2008-2009 George Washington University (GWU) Secondary Application Thread

This forum made possible through the generous support of SDN members, donors, and sponsors. Thank you.
Status
Not open for further replies.
Hi everyone,

I am a current GW student and I think it is important to put a few more facts in this thread. The fact that GW is on probation has very little to do with our curriculum and a lot to do with administrative details. The crux of the issue has to do with a move toward stating learning objectives in a more explicit way and also making the curriculum track-able. Let me give you an example. Currently GW states its learning objectives like this "Students will be proficient in performing a breast exam." LCME wants the objectives to be more specific including what specific skills we should have, how to palpate for masses etc. They also want our the objectives to be linked throughout so if in your fourth year if an attending says wow Katie you really suck at breast exams the school can go back and know exactly where and when I learned breast anatomy and physiology, where I learned a clinical exam, where I learned breast pathology etc. So they can evaluate and make program changes to make sure everyone is learning what they need to learn.

It has nothing to do with the actual teaching but the structure of how the administration follows the objectives integrated in all aspects of the curriculum. As others have pointed out, GW continues to be an excellent school with high board scores and students who match very well. The issue that has been mentioned about classes being over crowded is absolutely not true. Our class size has remained around 170 for a long time. None of the classrooms are cramped and there is plenty of interaction with professors, deans, etc.

I think its important to evaluate a school based on if it is a good fit for you. For me the things that make GW a great place to learn medicine are its location in DC, where we have access to everything from the Pan American Health Organization to the NIH. GW also has many different hospitals to rotate through. You can treat a gunshot patient at Washington Hospital Center, see incredible and unique infectious diseases at GW Hospital and deliver four babies in one night at Virginia Hospital Center. I saw my first patient within a month of starting medical school. My peers spent summers in Ethiopia, Nepal, Bolivia, Ecuador, South Africa etc. Others worked at the NIH, Harvard, or worked with GW physicians doing research for the summer.

I also appreciate that my peers are supportive of one another. We work together and motivate each other to get through the tough parts. When I was looking at medical schools I had plenty of other offers but made my decision based upon where I saw myself being happiest. I am sure that anyone who really will fit in to GW will be able to see this probation for what it is-- nothing of any real importance. If you want to be a great physician, learn from some of the best that are leaders in their fields and have access to all that DC has to offer then GW could be the right place for you. But believe me if you are more worried about rankings and 15 minutes of bad press you probably wouldn't fit in very well here.

Anyone who interviews and comes to visit our school will see it for what it is - an incredible and unique place to learn medicine. Good Luck to everyone in the application process. I can only hope that you each find a place you love as much as I love GW.


I would be more than happy to answer questions about GW about the probation etc as would anyone else.
 
Thank you Katie for the thorough post and for dispelling rumors. When I was interning in DC this summer, I remembered a moment when I sat on a bench in the GW quad. I looked at the hospital and imagined that someday I will be able to interview or even attend this great school. I know it's super cheesey, but I am so grateful that GW sees something in me that they like. I have an upcoming interview at GW next week and I am super excited and stoked. Sure the probation got me a bit worried, but I am sure it's just a small hiccup. Thank you so much for your post. Would you happen to know what types of resources I can look into before I head into my GW interview?
 
Yeah I am pretty excited about it too, regardless of this probation. I am interviewing on November 6th, hope to see some of you there!

Also, how long will it take for us to find out if we are accepted? I have dreams of walking into my december finals stress free and enjoying Christmas!
 
Yeah I am pretty excited about it too, regardless of this probation. I am interviewing on November 6th, hope to see some of you there!

Also, how long will it take for us to find out if we are accepted? I have dreams of walking into my december finals stress free and enjoying Christmas!


It will take 6 to 8 weeks after interview date.
 
i would definitely still be excited about an interview at GWU. actually i am really hoping they give me one still because it sounds like a great school. despite the probation status.. but i mean honestly rosalind franklin i knwo for a fact was on probation and wasn't albany? and people still apply there ! whatever, keep withdrawing people, so that an interview slot for me exists.
 
I am a Proud Second Year GWU medical student. The probationary status that we are currently under has a lot to do with having space for students to study (Student lounge). This status has nothing to do with the quality of education received at GWU. Yes, its horrible that we are on probation... but if this is your top school don't remove it from your list. There aren't many schools that can provide students with clinical skills to perform a full physical exam on a patient during the first year of medical school. Also, we are basically done with our core courses during the first semester of second year.. during the second semester we review all the body systems (Intro to Clinical Medicine) and prep for boards. I really wish GW would post the 2008 Match list because that list alone shows that GW is preparing students for distinguish careers in medicine. You can't beat our clinical years and EVERYONE KNOWS THAT!!!! We are GW WE WILL PULL THROUGH with the HELP of faculty AND students. So if its your first choice stick to it b/c u'll kick ur self next March when this probationary status ends. 🙂
 
Hey all,
Still interested in GW...contact GW students on SDN with your questions.😍😍
 
Last edited:
Awesome post^. I am actually reading up on GW for my interview. So excited. I love DC--I got to live in DC for a 2 month internship. One of the best experience of my life. It's such a dynamic and diverse city filled with opportunities and challenges across every spectrum you can imagine.
 
Are only acceptances being sent out via e-mail? What about waitlist and rejections(snail mail)?
 
The Committee on Admissions is pleased to inform you that you have been selected as an alternate for the first year class of the program leading to the Doctor of Medicine degree entering in August 2009. A final decision has yet to be made regarding an acceptance.

You should be very proud as you recognize that your selection as an alternate has been made from a large group of very talented applicants. Moreover, many alternates are ultimately offered acceptance to this program.

Recognizing that this waiting period may be difficult, our staff wants to make this easier for you. During this period it is important for you to use [email protected] to keep our staff updated with your current contact information. Our admissions counselors are available to answer your questions and listen to your concerns. Don’t hesitate to contact them through [email protected] or by phone.

Any new graded coursework must be submitted when available. Please be aware that all those accepted into the class must submit satisfactory completion of all required coursework and final official transcripts by July 15, 2009.

We greatly appreciate your interest in our School of Medicine. Again, please contact us for questions and concerns.

Sincerely,
mail

Diane P. McQuail, M.A.
Assistant Dean of Admissions
Chair, Committee on Admissions

---------------

=\ what are my chances of getting in now?
 
So was Jefferson.

ahahaha, ok this just makes me laugh at this point. because 4 of the schools i have applied to have been or are on probation . weeeeee ! oh well, whatever i still love gwu so it's fine !
 
How many people do you think withdrew from GWU after the probation? 10%?
 
How many people do you think withdrew from GWU after the probation? 10%?
Ha I wish! I don't think that many will. I'm guessing more like a 100 or 200. Even that might be a lot.
 
The Committee on Admissions is pleased to inform you that you have been selected as an alternate for the first year class of the program leading to the Doctor of Medicine degree entering in August 2009. A final decision has yet to be made regarding an acceptance.

You should be very proud as you recognize that your selection as an alternate has been made from a large group of very talented applicants. Moreover, many alternates are ultimately offered acceptance to this program.

Recognizing that this waiting period may be difficult, our staff wants to make this easier for you. During this period it is important for you to use [email protected] to keep our staff updated with your current contact information. Our admissions counselors are available to answer your questions and listen to your concerns. Don’t hesitate to contact them through [email protected] or by phone.

Any new graded coursework must be submitted when available. Please be aware that all those accepted into the class must submit satisfactory completion of all required coursework and final official transcripts by July 15, 2009.

We greatly appreciate your interest in our School of Medicine. Again, please contact us for questions and concerns.

This came in as an e-mail? How do you feel your student interview went if you don't mind me asking?
 
This came in as an e-mail? How do you feel your student interview went if you don't mind me asking?

My student was a joke. Her first interview, literally, and I think I overwhelmed her to the point where she didn't know what to do with me. The second interviewer, a cardiothoracic surgeon, really connected. Very tough interviewer, but at the end I felt like he wanted me there. He probably gave a strong recommendation which is why I'm still playing the game. I think I just don't have the numbers (29P/3.65ish) to get an out right acceptance to a school with 10K applicants. USUHS/Gtown are a better fit for me anyway. I felt much stronger coming out of those interviews and they're less of a number cruncher (Mrs. Sullivan at Gtown reads every application, thoroughly...it was almost eery how much she knew about me), so hopefully I'll hear back from them soon.

Migs
 
My student was a joke. Her first interview, literally, and I think I overwhelmed her to the point where she didn't know what to do with me. The second interviewer, a cardiothoracic surgeon, really connected. Very tough interviewer, but at the end I felt like he wanted me there. He probably gave a strong recommendation (and he made it sound like he had some influence), I just don't have the numbers (29P/3.65ish) to get out right accepted to a school with 10K applicants I guess. USUHS/Gtown are a better fit for me anyway. I felt much stronger coming out of the interviews so hopefully I'll get in somewhere soon.

Migs

Your numbers are what they tend to accept, IMO. In case, you're interested, one of the students told us of GW waitlists that;

For the 2007 entering class, 70% of the class got in from the waitlist
For the 2008 entering class, only five students got in from the waitlist


Stay hopeful.
 
Your numbers are what they tend to accept, IMO. In case, you're interested, one of the students told us of GW waitlists that;

For the 2007 entering class, 70% of the class got in from the waitlist
For the 2008 entering class, only five students got in from the waitlist


Stay hopeful.

That is quite a difference.
 
Your numbers are what they tend to accept, IMO. In case, you're interested, one of the students told us of GW waitlists that;

For the 2007 entering class, 70% of the class got in from the waitlist
For the 2008 entering class, only five students got in from the waitlist


Stay hopeful.

Can a current GWU student confirm these stats?
 
Last edited:
Can a current GWU student confirm these stats?

I don't know where these numbers are coming from, but I suppose it's possible they're true. It seems odd that it would vary by that much, however.
 
Does anyone know what it means for the school that it has been placed on probationary status. GW sent me an email saying "As a result of the review, the Liaison Committee on Medical Education (LCME) placed the program on probationary status. All School programs remain fully accredited during the probationary period."
 
Does anyone know what it means for the school that it has been placed on probationary status. GW sent me an email saying "As a result of the review, the Liaison Committee on Medical Education (LCME) placed the program on probationary status. All School programs remain fully accredited during the probationary period."

read the last 40 posts on here...
 
Your numbers are what they tend to accept, IMO. In case, you're interested, one of the students told us of GW waitlists that;

For the 2007 entering class, 70% of the class got in from the waitlist
For the 2008 entering class, only five students got in from the waitlist


Stay hopeful.

that doesnt sound very comforting - the most recent stats would make you think alt list people have no chance.. you are telling me that the waitlist can vary that much?!?!
 
Did anyone get the accept packet in the mail yet?? Its been a while and it makes me nervous because the 'rents are watching for my mail.
 
I'm just wondering, how much weight does GWU put on the interview? Do your stats come into play as much as they did before you got the interview or how does it work?
 
My status page states that my application is "currently under review" for a month now.

Anyone know how long is the wait from "currently under review" until you hear back from the school with an interview invite or a rejection?
 
My status page states that my application is "currently under review" for a month now.

Anyone know how long is the wait from "currently under review" until you hear back from the school with an interview invite or a rejection?

well, if their admissions is anything like their medical school.. your application will probably go on probationary status for the next 2 years.. 😀
 
well, if their admissions is anything like their medical school.. your application will probably go on probationary status for the next 2 years.. 😀

I know you're probably kidding, but still, that's a pretty low blow. The letter from the LCME makes it pretty clear that the probation is related to non-curriculum aspects of their program. On top of that, they are still fully accredited during the 24-month period. The word "probation" here has a more negative connotation than what their real status is, IMHO. They didn't just get out of "med. school prison" or anything...
 
I know you're probably kidding, but still, that's a pretty low blow. The letter from the LCME makes it pretty clear that the probation is related to non-curriculum aspects of their program. On top of that, they are still fully accredited during the 24-month period. The word "probation" here has a more negative connotation than what their real status is, IMHO. They didn't just get out of "med. school prison" or anything...

don't worry, i was just kidding. i'm still a little bitter for getting waitlisted. it seemed like a top notch school when i interviewed, especially after they finish all the construction/remodeling plans...
 
GWU has a very popular medical school that receives the most applicants almost every year, but is not ranked in medicine by US News. Looking at those rankings, most of the other unranked schools are much weaker as a whole institution than is GWU (i.e., GWU is around top 50 in undergrad, top 20 in Law, top 50 in Business), and has been spending and expanding vastly to build their programs, including the new teaching hospital. It seems like the school values the medical program at least somewhat on par with its other programs, and GWU Med is a favorable choice for many competitive applicants in the general pool. So, does anyone know why this medical school is totally unranked? Sometimes it's said that the school faces financial problems with the medical center, and this situation can be compared to that of Georgetown's crisis, and general losses in DC hospitals... but even Georgetown, whose financial issues put them over 330 million in debt over the last decade and forced them to sell their hospital to MedStar, is ranked, and even considering their losses, Georgetown still receives a somewhat significantly larger NIH research grant than does GWU. So I don't get it. Is there some great weakness in GW's program that the public does not know about? Is this medical school really "excellent", as it claims to be and by all accounts definitely seems to be? Do they not participate in the ranking? And now they've been placed on probation and all this... it's starting to look a little fishy. But still, when I think GWU, I think "great school", great location, and tons of stuff to get into, especially for those who like activism. But clearly some people (not the students) don't share that view.
 
GWU has a very popular medical school that receives the most applicants almost every year, but is not ranked in medicine by US News. Looking at those rankings, most of the other unranked schools are much weaker as a whole institution than is GWU (i.e., GWU is around top 50 in undergrad, top 20 in Law, top 50 in Business), and has been spending and expanding vastly to build their programs, including the new teaching hospital. It seems like the school values the medical program at least somewhat on par with its other programs, and GWU Med is a favorable choice for many competitive applicants in the general pool. So, does anyone know why this medical school is totally unranked? Sometimes it's said that the school faces financial problems with the medical center, and this situation can be compared to that of Georgetown's crisis, and general losses in DC hospitals... but even Georgetown, whose financial issues put them over 330 million in debt over the last decade and forced them to sell their hospital to MedStar, is ranked, and even considering their losses, Georgetown still receives a somewhat significantly larger NIH research grant than does GWU. So I don't get it. Is there some great weakness in GW's program that the public does not know about? Is this medical school really "excellent", as it claims to be and by all accounts definitely seems to be? Do they not participate in the ranking? And now they've been placed on probation and all this... it's starting to look a little fishy. But still, when I think GWU, I think "great school", great location, and tons of stuff to get into, especially for those who like activism. But clearly some people (not the students) don't share that view.

I've been wondering the same thing. My only idea is that the rankings are based so heavily on research, and GW doesn't give a hoot about research, really. But then I wonder why they are unranked in the primary care rankings.
 
Do they not participate in the ranking?

Exactly. Not sure why, as other GW programs (like the law school) do, but the med school doesn't. I don't know if they ever used to, but they haven't for quite some time.
 
I've been wondering the same thing. My only idea is that the rankings are based so heavily on research, and GW doesn't give a hoot about research, really. But then I wonder why they are unranked in the primary care rankings.

georgetown impressed me much more. gwu felt too corporate and money focused (the students raved on more than one ocassion about the starbucks in the hospital). the students at the lunch were nice--but i got the impression that gwu was the biggest "name" they could get into and they'd rather go there than somewhere in iowa (one student said he didn't get into california schools and gwu was his safe bet). of course, if i had the opportunity to go to gwu to get a mpp or mph in health policy i would never turn it down...

in the long run...medical school is medical school. unless you're going for a professorship or md/phd program, pick whichever med school feels right after your interview.
 
Did anyone get the accept packet in the mail yet?? Its been a while and it makes me nervous because the 'rents are watching for my mail.

I received mine yesterday, the letter was dated October 17th.
 
I received mine yesterday, the letter was dated October 17th.

For those of you already accepted, did you receive the CBC email the day you heard back from GW? I'm getting anxious to hear back from them so I want to know what to be expecting in my inbox... I interviewed the last week of September so hopefully I hear back soon!
 
For those of you already accepted, did you receive the CBC email the day you heard back from GW? I'm getting anxious to hear back from them so I want to know what to be expecting in my inbox... I interviewed the last week of September so hopefully I hear back soon!

I'm pretty sure they don't participate in the CBC.. I may be wrong though.
 
So, does anyone know why this medical school is totally unranked?

GW isn't ranked because they refuse to cooperate with US News. If you look at their entry in the US News med school rankings, all the entries are N/A, indicating that the school would not provide information to US News. There are a few other schools that do this, such as SUNY Downstate.

I don't know why GW won't participate--maybe they're afraid they'd get a low ranking. But you'd have to ask them if you really want to know.
 
hey everyone

What was all this talk about getting our Secondary App Fee back? Can we really do this if we withdraw?

I am just wondering anyway... I am not planning to withdraw from GW... but perhaps some other schools

Actually, GW is one of my top choices thus far. Location is great. Opportunities out of class are great. globally focused... and strong emphasis on early clinical education!!!

I am going to interview on the 20th of November and am really EXCITED about this school. anyone else have nov. 20th as an interview date?
 
It looks like GW did an email blast with acceptances on 10/17. Does anyone know when the next one will be?
 
Anyone know how much emphasis GWU places on research?
 
so im a little behind due to an august mcat...

i submitted my GW secondary a few weeks ago and got a confirmation email about 8 days ago saying that they received it.... my status doesnt say under review yet....

but a friend of mine mailed hers just last week... she couldnt log into her status page so she called -- and they told her she was approved for an interview but hadn't been sent the email yet..

i dont get it. how long does it take? should i call? 😕
 
So everyone who was accepted already got an email? My status just changed to your decision has been sent by snail mail today......so I guess I should assume I didn't get in? I interviewed 9/30
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top