CHOOSE YOUR OWWN III - Game Thread

[Lawpy]

---

Members do not see this ad.

just when one Lawpy was trying to finish his steps, he found himself few more pages behind and now completely lost why the Lumi wagon is accelerating

 

[WildZoo]

Anyone else want to claim black goo since that seems to be the chef’s special today?

I AM THE BLACK GOO

 

[potentialsheltervet]

just when one Lawpy was trying to finish his steps, he found himself few more pages behind and now completely lost why the Lumi wagon is accelerating

Outted as a fakeclaim because Wonder is black goo.

 

[potentialsheltervet]

I AM THE BLACK GOO

Black Goodas?

 

[Lawpy]

also obviously Lumi is not a noob but they are still new to SDN and i’d personally like to spend more time playing with them this game if that’s possible

 

[Lawpy]

Outted as a fakeclaim because Wonder is black goo.

Is there a reason why we’re believing Wondy’s claim is genuine?

 

[Chaostrodon]

Unvote genny , vote Lumi.

Pure self-preservation , but I would genuinely recommend rest of town to follow suit , I dont have any killing powers so you can get me anytime

I meant self-preservation in the sense that I am doing this purely to save myself and not for any altruistic reasons.

 

[potentialsheltervet]

Is there a reason why we’re believing Wondy’s claim is genuine?

Because it would be really foolish to fakeclaim black goo if Lumi is actually black goo, knowing that would get Lumi yoten and Wonder revealed as a liar.

 

[supershorty]

ok zenge.... noting that you're trying to start my misyeet train early

This is kinda reactive.

 

[WildZoo]

Black Goodas?

Yum

 

[supershorty]

Because it would be really foolish to fakeclaim black goo if Lumi is actually black goo, knowing that would get Lumi yoten and Wonder revealed as a liar.

I have a dream now that Lumi, Wondy, and Chaos are all the same faction and this is some epic scum theater.

I highly doubt that's the case, but I'd love it.

 

[Lawpy]

Because it would be really foolish to fakeclaim black goo if Lumi is actually black goo, knowing that would get Lumi yoten and Wonder revealed as a liar.

I mean that can be said for Lumi’s own claim which is how the chaos wagon accelerated.

 

[alissa14]

ok to keep my spreadsheet info vague for now. There are 2 players who have not checked in or claimed a role used for affiliation. Chaos is role claiming Judas but I am not following if he claimed anything for affiliation?? Did he claim black goo? Wonder claimed black goo for affiliation which I find interesting because I am using Dubz' reasoning over which role to discard and which to use for affiliation, it makes it very WIFOM in my head

 

[Animal Midwife]

Day 1 Yeet Tally
Stagg () -
mkg () -
O2 () -
genny () -
True () -
dubz (1) - Lumi
Chaos (5) - dubz, Lawpy, shorty, mkg, Zenge
Lumi (4) - True, Wonder, Chaos, alissa
mkg () -

10/16
yeet close in ~27 hours

 

[Lawpy]

I have a dream now that Lumi, Wondy, and Chaos are all the same faction and this is some epic scum theater.

I highly doubt that's the case, but I'd love it.

I can see this happening but i think one of the claims is genuine

 

[alissa14]

This is kinda reactive.

you get this way when you have a long history of misyeets and dying early on

 

[mkg323]

I AM THE BLACK GOO

 

[supershorty]

also obviously Lumi is not a noob but they are still new to SDN and i’d personally like to spend more time playing with them this game if that’s possible

Yeah, I'd personally not like to D1 yeet someone in their very first game on the site.

 

[Lawpy]

This is a pretty engaging D1

 

[potentialsheltervet]

I mean that can be said for Lumi’s own claim which is how the chaos wagon accelerated.

Yes. I'm thinking Lumi didn't expect to be caught.

 

[supershorty]

I can see this happening but i think one of the claims is genuine

I agree, but let me dream lol

 

[potentialsheltervet]

I agree, but let me dream lol

I had the same thought. That would be legendary.

 

[Lawpy]

Yes. I'm thinking Lumi didn't expect to be caught.

Hmm… … …

I’m going to revisit what transpired because I’m not really convinced Wondy is in the clear.

 

[alissa14]

Is there a reason why we’re believing Wondy’s claim is genuine?

It has been awhile since I have played with Wonder and even longer since I wolfed with her (20s i believe?). And I have a really hard time seeing scum!wonder coming on in her early posts to claim black goo as her affiliation just to make chaos (pun intended)

 

[WildZoo]

also obviously Lumi is not a noob but they are still new to SDN and i’d personally like to spend more time playing with them this game if that’s possible

That's all well and good but like...we have evidence they're lying unless Wonder has suddenly changed her entire playstyle, so I don't think usual d1 niceties apply

 

[supershorty]

I don't really love that it seems like whomever has claimed the goo most recently is automatically believed.

 

[alissa14]

That's all well and good but like...we have evidence they're lying unless Wonder has suddenly changed her entire playstyle, so I don't think usual d1 niceties apply

I don't really love that it seems like whomever has claimed the goo most recently is automatically believed.

I am not 100% believing wonder's claim but it is the most plausible based on what I know about her playstyle. If she is lying this opens up so much WIFOM my head hurts

 

[supershorty]

This is kinda reactive.

Eye rolling this is also kinda reactive.

 

[Lawpy]

Guess what shorty...this did happen!
What are the chances that both Chaos and Lumi decided on the same fake claim affiliation

Me when starting to read the thread: ummmm Chaos is lying.
Me when lumi claimed: ummmmm wtf why are two people lying about getting black goo
*clears throat* my affiliation card was black goo (village alligned)

Chaos could be lying about Judas and could be ie Saulus but just in case going to put my vote for now somewhere else (on the more sketchy player):

yeet lumi

What if lumi’s claim was actually genuine and wondy piled onto the chaos by asserting and driving the black goo claim? It’s actually a pretty bold scum play but remember lumi’s playstyle was already causing tensions by asking half the roster to reveal and relying on the discards.

 

[Zenge142]

I don't really love that it seems like whomever has claimed the goo most recently is automatically believed.

Isn’t that logical though?

 

[WorthlessOxygen]

I don't really love that it seems like whomever has claimed the goo most recently is automatically believed.

Seems weird to lie given that fake claiming seems like you'd be caught pretty fast though?

 

[WildZoo]

I don't really love that it seems like whomever has claimed the goo most recently is automatically believed.

Do you honestly believe that Wonder would come in and falsely claim it at this point?

She very clearly had seen the previous claims. I'm actually not sure that Lumi had seen Chaos's claim before they made theirs.

 

[Lawpy]

That's all well and good but like...we have evidence they're lying unless Wonder has suddenly changed her entire playstyle, so I don't think usual d1 niceties apply

Lumi was already in the heat for reasons unrelated to the black goo claim. Wondy piling onto the chaos by asserting that claim could be possible.

 

[supershorty]

What if lumi’s claim was actually genuine and wondy piled onto the chaos by asserting and driving the black goo claim? It’s actually a pretty bold scum play but remember lumi’s playstyle was already causing tensions by asking half the roster to reveal and relying on the discards.

Okay, but I just went back and looked at CYO II and you do see both components of the person's role when they flip (as in, what they used for aff and what they used for ability), so now I'm back to thinking about how badly this backfires for a scum!anyone to push the fakeclaim b/c as soon as the real person flips, they're definitely outted.

 

[WildZoo]

Lumi was already in the heat for reasons unrelated to the black goo claim. Wondy piling onto the chaos by asserting that claim could be possible.

What's the long-term benefit?

 

[WildZoo]

Unyeet chaos yeet Lumi

Interested to see what happens when they return

 

[Chaostrodon]

What if lumi’s claim was actually genuine and wondy piled onto the chaos by asserting and driving the black goo claim? It’s actually a pretty bold scum play but remember lumi’s playstyle was already causing tensions by asking half the roster to reveal and relying on the discards.

That would be bad scum play coz if lumi is found to not be black goo , wonder is next on the chopping block

 

[Viscernable]

Sup
Why are there 10 pages

 

[Lawpy]

What's the long-term benefit?

Chaos and disarray among village

 

[Chaostrodon]

Sup
Why are there 10 pages

Hi , is your role also black goo?

 

[Lawpy]

That would be bad scum play coz if lumi is found to not be black goo , wonder is next on the chopping block

Scum!wondy could be aware of that and set up countermeasures in advance of announcing the claim

 

[supershorty]

Scum!wondy could be aware of that and set up countermeasures in advance of announcing the claim

Countermeasures like what?

 

[Zenge142]

I thought you all would think it was a scum role and wouldnt pick it, I didnt know I was playing with a bunch of black goo connoisseurs

Why not just claim Judas outright? What’s the thought process there?

 

[Chaostrodon]

That would be bad scum play coz if lumi is found to not be black goo , wonder is next on the chopping block

I meant found to be black goo

 

[alissa14]

Chaos and disarray among village

but this is short term. Lumi flipping could prove or disprove wonder's claim pretty easily. Plus this is a small game so I imagine scum factions consist of no more than 1-3 players. It is really risky to the team to throw yourself out like that when it can be easily disproved

 

[WorthlessOxygen]

Scum!wondy could be aware of that and set up countermeasures in advance of announcing the claim

Curious what countermeasure you think would even be possible?

 

[Viscernable]

Last time we played CYO, I think it was Chaos who encouraged everyone to claim what role they used for AFFILIATION pretty early on, and I like the thinking behind that since you can catch slips later with it.

THIS IS TALKING ABOUT YOUR CHOICE FOR AFFILIATION, NOT ABILITY. DO NOT CLAIM YOUR ROLE.

I used town mason/lover for my aff.

RNGesus has a real trolly sense of humor giving me a lover possibility after my experience last year.

I used town mason/doctor… and had a “holy **** was this a totally voluntary self incrimination” moment reading this before realizing mason/lover != mason/doctor.

 

[Lawpy]

Countermeasures like what?

Vengeful?

 

[Chaostrodon]

Why not just claim Judas outright? What’s the thought process there?

I wouldnt trust anyone with a Judas claim , normal procedure is to vig people who do that at night , I might have owned up to it at somepoint later in the game , but not d1

 

[supershorty]

Vengeful?

I need a little more explanation to follow what you're saying.