Smash Bros WW Game Thread

Veterinary School Application Advising Ad
This forum made possible through the generous support of SDN members, donors, and sponsors. Thank you.
Members don't see this ad.
PrincessButterCup said:
I didn't say I trust it, but I am willing to consider other people. I realize I didn't make the most sense there. If someone else is a real possibility I could be persuaded to move my vote.

She didn't bring up another candidate in her defense (unless I missed it on my phone?) which is another weird feel. I'm more inclined to go with role reveals if they're making a effort to contribute themselves rather than hoping their reveal will magically take the pressure off.

Eh, I'm talking myself around in circles. I don't see another player I want to lynch more than her, especially from the other slight leaders - I don't want to vote Moose for inactivity when so many people still haven't come in at all, and I need to look closer and see what the coffee? votes are for.
Click to expand...
This is weird, if you believe her you believe her don't rely on others to bring up candidates. Think for yourself
 
Animal Midwife said:
What would either flip tell you about jboo and Cray? Why not PBC or anyone else that lynched Mixy today?

You seemed to insinuate earlier that a mislynch still held information.



Stated why a couple posts after this one.
Click to expand...
Because I was on phone in the lab and couldn't go back and see who was voting for her. But I saw mixys reply state those two and me and dubz (who was a later voter I think) so wouldn't tell me much about her. And yes a mislynch would tell us something but not about those two.
 
Coopah said:
This is weird, if you believe her you believe her don't rely on others to bring up candidates. Think for yourself
Click to expand...
How many times is someone leading lynch and we ask them for their reads? There's a reason.

I stand by that. She's trying to save herself with a role reveal and not by contributing to discussion. Her role reveal made me hesitate when I saw it at first, but the more I look at her, the more things are off.
 
Unofficial GAME ON Day 1 Lynch Tally:
RL-KB (1) - DVMD
SAR () -
MA (6) - PBC, jboo, Cray, Coop, Pippy, Elfabeth
bryndy (1) - SAR
Coops () -
genny (1) - BBC/Ferny
BBC () -
Paws (1) - Skimble
Elfabeth (1) - MOOSE
Cray (1) - MA
Mel () -
Coffee (4) - Stagg, genny, Mel, Glam
PBC (1) - WZ
allieh (1) - Coffee
MJ (1) - kc
MOOSE (3) - AM, Paws, RL-KB

22/27
Deadline in 30 minutes (at 10pm Eastern/9pm Central)
 
Coopah said:
Because I was on phone in the lab and couldn't go back and see who was voting for her. But I saw mixys reply state those two and me and dubz (who was a later voter I think) so wouldn't tell me much about her. And yes a mislynch would tell us something but not about those two.
Click to expand...

Who would you look at harder in the event of a mislynch?
 
PrincessButterCup said:
How many times is someone leading lynch and we ask them for their reads? There's a reason.

I stand by that. She's trying to save herself with a role reveal and not by contributing to discussion. Her role reveal made me hesitate when I saw it at first, but the more I look at her, the more things are off.
Click to expand...
There a difference between asking for reads and saying she hasn't proposed someone in her stead so that's why you're voting for her. I dunno feels weird.
 
Coopah said:
WHYYYYYYYY?!
Click to expand...
R0FylWX.gif
 
Coopah said:
There a difference between asking for reads and saying she hasn't proposed someone in her stead so that's why you're voting for her. I dunno feels weird.
Click to expand...
I'm saying she took a last ditch attempt (role reveal should always be dead last defense), commented on the people voting for her, role revealed, and that's it. I'm saying there was a lack of effort on her part and I don't like it.
 
Animal Midwife said:
Who would you look at harder in the event of a mislynch?
Click to expand...
PBC honestly, she's just so wishy-washy right now like she knows what's coming and is trying to prematurely build a defense. But I don't want to change my feels about mixy based on my feels for another person if that makes any sense. I'd be happy with either lynch rn.
 
Some thoughts:
johnnaboo said:
Is no one considering that Mixy could have been provided a cover role?
Click to expand...
Cover roles are frequent enough. Cover abilities seem to be more rare. That being said, safe from night kills is a great fake one for wolves to use. Safe from all night actions is a little harder to pull off which is why I'm willing to let it go for a few days to see if anything pops up. Also, in this game I feel like no one would need a cover role because everyone is kind of against everyone?
johnnaboo said:
No freakin clue.

Also, to answer your earlier question now that I was able to re-read and actually formulate thoughts...
KC popping in first thing but not saying much or voting came off as odd
BBC also popped in early and then poofed outta here, but I've never played with her so idk

But those are just WIFOM. I can't really do reads on people who haven't checked in.
Click to expand...
Saw the thread posted, have never been the first to post, took the opportunity and immediately went to bed because I'm an old lady now.
Miranda Senft said:
You seem like your normal questioning self
Mel seems like his normal self as well
Dubz is a bit quiet but I'm not too concerned
PBC seems a bit defensive but to be voted on the first day makes you so so I'm eh
I'm always suspicious of Cray just based on her meta so I'm keeping my eye on her
RL-KB is a dangerous hybrid since RL is a noob and can claim as such and KB is such an experienced player and, having wolfed with her recently, she's excellent at directing people
I don't agree with the Mixy vote as she sounds normal
I think allie is a bit defensive, but again, she got lynched last time for being quiet so I'm willing to give her a day
SAR seems suspicious
Jboo is kinda setting off my radar but I just wolfed with her last game and she was less active that game
Paws seems normal as well
I haven't played with a lot of the people here so this is what I've got so far.
Click to expand...
Dunno why but this post (and the underlined) bugged me. Feels like a lot of nothing? And where was allie being defensive? The only thing I really recall seeing from allie today was her essentially calling herself out for having been quiet... seems like a weird thing to say.

Unlynch MJ
Lynch Moose

Cuz them feels.
 
Miranda Senft said:
Whoops, I missed her post around 8 pm. I thought Cray called her out on stuff and then she disappeared for a bit, my bad. Although, that 8 pm post does seem a little too defensive about being away, but maybe she's (he's? sorry SAR!) super passionate about WW 😛
Click to expand...

Why aren't you voting for her?
 
PrincessButterCup said:
I'm saying she took a last ditch attempt (role reveal should always be dead last defense), commented on the people voting for her, role revealed, and that's it. I'm saying there was a lack of effort on her part and I don't like it.
Click to expand...
That I completely agree with and was one of the reasons I didn't like that role reveal at all. But I do understand she thought she couldn't speak again for the rest of the day so what do you think about that?
 
My initial feel was DVMDream...but idk it clearly won’t matter who I vote for bc I don’t like Mixy, and I’m not gonna vote Moose for being inactive. And Coffee doesn’t make enough sense at this point.

Lynch DVMDream
 
kcoughli said:
Some thoughts:

Cover roles are frequent enough. Cover abilities seem to be more rare. That being said, safe from night kills is a great fake one for wolves to use. Safe from all night actions is a little harder to pull off which is why I'm willing to let it go for a few days to see if anything pops up. Also, in this game I feel like no one would need a cover role because everyone is kind of against everyone?

Saw the thread posted, have never been the first to post, took the opportunity and immediately went to bed because I'm an old lady now.

Dunno why but this post (and the underlined) bugged me. Feels like a lot of nothing? And where was allie being defensive? The only thing I really recall seeing from allie today was her essentially calling herself out for having been quiet... seems like a weird thing to say.

Unlynch MJ
Lynch Moose

Cuz them feels.
Click to expand...
You are correct, I skimmed the thread as I'm exhausted and need to drive all day tomorrow. For some reason I thought she got upset when I was called out for being quiet because in my delirium, the hydra came after her next...I'm literally making stuff up in my brain because of exhaustion and too many soap operas 😛
 
GAME ON Day 1 Lynch Tally:
RL-KB (1) - DVMD
SAR () -
MA (6) - PBC, jboo, Cray, Coop, Pippy, Elfabeth
bryndy (1) - SAR
Coops () -
genny (1) - BBC/Ferny
BBC () -
Paws (1) - Skimble
Elfabeth (1) - MOOSE
Cray () -
Mel () -
Coffee (5) - Stagg, genny, Mel, Glam, MA
PBC (1) - WZ
allieh (1) - Coffee
MJ () -
MOOSE (4) - AM, Paws, RL-KB, kc
DVMD (1) - dolph

23/27
Deadline in 20 minutes (at 10pm Eastern/9pm Central)
 
Animal Midwife said:
Are the feels stronger for Elfabeth?
Click to expand...
A bit. I don't like the acknowledgement of being a noob without any prodding for it. Like, when you make a mistake or say something with improper etiquette in your first game, you say, "sorry, i'm still a noob", but not as a justification (along with bandwagoning!!) for the vote.
 
Animal Midwife said:
This seems a little retaliatory. Do you still feel SAR is a wolf? Anything else about Mixy wolfy?
Click to expand...

Lol, I forgot she voted me when I did that. Basically Mel took the wind out of my SAR vote sails so I looked to my next top suspect that I felt had reason to suspect foul play, not an RVS throwaway. I criticized MA's play before she voted me anyway.

If it feels retaliatory, I'm not surprised. There is a little heat behind my vote here. Not sure I like Mixy's style, frankly. I think her interactions with DVMD and others is not only reactive, counterproductive, arrogant, but also a bit too pushy and without good logic in my view, which I stated earlier about her reaction to DVMD.

Villagers can get a bit pushy, yes. I know in my case, I feel at my pushiest as a wolf. It never sits right for me to see a "villager" trying to run the village. I could be wrong on that gut feel, but it is a red flag in my book.

So yes, I find it all extremely wolfy. It seems to me that putting pressure on MA is the right thing to do here, period.
 
Animal Midwife said:
Why?
Click to expand...
You know why
PippyPony said:
Disagree, I feel like this is on the heels of a bunch of people saying "noobs, think for yourselves and vote for who you think is most wolfy"
Click to expand...
OK I guess you don't. It's fine if you disagree but maybe I'm expecting too much but a noob wolf would be like I don't wanna be on a bandwagon, too much attention. Especially if she flips village. Plus there's still the possibility of a swing. Wait what's the tally that might clear it up.
 
Coopah said:
That I completely agree with and was one of the reasons I didn't like that role reveal at all. But I do understand she thought she couldn't speak again for the rest of the day so what do you think about that?
Click to expand...

I think that's convenient.

She posted her role reveal just after 4 my time and posted up until 4:50 ish. She had time to try other tactics before her reveal.
 
Miranda Senft said:
And why are you voting for me if your initial reasoning for voting for me was that I wasn't here, why are you still voting for me? 🙂
I'm learning 20 questions from the best!
Click to expand...

It wasn't you being gone, but rather, the amount of time and reasoning between your unlynch and current lynch.
 
SportPonies said:
GAME ON Day 1 Lynch Tally:
RL-KB (1) - DVMD
SAR () -
MA (6) - PBC, jboo, Cray, Coop, Pippy, Elfabeth
bryndy (1) - SAR
Coops () -
genny (1) - BBC/Ferny
BBC () -
Paws (1) - Skimble
Elfabeth (1) - MOOSE
Cray () -
Mel () -
Coffee (5) - Stagg, genny, Mel, Glam, MA
PBC (1) - WZ
allieh (1) - Coffee
MJ () -
MOOSE (4) - AM, Paws, RL-KB, kc
DVMD (1) - dolph

23/27
Deadline in 20 minutes (at 10pm Eastern/9pm Central)
Click to expand...
Huh I guess she could've gone with coffee if protecting a wolf. OK
 
dolphin106258 said:
Oh okay, it was just the way it was phrased I guess especially the bolded part that made it sound like you were defending yourself or something. I dont know :ninja: maybe now I'm going too deep into things
Click to expand...

I don't think you're going too deep. I think it was worth thinking about.

Hard to tell if RL's comment there was nooby village or nooby wolf. So it's null but we always watch the noobs closely after that game with @Lawper
 
PrincessButterCup said:
I didn't say I trust it, but I am willing to consider other people. I realize I didn't make the most sense there. If someone else is a real possibility I could be persuaded to move my vote.

She didn't bring up another candidate in her defense (unless I missed it on my phone?) which is another weird feel. I'm more inclined to go with role reveals if they're making a effort to contribute themselves rather than hoping their reveal will magically take the pressure off.
Click to expand...
I thought she already had made a case for cray
 
Coopah said:
This is a toss away vote and makes me side-eye you hard.
Click to expand...
Like I said at the time the other leaders didn’t seem like a good enough vote. So I guess I could actually throw away my vote and pick one of them. But generally in the last game I played everyone went back to the beginning votes and questioned people’s reasons. So I’d rather have sound logic that I actually believe.
 
GAME ON Day 1 Lynch Tally:
RL-KB (1) - DVMD
SAR () -
MA (6) - PBC, jboo, Cray, Coop, Pippy, Elfabeth
bryndy (1) - SAR
Coops () -
genny (1) - BBC/Ferny
BBC () -
Paws (1) - Skimble
Elfabeth (2) - MOOSE, Nyan
Cray () -
Mel () -
Coffee (5) - Stagg, genny, Mel, Glam, MA
PBC (2) - WZ, Paws
allieh (1) - Coffee
MJ () -
MOOSE (3) - AM, RL-KB, kc
DVMD (1) - dolph

24/27
Deadline in 10 minutes (at 10pm Eastern/9pm Central)
 
dolphin106258 said:
Like I said at the time the other leaders didn’t seem like a good enough vote. So I guess I could actually throw away my vote and pick one of them. But generally in the last game I played everyone went back to the beginning votes and questioned people’s reasons. So I’d rather have sound logic that I actually believe.
Click to expand...
I like this one, she can stay
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

Similar threads

WildZoo
SDN Fairgrounds - 10th Annual Noob WW Game
9 10 11 12 13
Replies
613
Views
6K
katiemcat
katiemcat
Animal Midwife
Death Nommy - Game Thread
83 84 85 86 87
Replies
4K
Views
52K
Animal Midwife
Animal Midwife
WildZoo
  • Poll Poll
Mission ImpoWWssible Game Thread
46 47 48 49 50
Replies
2K
Views
38K
Clem J
Clem J
WildZoo
Noob WW Game 2025 Sign Ups: All New WW Players Welcome! (CLOSED)
2 3 4
Replies
178
Views
11K
katiemcat
katiemcat
kaydubs
Melee WW Game Thread-April 2024
27 28 29 30 31
Replies
2K
Views
31K
Sandy Dikson
Sandy Dikson
Top