MaWWke YoWWr OWWn WW - Game Thread

Veterinary Science Graduate Programs from U. of I.
This forum made possible through the generous support of SDN members, donors, and sponsors. Thank you.
Members don't see this ad.
JaggedJimmyJay said:
I think sheltermed has been a little suspicious. I don't share samac's pointed rage, but I do think there's a case. For example, I don't think eliminating the cult is actually worth any credit at all (literally zero) in the present scenario. I think there's definitely a believable narrative to spin that sheltermed asked for a 3p role, didn't specify what kind, received a solo SK type role, and has been super uncertain about how to approach the game with it. So they've followed the waves in the most literal sense (shooting into the consensus POE) to be involved and stay in good graces. I think all of this is quite feasible.

No matter. If we're in agreement about the process, then on we go.
Click to expand...
LITERALLY zero?!?
 
sheltermed said:
LITERALLY zero?!?
Click to expand...
In a conversation about serial killer possibilities, yes. This only demonstrates that you are not aligned with the cult, which is no longer in action. So, if we're looking for non-cult villains, I don't think it's evidence that you are aligned with the town.

That doesn't mean it wasn't valuable. It certainly was, and I am glad you shot genny! If we get out of this with a win, we will owe you for that.
 
Day 4 Tally:
1698026952827.jpeg


Stagg ()
Clem (4) - Stagg, Santy, Dy, SAR
Shelter (2) - Samac, JJJ

Vote Close in 23.666666 Hours
 
Unrelated to my shot but I do think someone said Mayo would be a likely cult recruit by genny so props to them for that
 
sheltermed said:
LITERALLY zero?!?
Click to expand...
None. They’re a threat to other scum too.
sheltermed said:
I shot mayo and that wasn't consensus.
Click to expand...
Hehehe
They’ve been making the argument you keep shooting into the consensus Poe
And this has been my argument back
Just funny we both wield that different ways
 
samac said:
None. They’re a threat to other scum too.

Hehehe
They’ve been making the argument you keep shooting into the consensus Poe
And this has been my argument back
Just funny we both wield that different ways
Click to expand...
Well I have been, just not that one time.
 
Did you ever express why you decided to shoot mayo, @sheltermed? Forgive me if so, but it's a huge thread. I don't recall.
 
Mayo was in my personal POE at the time. I didn't feel comfortable shooting chic after they claimed nor psv after the bomb comment. Also a bit of luck.
 
sheltermed said:
Mayo was in my personal POE at the time. I didn't feel comfortable shooting chic after they claimed nor psv after the bomb comment. Also a bit of luck.
Click to expand...
Thanks. I thought I recalled you suspecting mayo before that, so the shoe fits. It was my impression then that some people found mayo suspicious, and others had him hard null. I don't believe anyone town read him perhaps apart from samac briefly.
 
sheltermed said:
Mayo was in my personal POE at the time. I didn't feel comfortable shooting chic after they claimed nor psv after the bomb comment. Also a bit of luck.
Click to expand...
It looks like you didn’t mention mayo one time after cycle 1 or push there cycle 2
Or is the search failing me
sheltermed said:
########Vote mayo########

without having looked at the thread since around page 29-30 or so, my top wolf suspects atm are chic and mayo. Last I read, mayo was in the thread with arms swinging. my opinion of chic comes mainly from yesterday, where they went back and forth about a few things and I saw others whose opinions I'd trust on someone I don't know call them out for it. may have been shorty, AM, dya, +/- dubz (the people I'd trust). this thread blew up way too quickly for me and it's hard for me to catch up and remember everything right now.

re: nothing happening over night 0, I believe I've only played a handful of games with a day 0/mayoral election and I seem to recall at least one other having no deaths n0 either. is this typical for games with a day/night 0 in anyone else's experience?
Click to expand...

sheltermed said:
I think the last time I was village on SDN (not counting the small game where I got voted off immediately) was Clem's DND game, but I may be misremembering. I've been playing on the avocado recently, where I mistakenly(?) told them/demonstrated that I'm especially active when I'm excited about a role.

this game and the activity level is admittedly a lot for me though and I wasn't expecting it. I imagine people really like Zenge games.

that said.... I don't think I've read much off of this page since somewhere in the 30s and I'm still voted for mayo, who I voted for because of the combativeness sometime yesterday (possibly the day before) and then someone called him out saying the last time he wolfed he was like that. how are people feeling now? I imagine chic might still be a good vote. Don't know where the tally is presently.
Click to expand...

sheltermed said:
"asking question to ask questions" is nothing I haven't heard before. I think it's a point of contention in every game I play. The questions I asked came from a place of not having read a large portion of this very long thread that blew up way quicker than what I'm used to, being likely unable to read it all prior to close this evening, and wanting to solve and be helpful, thereby requesting assistance.

as for mayo, I have no additional thoughts. I have never played with him before to my knowledge. so, similar reactions to XYZ is actually helpful for me and is making me think further about my vote.

I know mkg is a chronically absent player, at least in my experience. outside of that, I would be interested in why there is a pile on her now. I haven't read anything other than this post above where you've tagged me. I know on d0 she low key advocated to be mayor herself, then disappeared. I will look to see if she's been back - I don't recall anything recently.

I'm home from work, but I'm tutoring dvm students in an hour and have last minute prep for that. I'll do my best to look into this now while I have a few minutes.
Click to expand...

sheltermed said:
unvote mayo

vote chic

@Zenge142

(am tutoring atm, will try to be back before close)
Click to expand...
 
samac said:
It looks like you didn’t mention mayo one time after cycle 1 or push there cycle 2
Or is the search failing me
Click to expand...

I just didn't feel that a push from me would make much of difference, iirc the group was pretty focused on someone else and no one tends to take me seriously (with good reason) lol
 
JaggedJimmyJay said:
Thanks. I thought I recalled you suspecting mayo before that, so the shoe fits. It was my impression then that some people found mayo suspicious, and others had him hard null. I don't believe anyone town read him perhaps apart from samac briefly.
Click to expand...
I did a bit , but mostly because I appreciated the post restriction and was funnee. Didnt have a real reason with much weight
 
I was leaf peeping and doing various other things today but I'm reading now. My general assumption was if the cult goes down and the game's not over then we yeet shelter and if the game's still not over then we figure out what to do next.
 
NateTheLesser said:
I was leaf peeping and doing various other things today but I'm reading now. My general assumption was if the cult goes down and the game's not over then we yeet shelter and if the game's still not over then we figure out what to do next.
Click to expand...
samac will be pleased to hear that.
 
JaggedJimmyJay said:
A cult can be a non-killing anti-town faction.

What else exists? If Clem does not kill but is anti-town, what is Clem? Apply the same question to anyone else without a claimed killing ability. I genuinely have no idea, but perhaps there is some SDN precedent.
Click to expand...

I've seen roles like Mayo's sneezing role, where you're "marking" people each night and win if everyone alive has been marked by you. (In fact, the last game on my homesite was a Mad Men themed game that ended up being won by Roger Sterling who was handing out martinis)
 
NateTheLesser said:
I've seen roles like Mayo's sneezing role, where you're "marking" people each night and win if everyone alive has been marked by you. (In fact, the last game on my homesite was a Mad Men themed game that ended up being won by Roger Sterling who was handing out martinis)
Click to expand...

But, as far as relating it to Clem's role, even if he's also "marking" and can win that way, I wouldn't expect the game to still be going unless there's an anti-town faction (sk/wolf/cult) still alive. Which I think was your point.
 
JaggedJimmyJay said:
Why did you eat a bomb bro
Click to expand...
lol it went like this.
I was told the bomb didn't even look real. Initially I was going to send it to Santy and have him blow up, but then I wavered on my read on him and wasn't sure who I wanted to send it to otherwise. At that point I was also pretty deep in the PoE and wanted to do something meaningful with the bomb in case I went down. Thus, I declared if scum were on my yeet one of them should die, and I ate the bomb. I have no idea if it's still active in my intestines.
 
Of course at the time I assumed we were up against wolves and not this (RIP) cult + mystery other 3p possible serial killer business, but eh. Just call me the bomb.com
 
I also don't know the state of my banana. I have had no tummy aches, but I have received no notification that I need to use the restroom. So it's still in there. Ominous banana.
 
Man all this talk about bombs and bananas, it is hard to know when a post is just being funny and when it is talking about something game related. I bet samac's laundry post ends up somewhat game related too
 
Boquise said:
Man all this talk about bombs and bananas, it is hard to know when a post is just being funny and when it is talking about something game related. I bet samac's laundry post ends up somewhat game related too
Click to expand...
Yes, these are unaccounted for mechanics.
 
I'm caught up but it just feels like throwing darts at this point. As long as it's Clem/shelter in some order, I find it difficult to care all that much about who goes first.
 
Shelter sounds believably confused about the game state. Like, if she's SK then she can pretty easily push Clem today and that would be the best move for her, but she's hesitant to go there. The only nugget that doesn't quite fit is that she said she wouldn't want to be a solo 3p, but she has been a SK on the avocado and had fun with it if I recall correctly. (That doesn't mean she'd want to be one *in this game* and would request it, though)
 
I'm also mulling whether a theoretical Arsonist Clem would just.. forget to arson one of the nights. Arson is more fun than sandwiches.
 
NateTheLesser said:
Shelter sounds believably confused about the game state. Like, if she's SK then she can pretty easily push Clem today and that would be the best move for her, but she's hesitant to go there. The only nugget that doesn't quite fit is that she said she wouldn't want to be a solo 3p, but she has been a SK on the avocado and had fun with it if I recall correctly. (That doesn't mean she'd want to be one *in this game* and would request it, though)
Click to expand...
This is something to talk about @sheltermed.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

Similar threads

Zenge142
MaWWke YoWWr OWWn WW -Sign Ups
2 3
Replies
130
Views
5K
NateTheLesser
NateTheLesser
Animal Midwife
Death Nommy - Game Thread
83 84 85 86 87
Replies
4K
Views
48K
Animal Midwife
Animal Midwife
WildZoo
  • Poll Poll
Mission ImpoWWssible Game Thread
46 47 48 49 50
Replies
2K
Views
35K
Clem J
Clem J
WildZoo
  • Poll Poll
Noob WW Game 2025 Sign Ups: All New WW Players Welcome! (OPEN)
2 3 4
Replies
153
Views
8K
RespectTheChemistry
R
kaydubs
Melee WW Game Thread-April 2024
27 28 29 30 31
Replies
2K
Views
29K
Sandy Dikson
Sandy Dikson
Top