So I am in-state, but I'll throw in my 2 cents.
DS wasnt even on my original list of schools. I added it as my 25th application and it ended up being the only school I got into. Honestly, I was a little apprehensive about coming here at first. It is a bit rough around the edges. That being said, I was pleasantly surprised by how well I fit in here. This is a school which does not have all the amenities of a private school, but I actually like that better. It sort of teaches you to work with what you have. This may sound a bit discouraging, but I promise it's a great learning experience.
The first 2 years here are average. I have my complaints and my favorite parts of first year, but looking back I feel really well prepared and I know a ton more than I ever thought I could know. The anatomy lab is brand new and is pristine. Plasma screens everywhere. The student to body ratio is 8:1 in groups of 4 (this is a good ratio trust me you dont want less).
DS is known for their second two years. We provide a clinical experience on par with top tier schools. We're in a bad neighborhood, so you'll see things here that will teach you incredible amounts. People get attacked, they let diseases grow out of control b/c they cant afford primary care, and all of it comes to kings county hospital. There is plenty of opportunity to get clinical experience outside of class in your first 2 years. They are also very good about helping you choose a direction in terms of specialty, through mentors, shadowing, specialty fairs, and so on.
The dorms are crappy, I'll say it up front. But we learn to live with them and then many people move out. I'm staying in them primarily cos I need to be close to class or else I wont go.
The class is pretty close knit. We all suffer together and we all help each other. Example: last week, we all arranged to sing to our musical-loving classmate on her birthday. All the boys she knew surprised her with flowers and sang "Your Song" from Moulin Rouge.
Overall, I am very happy with my experience here so far. I feel that I have been taught well, and am being advised well. I want to go into Emergency Medicine, so they have set me up with a mentor who is the residency director here, plus another attending to shadow. I think most people end up really enjoying it here.
All the best to you in the app cycle!