michmed1
Full Member
- Joined
- Nov 21, 2022
- Messages
- 29
- Reaction score
- 37
Did anyone get an A call today?
Negative ghost riderDid anyone get an A call today?
No. I did not.Did anyone get an A call today?
Nope, been over 5 weeks nowDid anyone get an A call today?
Im a current M1 and can confirm this. Don't worry, to put it simply, the changes are in your favor.They’re changing the curriculum which is affecting the start date
I'm coming atcha as a current M1 who was waitlisted during both the 2020-2021 and 2021-2022 application cycles. After I didn't get off the waitlist for 2020-2021, I met with an MSUCOM advisor who told me there was simply little to no waitlist movement that cycle (could have been pandemic-related). However, there was a TON of waitlist movement last cycle, and I am more inclined to guess this cycle will have similar waitlist movement.Interviewed 10/19 first-tier waitlist. Is anyone else in the same boat? how many people get offered off the waitlist for MSUCOM?
What do you think would cause someone to be waitlisted rather than accepted?I'm coming atcha as a current M1 who was waitlisted during both the 2020-2021 and 2021-2022 application cycles. After I didn't get off the waitlist for 2020-2021, I met with an MSUCOM advisor who told me there was simply little to no waitlist movement that cycle (could have been pandemic-related). However, there was a TON of waitlist movement last cycle, and I am more inclined to guess this cycle will have similar waitlist movement.
You want my take? For MSU COM, it's the timing of your interview.What do you think would cause someone to be waitlisted rather than accepted?
What do you think would cause someone to be waitlisted rather than accepted?
I interviewed 11/8. Was hoping to hear back either this week or next. I feel your pain, hang in there.Losing my sanity week by week. I hope they give me a response before winter break.
I thought they usually screen for your stats BEFORE the interview and if you get the interview, stats are not used usually to determine acceptance or not as the interview performance is more or less solely weighed upon. right? I keep hearing both (that stats are used after interview or stats are used after interview).You want my take? For MSU COM, it's the timing of your interview.
I interviewed (two cycles in a row) around April/May, and I genuinely don't think they had any or enough open seats to offer at that time, so I was at the mercy of the waitlist. For context, I submitted my application early both times, and I was a very appealing DO applicant. I suppose I just didn't stand out enough to be offered an interview right away.
Other than that, it could be anything, from not showcasing enough diversity/interest in diverse populations, not expressing enough interest in osteopathic medicine/MSU COM, or your stats (although I'm inclined to believe MSU COM doesn't weigh those as heavily as other schools)
I'm also an M1 and I do have a bit of a different take. My best guess is that if you received an interview, your stats/experience are acceptable. However, I do think that stats/experience give you more leeway with how you do on the interview, and having interviewed before winter break, I don't think a lack of spots is a problem. If you have above average stats/experience, having a meh interview ( not stand-out awesome, but not bombed) will get you accepted. If you have average stats/experience, having a meh interview may get you waitlisted or admitted, depends on your writing, interviewer eval, etc. If you have below average stats/experience, a meh interview may get you waitlisted or rejected. I do think they take the entire application into account when making final decisions, not just the interview. My personal opinion as well, but because MSUCOM's interviews are so laid back/unstructured, it can put you at a disadvantage of really making yourself shine.I thought they usually screen for your stats BEFORE the interview and if you get the interview, stats are not used usually to determine acceptance or not as the interview performance is more or less solely weighed upon. right? I keep hearing both (that stats are used after interview or stats are used after interview).
How are my stats then with a 504 MCAT, 3.7 GPA, URM, a unique story, 500 Clinical hours, 100 shadowing outside of country (no DO though but doctor used regenerative medicine and methods akin to a DO. I have 150 hours of Research as well. And 100 of volunteering. I also felt my interview was a B or good.From what I’ve been told by advisors and mentors is that your stats always matter throughout the entire application process. I’m not certain how MSUCOM reviews apps before interviews but typically the admissions committee has not even seen your application before your interview. Others have reviewed the basics and decided you meet criteria for an interview THEN after the interview, the admissions committee reviews your entire application including your stats and interview to make a holistic decision. If an area of your application is weak then that is likely why you were waitlisted rather than accepted, especially early on in the process and if you did not have something that really made you stand out to make up for the weak area.
For instance, my MCAT is in the mid-50X range, 3.7X cumulative and sGPA, which are pretty average overall for DO schools. However, I’m URM, non-traditional with >3000 clinical hours in the ICU, >1000 volunteer hours, >1000 research hours with a publication, graduate degree, and a unique story. I interviewed mid-October, interview went poorly and I was sure it was a waitlist but I was accepted 6 weeks later. My mentors and I have discussed it and feel my written application and “extracurriculars” carried me enough that the interview performance was overlooked. It’s only December though and being on the waitlist that early means you have a great chance of being accepted off of it especially since MSUCOM is a higher tier DO school. Many of those accepted may be accepted to MD later on and withdraw. Don’t lose hope!
I'm also an M1 and I do have a bit of a different take. My best guess is that if you received an interview, your stats/experience are acceptable. However, I do think that stats/experience give you more leeway with how you do on the interview, and having interviewed before winter break, I don't think a lack of spots is a problem. If you have above average stats/experience, having a meh interview ( not stand-out awesome, but not bombed) will get you accepted. If you have average stats/experience, having a meh interview may get you waitlisted or admitted, depends on your writing, interviewer eval, etc. If you have below average stats/experience, a meh interview may get you waitlisted or rejected. I do think they take the entire application into account when making final decisions, not just the interview. My personal opinion as well, but because MSUCOM's interviews are so laid back/unstructured, it can put you at a disadvantage of really making yourself shine.
Edited to add: MSUCOM does have one of the higher MCAT averages of all of the DO schools. They do care somewhat about stats.
Nothing as of yetDid anybody get a decision today?
Nothing as of yet
I made a quick sheet to see when post-II decisions have been coming out for this cycle and this is what i got:Seems like they are waiting until next Thursday and Friday. Fingers crossed and prayers up to everybody waiting!
Great analysis! How do you know they accept 70% of interviewed applicants?I do know that typically MSUCOM accepts 70 to 75% of their applicants who received an interview whether it be a waitlist who got accepted or those who got accepted without having to be waitlisted and most of the people who did NOT get accepted have their interviews after January. This is according to last years' thread. And that chance is more significant the earlier one gets accepted to an interview. So far for those who got an answer and interviewed from August till now, there have been little waitlist/rejections in comparison to acceptances if you were to get interviewed earlier. Also, I did read on the MSUCOM website that the pre-admissions committee decides and screens you for BOTH before and after the interview. As such, I really think that if your stats are good enough to pass through an interview; one's interview performance is more heavily weighed upon than stats. As such, if only 3% of those got an interview and they select 75% of those interviewed, one probably has good stats from school's end if you gotten an interview. I hope this gives comfort to those who interviewed and are waiting back. tl;dr, if you have been interviewed thus far and based on historical trends, you are more likely than not, I think, to get accepted either through WL Tier 1 or an A. That's my take.
Here is an excel sheet of an example of the 2018 application cycle for MSUCOM. Scroll down to MSUCOM and see how many people get interviewed vs how many admitted. It shows around 70 to 75%. However, this is a few years ago so it may fluctuate slightly. However, schools usually are consistent with the percent they take in so it should be around that 70 to 75% margin.Great analysis! How do you know they accept 70% of interviewed applicants?
The portal updated for me the next day.For those who were accepted, how long after your A call did take for the email or portal update?
What about the email?The portal updated for me the next day.
I got the email first and then checked the portal, both on the same day.What about the email?
Bro you are too patient to be a premed… are you secretly an adcom?Another week is coming. I wish the next batch, of those who are going to get a decision for this week, good luck!
Looking back on the forum, they are just finishing up those who got interviewed in October. Hopefully November will come up shortly. I think there is still a good amount of spaces still open for November, so try not to worry too much! Good luck!
If you really want to do this, don't give up. Sounds like you had a tough cycle, so let me just say one thing. I am very fortunate to be surrounded by a family of physicians, and all of them have their own story. My mom got into medical school right out of college, then had to repeat her first year because of burnout. My dad took 3 cycles before he got into one of his backup schools. My uncle had to redo his final year of residency because of some clerical error. I myself, had a horrible time in undergrad but made up for most of it in my post-grad years. It's a process, and you can only do it if you truly want to. Don't let a rejection take your dream from you.Interviewed 10/19.
Rejected 12/5.
This path wasn't for me it seems. Best of luck to all of you in your future endeavors.
dont give up , you interviewed so you are on the cusp of getting acceptance either here next year or somewhere else!Interviewed 10/19.
Rejected 12/5.
This path wasn't for me it seems. Best of luck to all of you in your future endeavors.
Yes, I am secretly an ADCOM, and all of you are getting Rs. lolBro you are too patient to be a premed… are you secretly an adcom?
NopeAnyone get an answer today?
yes they do. And they resume classes on the 9th. They have a 3 week break. Something tells me the November interview folks won't hear back until after the 9th of January. 🙁Does MSUCOM close for the break after this Friday?
Seems like they haven’t been interviewing in December so maybe they’re allocating more time to working on decisions?? Maybe some will hear back this Friday?yes they do. And they resume classes on the 9th. They have a 3 week break. Something tells me the November interview folks won't hear back until after the 9th of January. 🙁
I thought the timeline was 3-4. Based on last years thread, almost everyone who interviewed in November heard back this week so I'm hoping for the same this year.I interviewed on 11/17 and they said that it will take us longer to hear back than the usual time (which is 4-6 weeks) because of the Holidays. I don't think we will hear back before the new year.