Remember that you asked for this!
A lot of my reads are contingent on night results and knowing for sure (or at least with high likelihood) that we do in fact have remaining wolves, so expect a Δ reads list tomorrow if it changes anything.
Rae: V - My Raedar (see what I did there) is faulty at best. Seemed genuinely interested in pushing barks, seemed unpaired from W! flips given the hard spurs push. Could for sure be counter-scum, but her reads overall seem earnest and independent, and while she was top of my list yesterday for counter-scum, her reluctance to the PSV flip neutralized that for me. I think I may be reading village!rae here.
Kitz: V - The only way I see her scum here is if she's paired with the wolves, which isn't out of possibility, but nothing about her approach suggests pack tactic/coaching; she seems to be going her own way, and is def not other-scum. We also know for sure she had village options available.
Dubz: V - I'm going to yeet myself into the sun if I'm wrong about this one but… village. She is indubitably unpaired from the wolves, and cleared of mafia (which I do believe PSV; just don't see a reason to lie about that, and we know alpha goon was discarded), then that leaves alien or other scum, which although I would totally see Dubz picking, it's not the most likely scenario imo. And despite the astronomical signal: noise ratio, there has been some genuine solving and reading going on.
Alissa: V - Reasoning on this one is a little complicated. She was the first to point out Spurs' innocent child claim as risky considering ease of disproval, and pushed her own reads while PSV was in contention rather than jumping on the wagon, even when she was clearly going down (e.g. not bussing). Superficially this looks a bit like wolf pairing, but her reasoning seems independent and has village vibes. Since we don't know for 100% sure there are even remaining wolves, but given that we've flipped 2 are alomost guaranteed we have other-scum, she is solidly off that list and that pushed her into village territory.
Apop: V - Did she even post before she died? Idk village probably.
Shorty: V - My soul wants to say village lock but to be completely honest I can't get a great signal through the noise. Village to me but I wouldn't stake my life on it. She made a solid push on PSV which turned out well, but her on-and-off push of kitz doesn't feel the towniest. If you asked me to pull specific quotes that feel towny I couldn't do it. But village for now bc that's one I'd hate to be wrong on.
samac: NV - The day I put samac in village blocc is the day I need to be put on [more] meds but she's leaning neutral side of village to me. I don't love sheeping zenge, even though he was right. I don't think I've ever seen true scum samac but this doesn't feel out of range by any means. There's some signal in the noise though for some legit solving, and her reads seem reasonably formed.
Zenge: N - Push on PSV was solid and correct, and tunnel-vision zenge has been village before (technically, not including spn conversion) but considering the extreme likelihood of other-scum, is really NAI to me. I'd love for it to be a village lock but I'm keeping my eye on it still.
SAR: NW - Not my strongest village or wolf read, but I don't think SAR ever has been. I misyeeted in SPN and it took me several cycles to get a read on w!sar in Hallowws. She village read psv and pushed beans, which again leads me to either village or wolf paired, maybe independent 3p, and while statistically the former is more likely, other posts aren't super solvey. Depending on how the night turns out and if/when we're able to get more form her, I'm leaning scummy until otherwise convinced but wouldn't likely send a hammer that way.
Clem: W - I've seen more out of clem this game I think than any other game combined, yet with little signal in the noise. Maybe he's bored and this is his ****post outlet (which I vibe with ngl), but the village clem I've seen is 75% absent, 20% ****posting, and 5% a damn solid read here and there. Currently seeing 99% fluff and maybe half an opinion every 36 hours. However, the reads he does have I tend to agree with so that's throwing me.
Beans: W - Similar to what was discussed ysterday, in the absence of meta, this could very well be scum beans. It's not giving noob game wolf, but also not giving typical uber-villagey village beans.
Barks: W - Was on both scum reads, but similar to zenge is NAI and actually makes me particularly sus of other-scum. Nothing has been particularly villagey and process of elimination has me extra squinty. Could definitely vote this way pending night actions and day discussions.
)
