Wow really? I got the impression that my interviewer was seeing my file for the first time during my interview, they spent the majority of the time looking down at my application reading it and really didn't ask me many good questions that allowed me to show them who I am beyond my application. I was pretty upset about it afterwards. It worries me a lot that there can be this much discrepancy between interviewers. I don't know what to make of this....
Mine had my file open and reading it during but had annotated it and said she read through it multiple times. She definitely showed she knew a lot about me but more asked me to fill in gaps or explain things further