Once Upon A Time WW Game Thread

Veterinary School Application Advising Ad
This forum made possible through the generous support of SDN members, donors, and sponsors. Thank you.
I would think that Peter Pan would be a wolf, but I also thought the same of Tamara. I really don't know what to do. We've got Peter Pan and Rumple, but may decide to vote out an unknown player instead. This game is just confusing me to know end.
 
Final lynch tally:
Lupin 6 - cuit (contingency), Minnerbelle (contingency), tuckervet, Fancy, swings, TRH
EC 0
SOV 0
TRH 0
FF 0
swings 6 - SOV, EC, Lupin, NStarz, wld, hedgie
tuckervet 2 - Dwin, rojo
dyachei 0
SOV 1 - LIS
 
I think that if we're going to give a bit of time to investigate Rumple, we should do the same with Peter. We ALL thought that Tamara was a definite wolf and we were proven wrong - so the game mechanics are a lot more complicated than we had originally anticipated.

I'm still not sold on swings being innocent. If only I could vote 🙁
 
Wow I can't believe I almost missed this. Passed out from being in the hospital all day *** lynch lupin**** just so we don't have a tie.
 
PLEASE NOTE: kaydubs has decided to have some mercy on you all.

You have 10 minutes. Settle it.
 
It's fairly obvious lupin is going down at this point.
 
Final final lynch tally:
Lupin 10 - cuit (contingency), Minnerbelle (contingency), tuckervet, Fancy, swings, TRH, dyachei, Alors, bbeventer, hedgie
EC 0
SOV 0
TRH 0
FF 0
swings 5 - SOV, EC, Lupin, NStarz, wld
tuckervet 2 - Dwin, rojo
dyachei 0
SOV 1 - LIS
 
The villagers quickly show up to avoid a tie.

Lupin21 - The Shadow/Peter Pan has been lynched.

Peter-Pan-Shadow--1649406177441174583.jpg


It is now Night 10. Deadline 10pm EST.

There are 18 players remaining.

Clock Tower
1. Rojo
3. dyachei
5. Alors
6. Dwin
8. cuit

Mary Margaret's Apartment
4. FantasyFlyer
5. Hedgie
6. Tuckervet
7. bbeventer

Sheriff's Department
2. that redhead
5. Minnerbelle
6. The LIS
8. NStarz

Granny's Diner
2. Swings
6. Fancy

Mr. Gold's Pawn & Antiques Shop
4.wldlfstdnt
5. equineconstant
6. SOV

Cemetery kayd:
Lissarae06 - Grumpy/Leroy
FFM - Tamara
nohika - Belle/Lacey
SV88 - Mad Hatter/Jefferson
Frozenshades - Captain Killian "Hook" Jones
FH - Red Riding Hood/Ruby
SnS - Emma Swan
Jamr0ckin - Owen Flynn/Greg Mendell
WS - Prince Phillip
Allie - Maleficent
devyn - Dr. Frankenstein/Dr. Whale
wildcatj - Genie/Magic Mirror/Sidney Glass
DVMD - Jiminy Cricket/Archie Hopper
Lupin21 - Peter Pan/The Shadow
 
A new color? There is no way peter pan could of been good though 😕
 
kaydubs said:
And, if you would've waffled to cause *ANOTHER* tie.....I may've killed the wafflers. 😉
Click to expand...

In all fairness to the first tie I was going to change it back if no one was around to vote but lynch closed at 2:10 instead of 2:30.
 
Lynch closed because we felt like it. Keep that in mind the next time you create a tie. :meanie:

(I really do hope you do though...)
 
I'm considering that a good lynch, even if we don't know what the color means.
I'm also a little disappointed that there was no tie, I was very curious to see what DVMD would have come up with!
 
Escalla said:
Lynch closed because we felt like it. Keep that in mind the next time you create a tie. :meanie:

(I really do hope you do though...)
Click to expand...

If I create a tie will I be killed? I'm not going to tie up a vote if I'm liable to die.
 
hedgiehog said:
If I create a tie will I be killed? I'm not going to tie up a vote if I'm liable to die.
Click to expand...

Liable doesn't feel right. it's my day off so my brain doesn't want to function. I mean likely to die.
 
Sigh. Too many people have been drinking at the SOV-modding pool. Just once I want a good old-fashioned game where wolves are wolves, villagers are villagers, and this color crap doesn't get half the posting time.
 
LetItSnow said:
Sigh. Too many people have been drinking at the SOV-modding pool. Just once I want a good old-fashioned game where wolves are wolves, villagers are villagers, and this color crap doesn't get half the posting time.
Click to expand...

******
If you still want to put together firefly with me we can have a game like that 😀
******
 
Escalla said:
I can't give away all the secrets. How about: "It depends".
Click to expand...

It depends is no fun. I just don't want to be killed for a lynch ending early when I'm trying to waffle based on new info and would have been able to come back and change my vote. It doesn't really allow for the chance to process someone's defense. How was I to know that no one would be on to see lupin's role info and that the lynch would close twenty minutes early?
 
wildcatj said:
******
If you still want to put together firefly with me we can have a game like that 😀
******
Click to expand...

CRAP. I totally forgot to respond to your PM from a few weeks back. Yes, I'm absolutely in.

I'm going out of town a few days later this week ... can we start throwing it together next Sunday-ish? That gives me time to rewatch the whole series, too. It's been a little while.
 
hedgiehog said:
It depends is no fun. I just don't want to be killed for a lynch ending early when I'm trying to waffle based on new info and would have been able to come back and change my vote. It doesn't really allow for the chance to process someone's defense. How was I to know that no one would be on to see lupin's role info and that the lynch would close twenty minutes early?
Click to expand...

Maybe "it depends" means that I take those kinds of things into account? 😉
 
LetItSnow said:
Sigh. Too many people have been drinking at the SOV-modding pool. Just once I want a good old-fashioned game where wolves are wolves, villagers are villagers, and this color crap doesn't get half the posting time.
Click to expand...

***********************
The game I am modding at the end of this summer... late August. Will be like this. You will know if you got a wolf or not, and there won't be any colors. I kind of don't like the whole color thing to be completely honest, which was why I mostly ignored it in SOV's game until he gave me that role.
************************
 
hedgiehog said:
It depends is no fun. I just don't want to be killed for a lynch ending early when I'm trying to waffle based on new info and would have been able to come back and change my vote. It doesn't really allow for the chance to process someone's defense. How was I to know that no one would be on to see lupin's role info and that the lynch would close twenty minutes early?
Click to expand...

i'm on all day and then finally have my meeting in the middle of the lynch closing... oh well, not sure how I would have reacted to Lupin's defense in real time... I at least gave her more time when i pointed out to the mods that it A) wasn't plurality and B) change it so she wasn't at the not plurality...

I'm not sold on this lupin lynch benefitting the villagers... I dunno... I kinda agree with LIS though, and definitely agree with DVMD (that yellow is a horrible color)....

This is a perfect example why people need to be a bit more willing to defend themselves adequately EARLY... if Allie had told us she was the huntsman at her first defense, most people it seems would have been much more likely to believe her... just like if Lupin had posted that with more than like an hour left, maybe more people would have been able to see it and considered waffling. That's just my opinion... it was clearly going to be close for lupin, and she didn't do herself any favors... Oh well...
 
still suspicious of Swings.

Also, I noticed wldlfstdnt, who I have trusted has post way less after night4 than before night 4 when there was a conversion. could be coincidence, or not.

Just saying our mayor may be worth looking into.
 
On the colors.. if I did it again, perhaps I would probably provide a "key" so you didn't have to guess, but in a complex game, it does help to keep various groups separate.

But I am more inclined to smaller games in the future, so probably wouldn't do that anyway.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

Similar threads

WildZoo
SDN Fairgrounds - 10th Annual Noob WW Game
2 3 4 5
Replies
235
Views
2K
fruitsalad
fruitsalad
Animal Midwife
Death Nommy - Game Thread
83 84 85 86 87
Replies
4K
Views
52K
Animal Midwife
Animal Midwife
WildZoo
  • Poll Poll
Mission ImpoWWssible Game Thread
46 47 48 49 50
Replies
2K
Views
38K
Clem J
Clem J
WildZoo
Noob WW Game 2025 Sign Ups: All New WW Players Welcome! (CLOSED)
2 3 4
Replies
171
Views
11K
WildZoo
WildZoo
kaydubs
Melee WW Game Thread-April 2024
27 28 29 30 31
Replies
2K
Views
31K
Sandy Dikson
Sandy Dikson
Top