How big of a deal are the scholarly concentrations? I am just trying to see if they are a significant part of the Brown curriculum? Do residencies think highly of them?
The scholarly concentrations are a significant part of the school culture in that a third of students are directly involved in it but it is by no means required and a number of the resources it provides are available to students regardless as to whether they enroll. I am in an SC (health policy) and personally enjoy it quite a bit but if you don't want to make the time commitment, it's completely understandable. The SC is there for some formal structure and support if you want it.
Being a second year, I can't tell you much about how residencies view them aside from what I've heard from 4th years and faculty, which is that anything that enriches your educational experiences, without causing detriment to you clinical grades or board scores, is generally going to be viewed positively but at the end of the day, you are going to be evaluated on your technical capacity, bedside manner, and analytical abilities foremost. It certainly doesn't hurt though to have a few high impact publications, the development of an EM residency curriculum abroad, or the creation of a free urgent care clinic under your belt (projects I've seen classmates complete both within and without the SC program).
Just in case there are more questions regarding the SC's, I've pasted below a response I posted last year with regards to the program. I just quickly read through it and unless I missed something, it all holds true still.
For those of you in the northeast, hope you are all well, have power, and are not snowed in (and most importantly, that you get a chance to sled/ski/snowboard and commit snowy hijinks).
Question: Can any current students talk about the Scholarly Concentrations Program? I was browsing the website and some concentrations have limits on the number of students accepted. How competitive is it and is it easy to find a mentor? About what percentage of the class participates? Is it a significant amount of extra work?
Answer: All most excellent questions. Each SC generally has two leaders who are selected from the faculty. As you might imagine, they typically have a major interest and a good amount of experience in their respective concentration's topic field. While you can most certainly seek these leaders out as mentors, the only requirement is that your mentor is a member of Brown faculty (of course they can be med school faculty but you're more than welcome to select faculty from other departments, grad or undergrad). Generally you find a mentor on your own but if you want the process to be facilitated for you, there's plenty of options, and there's an SC fair towards the end of first semester where you will meet the concentration leaders and they can help you contact faculty who have projects in line with your interests or who can help you with projects you're developing from scratch. As long as you give yourself time, I'd say it's pretty easy to find a mentor, especially given the diversity of faculty interests.
The competitiveness varies of course by concentration. From what I've seen, a well thought out project will get accepted regardless of where you apply and chances are good that a project could fit well within several SC focuses. I have the feeling that global health in past years has may have been a tad more selective than the other concentrations simply because of the popularity of traveling abroad (for the global health nuts out there, yes, I know that domestic issues are a part of it!). They also are the only concentration that requires that you receive a recommendation not only from your mentor but also with someone at the community site you will be working at if you are traveling abroad (sound reasoning). In past years we were told at least a third of the class participates in the SC program. I've asked around and been told that the workload you are committing to is pretty variable. For the most part, people get the vast majority of their research or project done over the course of the summer when free time is of course easier to come by and then tend to take things easy during the academic year, writing up their conclusions and presenting at conferences when appropriate. I've been doing work related to my SC throughout the year but that is by no means expected or asked for (it's nice though if you're like me and need side projects to keep yourself content). In addition, each SC focus has additional components independent of your project. Most have some form of a monthly meeting/lecture/discussion on a topic of interest. Some have a short writing component. Education (speaking without biased since it is not my SC) is particularly interesting since the emphasis is on hands on curriculum reform and teaching within the medical school.
As you likely discovered, you can receive summer funding for your SC project but you can apply for summer funding separately if you so wish. The trade off of course is that you have less support and fewer people with whom to regularly discuss your project but you also have fewer requirements to comply with (which vary significantly between SC topic areas). The summer funding application is included in the SC app though again, you can apply for summer funding without applying to an SC and vice versa. You are also accepted into both separately as well, so admission into an SC does not guarantee summer funding. Generally, everyone who puts together a well thought out proposal (they give you plenty of opportunities to submit drafts so you can edit before the final deadline) obtains funding which comes out to $3,500 (students doing basic and translational research can apply for a larger stipend of $4,370). The review committee members takes their jobs seriously and your proposal decision comes with a full critique (mine was helpful and more than fair). By accepting funding you commit 8-10 weeks of your summer to your project but by no means are you restricted to your project alone (some of us are teaching this summer and engaging in other pursuits).
Hope this was at least moderately helpful! If there's anything you'd like me to hash out further, just say the word!