CHOOSE YOUR OWWN - Game Thread

[Animal Midwife]

---

Members do not see this ad.

Day 2 Lynch Tally
Sporty (1) - Suni
Wonder (1) - Coffee?

2/11
lynch close in ~10 hours

 

[deleted804295]

So I'm confused how a mafia member died last night unless we have a vig in game with night kills.


How many different factions are there? This game is so confusing!!!

 

[genny]

So I'm confused how a mafia member died last night unless we have a vig in game with night kills.


How many different factions are there? This game is so confusing!!!

Did you read what you were singing up for? Lol. There was a complete list of possible roles posted in the signups. There are likely other factions with kills, not just vigs as a possibility.

 

[genny]

lynch bc

 

[CoffeeQuestionMark]

Wonder is not mafia. They might be another faction but I investigated them and they're not mafia.

Are you only looking for mafia? I'm personally looking for wolves and mafia and any 4P

 

[CoffeeQuestionMark]

So I'm confused how a mafia member died last night unless we have a vig in game with night kills.


How many different factions are there? This game is so confusing!!!

Sunny, this is what I'm saying. If there are both wolves and mafia, they are equally as bad as they can both NK.

 

[Barkley13]

I’m still content with my vote from yesterday. Alissa was acting pretty sketchy and I see she kinda explained the cubs vote but the whole “don’t make me tunnel you” to a joke cubs made that she said was a joke but didn’t sound like one and then how she ended up voting for him was weird. Plus she had some other sketchy posts

lynch alissa

 

[Barkley13]

I also am not satisfied with the BC situation. I guess I could see "thinking sunbodi so I put sunbodi" but that also seems like an easy way out. But, I don't know if a wolf would be more likely to make that mistake than a villager in the first place.

I agree that it was weird but I’m leaning more NAI

 

[WildZoo]

lynch bc

 

[SARdoghandler]

lynch Alissa

I am ok flipping Alissa for weird tone yesterday. Wouldn't be overly opposed to BC either.

 

[WildZoo]

Kinda quiet around here. Where is everyone?

 

[WildZoo]

Cubs joked about being sacrificial lamb and then he died. Spooky.

 

[WonderingStudent]

@katashark how are you feeling about sunbodi today?

@BigCats why did you angry react alissas joke vote comment? You guys said last game that you agreed to be each others D1 joke votes. And in general you seemed a little off last night when you came back on thread.

Hi I’m here - continuing with tradition
lynch bigcats

You didn't seem to read that mods also invented a town vanilla cop role. Presumably they had to add in extra investigative roles after randomzing a second time because everyone was discarding it.

They're not following the list 100%. You're mafia and you're going to kill me anyways.

Mods are following the list of roles to my knowledge though? There is a vanilla cop on the list.

 

[WonderingStudent]

I already said that trying to figure out the numbers in this game are not going to be that easy but just in case someone who understands faction games better than myself can do anything with these numbers:

28 roles distributed

Spoiler: Number of each alignment that was discarded

Mafia: 1
Village: 9
Wolf: 2
Alien: 1
(not very helpful) Wildcard: 1

Spoiler: Adding death alignments in there

Mafia: 2
Village: 11
Wolf: 2
Alien: 1
(not very helpful) Wildcard: 1

AM said that she wanted to have a minimum of 50% villagers in the game to start (Not sure if "wants to" means that the game wouldn't have run without having this number though).

If we are going based on AM's "minimum" scenario:
We started with >=7 villagers
Now we would be at >=5 villagers.

 

[WonderingStudent]

Assuming that the two kills were from Wolves and Mafia then:

Cubs was killed by the mafia
3m was killed by the wolves (based on that 3m was a mafia goon)
That was kinda mean wolves if it was actually you guys. This was 3ms first time ever being non-village. At least let her have some time to have fun.


Of little note since after last game D1 votes especially don't mean much but 3m voted to lynch sunbodi (2 hrs and 25 mins before lynch close). If sunbodi is lying about being village it might be less likely sunbodi is mafia as well since 3m would know that sunbodi is an easy D1 lynch for players to hop onto. Or of course (if sunbodi is mafia) this vote could have been for village credit which seems less likely to me since I would assume that especially in a faction game non-villagers wouldn't want to sacrifice anyone on their team (especially when the promise of village credit seems extremely slim). In general, voting to lynch a non-villager in this game doesn't mean too too much to game solve/label people "village" at this point in the game at least.

 

[Barkley13]

Assuming that the two kills were from Wolves and Mafia then:

Cubs was killed by the mafia
3m was killed by the wolves (based on that 3m was a mafia goon)
That was kinda mean wolves if it was actually you guys. This was 3ms first time ever being non-village. At least let her have some time to have fun.


Of little note since after last game D1 votes especially don't mean much but 3m voted to lynch sunbodi (2 hrs and 25 mins before lynch close). If sunbodi is lying about being village it might be less likely sunbodi is mafia as well since 3m would know that sunbodi is an easy D1 lynch for players to hop onto. Or of course (if sunbodi is mafia) this vote could have been for village credit which seems less likely to me since I would assume that especially in a faction game non-villagers wouldn't want to sacrifice anyone on their team (especially when the promise of village credit seems extremely slim). In general, voting to lynch a non-villager in this game doesn't mean too too much to game solve/label people "village" at this point in the game at least.

Yeah I don’t really think you can read into VCA much at all really since there’s so many possibilities (like how mafia, 3p, and village would all want to lynch wolves and so on)

 

[Barkley13]

@CoffeeQuestionMark what posts of wonder’s bother you? I have her as neutral rn because her posts about numbers and info seem helpful but don’t say anything about affiliation

 

[WildZoo]

Wonder's posts today ping me more in her village range so I'm comfy with her for now

 

[alissa14]

Oh sorry I mixed up you and Alissa!!!

Thanks so much for saving me last night BC xoxoxo

Heyyy I defended you too! Popping in the back to raccoon feeding. We have two coyote pups now 😍

 

[alissa14]

lynch Alissa

I am ok flipping Alissa for weird tone yesterday. Wouldn't be overly opposed to BC either.

🙄 Okayyyy.... idk I was just chilling yesterday on thread but apparently that’s sketchy

 

[deleted804295]

Okay guys!!!!

I asked the mods in my PM how many factions and they said more than 2 but less than 8.

We are actually f**ked

 

[deleted804295]

I left for a couple of hours and now there are 9 pages

This is going to take FOREVER

 

[deleted804295]

Why are so many people voting for alissa?

 

[deleted804295]

I’m still content with my vote from yesterday. Alissa was acting pretty sketchy and I see she kinda explained the cubs vote but the whole “don’t make me tunnel you” to a joke cubs made that she said was a joke but didn’t sound like one and then how she ended up voting for him was weird. Plus she had some other sketchy posts

lynch alissa

Wouldn't a mafia want to draw less attention not more?

I'm not sure I follow the logic of going after people who have flat out said they're going to tunnel someone on thread.

 

[deleted804295]

Wait???

Why are there barely any posts from today???

 

[deleted804295]

Wonder's posts today ping me more in her village range so I'm comfy with her for now

What are your reads?

 

[CoffeeQuestionMark]

@CoffeeQuestionMark what posts of wonder’s bother you? I have her as neutral rn because her posts about numbers and info seem helpful but don’t say anything about affiliation

I quoted them I believe on the last page.

 

[CoffeeQuestionMark]

Assuming that the two kills were from Wolves and Mafia then:

Cubs was killed by the mafia
3m was killed by the wolves (based on that 3m was a mafia goon)
That was kinda mean wolves if it was actually you guys. This was 3ms first time ever being non-village. At least let her have some time to have fun.


Of little note since after last game D1 votes especially don't mean much but 3m voted to lynch sunbodi (2 hrs and 25 mins before lynch close). If sunbodi is lying about being village it might be less likely sunbodi is mafia as well since 3m would know that sunbodi is an easy D1 lynch for players to hop onto. Or of course (if sunbodi is mafia) this vote could have been for village credit which seems less likely to me since I would assume that especially in a faction game non-villagers wouldn't want to sacrifice anyone on their team (especially when the promise of village credit seems extremely slim). In general, voting to lynch a non-villager in this game doesn't mean too too much to game solve/label people "village" at this point in the game at least.

Are you suggesting the wolves knew 3M was mafia?

 

[WildZoo]

What are your reads?

What are yours?

 

[Barkley13]

Wouldn't a mafia want to draw less attention not more?

I'm not sure I follow the logic of going after people who have flat out said they're going to tunnel someone on thread.

I don’t know what you mean? It’s not like she was being loud and super out there, she was just saying things that were sketchy

 

[deleted804295]

What are yours?

Are you going to answer or deflect? 🙄

 

[genny]

Are you suggesting the wolves knew 3M was mafia?

Well, they certainly knew she wasn’t a wolf. And it would make sense to try to take out another faction that could kill them.

 

[WildZoo]

Are you going to answer or deflect? 🙄

That should be obvious I have spoken about my reads on thread, feel free to read my posts

 

[WonderingStudent]

Are you suggesting the wolves knew 3M was mafia?

Of course wolves wouldn't have known 3m was mafia. I don't know how they would have known.

But literally the first thing we talked about on this thread was that 3m was likely non-village (based on this game's increased chance that she would have the option to be non-village + her known desire to try out a non-village role). Some players even talked on thread about not wanted to lynch there so that if she was non-village, she would have some time in the role. So, even if wolves didn't know for a fact that 3m was non-village and they were actually the ones to kill her, it still was a sad move to NK her.

 

[katashark]

@katashark how are you feeling about sunbodi today?

I'm feeling better about sun today, not 100%, but better.

 

[katashark]

Why are so many people voting for alissa?

Probably because of how sketch alissa was yesterday.

 

[deleted804295]

I'm feeling better about sun today, not 100%, but better.

Where were you yesterday? Are you a noob or a veteran?

 

[WonderingStudent]

Probably because of how sketch alissa was yesterday.

Any particular posts you can point to that give you sketch vibes for alissa?

 

[katashark]

Where were you yesterday? Are you a noob or a veteran?

Not a noob, but haven't played in a while. I don't consider myself good enough to be a veteran, but I've played for several years now.

 

[Animal Midwife]

Subbing in for @BigCats is @Lawper ​

 

[cubsrule4e]

Kinda quiet around here. Where is everyone?

***************************
Dead. Go village and whatnot.
***************************

 

[WonderingStudent]

@SportPonies I see that you reacted to some posts today. Have any thoughts?

 

[WonderingStudent]

I'm feeling better about sun today, not 100%, but better.

What makes you feel better about sun? Is it based on their role claim or their posts?

 

[WildZoo]

But how am I supposed to evaluate lawp without AM here to tell me his affiliation??

 

[Lawpy]

and we're

 

[Lawpy]

*insert tally request*

 

[Lawpy]

Final Day 1 Lynch Tally
3m (1) - cubs
Stagg (4) - SAR, Wonder, Suni, BC
Sporty () -
dubz (1) - Sporty
BC (2) - dubz, genny
cubs (1) - alissa
Wonder () -
alissa (1) - Barks
Suni (3) - 3m, kata, Stagg
kata () -

13/14
Missing: Coffee?

ok

 

[Lawpy]

there was a lot of talk about alissa so the D1 tally is a bit odd

 

[katashark]

Any particular posts you can point to that give you sketch vibes for alissa?

Go ahead and lynch me guys. Ain’t gonna get you anywhere. Wish I had something useful to offer like “keep me alive because ____” But I honestly dont

The Chart was here....
tbf I guess I’ve only been lynched D1 once but I have a terrible win record sooooo....

I always think its so funny when people are like "wow Alissa seems sketchy..." when Im really trying to not be sketchy..

but thats the thing. Im not even trying one way or the other which is so weird to me that it comes off to you all as sketchy.

She panicked with 2 votes on her instead of actually defending? Just pointing out that she has been lynched D1 before (most of us have), and wants to stay because she isn't trying to be sketchy. I think everyone is trying to not be sketchy.

 

[katashark]

What makes you feel better about sun? Is it based on their role claim or their posts?

A little of both, not the role claim by itself, but also the follow-up about it today. Also posts seem better. At least not mafia most likely due to the 3m vote.