I really hate seeing people say things like this that are self-defeating and out of perspective. You guys need to remember that SDN is far from being representative of the average pre-med. In the real world, most MATRICULATING med students don't come in with stats like that. If you look at the
AAMC data (bottom chart), the averages for allo med school matriculants have only increased slightly over the past decade, from 3.56 to 3.66 GPA and from 30 to 31 MCAT. That's hardly an exponential increase! So, paki20, a 3.6/30 would still be considered competitive, while a 3.8/35 would be extremely competitive.
As for schools that people come from, it shouldn't discourage you, SN2ed. Instead of looking at it like, OMG, these people are such insane candidates, look at it this way: they may have attended Harvard and Stanford and wherever else, but guess what, you got just as far as they did (i.e., to this interview). That's not to make light of their achievements, because obviously they are strong candidates to have so many interviews. But, don't sell yourself short either. You wouldn't have gotten that interview if the UP adcomm didn't think you were a competitive candidate. They don't give away interviews for no good reason. Think for a minute about how much time and effort goes into making an interview day happen: coordinating volunteers (interviewers, tour guides, student panels, etc.), reserving interview rooms, ordering the catered meals, etc. Now multiply that by three times a week and multiply it again by six months, rinse and repeat it all again next year. The point is that it's a HUGE undertaking requiring tons of human, financial, and other resources for the med school to interview you guys. For those of you who interview at both programs, the med school will do all of this for you not once, but twice. Believe me, the Case admissions offices aren't going to so much trouble for the sheer fun of it!
What it comes down to is that both Case programs care about fit. The adcomms recognize that it takes more than just straight As from a brand-name school and a 40+ MCAT to make the kind of physician that Case wants to turn out. Have some confidence in yourselves and some faith in the process, because as imperfect as it is, it works fairly well much of the time in weeding out the wrong candidates and choosing the right ones. There are already a few people posting on this thread who didn't get in anywhere last year but already have acceptances this year. They're not inherently any smarter or better than you are. They just figured out what they needed to do to make it happen, and they did it. You can, too.