Case Western or Brown Med?

This forum made possible through the generous support of SDN members, donors, and sponsors. Thank you.
Status
Not open for further replies.

MedTrip

Membership Revoked
Removed
10+ Year Member
Joined
Jun 29, 2011
Messages
2
Reaction score
0
Hey everyone,

I'm in the process of choosing between Case Western School of Medicine and Brown Med (Alpert Medical School). Assuming there is no issue of finances or distance (I'm pretty far away from both of them), which one is better?
 
Also, I think both locations are fine (at least on the surface), so that isn't really a big deal to me.
 
I liked the facilities at Brown much more and Providence seems like a nice place to live, but Case's match list is much much better than you would expect from its ranking... looks like it should be a top 10 almost. The 3rd/4th year options at Case were also very appealing. If all things are equal, I would probably lean to Case.
 
I was far more impressed with Brown than I was with Case. If you're into research, though, Case is probably the 'better' choice.


Case by a long shot.

Care to elaborate?


I liked the facilities at Brown much more and Providence seems like a nice place to live, but Case's match list is much much better than you would expect from its ranking... looks like it should be a top 10 almost. The 3rd/4th year options at Case were also very appealing. If all things are equal, I would probably lean to Case.

I don't know, Brown's 2013 list is pretty surprisingly good. I wouldn't say Case's is "much much better" - I don't know that it's even better, esp. not for 2013.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
I don't know, Brown's 2013 list is pretty surprisingly good. I wouldn't say Case's is "much much better" - I don't know that it's even better, esp. not for 2013.

In the past it seemed a lot of people at Brown went into primary care fields, while Case had more diversity in specialties. Maybe this is more indicative of students though more than the school.
 
Last edited:
I was far more impressed with Brown than I was with Case. If you're into research, though, Case is probably the 'better' choice.




Care to elaborate?




I don't know, Brown's 2013 list is pretty surprisingly good. I wouldn't say Case's is "much much better" - I don't know that it's even better, esp. not for 2013.

Brown is mostly BS/MD, has less research opportunities, has no top residency programs, and is a newer school. Less important: the med school is also not directly connected to the ugrad compus or the hospital.

Case has a much better reputation, more research opportunities, multiple top residency programs, and has better clinical training at some of the best hospitals in the world (CC, UH, MH). Its not an Ivy though...
 
As a Brown alum, I feel a need to weigh in.

It really depends on what your long term goals are. Brown is definitely not as research heavy as Case. The match list is less impressive (though, I wouldn't put much stock in this, b/c many of the kids at Brown med were BS/MD and may not have gotten into Brown med if they weren't and a good portion match primary care [though some truly want to do this from the start]). Also, integrating into Brown med will be more difficult (many of the kids have already known each other for 4 yrs as undergrads).

I think the areas that Brown exceeds in are secondary. Providence is a cool city, you can always walk to the main campus, if you get time Boston/NY are not too far away. And, there is a ton you get involved in if you like and the night life in Providence is decent.

That said, I'd lean toward Case myself given these two options (I'm not particularly eager to spend 4 MORE years in Providence). And, I do hate that the med school is no longer on the same campus as the rest of the university (like it was when I was there).

Brown Med School has been around since 1975 (given the plethora of new schools, I think this would qualify it as established at this point).
 
Last edited:
You're right. I guess things have changed quite a bit from when I was at Brown. Now I'm really starting to feel old!


I'm not sure match lists over the least few years support this.

Just for reference:

Case Western 2013: http://mediswww.case.edu/admissions/CWRU Match 2013 Anonymized by Program.pdf

Brown 2013: http://brown.edu/academics/medical/about-us/facts-and-figures/md-2013-match-list

The differences here seem negligible. For me, a choice between these school would come down to financial aid packages and location.
 
I'd say go with whichever school ends up being cheaper.
 
Brown is mostly BS/MD, has less research opportunities, has no top residency programs, and is a newer school. Less important: the med school is also not directly connected to the ugrad compus or the hospital.

Case has a much better reputation, more research opportunities, multiple top residency programs, and has better clinical training at some of the best hospitals in the world (CC, UH, MH). Its not an Ivy though...

This opinion is very uninformed. Not sure why someone who hasn't attended both schools or at the very least done an away rotation at both schools would decide to chime in this way. Take radiology for example (our residency program has been in the top, if not the top, for several years in a row).

There are plenty of research opportunities at both schools for most medical students. We do not have a MD PHD program. If you want to do neuroscience research...you want to come to Brown over pretty much any other place. So...it all depends on what you want to do. You could also say that Cleveland Clinic students are taking away resources from Case...Obviously this is just conjecture.

The majority of our student body is now standard admit or post-bacc. And the PLME program continues to shrink. And please tell me what is the difference between a standard admit who goes to med school right after college and a PLME who did 4 years at brown and is now in med school at brown? The MCAT?

The medical training at most MD schools is EXACTLY THE SAME (this includes Harvard, Brown, Case, Iowa, USF etc.....). You just have to match which school best fits with your learning style.

Absolutely NO-ONE except you can tell you what school is best for you!

The way to choose a medical school is:
1. Financial Package
2. Administration Support of your learning style...because this will eventually effect how you perform in school.
3. What kind of people you want to work with.

Oh! One more thing. Most of the PLME students at Brown either don't know each other.
 
As a Brown undergrad, I'm kind of surprised by this. Granted, I do realize the PLME program has been shrinking. This would be a huge change from when I attended Brown about a decade ago.

When I was there all the PLME kids knew each other (I mean, they were often in the same classes (Ch 33, 35, 36, BI 20, BN 1 etc.) and they often had get togethers for PLME students. Hell, when I was last in NYC I went to a party with a whole bunch of PLME students that knew each other from my freshman year (they are now residents and still hang out together).

Either my year was an exception (possible) or things have changed!

Oh! One more thing. Most of the PLME students at Brown either don't know each other.
 
As a Brown undergrad, I'm kind of surprised by this. Granted, I do realize the PLME program has been shrinking. This would be a huge change from when I attended Brown about a decade ago.

When I was there all the PLME kids knew each other (I mean, they were often in the same classes (Ch 33, 35, 36, BI 20, BN 1 etc.) and they often had get togethers for PLME students. Hell, when I was last in NYC I went to a party with a whole bunch of PLME students that knew each other from my freshman year (they are now residents and still hang out together).

Either my year was an exception (possible) or things have changed!
My class and subsequent class most kids don't really know each other and had taken a year or more off prior to starting med school.
 
Go to Case...



... so we can start getting some good waitlist movement going at Brown 😀
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top