CHOOSE YOUR OWWN III - Game Thread

This forum made possible through the generous support of SDN members, donors, and sponsors. Thank you.
We also don’t know that he’s being honest about the Alien claim. I don’t think he’s a wolf because I don’t think he would have bussed chaos, but he could be Mafia.
When I flip Alien Lover, one of the worst possible combinations of alignment and power, I hope it gives a little weight to what I've said.

We could have worked together! The village deserves a loss. But you and Dubz just had to come for me on Day 2.
 
Finally caught up -

Feel like other players have already said what I would say in response to @Zenge142's theory regarding Chaos:myself being w:w. In multifaction games, packs are extremely small so one pack mate's death is a pretty big blow - wouldn't be worth it to risk two pack mates for such a play and if lets say your theory was true for chaos and I being on the same team + they took my black goo claim - with a scenario where I flipped before chaos - chaos would be outed. It would be a pretty dangerous play. Additionally, a point to bring up is that I'd rather be a villager especially when I haven't played in a while. I am confirmed to have thrown out a village card thus even if somehow someone doesn't believe that I used the black goo card for affiliation, I did have another village card I could have used for affiliation.

@alleycat03 I don't think anyone answered you but cc = counterclaim
 
Not the most comfy that Zenge spelled out that lumi was hinting at being bloodhound. This isn't the shortest thread, not everyone is going to pick up on role claims. Similar concept to how we were restraining from talking about what cards shouldn’t have anyone else claim D1 because they were already claimed. Of course the information was on thread already but in case scum factions hadn’t looked into lumi’s post - now that info is much easier for all factions to know about.
 
I just looked at night results, and I’m really upset that we lost so many people in 1 night.

I agree with a lot of shorty’s list, and I specifically want more pressure on genny, MKG, and True. Still concerned about Lumi and WO2, but less so. Dubz, Z, and Vis are all hanging out on the village side of neutral. I’m hoping Lumi comes back soon, along with hoping to hear more from Wonder and Staygo.
why did you put WO2 into the "still concerned" versus the "want more pressure" pile?
 
Didn't that only come after Lumi said to read the first letter of their post spelling out bloodhound?
Yes.

Lumi got caught lying about being the goo, and told us all to do this.

Wonder trying to blame me for “outting Lumi’s PR” is some mental gymnastics I’m not ready to handle so soon after eating dinner.
 
We also don’t know that he’s being honest about the Alien claim. I don’t think he’s a wolf because I don’t think he would have bussed chaos, but he could be Mafia.
It doesn’t really matter to me what aff he is, I don’t think it has relevance to whether he’s being genuine except if he has partners
 
Wdym “another”?
Lol me sleep deprived and running on not enough sleep for the last week thinking that edit made more sense but actually made less. Black goo is village aff + cult leaning ability which would only be beneficial for a wincon if my third card was cult aff. So culty (black goo) + cult aff possibility in my head = another
 
Anyone but me.

I'd really like to go for Lumi or Alley. And I can't quite figure out what witchcraft Vis has performed that has her in most village piles, but I don't think she really belongs there. True is obviously getting yeeted though, so I don't think it really matters where I vote.
genny’s played more than enough games to know that a lot can change in 3 hrs and even in 30 mins to vote close so I don’t know why she is playing weirdly defeated
 
yeet true

I think we’ve gleaned all the info we could from his reveal. I plan on pursuing Dubz and Zenge after today.


I hope your wedding goes well!
 
It doesn’t really matter to me what aff he is, I don’t think it has relevance to whether he’s being genuine except if he has partners
It matters because Aliens get a 1x kill and Mafia get a normal, every night factional kill.

Alley was saying we shouldn’t yeet him because he’s not a threat to village if he already used his one kill.

I’m saying if he’s lying and actually Mafia, then he potentially has more kills.
 
It matters because Aliens get a 1x kill and Mafia get a normal, every night factional kill.

Alley was saying we shouldn’t yeet him because he’s not a threat to village if he already used his one kill.

I’m saying if he’s lying and actually Mafia, then he potentially has more kills.
I can't be Mafia, because you and I aren't in the same role PM
 
Day 2 Yeet Tally
genny () -
Lumi () -
True (4) - Zenge, dubz, Vis, alley
mkg () -
dubz (1) - True

5/11
True is in the lead!
Missing: Wonder, genny, O2, mayo, mkg, Lumi
yeet close in ~45 minutes
 
It matters because Aliens get a 1x kill and Mafia get a normal, every night factional kill.

Alley was saying we shouldn’t yeet him because he’s not a threat to village if he already used his one kill.

I’m saying if he’s lying and actually Mafia, then he potentially has more kills.
Oh I don’t think yeeting him is seriously in question lol
 
It matters because Aliens get a 1x kill and Mafia get a normal, every night factional kill.

Alley was saying we shouldn’t yeet him because he’s not a threat to village if he already used his one kill.

I’m saying if he’s lying and actually Mafia, then he potentially has more kills.
just leave him for the stump vig, like dubz and alley wanted to do with chaos yesterday 🤣
 
just leave him for the stump vig, like dubz and alley wanted to do with chaos yesterday 🤣
I thought it was a good plan to let chaos be vig shot, okay? Idk why that’s such a preposterous idea. He would’ve been killed either way
 
Vig shot prevented chaos from turning into Judas in the small 1% chance he had been telling the truth about that
 
just leave him for the stump vig, like dubz and alley wanted to do with chaos yesterday 🤣
Pretty sure that’s 1x.

Although that does give me an idea for a role that turns people into stumps, but there can only be 1x stump at a time. So you stump someone, and then the next night you stump someone else and the original stump officially dies.
 
Zenge and Dubz are both Mafia, they're driving this bus, and the remaining villagers are either being too passive or are kinda checked out and willing to go along with strong voices.
not sure why this was stated so matter of factly and very specific mafia - not some other flavor of scum :laugh:
 
It’s like trying to play a game with someone who has no intention of playing the game and just wants to heckle what everyone else does
 
I seriously don’t get what’s up with genny this game. Her snark isn’t usually this weirdly belittling.

It’s like trying to play a game with someone who has no intention of playing the game and just wants to heckle what everyone else does
Yeah. She’s had some good points but I have felt more upset/hurt at some of her jabs this game than I usually do.
 
not sure why this was stated so matter of factly and very specific mafia - not some other flavor of scum
I suppose I should have been a little more clear; Zenge is Mafia, Dubz could be either. It feels like she's working with him, but they could be two different scum factions and be working together on thread.
 
Mkg more process of elimination after looking at who I felt vaguely ok with for now
Made me feel weird that WO2's explanation for their second and third most sus on their reads list is based on dead players + POE. eh if true is telling the truth about being alien then we dont have to worry right now and I would rather use a vote to talk about other scum also

Need to go walk two dogs for someone so in case I somehow don't return in time:

yeet WO2
 
Top