46 47 48 49 50
Replies
2K
Views
37K
Clem J
Clem J
supershorty
GGoats ThWWee: Here It GGoats Again - GAME THREAD
93 94 95 96 97
Replies
5K
Views
51K
vampyrica
vampyrica
Animal Midwife
Matrix - Game Thread
77 78 79 80 81
Replies
4K
Views
87K
samac
samac
WildZoo
  • Poll Poll
PokeWWon: A Wild Kanto Adventure - Champs Season 12 Practice Game Thread
87 88 89 90 91
Replies
5K
Views
56K
Animal Midwife
Animal Midwife
Top