CHOOSE YOUR OWWN III - Game Thread

[Truenamer]

---

Members don't see this ad.

Ironically, I'd be more comfortable with someone saying that if I had discarded a village role because them coming to the conclusion of "I don't think shorty would discard a village role in favor of choosing scum" makes more sense to me than this one.

lmao you ninja'd me by seconds

 

[Lawpy]

Okay pls
No need to show off exercise to the thread pls
Join the SDN Fitbit group and show us your steps there pls

I traded Fitbit pls 🙁

 

[Animal Midwife]

Day 1 Yeet Tally
Stagg (1) - dubz
mkg (1) - Lawpy
O2 () -
genny (1) - Chaos
True (1) - shorty

4/16
yeet close in ~30.5 hours

 

[LuminousLag]

By luminous out of day, here only, unto nightly dark

 

[LuminousLag]

What the hell, I don't check this site daily and check after a holiday weekend to see that I got randed a town black goo

Why are negative utility roles even in this setup. Why wasn't I messaged on discord or something to be told that the game started

 

[Lawpy]

What the hell, I don't check this site daily and check after a holiday weekend to see that I got randed a town black goo

Why are negative utility roles even in this setup. Why wasn't I messaged on discord or something to be told that the game started

I’m locked out of discord

 

[potentialsheltervet]

So after pulling each of True's opening posts from the games he's played... I still have wolfy tingles from his joke about Lawpy identifying the whole pack. There's a "how do you do, fellow kids?" vibe. However, I'm also getting blue from the sad reacts he's giving me and if he's wolfing it SUCKS to be pinned this early in the game so I'm going to look elsewhere as well now.

 

[Truenamer]

Especially in Multiball.

Different scum factions might know each other are lying but can’t out the other faction without outting themselves.

Like Wolf A uses Village Role X for ability.
Mafia A fake claims Village Role X for affiliation. Wolf A knows it’s a lie, but can’t say anything. But when we flip wolf A we’ll know Mafia A was lying.

It’s also more effective to do it earlier, because it narrows down the number of village roles scum can fake claim to have used for affiliation. The longer someone holds off, while not a guarantee, the more it feels like an attempt to be last and not claim something someone else can counter claim.

Wait, I know for a fact this isn't how it works, because I personally had Village Lover twice.

The roles aren't conserved.

 

[Lawpy]

Town Lover.

I see 🤔

 

[WildZoo]

Wait, I know for a fact this isn't how it works, because I personally had Village Lover twice.

The roles aren't conserved.

Some roles are. If you look at the wiki you can see that some have multiple numbers next to them (meaning they are in the rand multiple times) vs ones that have a single number and therefore can only be randed once.

 

[Truenamer]

So after pulling each of True's opening posts from the games he's played... I still have wolfy tingles from his joke about Lawpy identifying the whole pack. There's a "how do you do, fellow kids?" vibe. However, I'm also getting blue from the sad reacts he's giving me and if he's wolfing it SUCKS to be pinned this early in the game so I'm going to look elsewhere as well now.

PSV you're really sweet but not wanting to hurt my feelings is not a good reason to look elsewhere, and feels borderline sheepy after you jumped behind shorty's read like that :/

 

[Lawpy]

I am hoping dartboard reads doesnt mean going by discards

I RNGed the roster pls

 

[Lawpy]

Im black goo aligned (Thats town btw , even tho the name looks very scummy)

Engaged. Because iirc a small Flushy made that as a 3P role a while ago.

 

[LuminousLag]

@WonderingStudent
@genny
@Truenamer
@WildZoo
@Zenge142
@Viscernable
@Chaostrodon
@mkg323

It is optimal play for all of these people to full claim their roles today on day 1

If they refuse or don't cooperate, then I guarantee they are scum

 

[Lawpy]

@WonderingStudent
@genny
@Truenamer
@WildZoo
@Zenge142
@Viscernable
@Chaostrodon
@mkg323

It is optimal play for all of these people to full claim their roles today on day 1

If they refuse or don't cooperate, then I guarantee they are scum

Wait what

 

[WildZoo]

What the hell, I don't check this site daily and check after a holiday weekend to see that I got randed a town black goo

Why are negative utility roles even in this setup. Why wasn't I messaged on discord or something to be told that the game started

Um

@Chaostrodon

 

[WildZoo]

@WonderingStudent
@genny
@Truenamer
@WildZoo
@Zenge142
@Viscernable
@Chaostrodon
@mkg323

It is optimal play for all of these people to full claim their roles today on day 1

If they refuse or don't cooperate, then I guarantee they are scum

No thank you, good luck with your guarantee

 

[supershorty]

What the hell, I don't check this site daily and check after a holiday weekend to see that I got randed a town black goo

Why are negative utility roles even in this setup. Why wasn't I messaged on discord or something to be told that the game started

Wait a minute

 

[potentialsheltervet]

If they refuse or don't cooperate, then I guarantee they are scum

Claim their roles fully?

 

[WildZoo]

@WonderingStudent
@genny
@Truenamer
@WildZoo
@Zenge142
@Viscernable
@Chaostrodon
@mkg323

It is optimal play for all of these people to full claim their roles today on day 1

If they refuse or don't cooperate, then I guarantee they are scum

Why these people in particular?

 

[LuminousLag]

I bet the majority of the scum in the game are actually just in that list already

 

[supershorty]

Dammit Dubz, FINE, you can ninja me ONCE.

 

[Truenamer]

@WonderingStudent
@genny
@Truenamer
@WildZoo
@Zenge142
@Viscernable
@Chaostrodon
@mkg323

It is optimal play for all of these people to full claim their roles today on day 1

If they refuse or don't cooperate, then I guarantee they are scum

Oh definitely, we should all go into detail about our PRs.

We should also leave our doors unlocked and open

 

[Lawpy]

Village godfather is just Vanilla townie with a fancy name

Yeah makes sense

 

[potentialsheltervet]

I bet the majority of the scum in the game are actually just in that list already

Explain please

 

[LuminousLag]

Why these people in particular?

Non cooperater here

Got my first scum of the game

Yeet WildZoo

 

[supershorty]

Alright someone in Chaos or Lumi is lying.

And this is why I wanted people to claim their aff role.

 

[LuminousLag]

Explain please

No

 

[WildZoo]

Non cooperater here

Got my first scum of the game

Yeet WildZoo

Okay

 

[Chaostrodon]

Um

@Chaostrodon

Well , frick

 

[Lawpy]

Vote Worthless Oxygen

Mainly coz I think the name is really nice

Agreed. That and tungsten dioxide from WO2. We need a periodic table WW so bad pls

 

[WildZoo]

Well , frick

unyeet stagg yeet chaos

 

[Lawpy]

Wait did Lags make the same claim as chaos?

 

[LuminousLag]

Alright someone in Chaos or Lumi is lying.

And this is why I wanted people to claim their aff role.

If cards can't be reused and they're claiming black goo then they're just outed

 

[Lawpy]

Unyeet MKG
Yeet chaos

 

[supershorty]

Wait, I know for a fact this isn't how it works, because I personally had Village Lover twice.

The roles aren't conserved.

Yeah, to add to Dubz's point above, the number of roles is exactly why I asked people to claim. It gives some interesting data points to see who claims roles only in the game once vs roles like vanilla town, where there are enough for almost the whole roster to claim.

 

[supershorty]

Unyeet True
Yeet chaos

"Well, frick" doesn't feel like a towny reaction

 

[Chaostrodon]

Nothing I can do except be completely honest now , It was indeed a fakeclaim. My role is actually Judas , I didnt want to claim it directly for well , umm obvious reasons

 

[WildZoo]

I'm still giggling. Rough luck, chaos.

 

[LuminousLag]

Wait did Lags make the same claim as chaos?

It's Lumi now

 

[Lawpy]

Nothing I can do except be completely honest now , It was indeed a fakeclaim. My role is actually Judas , I didnt want to claim it directly for well , umm obvious reasons

Engaged

 

[supershorty]

Nothing I can do except be completely honest now , It was indeed a fakeclaim. My role is actually Judas , I didnt want to claim it directly for well , umm obvious reasons

I want to cares and laugh react this, but I can't, so please feel my sympathy vibes through my giggling.

 

[Lawpy]

It's Lumi now

Oho! Thanks. That also fits with the -y sounding nickname list i have

 

[LuminousLag]

Nothing I can do except be completely honest now , It was indeed a fakeclaim. My role is actually Judas , I didnt want to claim it directly for well , umm obvious reasons

Someone vig this scum

 

[Lawpy]

Hold pls as i continue to catch up

 

[potentialsheltervet]

If Chaos is actually Judas, is it beneficial to yeet him now? Because then we'd have to yeet him again tomorrow.
Why not keep him around for a bit as "the devil you know"?

 

[LuminousLag]

I'm still giggling. Rough luck, chaos.

This guy is literally howling too

 

[WildZoo]

Nothing I can do except be completely honest now , It was indeed a fakeclaim. My role is actually Judas , I didnt want to claim it directly for well , umm obvious reasons

Why would you choose to be Judas lol

 

[potentialsheltervet]

Although I suppose there's nothing stopping him from another fakeclaim to try and save himself.

 

[potentialsheltervet]

Why would you choose to be Judas lol

Myrrh-der!
Judas! No!