FTF's Worst Idea Yet (Game Over)

Veterinary School Application Advising Ad
This forum made possible through the generous support of SDN members, donors, and sponsors. Thank you.
Members don't see this ad.
Crayola227 said:
N
Need more info. First post that *really* made me wonder about Pip. Rn not in a place to be able to check into WZ claim more.
Click to expand...
If it makes you feel better, in the last few minutes I have looked up whether there are any roles that don't allow voting, and she appears to be correct in saying that's about it, other than the village tree stumps (which I don't think can vote?)

There is a ninja mafia treestump, but if I'm interpreting that correctly, it's not active until N3

Still haven't fully gotten to what the solar god thing is but was planning to ask FTF for clarification on those role modifiers.

If she shares a survivor win con though, she is not village. Not necessarily harmful, but also not village.
 
JustPaws said:
I'm more inclined to worry about the people who rejected village roles like zenge and cray with normalish village roles. What were they lured by?
Click to expand...
Oh please, like I couldn't have gotten a village role that seers/cops clean and went for that over hirsute
 
Also I don't really feel this will be a super productive line of discussion, but if Dubz is mafia, then she would not have been defending Alissa or Paws, which seemed like what she was doing yesterday and what caused me to move her wolf.

So occam's razor is that she's probably telling the truth.
 
JustPaws said:
@Crayola227 the last minute vote we were discussing was VIS not mine. Please dont throw shade if you aren't tracking the conversation
Click to expand...
Guess what beeches? I don't track diddly squat I do my best. I'm reading but you guys aren't always the best with your pronoun usage. If I get something wrong, just frakking correct me but you don't have to be a jerk about it.

I don't understand why you are this reactive but keep it up, it reeks of scum
 
sunshinefl said:
@Animal Midwife: sus

Tunneling me from post #1 based on “wolf last time”, double down on read even after I said Alissa was in my top 3 AND Genny voted for me

@PippyPony: mixed to okay

Making sense, emotive NAI

@Zenge142: mixed to okay

called out chaos weird reveal, but voting cray for usual cray posts, now making more sense re: Visc

@WildZoo: 3P - okay

3P aligned with survivors per claim, throwing shade on Pippy, acknowledged genny’s BS

@sunshinefl: town

@Crayola227: town / not WW

Full on, on Alissa

@Viscernable sus

Odd feeling, weird last minute unyeet bob

@Aprilthearab: town

makes sense about Cray being in line with her meta rather than sus

@JustPaws: sus

exaggerating “momentum”, weird obsession with things while also being flippant
Click to expand...
Can you explain to me why you're clear for "not being a wolf with alissa and genny" but you have Cray as "not WW"?
 
PippyPony said:
If she shares a survivor win con though, she is not village. Not necessarily harmful, but also not village.
Click to expand...
That's meaningless though. As long as the game's still going, that means there are harmful scum alive. It will end as soon as they're gone.
 
Crayola227 said:
Did she have a choice? Did she discard a village role?
Click to expand...
Yes, she discarded the princess role, but it honestly doesn't really matter to me. I liked her reads list just now and overall do not think she is acting scummy. I also think people should look back at genny's vote yesterday.

I think AM's weirdly stuck on sunshine rn and that is making me move AM down the list towards baddie.
 
Viscernable said:
I feel weird about cray apparently skimming the thread and throwing shade without paying attention. That does not look like sincere wolfhunting.
Click to expand...
That is not what it happening. I had to bounce earlier but my appt no-showed. Wherever I have liked and replied is where I am caught up. Same way I always play.

On mobile and also on the go, so admittedly I'm not doing anything besides reading liking and replying. No going back over the thread checking claims or googling.
 
Good lord, every game. When are you people going to figure out that indecision is indicative of my sincere wolfhunting? This is why I’ve been yeeted early in all but 2 games I villaged (once I was cleared in most players’ eyes by a wolf throwing mad sus on me D1, and once I was NK N1 for correctly suspecting kras), and have lived longer in both games I wolfed. Do you not understand how easy it is to avoid suspicion for last-minute vote changes by throwing down a vote and sticking with it when you truly don’t gaf about hunting wolves? When I want to yeet scum, I care more about getting scum yeeted than having village-looking vote timing so I will waffle and throw last-minute votes as I feel is needed. On my own head be it, whatever.

I’m the night N suicidal king whatever thing. On day 7 (which obviously we are extremely unlikely to reach, and I plan to vote for whoever my village reads think should be voted if it comes to it) I have the only vote that counts, on night 7 I die. I win if I’m alive when another faction wins, but idrc about wincon when I’m not part of a team. I’m here to have fun by trying to figure out who the scum are and help town yeet them.
 
Animal Midwife said:
Can you define "multiball" for me?
Click to expand...
Lottery Lotto GIF

Lotto Lottery GIF

Winning Season 3 GIF by The Simpsons
 
Viscernable said:
Good lord, every game. When are you people going to figure out that indecision is indicative of my sincere wolfhunting? This is why I’ve been yeeted early in all but 2 games I villaged (once I was cleared in most players’ eyes by a wolf throwing mad sus on me D1, and once I was NK N1 for correctly suspecting kras), and have lived longer in both games I wolfed. Do you not understand how easy it is to avoid suspicion for last-minute vote changes by throwing down a vote and sticking with it when you truly don’t gaf about hunting wolves? When I want to yeet scum, I care more about getting scum yeeted than having village-looking vote timing so I will waffle and throw last-minute votes as I feel is needed. On my own head be it, whatever.

I’m the night N suicidal king whatever thing. On day 7 (which obviously we are extremely unlikely to reach, and I plan to vote for whoever my village reads think should be voted if it comes to it) I have the only vote that counts, on night 7 I die. I win if I’m alive when another faction wins, but idrc about wincon when I’m not part of a team. I’m here to have fun by trying to figure out who the scum are and help town yeet them.
Click to expand...
Okay so you are scum then? Do you have other reads?
 
PippyPony said:
Yes AM, I am frozen and terrified. please show me the truth!!!!

On Fire Burn GIF by Shark Week



Did you read any posts yesterday at all? Because you're acting like you didn't.
Click to expand...
Yes, I read that I posted that huge chunk of role definitions for hours and offered to define things for you so you could just refuse my efforts and continue to act blind.
 
Animal Midwife said:
Okay so you are scum then? Do you have other reads?
Click to expand...
That’s not scum, AM. Scum have a wincon against village. I win if I’m alive when village wins.

Neutral on sunny and Z, scumlean on cray. Pippy’s stubbornness to the point of having suspicion heaped on her for it doesn’t seem like wolf, mafia, or survivor to me, I feel like she’d be more concerned about the optics of her arguments than about stubbornly making sure she’s verified Dubz’s claim to her own satisfaction before accepting it on thread. Could be a different 3p but I haven’t looked closely at the roles to see if there are roles that we need to worry about (i.e. wincon exclusive of village win) who wouldn’t care about being yeeted.
 
Viscernable said:
That’s not scum, AM. Scum have a wincon against village. I win if I’m alive when village wins.

Neutral on sunny and Z, scumlean on cray. Pippy’s stubbornness to the point of having suspicion heaped on her for it doesn’t seem like wolf, mafia, or survivor to me, I feel like she’d be more concerned about the optics of her arguments than about stubbornly making sure she’s verified Dubz’s claim to her own satisfaction before accepting it on thread. Could be a different 3p but I haven’t looked closely at the roles to see if there are roles that we need to worry about (i.e. wincon exclusive of village win) who wouldn’t care about being yeeted.
Click to expand...
Okay, the official definition of scum anything that isn't village. Some are exclusive while others are inclusive. You're claiming an inclusive one.

I will think on this more though.
 
sunshinefl said:
Nope. Not all I said. That’s a straight up lie. Full text below.



Yes we’re all aware it’s town aligned. That’s in the role. But this is also a bastard game and it wasn’t just “beloved princess” so you’re only defining half the role.

Nope you don’t have to be sure of day 1 first vote reads, but on the same hand you def don’t get village cred for your day 1 first vote that you changed and only later revisited for self prez.

🙄🙄 now you’re being a jerk for literally no reason. At no point on this thread have I misunderstood sarcasm. That was other players who apparently are all interchangeable to you since you just need to eliminate us all.
Click to expand...
My bad I just dont remember that post.
The other have is a NIGHT KILL CANCEL. I didnt discuss whether virgin was protown because it so clearly is ffs.
Just because you dont like my attitude on thread doesn't make me scum. My two votes yesterday were actually backed up by post references.
 
Animal Midwife said:
Okay, the official definition of scum anything that isn't village. Some are exclusive while others are inclusive. You're claiming an inclusive one.

I will think on this more though.
Click to expand...
So, Dubz is not village but is village inclusive, but anything that isn't village is officially scum?

If you're going to get after me for not following strict definitions, then I don't think you can decide to apply your own rules willy-nilly in the span of half a page.
 
I feel like AM is chaos +/- one of the serial killer roles and she should be taken out prior to end game.

She's setting up conditional arguments for why her definitions of scum/not scum are the only ones that matter, and she is blanket-ignoring pages of posts.
 
PippyPony said:
So, Dubz is not village but is village inclusive, but anything that isn't village is officially scum?

If you're going to get after me for not following strict definitions, then I don't think you can decide to apply your own rules willy-nilly in the span of half a page.
Click to expand...
Yes, that's why I've been saying scum since this game started. I haven't changed anything, Pippy. dubz is also scum. dubz is claiming harmless scum and has a visual way of seeing it's true. Vis's claim is hidden and can't ever really be proven so I'm thinking on it. Only certain scum needs to be eliminated.
 
Animal Midwife said:
Yes, that's why I've been saying scum since this game started. I haven't changed anything, Pippy. dubz is also scum. dubz is claiming harmless scum and has a visual way of seeing it's true. Vis's claim is hidden and can't ever really be proven so I'm thinking on it. Only certain scum needs to be eliminated.
Click to expand...
Why did Ms P need to die?
 
I'm only going to ask you this one last time @PippyPony , so answer wisely.

Are you going to stay on a vote, knowing you're not voting out any threats to village?
 
JustPaws said:
If we assume chaos was an accidental self kill, and that wolves didn't kill genny, then why msp over Bob as a wolf kill specifically. I'm just not following
Click to expand...
Bob could have been a different scum kill like mafia. As for MsP, look at the tracker.
 
JustPaws said:
Fine I will look but you could just as easily tell me what you noticed since you know I'm not going to understand and come ask you to restate lol
Click to expand...
If we need to do so, I can answer then, but I'd like to see if you see it as well.
 
Animal Midwife said:
Can you explain to me why you're clear for "not being a wolf with alissa and genny" but you have Cray as "not WW"?
Click to expand...
Yes, because I have a mod PM that says I’m town.

also I only put that note there for cray so I don’t possibly overlook that.
Crayola227 said:
Did she have a choice? Did she discard a village role?
Click to expand...
I did discard a town role, but I didn’t have a choice. I was trying to avoid spelling it out in case wolves thought I might be some other faction and vice versa, but both of my choices were town.
Viscernable said:
Good lord, every game. When are you people going to figure out that indecision is indicative of my sincere wolfhunting? This is why I’ve been yeeted early in all but 2 games I villaged (once I was cleared in most players’ eyes by a wolf throwing mad sus on me D1, and once I was NK N1 for correctly suspecting kras), and have lived longer in both games I wolfed. Do you not understand how easy it is to avoid suspicion for last-minute vote changes by throwing down a vote and sticking with it when you truly don’t gaf about hunting wolves? When I want to yeet scum, I care more about getting scum yeeted than having village-looking vote timing so I will waffle and throw last-minute votes as I feel is needed. On my own head be it, whatever.

I’m the night N suicidal king whatever thing. On day 7 (which obviously we are extremely unlikely to reach, and I plan to vote for whoever my village reads think should be voted if it comes to it) I have the only vote that counts, on night 7 I die. I win if I’m alive when another faction wins, but idrc about wincon when I’m not part of a team. I’m here to have fun by trying to figure out who the scum are and help town yeet them.
Click to expand...
Viscernable said:
That’s not scum, AM. Scum have a wincon against village. I win if I’m alive when village wins.

Neutral on sunny and Z, scumlean on cray. Pippy’s stubbornness to the point of having suspicion heaped on her for it doesn’t seem like wolf, mafia, or survivor to me, I feel like she’d be more concerned about the optics of her arguments than about stubbornly making sure she’s verified Dubz’s claim to her own satisfaction before accepting it on thread. Could be a different 3p but I haven’t looked closely at the roles to see if there are roles that we need to worry about (i.e. wincon exclusive of village win) who wouldn’t care about being yeeted.
Click to expand...
So you are a 3P with survivor win con? Well then you could win with anyone and aren’t necessarily going to help village.
PippyPony said:
I feel like AM is chaos +/- one of the serial killer roles and she should be taken out prior to end game.

She's setting up conditional arguments for why her definitions of scum/not scum are the only ones that matter, and she is blanket-ignoring pages of posts.
Click to expand...
Yeah AM is going further and further up my radar. Basically AM or justpaws would be the 2 I consider today. And I’m currently on justpaws.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

Similar threads

Animal Midwife
Death Nommy - Game Thread
83 84 85 86 87
Replies
4K
Views
51K
Animal Midwife
Animal Midwife
WildZoo
  • Poll Poll
Mission ImpoWWssible Game Thread
46 47 48 49 50
Replies
2K
Views
37K
Clem J
Clem J
supershorty
GGoats ThWWee: Here It GGoats Again - GAME THREAD
93 94 95 96 97
Replies
5K
Views
50K
vampyrica
vampyrica
WildZoo
  • Poll Poll
Mystery WW Signs Ups - Game Start May 25th
2
Replies
79
Views
3K
KayJayQueue
KayJayQueue
Animal Midwife
Matrix - Game Thread
77 78 79 80 81
Replies
4K
Views
86K
samac
samac
Top