So this is the match results of the 2017 class. I want you guys to understand a few things before you dive head long into this data and start making snap judgements. 1st it is impossible to account for people that wanted a competitive specialty but just could not make it vs those that change their minds for other reasons. I myself was very interested in a very competitive specialty and after taking step 1 and NOT getting a score high enough I still had a good change of landing it in either the AOA match or the Military match however 3rd year happened I rotated in the specialty and hated everything about it. Now my target is a specialty that is considered not competitive. 2nd pay attention to the number of those that scramble, SOAP or get placed. While these persons did eventually land a spot they did not match and it is more likely they were pushed into a field they didn't want to be in but had to settle. The whole placement thing is a whole different can of worms usually involving a dean calling up a friend to place a student. 3rd once the AOA match is completely closed competition will go up not down. It really is simple math there will be more applicants than there are competitive spots. More and more people will want to get into these spots every year. That does mean that some things will just be out of your league, some will be quite difficult and others not too bad. 4th it is hard to tell if an applicant applied wisely or not. Some people just do not apply to enough programs, regions or just do things that are not smart and end up either not matching at all or SOAP/scrambling into a program they really don't want. 5th the total percent match rate that schools post is after SOAP/scramble and does not mean anything. 6th take notice for the specialties you don't see people matching into vs the ones they do. Schools that regularly have people matching into Ultra competitive specialties like Derm, opthal, urology, rad onc and ortho have a support network that makes this a possibility for their students. It also means for the other specialties they have something in place too which will make it easier for you and trust me you will want any help you can get. 7th You can't account for the special snow flake phenomena. There is always one person that no matter what kills boards, is top of the class, has connections to research and gets published, is president of every club, has mountains of letters or rec, has a personal statement that reads like a novel, is married to the senator of California daughter and ect. This is NOT you. Its not and this is fine. Don't get stupid and think that well that dude matched ortho that one year so I can do it to so it doesn't matter what school you go to. Nor should you look a match summary and see one person matched in Derm and think a school matches people in derm all the time or even it is likely. If you don't see a trend of those matches most years, it was the special snow flake phenomena.
If you are looking at a schools match data trying to figure out if a school is right for you I hope it isn't high up on your reasons for choosing a school or not. Schools have little control over what specialty you choose but they can and WILL push you to go the direction that fits what they want. Carey's mission is to make rural primary care physicians for the gulf south USA. That means Family Medicine.
Look into how a school facilitates NOT forces learning. A school should make it easier for you to learn all this data not harder. Lastly a good medical school never makes good doctors they make good medical students, good residencies make good doctors. It is a transition to each step and each step before should prepare to or enable you to learn the next step if it doesn't or it feeds you BS about trying to make better doctors not just good board scores be cautious.
Ok soap box time over... Do what you will with this data.
Total number of students who participated in the 2 matches = 93
Military Match
Number of students who participated = 2
Number who obtained their primary choice of specialty = 2 (100% primary choice success rate)
Breakdown of specialties:
FM=1, IM=1
AOA Match
Number who participated = 55
Number who matched = 33 (60%)
Number who obtained their primary choice of specialty = 31 (93.94% of those matched)
Number who obtained their secondary choice of specialty = 2
Number who went into the scramble = 22
Number who actively sought GME placement in scramble = 12
Number who bypassed scramble to try the NRMP = 10
Number who successfully found GME via the scramble = 8
Number who obtained their primary choice of specialty via scramble = 2 (25%)
Number who obtained their secondary choice of specialty via scramble = 4 (50%)
Number who entered TRI and ultimate specialty is TBD next year = 2 (25%)
Breakdown of specialties in the AOA:
Match: FM-11, IM-8, OB-5, EM-3, Psych-2, General Surgery-2, Ortho-1, TRI-1
Scramble: FM–1, IM–3, OB–1, TRI-3
NRMP Match
Number who participated = 50
Number who matched = 36 (72%)
Number who obtained their primary choice of specialty = 34 (94.44% of those matched)
Number who obtained their secondary choice of specialty = 2
Number who went into the SOAP = 14
Number who successfully found GME via the SOAP = 3
Number who obtained their primary choice of specialty via SOAP = 0
Number who obtained their secondary choice of specialty via SOAP = 0* (secondary specialty was FM but they found a very similar specialty via SOAP)
Number who signed to a different residency specialty outside of their primary and secondary choices during SOAP = 2
Number who are TBD after SOAP due to signing a TRI and ultimate placement is pending = 1
Breakdown of specialties in the NRMP:
Match: FM-11, IM–8, OB–1, EM–5, Radiology–4, Peds–2, PMR–2, Anesthesiology–2, Neuro-1
SOAP: FM-1, TRI-1, Med/Peds-1
Residency placement after the SOAP closed
Number of students who were still seeking GME after the NRMP concluded = 11
Number of students who have been successful so far in obtaining GME placement = 9
Number who obtained their primary choice of specialty after the matches = 2
Number who obtained their secondary choice of specialty after the matches = 2
Number who are TBD after the matches due to signing a TRI and ultimate placement is pending = 5
Number who are still unsigned and working on obtaining GME Position = 2
Breakdown of specialties in the post matches period:
TRI-4, FM-3, IM-1, EM-1