This thread has existential crisis (an SDN mafia game)

Started by Clem J
This forum made possible through the generous support of SDN members, donors, and sponsors. Thank you.
Get help with your application

Use all the free resources available to you from SDN: articles, guides, expert advising, forums discussions, and school research.

Advertisement - Members don't see this ad
Night 2 vote tally!!!

genny (8) - @Zenge142 , @SARdoghandler , @GoSpursGo , @Animal Midwife , @apoptosis09 , @mkg323 , @_rae_ , @Kcalb
Kcalb (1) - @genny

9/9
Missing (but apparently alive, per the start of night): @WildZoo

Night actions end at 2pm Pacific (5pm Eastern) TOMORROW 4/14 (~19.5 hours)

@Clem J @supershorty @kaydubs

ETA: start of "night" not day
Yu8Ms8c.gif

@Clem J @kaydubs @supershorty
 
I have the following roles as dead:


chic
mkg
Stagg
rae
PSV
samac
sporty
MsP
apop
Zenge
fruitsalad
Dina
Clem
stoat
kitz
AM
Barkley
shorty

I am kaydubs. There are 8 roles left. I would assume it would include:

Definitely
dubZ
Spurs
genny
SAR

Probably
beans
... maybe kcalb?

I'm missing 2
 
Advertisement - Members don't see this ad
Well, I have one now 🙂

If you don't want to RR, that's OK, but could you at least give me how you feel about AM and her concern about whoever is dubZ?
I will wait to see what she says but I think her argument will be that since whatever targeted her had a negative outcome, it must have come from a wolf. I don't know that I agree with that on principle of how actions aren't affiliation indicative
 
There is a NEW CONTEST OPEN: write your best two sentence horror to be used for the day 2 flavor. Submissions must be done publicly in thread and must tag the hosts.
A crazed diminutive dancer flings her whip wildly in a crowded room, and each time it lands her victim poofs into smoke. Finally once the room is full of smoke she reaches for an axe, and with a wild laugh she swings--finally releasing the blood she has been craving.

@Clem J @supershorty @kaydubs
 
I have to agree with SAR, it feels as if there are wincons/actions that seem to target a specific identity so I don’t think I want to reveal who I am yet, especially during a night cycle where that action could be death.
 
I have to agree with SAR, it feels as if there are wincons/actions that seem to target a specific identity so I don’t think I want to reveal who I am yet, especially during a night cycle where that action could be death.
That’s fine. If you could at least give me your thoughts on AM and her thoughts on the dubZ role, that would be appreciated 🙂
 
A crazed diminutive dancer flings her whip wildly in a crowded room, and each time it lands her victim poofs into smoke. Finally once the room is full of smoke she reaches for an axe, and with a wild laugh she swings--finally releasing the blood she has been craving.

@Clem J @supershorty @kaydubs
Why do I feel oddly called out by this paragraph :thinkies:
 
Advertisement - Members don't see this ad
How are you sure fake dubZ is scum? And do you think real genny is scummy?
Because of this "You are Clem, noted DubZ reader. Target a player every night--if that player is dubz, you get a cop result. Otherwise nothing happens."

And before you say roles are RNG, they had to have started as (and will likely remain as) Dubz or this doesn't make any sense.

I don't have a read on genny.
 
Because of this "You are Clem, noted DubZ reader. Target a player every night--if that player is dubz, you get a cop result. Otherwise nothing happens."

And before you say roles are RNG, they had to have started as (and will likely remain as) Dubz or this doesn't make any sense.
How did real dubZ tell you their cop result?

The only players who could have been dubZ from the start are apoptosis, Kcalb, and mkg, as they are the only players who haven't died.

Why couldn't they have become dubZ after D1? Or after N1?
 
How did real dubZ tell you their cop result?
She didn't. It's the combination of Dubz knowing it's a Dubz thing without me alluding to that + it being her sole ability. Clem is known to push wolf!Dubz.
The only players who could have been dubZ from the start are apoptosis, Kcalb, and mkg, as they are the only players who haven't died.
Then it's one of them. Whoever's attacked tonight needs to submit one of these names. I know she was teasing mkg but I don't know if that means anything.
Why couldn't they have become dubZ after D1? Or after N1?
Because then Dubz's ability doesn't work. There had to be someone for her to N1. Hinging them on dying D1 is a good way to ensure it never happens.
 
She didn't. It's the combination of Dubz knowing it's a Dubz thing without me alluding to that + it being her sole ability. Clem is known to push wolf!Dubz.

Then it's one of them. Whoever's attacked tonight needs to submit one of these names. I know she was teasing mkg but I don't know if that means anything.

Because then Dubz's ability doesn't work. There had to be someone for her to N1. Hinging them on dying D1 is a good way to ensure it never happens.
@SARdoghandler (or @Zenge142 , but I feel like you're not gonna respond) do you have an opinion on whether this tracks?

I'll accept thoughts from others too.

I'm kind of inclined to believe this and see what happens, and if it backfires then we can just go after AM afterwards. But idk.
 
@SARdoghandler (or @Zenge142 , but I feel like you're not gonna respond) do you have an opinion on whether this tracks?

I'll accept thoughts from others too.

I'm kind of inclined to believe this and see what happens, and if it backfires then we can just go after AM afterwards. But idk.
What do you mean "if it backfires"?
 
Advertisement - Members don't see this ad