I think there's a certain time window where you can edit without it being flagged as edited. I'm not sure what the time window is though. After that it will say on the post that it was edited.
Felt like a joke that was revealing of his mindset towards voting, i.e. not valuing it as much as I expect of a villager
...I would've thought that was obvious from the post
This just feels hella stretchy to me. People make jokes about current and future voting all the time, no matter their affiliation.
It depends on how quickly the edit is done. If it’s within 5 minutes of posting, no.
... Before being noted as edited?
My point about that specifically is that I don’t think scum would give up powerful roles over weaker scum roles, just to try and get village cred. Sunny finds it suspicious that I was unwilling to consider that possibility.
Which ones made you think this?Well I'm currently not splitting hairs too hard (which is probably the wrong approach for a multiball game butI'll refine it later if I'm alive). I haven't come across any pingy posts from him myself, at least not the ones I've been reading closely, and did have a few where I was like "yes, village mindset here." Hence, village pile.
Please tell me I’m misunderstanding and you aren’t really saying that you’re basing a town read of Zenge just on Cray sussing him.
Knew I should have included an emoji...
… oh
This one in particular felt good
still have to read from page 6 to close yesterday though.
I can’t really justify my gut reaction to a post. It’s just how I felt about it.
Can I get your thoughts on putting Vis in your village pile here?
Yeah and I'm saying your gut feeling is resulting in you throwing mad shade which I don't think is justified.
adding to this, do we know how parity works for the factions? like if there are 2 mafia and 2 wolf, does that make 4 parity or 2 parity
why? i'm going w the explanation of pure joke for now- but what made you flip towny on it?
like i guess but idk if i'd town lean her just for that
curious as to why WZ was in your village leans instead of like a seperate neutral category?
but see i don't think she's doing that. when i woofed w visc (granted they were SUPER busy at the time) it was more speculation and wall posts, not as much getting into the action like we've seen here. I'm town leaning visc for now
similarly, i've given a single village point to anyone who claimed an affil role besides vanilla, and no points either way for those who did. my logic being is that it's bold to claim something that could be refuted by someone else
this is very helpful
i love when shorty and z get sassy on the thread. its fun to picture them ww'ing while like putting together place cards for the wedding and having a very sassy interaction here and a pleasant conversation at the same time irl
to be fair she's asked nearly everyone for reads, just asked multiple times from people who haven't given like comprehensive ones yet
this interaction between dubz and shorty is feeling a little more v/v to meIt's what you were pointing to
i here!!!!
im not understanding the visc sus
Like I said, I can understand that not everyone reacts to wolfing the same way I do, so with Dubz vouching that she wouldn’t expect you to be tense I’m not putting weight on my read of those posts. But they never factored into my read of you as much as the possible fishing, playing up not understanding, and refusal for much of yesterday to work with anyone.
This is equivalent to being at parity with town and no other killing roles alive/active, if that helps thinking about when we would be at mylo etc @alleycat03
Hmm. I guess I was reading it as last faction standing but the "or nothing can prevent this from happening" line makes sense for referring to normal parity. Though technically idk if that is the case since if it's 2 village 2 mafia there could still be a tie vote (do we know how toes are decided) and parity is just convention in that case.
Meh, because I'm not getting feels either way
That should say ties but the typo is amusing me
Tanks
And my response to that is bite me
The bottom line is Neutrals are neutrals. Some I’m a little more concerned about, some a little less, but they’re all Neutral at the moment.
Having also wolfed with Vis, and more recently, when she wasn’t busy, she has gotten better. She’s in my neutrals at the moment. I just want to watch her more closely, because I know she can be a powerful wolf who can look very village.
Is there anyone you do have feels on other than sunny?
Edited for correctness
If neutrals are neutrals, why did you split them up? It's just weird because you have Dubz, an apparent true neutral, sandwiched between people where you specifically say that they were village-neutral. Almost like you needed to stick her in somewhere and forgot to be careful with your phrasing to be consistent.
I have village feels. I don't like to talk about them because I feel like it paints targets for the scum to hit
Also I don't feel great about vis.
Because there were a lot of them and I felt slightly better about some, and more concerned about others, but not good enough or poor enough about any of them at that moment to move them into village or scum piles.
Why did zenge voting with you bother you so much?
Where are the pretty colors 🙁
The behavior in general of bringing up the option to role reveal the affiliation role picks, seemed pro village at the time. Driving that conversation felt like a villager thing to do.
The proximity in time bugged me a little because wolf!Zenge has sheeped my votes like that before on people who are misyeeted easily (sunny comes to mind), but what bothered me even more was the fact that he hadn't mentioned Stagg AT ALL prior to putting his vote there. Zenge has 3 posts on Stagg in this entire game, and all of them are from his vote onward. So that, paired with him just following me onto the vote with his justification being that he felt good about me and alley, and didn't like that Stagg was sussing him and chaos, really didn't feel good.
Wonder’s role reveal felt plausible and believable. So I left that vote and the clock was rapidly ticking to close. I wanted to vote somewhere that I felt good about and I can certainly understand the Stagg sus. Worst case scenario the thread moving forward wouldn’t be clogged with people so blinded by Staggs sketch, they were unwilling to vote anywhere else until they saw him flip.
This is fair (in particular I did not track that he hadn't mentioned stagg prior) but this
is kind of what I had in my head when I was reading back. Voting with your village reads seems reasonable with less than an hour to close and a believable reveal from the person you were previously voting for.
I’m hesitant to read Sunny this way on participation. It’s my understanding she’s currently very busy and that we shouldn’t expect the same level of participation we’re used to.
I've also had some misgivings about chaos as I'm reading through. I'm getting the impression that it was kind of all he talked about, along with general theory about how this game structure works, and not so much about reads on people until much later. I know he posted a reads list around here somewhere, need to find it again.
Hmm. Yes busy, and I give her that for the sparcity of her reads, but I don't so much track why that would change how she reacts to being scum read.
Hmm. I don't so much mean a sunny blow up, because I agree that's not as much of a thing anymore, but really any type of reaction at all. Who knows. Maybe she really is that disinterested in the game. Doesn't feel right to me though.
