Time To Get a WWatch - Game Thread

Veterinary School Application Advising Ad
This forum made possible through the generous support of SDN members, donors, and sponsors. Thank you.
Members don't see this ad.
I also think PSV townslipped (IMO, opinions may differ here). I can find the actual post, but I was saying something about wolf cover roles and she pointed out that parts of the header were copy-pasted from an earlier game so that may not actually be the case. That's a thought that I would not expect a wolf to have there. Like, it's towny lack of TMI about whether wolves do in fact have cover roles. (Not sure if this explanation makes sense, but there it is)
 
By vote movements, I think the trend of samac+ new people being in the wagons is kinda consistent too? Tho I am throwing this argument as brainspew and not checking really.

But assuming a team of three, the first thought that crosses me is Nate+2 regulars. Or like, highly likely that there are 2 regulars? Should check unpairings there . But its also true that I could be for the more quiet playstyle in general that is apparent kinda
 
Santygrass said:
Samac thoughts on the slot, they were giving a fairly confident tr there. That + the EoD seemed like they didnt have a partner at risk for sure (Unless its True, and if it is the timing of that defense still is super weird) .

I think they are Rand>V tbh
Click to expand...
"Didn't have a partner at risk" does not equal town, though. I agree that it didn't seem like they had a partner at risk, but that can also mean that there wasn't a wagon on a wolf at that point.
 
NateTheLesser said:
I also think PSV townslipped (IMO, opinions may differ here). I can find the actual post, but I was saying something about wolf cover roles and she pointed out that parts of the header were copy-pasted from an earlier game so that may not actually be the case. That's a thought that I would not expect a wolf to have there. Like, it's towny lack of TMI about whether wolves do in fact have cover roles. (Not sure if this explanation makes sense, but there it is)
Click to expand...
I’m village reading her but I don’t think this is the townslip you think it is. It had already been mentioned that the rules were copied from an old game.

A wolf could just as easily be like “hey wolves may not have cover roles” even if they DID to try and make their reveals more convincing
 
NateTheLesser said:
So why is my vote on Sporty. I'm not totally seeing the towniness that others have mentioned there? She's seemed very surface-level when she's been around. I admit I was townreading her catch-up near EOD yesterday, but that's also easy to do (and an easy thing to do to "look busy" if no wolves were in danger). Her strongest take has seemed to be the PSV townread which is based on not seeing a secret wolf tell, which is an all-timer for "easiest town read to fake" because it doesn't require pointing at actual content. (And.... I haven't gotten the sense that she's been caught up at any point, so I'm not sure why she'd be confident that PSV hasn't done whatever this wolf tell is..?)

I'd appreciate thoughts there.
Click to expand...
I'm not sure where I land on Sporty because I don't agree with her PSV take. It's nice to be on the same page (literally) with her most of this game though.
 
SportPonies said:
I’m village reading her but I don’t think this is the townslip you think it is. It had already been mentioned that the rules were copied from an old game.

A wolf could just as easily be like “hey wolves may not have cover roles” even if they DID to try and make their reveals more convincing
Click to expand...
Yeah, I was rereading through to see if I could find where PSV said that and I came across samac saying it even before PSV posted for the first time.
 
Also, I think that April is p wolfy either way? Like, I dont think their reaction to Nate role makes much sense. Cuz even if we assume they forgot that the item they received from me related to a fruit vendor, that relates to fruit vendor being a unfamiliar role to them.

So then comes Nate claiming that way with so much wait, and get a counterclaim. And they take both at face value ? I don't see that making much sense from their PoV? Maybe regulars sanity check me if this is too crazy .

Like, even if we assume Nate is V, it could be a TMI read cuz in that case they knew Nate was telling the truth and didnt felt weird the cc of a role they were unfamiliar to begin with.

Standing Emoji
 
Animal Midwife said:
Yeah, I was rereading through to see if I could find where PSV said that and I came across samac saying it even before PSV posted for the first time.
Click to expand...
I remember some mention that the game info was copy-pasted, but not specifically wrt the rules. Idk
 
Why are you townreading Nate if not for the mechanical stuff @JaggedJimmyJay ?
What do you think of Empire opposite take on Nate on that? (With which I agree more tbh)
 
JaggedJimmyJay said:
Exercise for the room:

If you were to pretend for a moment that mechanics and claims don't exist whatsoever, what do your reads look like right now?
Click to expand...
The same as they are, really. You've maybe fallen a spot or two with the odd focus on Samac's role, which felt fairly settled to me. It just doesn't seem like a productive thing to spend time chewing on; more like something that appears busy and productive.

Animal Midwife said:
Nonetheless, do not take any flavor claim at face value until we know what the wolves look like.
Click to expand...
Given every game I've seen from Zenge and Dubz, there's not a chance in hell that flavor should factor into any of our votes.
 
Santygrass said:
Why are you townreading Nate if not for the mechanical stuff @JaggedJimmyJay ?
What do you think of Empire opposite take on Nate on that? (With which I agree more tbh)
Click to expand...
Not playing like I expect a mafioso with a big tally lead to play. I think Empire’s view is a bit uncharitable.

I might just vote Nate anyway. I don’t have any better ideas.
 
If there’s anything that I am not doing right now, it’s laugh. I’m starting to get cranky! Irritated! Mad babyrage!

(I’m confused, and I don’t think I have been able to effectively communicate why or to what extent, so *throws hands up*)
 
Santygrass said:
Also, I think that April is p wolfy either way? Like, I dont think their reaction to Nate role makes much sense. Cuz even if we assume they forgot that the item they received from me related to a fruit vendor, that relates to fruit vendor being a unfamiliar role to them.

So then comes Nate claiming that way with so much wait, and get a counterclaim. And they take both at face value ? I don't see that making much sense from their PoV? Maybe regulars sanity check me if this is too crazy .

Like, even if we assume Nate is V, it could be a TMI read cuz in that case they knew Nate was telling the truth and didnt felt weird the cc of a role they were unfamiliar to begin with.

Standing Emoji
Click to expand...
I feel like as a wolf she might be more hyperaware any vending action if she w/w with Nate.
 
I am about to do my examIn anxious af help.

Also feeling naughty

Unteet Nate
Yeet April
 
NateTheLesser said:
This wagon formation something something 😅

Code: 
Nate    4 (JJJ, Clem, Santy, Empire)
JJJ     1 (PSV)
Empire  1 (April)
PSV     1 (AM)
April   1 (Truey)
Sporty  1 (Nate)
AM      1 (Sporty)
Click to expand...
If there are three mafia and you are town, then this elimination would [probably] be the last mistake we are allowed. Accordingly, it could be an emergency. I don't sense much urgency from you. What's your mindset?
 
SportPonies said:
You’re playing different.

I just noticed the lack of 20Q. Contemplating that.

Still okay with a Nate yeet, but no point in piling on rn.
Click to expand...
Ignoring the fact that I yeeted Nate and have continued to pressure him, I've questioned plenty of people this game. I'm going to give you a chance to recant.
 
Animal Midwife said:
Ignoring the fact that I yeeted Nate and have continued to pressure him, I've questioned plenty of people this game. I'm going to give you a chance to recant.
Click to expand...
SportPonies said:
You’re playing different.

I just noticed the lack of 20Q. Contemplating that.

Still okay with a Nate yeet, but no point in piling on rn.
Click to expand...
She's 20Q'd me, at least.

I am pretty sure she's village AM.
 
SportPonies said:
sure.

I'm still allowed to sit on your vote while I read.
Click to expand...
Add this to your reading material.
SportPonies said:
I actually was just finishing typing this when both Coffee asked for it and Dubz came back:

Been waiting for Dubz to come back, but I really need to disappear to study, so I need to say this now. I simply do not see how AM is village. When I asked for her last games, I wanted to double check that she still plays the way I remember her playing, and she does. Even when she's in a village panic-spiral, she's playing 20Q. I've hardly seen any questions from her the last few days. More importantly, she has not posted a single tally this game. This has historically, without exception, been a giveaway for AM.

And like, sure, if you guys want to take her "second" post as evidence of wolfiness, go ahead. Whatever makes you happy. Just lynch her for god's sake.
Click to expand...
 
JaggedJimmyJay said:
If there are three mafia and you are town, then this elimination would [probably] be the last mistake we are allowed. Accordingly, it could be an emergency. I don't sense much urgency from you. What's your mindset?
Click to expand...
Unfortunately, I'm just as lost as the rest of you. But I think my wagon is all or almost all town, so I'm not giving up yet (and having to miss this EOD is, uh, poor timing).

(Setting aside for a moment that I know I'm town), I don't really understand wolfreading my claim. In the scenario where I'm a wolf, I think it would be reasonable for the wolf team to expect that I would be POE again today. And the plan for that was.. to claim something that ties me to the nightkill, unprompted? The responses that are "it's FPS, just kill it" are more understandable to me (which I think Clem falls under and at least your initial reaction leaned that way).

Yeah, people brought up an earlier case of PSV doing it as a wolf, but in that case she knew she was blocked so there was known mech info to get out ahead of.
 
NateTheLesser said:
Unfortunately, I'm just as lost as the rest of you. But I think my wagon is all or almost all town, so I'm not giving up yet (and having to miss this EOD is, uh, poor timing).

(Setting aside for a moment that I know I'm town), I don't really understand wolfreading my claim. In the scenario where I'm a wolf, I think it would be reasonable for the wolf team to expect that I would be POE again today. And the plan for that was.. to claim something that ties me to the nightkill, unprompted? The responses that are "it's FPS, just kill it" are more understandable to me (which I think Clem falls under and at least your initial reaction leaned that way).

Yeah, people brought up an earlier case of PSV doing it as a wolf, but in that case she knew she was blocked so there was known mech info to get out ahead of.
Click to expand...
Thanks for indulging my questions. Gun to your head, you have to name two mafia right now. Who?
 
SportPonies said:
well, that's my memory failure then. I will properly reassign it.

Regardless, people are allowed to vote for you and this conversation happens every game someone votes for you.
Click to expand...
And I'm going to continue to hold people accountable every time. I expect to see improvement by 9EDT.
 
SportPonies said:
Who here has played with Nate, again?

Do we have any sense of metanalysis?

Sorry if this has been asked already.
Click to expand...
Spectated once, played once. He was town in both. I was mafia when we played. I have only vague impressions. I think he looks similar to his town games in spirit, albeit at a level that wouldn't be terribly difficult to replicate. This is a big part of my struggle today.
 
NateTheLesser said:
Unfortunately, I'm just as lost as the rest of you. But I think my wagon is all or almost all town, so I'm not giving up yet (and having to miss this EOD is, uh, poor timing).

(Setting aside for a moment that I know I'm town), I don't really understand wolfreading my claim. In the scenario where I'm a wolf, I think it would be reasonable for the wolf team to expect that I would be POE again today. And the plan for that was.. to claim something that ties me to the nightkill, unprompted? The responses that are "it's FPS, just kill it" are more understandable to me (which I think Clem falls under and at least your initial reaction leaned that way).

Yeah, people brought up an earlier case of PSV doing it as a wolf, but in that case she knew she was blocked so there was known mech info to get out ahead of.
Click to expand...
Why would PSV be blocked?
 
JaggedJimmyJay said:
Spectated once, played once. He was town in both. I was mafia when we played. I have only vague impressions. I think he looks similar to his town games in spirit, albeit at a level that wouldn't be terribly difficult to replicate. This is a big part of my struggle today.
Click to expand...
Don't know how I got myself into the middle of a game that consists of some of the best SDNers and a bunch of outside ringers.

This is sehr stressig.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

Similar threads

Animal Midwife
Death Nommy - Game Thread
83 84 85 86 87
Replies
4K
Views
52K
Animal Midwife
Animal Midwife
WildZoo
  • Poll Poll
Mission ImpoWWssible Game Thread
46 47 48 49 50
Replies
2K
Views
38K
Clem J
Clem J
supershorty
GGoats ThWWee: Here It GGoats Again - GAME THREAD
93 94 95 96 97
Replies
5K
Views
52K
vampyrica
vampyrica
WildZoo
  • Poll Poll
PokeWWon: A Wild Kanto Adventure - Champs Season 12 Practice Game Thread
87 88 89 90 91
Replies
5K
Views
56K
Animal Midwife
Animal Midwife
Animal Midwife
Matrix - Game Thread
77 78 79 80 81
Replies
4K
Views
87K
samac
samac
Top