The WWatering Hole Bar Grand Opening - Game Thread.

[raf2769]

ah nevermind, don't elaborate if you don't think you should yet

---

Members don't see this ad.

 

[raf2769]

also paging @mmmdreamerz in case she doesn't know lynch is going her way

 

[TheGirlWithTheFernTattoo]

Here is the D3 lynch vote tracker.

Upon quickly looking at it I will stick with 3M for today unless she gives an adequate defense. Her vote yesterday was just jumping on the Snowy bandwagon with pretty minimal reasoning.

 

[TheGirlWithTheFernTattoo]

Btw is anyone else not getting notified when they are tagged?

I haven't gotten a single tag notification this game and realized it when I was going through posts for this latest lynch tracker and noticed I had been tagged quite a few times.

 

[Animal Midwife]

*********************************************************
The Dead's Unofficial Lynch Tally

Ceke (2) - LIS, Ski
WZ () -
britzen (4) - Kam, WZ, Ceke, Crayola
Ski () -
3m (5) - allieh, Cyndia, Fern, Pippy, britzen

11/17
lynch close in ~ 2 hours
*********************************************************

 

[PippyPony]

I thought we had established that we couldn't really tell wolf/village from role alone?
also, were you guys talking before and then she just stopped talking to you completely? or what exactly is happening in pms to bother you enough to lynch?

Sorry, when I say role I am talking about ability.

We were talking a little bit before, but yes -- it's the fact that she has stopped that is bothering me.

 

[PippyPony]

ah nevermind, don't elaborate if you don't think you should yet

Haha welp, that's all you're going to get for now

 

[SummerTheLynx]

So my vote would be going to ceke right now, but I will have a heart for once and not kick her while she's down.

Instead, let me propose a slightly less paranoid than normal alternative, pippy. Her relative lack of all over the placeness has made me pause and think that it might just be because she knows who the wolves are.

**************lynch pippy************

 

[PippyPony]

Her relative lack of all over the placeness has made me pause

To quote dubz:

Rude.

 

[PippyPony]

If you want paranoid, consider that I am still side-eyeing you despite you having the most villagey ability ever.

You were conspicuously absent in most (all?) discussions about genny, which I found a tad odd, because don't you claim to be able to read her pretty well? Bragging in a game a while back about how you were 3 for 3 on spotting her as a wolf or some such?

Don't worry, it's still there. Maybe it's just all relative

 

[SummerTheLynx]

If you want paranoid, consider that I am still side-eyeing you despite you having the most villagey ability ever.

You were conspicuously absent in most (all?) discussions about genny, which I found a tad odd, because don't you claim to be able to read her pretty well? Bragging in a game a while back about how you were 3 for 3 on spotting her as a wolf or some such?

Don't worry, it's still there. Maybe it's just all relative

Hence why I said relatively

 

[SummerTheLynx]

If you want paranoid, consider that I am still side-eyeing you despite you having the most villagey ability ever.

You were conspicuously absent in most (all?) discussions about genny, which I found a tad odd, because don't you claim to be able to read her pretty well? Bragging in a game a while back about how you were 3 for 3 on spotting her as a wolf or some such?

Don't worry, it's still there. Maybe it's just all relative

And to respond to your concerns about genny, look at the following quoted info from the evening prior and that day. Funny enough, the majority of my posts that day actually involved genny in some way shape or form.

 

[SummerTheLynx]

Fun question: where is the multi quote button now located? Because I have 5 quotes I want to insert and the button is magically missing...

 

[PippyPony]

Fun question: where is the multi quote button now located? Because I have 5 quotes I want to insert and the button is magically missing...

Psssh. Likely story. Seems pretty convenient if you ask me!

 

[SummerTheLynx]

Psssh. Likely story. Seems pretty convenient if you ask me!

You could also do the not lazy thing and look back, and see, but I am trying to be helpful, so if anyone legitamitely knows what happened to the button (where it is now located) that would be great

 

[britzen]

You could also do the not lazy thing and look back, and see, but I am trying to be helpful, so if anyone legitamitely knows what happened to the button (where it is now located) that would be great

Highlight text and hit "+quote" to gather. Repeat for each quote. When you go down into the reply window a "Insert Quotes..." button will be on the bottom left of the text box

 

[PippyPony]

You could also do the not lazy thing and look back, and see, but I am trying to be helpful, so if anyone legitamitely knows what happened to the button (where it is now located) that would be great

But that would require effort, and I am enjoying sitting here and gorging myself on halloween candy.

(vvv I still see the button right below here)

 

[SummerTheLynx]

Because I didn't want to get lynched and I was hoping someone else would switch. Playing 20 questions with AM was getting me nowhere (big surprise, right?). Used my ability on Snowy last night, you can ask her what she thinks of it. I'm not just going to reveal something like that day 1.

I never said reveal your role, I asked for your rationale. Not a fan of the deflection.

But why did AM have to be the one to switch: Villager logic: I am villager, other person may not be, I should vote them so village doesn't lose a villager. You wanting someone else to have switched instead of you just seems off. If you wanted to keep your vote you say something like: "hey guys, I like my current vote but am switching for self preservation, anyone else feeling this person. I think we should vote them for *insert reason here*. Instead, you played twenty questions and BSed until the end, and switched at last possible second. So yes, your approach was sketchy, but almost everything you do is sketchy, so I take it wth a grain of trout seasoning

Here's the issue I have with today, everyone has piled on genny early. Yes there were lots of reasons to go for genny, and I think it is a decent vote even though she is sketch balls always, but at least allow other people to accumulate a bit of votes (without a guaranteed wolf) to allow some back and forth discussions, defending, etc.) now we are at a point where everyone feels safe, so any votes on them don't really matter

Here are all my genny quotes from then, I think 9'posts total with 4 about genny, and 3 bickering with you @PippyPony over your misguided theory

 

[Ceke2002]

Fun question: where is the multi quote button now located? Because I have 5 quotes I want to insert and the button is magically missing...

There's a multiquote button? I just hit the little quote with a cross next to it button on every post I want to quote and then wait for it to say 'insert quotes'.

The forum has been a little odd lately, I'm not getting tags or notifications all that much for the past day or so.

 

[SummerTheLynx]

Edit: couldn't re-find the first quote so I simply pulled gennys response. And I can see the quote button, just not the insert quote button

 

[PippyPony]

and 3 bickering with you @PippyPony over your misguided theory

And this is abnormal how?

 

[Animal Midwife]

*********************************************************
The Dead's Unofficial Lynch Tally

Ceke (2) - LIS, Ski
WZ () -
britzen (4) - Kam, WZ, Ceke, Crayola
Ski () -
3m (5) - allieh, Cyndia, Fern, Pippy, britzen
Pippy (1) - STL

12/17
lynch close in 50 minutes
*********************************************************

 

[WildZoo]

Aw come on STL, leave pip alone and make it a tie

 

[DVMDream]

I need a tl;dr version

 

[DVMDream]

What defences do we have from each player?

 

[PippyPony]

And thanks for quoting those, @SummerTheLynx . Some of them were after people had already brought up substantial concerns, though, so not sure they help your case THAT much...

And looking back, your reasoning for staying off the genny vote on D1 was not the strongest. Came across to me as more villagery at the time, but idk. You're a sneak.

Sticking on 3M for now, but just wanted to make the point that you have yet to make it onto my villager list

 

[DVMDream]

What defences do we have from each player?

Anyone????

I'd also be willing to ignore all defences and take $1 million dollars for my vote to not go to the player that gives me monies. I mean, I am a vet, all about that money per the last client I just saw.

 

[PippyPony]

Anyone????

I'd also be willing to ignore all defences and take $1 million dollars for my vote to not go to the player that gives me monies. I mean, I am a vet, all about that money per the last client I just saw.

(Theme-appropriate because I heard this song in every bar I went to when I studied abroad in Ireland. Every.single.one.)


Oh, and 3M has not been on yet to defend. You can iso britzen pretty quick to get her defenses.

 

[SummerTheLynx]

And thanks for quoting those, @SummerTheLynx . Some of them were after people had already brought up substantial concerns, though, so not sure they help your case THAT much...

And looking back, your reasoning for staying off the genny vote on D1 was not the strongest. Came across to me as more villagery at the time, but idk. You're a sneak.

Sticking on 3M for now, but just wanted to make the point that you have yet to make it onto my villager list

Day 1? I checked in for half a second on day 1 as I didn't know game had started. The only one that was really after was the retrospect post that said, hey, maybe we shouldn't all pile on one person so we can have a discussion. I also see you as a little bit of pot calling kettle black with how your posts went and where you voted throughout say on day 2

 

[DVMDream]

Voting brit makes it a tie....I'm kind of tempted.

3m hasn't been on, so might vote that way to avoid tie and because no defense.

 

[raf2769]

lynch 3M

 

[DVMDream]

What were the reasons for 3m?

 

[raf2769]

I agree with what everyone has said, just waited on lynching in case she wanted to come in and defend... but I also don't want to risk missing lynch close, so there it is

 

[DVMDream]

And why did the ski vote stop?

 

[britzen]

Anyone????

I'd also be willing to ignore all defences and take $1 million dollars for my vote to not go to the player that gives me monies. I mean, I am a vet, all about that money per the last client I just saw.

$5. Final offer.

Sent from my SM-G920T using SDN mobile

 

[PippyPony]

And why did the ski vote stop?

Ski role revealed as Innocent Child role

 

[britzen]

And why did the ski vote stop?

Mods cleared her

Sent from my SM-G920T using SDN mobile

 

[Animal Midwife]

*********************************************************
The Dead's Unofficial Lynch Tally

Ceke (2) - LIS, Ski
WZ () -
britzen (4) - Kam, WZ, Ceke, Crayola
Ski () -
3m (6) - allieh, Cyndia, Fern, Pippy, britzen, raf
Pippy (1) - STL

13/17
lynch close in 24 minutes
*********************************************************

 

[SummerTheLynx]

And why did the ski vote stop?

Ski is innocent child Mafia role, mod confirmed village

 

[DVMDream]

Ski is innocent child Mafia role, mod confirmed village

I'm not familiar with this role

 

[TheGirlWithTheFernTattoo]

What were the reasons for 3m?

And why did the ski vote stop?

My reasons for 3M were her sketchy lynch vote D1 (voted for PBC to bring it more even between her and Genny once Genny started to get some votes on), combined with a non-vote D2 and jumping on the Snowy bandwagon D3. Plus the few analysis posts I saw were pretty unremarkable.

Ski was mod-confirmed villager as per innocent baby/cherub/whatever role.

 

[DVMDream]

$5. Final offer.

Sent from my SM-G920T using SDN mobile

Lynch britzen

 

[raf2769]

What were the reasons for 3m?

mostly that she has been quiet and non-committal, and that no one really has any reads on her one way or another and also these inputs made sense to me:

I'm leaning 3M again today. D1 when Genny was at 4 and PBC was at 2 she jumped onto to PBC, in what I interpret as possible trying to help a wolf out. Didn't vote D2. Read a few posts and didn't see much of substance, except throwing some suspicion at confirmed neutral/chaos individuals.

Lynch 3M
Also because I have a hunch I know what her role is, and I do not appreciate the continued radio silence in PMs

 

[SummerTheLynx]

I'm not familiar with this role

Essentially in the card game, the host of the game during a lunch cycle can say that they are village if they ask the host to clarify that they are village. Can only be done once.

 

[Trilt]

Officialish Lynch Tally

Ceke (2) - LIS, Ski
WZ () -
britzen (5) - Kam, WZ, Ceke, Crayola, DVMD
Ski () -
3m (6) - allieh, Cyndia, Fern, Pippy, britzen, raf
Pippy (1) - STL

14/17
lynch close in 15 minutes

 

[britzen]

Lynch britzen

To be fair, that's like infinity more dollars than my current salary. Which is $0.

 

[Cyndia]

Well I got home really late from the movie - can anyone give me a quick summary on any major changes on 3m vs brit?

 

[WildZoo]

Not necessarily. We got burned hard by under the radar players last game, which I suspect is happening now too. But I don't know anybody particularly well and don't have the bandwidth right now to really go hunting for that many players in 27 pages of thread.

I only ask because they were your only super sketchy suspects, and we probably have at least 3 wolves left to find. So if you don't think they're both wolves, I was interested in who your top 3 (or 4 if we're unlucky) were for remaining pack members.

 

[WildZoo]

Aaaaand I just realized that close is at 10 and not 11

 

[WildZoo]

Well I got home really late from the movie - can anyone give me a quick summary on any major changes on 3m vs brit?

Ritz posted a reads list and has been around, 3m hasn't been here all day, idk not much has really changed imo