2012-2013 University of Iowa (Carver) Application Thread

This forum made possible through the generous support of SDN members, donors, and sponsors. Thank you.
Status
Not open for further replies.
I just recently submitted my secondary app after sitting on it for a while. I called Carver and was dealing with different departments to ascertain what my chances are for an ii this late in the game. I just have to say that Carver has some of the nicest and outgoing staff and students I have come across in this entire application season. To those who have been accepted and those whom will be, congrats! And I am sure you will be joining a wonderful organization!
 
...was stalking last year's thread... Have we talked about this "random 25" idea for the weekly committee meeting? It seems like the assumption has been that the order of review is definitely chronological, but that does not seem to be the case for last year(?).
 
ErrantWhatever said:
...was stalking last year's thread... Have we talked about this "random 25" idea for the weekly committee meeting? It seems like the assumption has been that the order of review is definitely chronological, but that does not seem to be the case for last year(?).
Click to expand...
I met with Barbara in early November when I passed through Iowa City. I interviewed on 9/19. Once you interview, you're placed into an in-state pile or an out-of-state pile. The files that are presented to the full committee are chosen by a subcommittee member. This is done without regard to who interviewed first.
 
HawkDoc76 said:
I met with Barbara in early November when I passed through Iowa City. I interviewed on 9/19. Once you interview, you're placed into an in-state pile or an out-of-state pile. The files that are presented to the full committee are chosen by a subcommittee member. This is done without regard to who interviewed first.
Click to expand...

Thanks for the info!
 
HawkDoc76 said:
I met with Barbara in early November when I passed through Iowa City. I interviewed on 9/19. Once you interview, you're placed into an in-state pile or an out-of-state pile. The files that are presented to the full committee are chosen by a subcommittee member. This is done without regard to who interviewed first.
Click to expand...

Yeah, I definitely don't think it's chronological. Who knows what criteria they use. :shrug:
 
HawkDoc76 said:
I met with Barbara in early November when I passed through Iowa City. I interviewed on 9/19. Once you interview, you're placed into an in-state pile or an out-of-state pile. The files that are presented to the full committee are chosen by a subcommittee member. This is done without regard to who interviewed first.
Click to expand...

That's great to know--thanks!
 
HawkDoc76 said:
I met with Barbara in early November when I passed through Iowa City. I interviewed on 9/19. Once you interview, you're placed into an in-state pile or an out-of-state pile. The files that are presented to the full committee are chosen by a subcommittee member. This is done without regard to who interviewed first.
Click to expand...

I was thinking about this further: "without regard to who interviewed first" doesn't mean "random." It could just as easily (and perhaps more likely) imply a value to post-interview applicants. I don't know if last year somebody heard it was random or they inferred it from other info, but it seemed to send a lot of people into thinking "random" was the order of the day.

#overanalysis
 
Subcommittee members choose which files to bring to full committee meetings each week. Their is no process by which they select these files each week. That's what I meant by random.
 
HawkDoc76 said:
Subcommittee members choose which files to bring to full committee meetings each week. Their is no process by which they select these files each week. That's what I meant by random.
Click to expand...

Oh--I wasn't implying that you said anything about it being random. Last year people created a dichotomy between it either being completely random or chronological. All I'm saying from your information is that perhaps there's a third way: subcom members choose based on their preferences/interest in the applicant.

Possible?
 
Secondary submitted: I think...10/1
II: 10/6 (It took 5 days to get the interview. I was shocked)
Interviewed 11/14
Accepted 12/ (4th or 5th)

OOS: 3.8+ / 33

Good luck everyone. This program is amazing. The LCs are absolutely top notch. The MERF building is top notch and everybody is super nice. Also, getting accepted means you automatically gain access to some of the best labs. There will be plenty of opportunity to work on an interesting project and also publishing. Still waiting to interview at other places, but it is unlikely that I'll find a place better than this. Very humbled to received an offer from a place like this.

Yes I am having trouble logging in with the hawk id.
 
Global Warming said:
Secondary submitted: I think...10/1
II: 10/6 (It took 5 days to get the interview. I was shocked)
Interviewed 11/14
Accepted 12/ (4th or 5th)

OOS: 3.8+ / 33

Good luck everyone. This program is amazing. The LCs are absolutely top notch. The MERF building is top notch and everybody is super nice. Also, getting accepted means you automatically gain access to some of the best labs. There will be plenty of opportunity to work on an interesting project and also publishing. Still waiting to interview at other places, but it is unlikely that I'll find a place better than this. Very humbled to received an offer from a place like this.

Yes I am having trouble logging in with the hawk id.
Click to expand...


Congrats!!

On the hawk ID thing, I just called that tech support number and had them change my password.
 
Was just thinking: of course Christmas/New Year's had to land on a Tuesday this season. 👎
 
ErrantWhatever said:
Was just thinking: of course Christmas/New Year's had to land on a Tuesday this season. 👎
Click to expand...

Yeah that's unfortunate. I called them the other day and they said my file hasn't even been reviewed since my interview. I interviewed in the very first week, way back in September. It's just frustrating that they don't review applicants in order. It drives me crazy seeing people get accepted to interviewed later than me knowing that my file hasn't even been looked at by the committee yet. #endrant
 
futchadoc89 said:
Yeah that's unfortunate. I called them the other day and they said my file hasn't even been reviewed since my interview. I interviewed in the very first week, way back in September. It's just frustrating that they don't review applicants in order. It drives me crazy seeing people get accepted to interviewed later than me knowing that my file hasn't even been looked at by the committee yet. #endrant
Click to expand...

Wow, they'll tell you if your file has been reviewed? Interesting. Yes, it definitely sucks. Interviewed 9/21--just torture.

Thanks for the cathartic moment of commiseration. 👍
 
ErrantWhatever said:
Wow, they'll tell you if your file has been reviewed? Interesting. Yes, it definitely sucks. Interviewed 9/21--just torture.

Thanks for the cathartic moment of commiseration. 👍
Click to expand...

Yep she said she could tell me if it was in review or if a decision had been made, and mine was neither of those, so that means they haven't reviewed it yet.

You interviewed the same week as me! :highfive:

Hopefully we'll find out soon... but just in case... does anyone remember the date that they'll tell us we're in the final pool or whatever it is?
 
futchadoc89 said:
Yep she said she could tell me if it was in review or if a decision had been made, and mine was neither of those, so that means they haven't reviewed it yet.

You interviewed the same week as me! :highfive:

Hopefully we'll find out soon... but just in case... does anyone remember the date that they'll tell us we're in the final pool or whatever it is?
Click to expand...

Interviewed on 9/19. I'm an IS applicant. Haven't been reviewed yet either. Let's hope for something tomorrow!
 
futchadoc89 said:
Yep she said she could tell me if it was in review or if a decision had been made, and mine was neither of those, so that means they haven't reviewed it yet.

You interviewed the same week as me! :highfive:

Hopefully we'll find out soon... but just in case... does anyone remember the date that they'll tell us we're in the final pool or whatever it is?
Click to expand...

Nice--it was a good week! I may or may not have stalked the crap out of the last 2 years' threads yesterday while snowed in all day (I had already cleaned every surface in the house and done 3 loads of laundry), and I'm pretty sure it was the 2nd or 3rd week in January that they sent out final pool notices. Hopefully we hear good news before then! 👍

HawkDoc76 said:
Interviewed on 9/19. I'm an IS applicant. Haven't been reviewed yet either. Let's hope for something tomorrow!
Click to expand...

Wow--IS here too, and I can only assume the same for futchadoc judging from the avatar. I seem to recall either last year or two years ago that the OOS bunch was heavily favored before Christmas time. Maybe that's going on again, or maybe I'm just not aware of many IS acceptances thus far.

...or maybe they just don't like us...😛
 
ErrantWhatever said:
Nice--it was a good week! I may or may not have stalked the crap out of the last 2 years' threads yesterday while snowed in all day (I had already cleaned every surface in the house and done 3 loads of laundry), and I'm pretty sure it was the 2nd or 3rd week in January that they sent out final pool notices. Hopefully we hear good news before then! 👍

Wow--IS here too, and I can only assume the same for futchadoc judging from the avatar. I seem to recall either last year or two years ago that the OOS bunch was heavily favored before Christmas time. Maybe that's going on again, or maybe I'm just not aware of many IS acceptances thus far.

...or maybe they just don't like us...😛
Click to expand...

Yep I'm IS as well and interviewed the same day as HawkDoc. It seems to be that way to me as well right now - mainly OOS or IS with >30 MCATs being accepted. It's kind of obnoxious. I'm spoiled because I applied DO this round as well and most of the DO schools will make a decision within 2-4 weeks of your interview. I have a deposit due at a DO school in 5 days so hopefully I hear some good news from Iowa tomorrow before I have to put down my deposit....... but probably not :laugh:
 
futchadoc89 said:
Yep I'm IS as well and interviewed the same day as HawkDoc. It seems to be that way to me as well right now - mainly OOS or IS with >30 MCATs being accepted. It's kind of obnoxious. I'm spoiled because I applied DO this round as well and most of the DO schools will make a decision within 2-4 weeks of your interview. I have a deposit due at a DO school in 5 days so hopefully I hear some good news from Iowa tomorrow before I have to put down my deposit....... but probably not :laugh:
Click to expand...

All the more--here's to hopin' for good news tomorrow! 👍
 
futchadoc89 said:
Yeah that's unfortunate. I called them the other day and they said my file hasn't even been reviewed since my interview. I interviewed in the very first week, way back in September. It's just frustrating that they don't review applicants in order. It drives me crazy seeing people get accepted to interviewed later than me knowing that my file hasn't even been looked at by the committee yet. #endrant
Click to expand...

Sorry to hear that. I'm sure good news is awaiting you. If you're IS and received an interview, you have a very strong chance of getting accepted. Good luck!!
 
futchadoc89 said:
I'm spoiled because I applied DO this round as well and most of the DO schools will make a decision within 2-4 weeks of your interview. I have a deposit due at a DO school in 5 days so hopefully I hear some good news from Iowa tomorrow before I have to put down my deposit....... but probably not :laugh:
Click to expand...

I'm in the same boat!! Nice to hear back so early, but since Iowa is my top choice, it's hard being patient, too! Good luck!!! 🙂
 
futchadoc89 said:
Yep she said she could tell me if it was in review or if a decision had been made, and mine was neither of those, so that means they haven't reviewed it yet.

You interviewed the same week as me! :highfive:

Hopefully we'll find out soon... but just in case... does anyone remember the date that they'll tell us we're in the final pool or whatever it is?
Click to expand...

This is interesting. I called them and they said that I am "in review." So this means I have been reviewed and passed over? Or have I not been sent to the committee yet and might not until Jan?
 
CellMaster said:
This is interesting. I called them and they said that I am "in review." So this means I have been reviewed and passed over? Or have I not been sent to the committee yet and might not until Jan?
Click to expand...

Did you just call today?
 
ErrantWhatever said:
I would interpret that to mean that your application is before the adcom today, no?

Jealous.
Click to expand...

Im not sure, she didnt really make it sound like that. It sounded as if everyone who has been reviewed (and did not get accepted) remains "in review" until Jan. But I'm not sure...thoughts?
 
CellMaster said:
Im not sure, she didnt really make it sound like that. It sounded as if everyone who has been reviewed (and did not get accepted) remains "in review" until Jan. But I'm not sure...thoughts?
Click to expand...

That certainly sounds like a reasonable interpretation. I guess it's not clear from what people have heard in the past whether you continually are considered for admission once first reviewed or simply final pooled if not accepted initially. Since they likely have so many applications to review, I would think the latter (and therefore, when she said your application is "in review" it was merely code for "sorry, you were final pooled").

?
 
CellMaster said:
This is interesting. I called them and they said that I am "in review." So this means I have been reviewed and passed over? Or have I not been sent to the committee yet and might not until Jan?
Click to expand...

Can I ask who you called? Because I just tried calling the admissions office to check my status and the lady who answered said she couldn't tell me anything about whether or not I have or have not been reviewed. I interviewed on Oct. 3 and also have to deposit at another school this week. Pretty frustrating.
 
menkeiwitz said:
Can I ask who you called? Because I just tried calling the admissions office to check my status and the lady who answered said she couldn't tell me anything about whether or not I have or have not been reviewed. I interviewed on Oct. 3 and also have to deposit at another school this week. Pretty frustrating.
Click to expand...

Oh cool we interviewed the same day! Unfortunately I have no idea who I spoke with, it was just the general admissions number. I asked if there was any way I could be notified on the status of my secondary and that I interviewed Oct 3rd. To that they stated I was "in review" which Im assuming just means complete. Im assuming ErrantWhatever is correct that I am basically in the final pool and will be a/wl/r in Jan. So even if they will tell you that it might not really help with your deposit issue. On a positive note, congrats on one acceptance 🙂
 
Soooooo...nobody on here heard anything today? I assume they met, but what do I know?
 
ErrantWhatever said:
Soooooo...nobody on here heard anything today? I assume they met, but what do I know?
Click to expand...

This is super frustrating!!

Also when I called the other day the lady said it's "not uncommon" to have interviewed very early like I did and not have a decision made on your file until the spring. It seems to me like Iowa accepts a few people and puts everyone else in the final pool.....
 
futchadoc89 said:
This is super frustrating!!

Also when I called the other day the lady said it's "not uncommon" to have interviewed very early like I did and not have a decision made on your file until the spring. It seems to me like Iowa accepts a few people and puts everyone else in the final pool.....
Click to expand...

Yes. Yes it is(!!!). I don't know why, but I got really into this today. Ah well! Thanks for the info--seems like an accurate statement from what I perused of the past 2 years' threads.
 
futchadoc89 said:
This is super frustrating!!

Also when I called the other day the lady said it's "not uncommon" to have interviewed very early like I did and not have a decision made on your file until the spring. It seems to me like Iowa accepts a few people and puts everyone else in the final pool.....
Click to expand...

I can confirm that is the case. I went to Iowa and my premed advisor told me that most of Iowa's acceptances come from the final pool in March. With that in mind, most of us probably still have a long wait until we receive a decision.
 
Anyone know if the ADCOM is meeting tomorrow? Or are they on break already?
 
Updated my secondary with grades and whatnot. Hoping that gets me some love here in the form of an interview
 
ErrantWhatever said:
Is it Tuesday again already?
Click to expand...

Tuesday came and went with no news. I figured the committee probably wouldn't meet again since Iowa students have been on break for a few days now. Ah well. Everyone have a happy holiday season and here's hoping to good news in the new year!
 
Moved to the final pool, just found out today. Interviewed 11/14. Will not find out until March. Good luck, everyone.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Similar threads

chilly_md
2023-2024 Iowa (Carver)
8 9 10 11 12
Replies
593
Views
159K
orthodontisto
orthodontisto
wysdoc
2022-2023 Iowa (Carver)
10 11 12 13 14
Replies
665
Views
155K
TiramisuLover99
TiramisuLover99
wysdoc
2024-2025 Iowa
8 9 10 11 12
Replies
590
Views
137K
Chickabob29
C
wysdoc
2024-2025 University of Washington
10 11 12 13 14
Replies
680
Views
147K
stew_md
S
wysdoc
2024-2025 University of Chicago (Pritzker)
12 13 14 15 16
Replies
778
Views
207K
X0001234
X0001234
Top