2013-2014 The Commonwealth Medical College

This forum made possible through the generous support of SDN members, donors, and sponsors. Thank you.
Sorry, Bombay2pac, but I am confused by your response. Have you received any notifications after your first deferral?
Sorry for not clarifying, I really want to know the answer to that question you asked. I have been deferred once with no notification since Dec 6. I am guessing its just going to be silent from there on out until we have a final decision. But clarification would help from someone who has gone through the system..
 
When I interviewed in October they said if you're deferred, you won't hear back again until a final decision has been made.
 
When I interviewed in October they said if you're deferred, you won't hear back again until a final decision has been made.
Looking back through the thread from last year, those who were deferred more than once did receive a notification of deferral each time. So, the one time deferral notification may be new.
 
Looks impressive!
 
I think that advice is definitely directed at more traditional med schools. We are smaller, but growing so we may not have individual departments outside of the core 6 specialities (the LIC specialities). As far as charter class and what those who matched competitively did - many have stated that because Scranton has never had med students before, the local specialists rally around our students and help them in whatever manner possible to get them interviews, research, etc. For example - one of the 4th years who matched into ENT said the local ENTs really took him under their wing and made sure he was up to par with all of the requirements for such a competitive specialty. Currently, for derm - the President of the American Academy for Dermatology is the father of a current 4th year (and also a local physician) and has been invaluable to other TCMC students pursuing derm. Similarly - there are many extremely accomplished physicians in the area helping out with other specialties. Dr. Dudrick , the father of TPN (total parenteral nutrition), is part-time faculty here and extremely respected. He was full-time faculty at UPenn for many years and has been helping students who are interested in surgical specialties. I could go on and on. For whatever reason, NEPA seems to have an abundance of extremely accomplished physicians. Part of the problem is that they are aging and towards the end of their careers (hence TCMC's mission). Hope that helps.
Wow I didn't know all that. Thank you!
 
Rejection letter via snail mail received Sat. Interviewed Feb. 7th.
 
Rejection letter via snail mail received Sat. Interviewed Feb. 7th.
I'm so sorry to hear that. I am sure you will get in somewhere. Quick question, on your TCMC portal does it reflect that status as well?
 
I'm so sorry to hear that. I am sure you will get in somewhere. Quick question, on your TCMC portal does it reflect that status as well?

There is nothing on the portal indicating that there was a rejection. There is only a note posted after interviewing that says "It was a pleasure meeting you......" when you click on the interview tab.
 
There is nothing on the portal indicating that there was a rejection. There is only a note posted after interviewing that says "It was a pleasure meeting you......" when you click on the interview tab.
That sucks! ..... So is rejection = letter only with no portal status change and acceptance = email and portal status change
 
Have they sent out acceptances from this past committee meeting yet? Interviewed in January and deferred last month. This wait is killing me lol
 
I see that they sent the notification for those who were deferred this past Wednesday, but I haven't seen any acceptance post yet. If anyone can shed some light on this, it would be much appreciated. Fingers crossed. Good luck to you as well @bombay2pac
 
Have they sent out acceptances from this past committee meeting yet? Interviewed in January and deferred last month. This wait is killing me lol
I am in the same exact boat and really hoping for some good news this time around! I haven't heard of any acceptances from this committee meeting but fingers crossed! This wait is also killing me!
 
D0es anyone know if TCMC is on rolling or non rolling admissions. I interviewed back in late Oct, Deferred in Dec and still no word yet. Is this necessarily worrisome since I was deferred a few months back versus someone who was deferred last month?
 
D0es anyone know if TCMC is on rolling or non rolling admissions. I interviewed back in late Oct, Deferred in Dec and still no word yet. Is this necessarily worrisome since I was deferred a few months back versus someone who was deferred last month?

From this thread, it doesn't look like they look at the applications in order. You might have gotten deferred a second time, or they haven't reviewed your application again. At this point, it may be appropriate to call and check. Or, send them an update letter if you have anything to update them on.
 
From this thread, it doesn't look like they look at the applications in order. You might have gotten deferred a second time, or they haven't reviewed your application again. At this point, it may be appropriate to call and check. Or, send them an update letter if you have anything to update them on.
Just called and was told to hold off on any update letters until we are waitlisted 🙁
 
Just called and was told to hold off on any update letters until we are waitlisted 🙁
Really? That's weird because I definitely called after I was deferred, and they told me it was ok to send an update. I updated them on my final grades, and I received an e-mail saying my file was updated.
 
I am guess they only accept update in grades. I was going to send an update with a new publication and volunteer job I received. Oh well. Fingers crossed!
 
I am guess they only accept update in grades. I was going to send an update with a new publication and volunteer job I received. Oh well. Fingers crossed!
Hmmm, weird...I included other updates along with the grades. It's so strange that I still have no seen anyone post about acceptances since this recent committee meeting. Stay optimistic, I'm sure things will work out 🙂
 
Hey guys let me update you about the MBS acceptances during this committee meeting. Atleast 4 members of my class got in possessing the following characteristics : 1 re re applicant, 1 local who knew people around and has strong political ties ( i swear this is true) , 1 applicant who sucked up to the committee ( also very true- the post in 2012-2013 tcmc thread is on point about suck ups), 1 underrepresented minority( he had undergrad gpa of 3.0 and mbs gpa deff not over 3.4) . Some of the smartest applicants of our class with good stats have been differed , especially Asians and Indians . I Feel bad for them but they chose the wrong program I guess. I was accepted way back in jan so dont care to tell the truth
 
Last edited:
Hey guys let me update you about the MBS acceptances during this committee meeting. Atleast 4 members of my class got in possessing the following characteristics : 1 re re applicant, 1 local who knew people around and has strong political ties ( i swear this is true) , 1 applicant who sucked up to the committee ( also very true- the post in 2012-2013 tcmc thread is on point about suck ups), 1 underrepresented minority( he had undergrad gpa of 3.0 and mbs gpa deff not over 3.4) . Some of the smartest applicants of our class with good stats have been differed , especially Asians and Indians . I Feel bad for them but they chose the wrong program I guess. I was accepted way back in jan so dont care to tell the truth

Do you happen to know what day they found out? It's not really important, I'm just curious. And being from the area, I can see the political aspect. Still, you probably shouldn't put your classmates down on a public forum, it's bad form. Thanks for the update on their acceptances though.
 
Do any of you who were accepted see the "health services" tab on the portal? I see the "pre-matriculation" tab but not the "health services" tab.
 
Do any of you who were accepted see the "health services" tab on the portal? I see the "pre-matriculation" tab but not the "health services" tab.

I see the Health Services tab toward the bottom of the list of links on the Pre-Matriculation tab, but nothing pops up when I click it. Hmm
 
I see the Health Services tab toward the bottom of the list of links on the Pre-Matriculation tab, but nothing pops up when I click it. Hmm


Yup nothing, but under "registrar" there are some docs to get started on
 
Nothing here, either. Just a blank page.

interesting. what browser are you using? just checked again this morning and nothing is under health svcs but the registrar tab still works along with its hyperlinks and pdfs
 
interesting. what browser are you using? just checked again this morning and nothing is under health svcs but the registrar tab still works along with its hyperlinks and pdfs


Sorry, I meant "nothing on my end" in reference to the student health tab, not "nothing here" under the registrar tab! I don't see anything on the student health tab, but all of the other ones seem fine.
 
Are they done with acceptances for this upcoming MD class?
 
Are they done with acceptances for this upcoming MD class?
Not technically. I believe it depends on how many decline offers before the next meeting in late April. Hopefully there will be a lot of positive news soon. Good luck to all still waiting!
 
Not technically. me beleive it depends on how many decline offers before the next meeting in late April. Hopefully there will be a lot of positive news soon. Good luck to all still waiting!
Thank you! My fingers are still crossed!!
 
Hey guys let me update you about the MBS acceptances during this committee meeting. Atleast 4 members of my class got in possessing the following characteristics : 1 re re applicant, 1 local who knew people around and has strong political ties ( i swear this is true) , 1 applicant who sucked up to the committee ( also very true- the post in 2012-2013 tcmc thread is on point about suck ups), 1 underrepresented minority( he had undergrad gpa of 3.0 and mbs gpa deff not over 3.4) . Some of the smartest applicants of our class with good stats have been differed , especially Asians and Indians . I Feel bad for them but they chose the wrong program I guess. I was accepted way back in jan so dont care to tell the truth

SPOT ON about the sucking up. If you talk to the administration, they will tell you that it's only a few members on the admissions committee. However, if you keep bothering them about how good you are (even if you're not that great), you will have a much better chance to get in. My advice for any MBS: get involved in leadership positions of clubs, volunteer your ass off, talk & be sweet to julia, gloria, professors, etc...

Also SPOT ON about the 3.7+ asians/indians which I find very odd.

I believe that the TCMC school has a quota on how many MBS people they accept each year. For example, many students in my current class were in the MBS class 2 years ago, and honestly, based on their records/ECs/personality, they should have got in last year.
 
Ok so, there have been no acceptances or rejections after the March meeting? Does anybody know?
I was deferred last month and I want to have an idea...
 
Ok so, there have been no acceptances or rejections after the March meeting? Does anybody know?
I was deferred last month and I want to have an idea...
Seriously! Interviewed in late October, Deferred in Dec! I am so anxious!
 
I haven't heard of March acceptances, but there were probably a few? Are those currently deferred IS or OOS? I get the feeling they're keeping most PA residents on reserve in case too few residents accept.
 
I haven't heard of March acceptances, but there were probably a few? Are those currently deferred IS or OOS? I get the feeling they're keeping most PA residents on reserve in case too few residents accept.
I am OOS, however made it very clear in my interview and secondary that I have family in Scranton and visit it frequently..
 
I haven't heard of March acceptances, but there were probably a few? Are those currently deferred IS or OOS? I get the feeling they're keeping most PA residents on reserve in case too few residents accept.

I am OOS and have no ties to PA 🙁 but I loved the school and the people.
 
I am OOS and have no ties to PA 🙁 but I loved the school and the people.
That doesn't necessarily mean you're done for, it was just a theory I had, which now seems incorrect judging by your posts. Thanks for the replies, and stay positive!
 
Has anyone inquired to admin about the student health tab not working? Just dont want to bombard them with emails if they are working on it. Thanks!
 
Just a heads up, I will be withdrawing my acceptance to TCMC. I'm going to stay out here in the desert. I hope my seat goes to one of you guys! TCMC is a great school and it was not an easy decision to make by a long shot.
 
Just a heads up, I will be withdrawing my acceptance to TCMC. I'm going to stay out here in the desert. I hope my seat goes to one of you guys! TCMC is a great school and it was not an easy decision to make by a long shot.
Thank you so much for letting us know. Good luck and congrats on all your future endeavors!
 
Has anyone inquired to admin about the student health tab not working? Just dont want to bombard them with emails if they are working on it. Thanks!

Yeah, I called yesterday...they said they're in the process of updating the student health tab, so it should be up within a few days. 👍
 
Did anyone else receive the email this morning about the timeline?
 
Yes I did... I hope they still have some acceptances to give out.
 
I didn't receive the email - interviewed late February and haven't heard anything. What is the timeline?
 
Top Bottom