which would you chose?
The one with the best financial aid package.
Same tuition as well? Is one closer to your family? Did you like the location of one more than the other?
I'm a student at Albany Med. My advice is go with your gut, everything else aside. The people make or break your experience. I don't know what you mean by you couldn't get a read on the school but I can tell you why I chose to come here. I worked for two med schools before finally going to med school myself. The students at the other schools were so cut-throat and backstabbing. That type of environment is so exhausting and I didn't want to deal with that kind of crap for four years. Hardly ever does a day go by when I don't have at least one email from a classmate sending out a link to a helpful website or a summary table someone made. The students here work their asses off but we are more interested in helping each other than competing with each other. I can usually just walk in to see one of the deans at any time without making an appointment. The professors most of the time will drop whatever they are doing to help you if you walk into their office, they hold extra help sessions, all materials including notes and recorded lectures are online.... the list goes on and on. These were the things that were important to me in choosing a school, and after coming here I know beyond a shadow of a doubt that I made the right decision. Hopefully this sheds some light on the school situation. If you have any specific questions let me know. I'll tell you the downsides as well and try to give an accurate representation of what life is like here. In the end though, determine what is most important to you and go with your gut.