CHOOSE YOUR OWWN - Game Thread

This forum made possible through the generous support of SDN members, donors, and sponsors. Thank you.
I investigated kata last night and I got no results. I didn't know why so I looked into mafia wiki and it says this:

You are a Town Cop.

Abilities

  • During the Day, you may vote for whomever you want lynched.
  • Cop: During the Night, you may PM me the name of another player. You will receive You believe NAME to be GUILTY if that player is aligned with the Mafia. You will receive You believe NAME to be NOT GUILTY if that player is not aligned with the Mafia. You will receive No result if your investigation failed.
Possibilities based on skimming the possible roles that I think could produce no results being received:
- you were blocked (Village Roleblocker [would be strange for villager to do this though]/ Mafia Roleblocker or Town Jailkeeper)
- Town Hider
- or of course could be that you aren't the town cop

edited: only one village blocker card possible in the game so could not have been village role blocker
 
Last edited:
Possibilities based on skimming the possible roles that I think could produce no results being received:
- you were blocked (Village Roleblocker [would be strange for villager to do this though]/ Mafia Roleblocker or Town Jailkeeper)
- Town Hider
- or of course could be that you aren't the town cop
village roleblocker was discarded
 
Although... I would put SAR lower down the list but still on it because I do kinda believe that she wouldn’t want to pick a non-village role (although it’s possible those were her only options)
lol after Hannibal and Milkshakes I think that SAR would have quit this game if she got two non-village roles. That's one of the reasons I don't have her higher on my reads list.
 
Day 3 Lynch Tally
kata (1) - Suni
Wonder (1) - Coffee?
Coffee? (1) - dubz

3/9
lynch close in ~9.5 hours
 
Yes but there are two of those in the role list (I looked at it more closely after lawp flipped). There is only one town roleblocker.
so we think there was a possibility of 2 town cops (16-17), cop/lover (not what sun claimed), cop-of-all-trades (not what sun claimed), and werewolf cop. But there are 1-12 potential vanillager roles. just based on numbers, we know there aren't that many.
 
so we think there was a possibility of 2 town cops (16-17), cop/lover (not what sun claimed), cop-of-all-trades (not what sun claimed), and werewolf cop. But there are 1-12 potential vanillager roles. just based on numbers, we know there aren't that many.
It's possible, yes
 
I might be able to support this, but I still want to lynch wondering. I'm also curious about dubz/SAR.

Completely unrelated to your results, though, as unseerable doesn't appear to be one of the available roles.
I investigated wonder and they showed up as not mafia. They might be alien, werewolf or 3p as well.
 
Dubz is coming off defensive when I put a little pressure on them this morning. More on kata later

Unlynch Kata
Lynch Dubz
 
I don't see a current roster posted by the mods this morning (maybe I missed it but just in case)

Roster
1. @SARdoghandler
2. @katashark
7. @WildZoo
10. @alissa14
12. @Sunbodi
13. @Barkley13
14. @SportPonies
16. @WonderingStudent
18. @CoffeeQuestionMark

9 players alive; Maj is 5 today

I think it's useful to look at who is alive just so we don't forget about questioning anyone
I've been insisting this since yesterday. I asked @SportPonies to say more yesterday but they're still under the radar. I put pressure on kata this morning and Dubz comes out full swing.

I think this might be the most kata has spoken over the past 3 days and that's saying something.
 
My hesitation with going for either sun or Alissa today is that they chose to claim roles that only have one card remaining in the setup. So opened themselves up to the possibility of a counterclaim if they were lying.

For alissa I could believe it was a desperation move (see warriors for caiter doing something similar when a lynch looked inevitable lol). Need to look at timing of sun's claim. But neither are roles I want to mislynch so higher bar for lynching at this point.
 
My hesitation with going for either sun or Alissa today is that they chose to claim roles that only have one card remaining in the setup. So opened themselves up to the possibility of a counterclaim if they were lying.

For alissa I could believe it was a desperation move (see warriors for caiter doing something similar when a lynch looked inevitable lol). Need to look at timing of sun's claim. But neither are roles I want to mislynch so higher bar for lynching at this point.
And so far you haven't role claimed at all and are defending somebody who has made less than one page of posts. You're very suspicious Dubz.
 
so we think there was a possibility of 2 town cops (16-17), cop/lover (not what sun claimed), cop-of-all-trades (not what sun claimed), and werewolf cop. But there are 1-12 potential vanillager roles. just based on numbers, we know there aren't that many.
All I'm saying is that it is possible that sun could actually have gotten a town cop card (even if 1 town cop card was discarded). We don't know what roles are actually out there but I do think it's extremely unlikely that there would be that many vanilla cards out there or anyone who chose vanilla villager.

edited: grammar
 
Kata and Dubz trying to lynch me after I said they likely had a mafia/wolf pack.

Nothing new here +pity+ +pity+
 
And so far you haven't role claimed at all and are defending somebody who has made less than one page of posts. You're very suspicious Dubz.
I don't roleclaim unless I have to. If you want to talk about the content of kata's posts rather than numbers, I am willing to listen. Otherwise you are clinging to something that is NAI.

Your incorrect suspicion of me is noted.
 
I've been insisting this since yesterday. I asked @SportPonies to say more yesterday but they're still under the radar. I put pressure on kata this morning and Dubz comes out full swing.

I think this might be the most kata has spoken over the past 3 days and that's saying something.
well then ask players questions like reads or something if you are suspicious. In general, this game needs more questioning of everyone.
 
@alissa14 tagging you right now so that you know people are trying to lynch you
Yeah nothing new here 🙄 I honestly don’t know why I didn’t die last night... gonna catch up on thread while I’m on lunch. I have one hour if anyone has burning questions
 
@Sunbodi also I just confirmed with mods that when I protected you last night I did not block you. Someone else must’ve blocked you
 
well then ask players questions like reads or something if you are suspicious. In general, this game needs more questioning of everyone.
I did with Dubz and she just retorted back that she did post reads.

Everyone is bullying us noobs for no reason. We have to answer everyone's questions and nobody answers ours.
 
I did with Dubz and she just retorted back that she did post reads.

Everyone is bullying us noobs for no reason. We have to answer everyone's questions and nobody answers ours.
My response had nothing to do with you being a noob. It had to do with you asking me something I had already addressed on thread, which gets on my nerves. If you want me to answer questions, read my posts first. Otherwise the questions don't come across as sincere.
 
I... Don't like this. So you had no wolf reads you'd rather vote for at that time?
It was D1 I didn’t have wolf reads and I didn’t want to hop on the sunbodi/stagg wagon
Probably because of how sketch alissa was yesterday.
Again wasn’t trying to be sketchy but this is cool
She panicked with 2 votes on her instead of actually defending? Just pointing out that she has been lynched D1 before (most of us have), and wants to stay because she isn't trying to be sketchy. I think everyone is trying to not be sketchy.
I panicked because I didn’t have time to actually come up with a real defense. I came on 30 min before lynch close to find I was in the lead. I was at my internship until 10:30 last nit
Maj at 6 votes, yes?

unlynch lawp, lynch alissa
Because I felt like giving him a day to establish himself
See quoted above post. So apparently you’re okay lynching someone who made it very clear that they would be busy/gone all day and not here to defend themselves? That’s cool
I don't like that none of the people up for lynch care enough to defend themselves.
I was busy with raccoons, opossums, a freakin’ goose.... it was super sad. One of the baby raccoons died last night while I was there. I was very sad about this because I have no idea if I had anything to do with it’s death. It’s very possible because I’m new at this and have definitely aspirated babies while feeding but I’ve always been quick to react and let them know when it happens. Anyways, it was sad because it was one of the littler ones...
Is it a Canada goose? Because if so, it was nice knowing you.
Yes it was a Canada goose. Got hit by a car and came in with a neck laceration (this was last week and it’s mostly healed now) and some injuries to its back end. We had to tube feed him because he’s noeating on his own
Just gotta grab the neck and not let go
thankfully the girl that’s training me caught the goose and handed him to me since I've never caught/handled a goose before. She’s the reason im alive today because that was an angry goose
I wrestled a trumpeter swan with bumble foot once. It was fun and terrifying at the same time.
That sounds terrifying
Agree. RIP you fighting a cobra chicken, Alissa
100% accurate description
Probably not. I didn’t get a notification if I was successful or not
I didn’t get a notification N1 but I got a notification N2 that I was successful at protecting sunbodi last night
I mean that with multiple doctors dead and a claimed nurse still alive, I would have expected alissa to be targeted.

But good on you for defending your kill choice 😉
Well I’m guessing wolves wanted to keep me alive (really rude to play with your food btw) because they’re assuming they can push my lynch for being “sketchy”
Also of note is that there was only one death last night.

Possibilities I can think of:
- Alissas protection was successful (@alissa14 did you target sunbodi or someone else last night?)
- somehow one of the factions all died (seems EXTREMELY unlikely for 3m to be the only one in the mafia so this possibility does not seem right)
- there’s a blocker/jailer or some other role that was successful
- one faction submitted a no kill action/forgot to submit
- factions targeted the same player last night
I was successful last night at protecting sunbodi
My hesitation with going for either sun or Alissa today is that they chose to claim roles that only have one card remaining in the setup. So opened themselves up to the possibility of a counterclaim if they were lying.

For alissa I could believe it was a desperation move (see warriors for caiter doing something similar when a lynch looked inevitable lol). Need to look at timing of sun's claim. But neither are roles I want to mislynch so higher bar for lynching at this point.
Ok... that’s cool good luck with that..

@Sunbodi why didn’t you investigate dubz? Can you investigate me or dubz tonight?
 
I think I’m gonna lynch SAR because I wanna see how SAR flips and it would help my read on dubz. Back to work (apparently I only get half an hour). Zoom party tonight after lynch close. I’ll send the link out later!!
 
@Sunbodi why didn’t you investigate dubz? Can you investigate me or dubz tonight?
Why yourself? Even getting cleared as non mafia doesn’t mean you are not something else.
@Sunbodi you decide who you want to investigate and please don’t say it on thread as I talked about yesterday. Better to be unpredictable where you are going to go with your action so non villagers can’t anticipate it. You can of course check WZ; it’s up to you. Just my advice is not to say.
 
Why yourself? Even getting cleared as non mafia doesn’t mean you are not something else.
@Sunbodi you decide who you want to investigate and please don’t say it on thread as I talked about yesterday. Better to be unpredictable where you are going to go with your action so non villagers can’t anticipate it. You can of course check WZ; it’s up to you. Just my advice is not to say.
This is fair. I’m just frustrated because everyone is getting “sketch feels” from me. Sunbodi, investigate whoever you want but don’t do me okay? Don’t waste your time.
 
I’m gonna go try taking a nap now since I’ve got work in a few hour and didn’t get enough sleep last night to be up until 8 am tomorrow for my shift but currently @CoffeeQuestionMark and @SportPonies are at the bottom of my list due to having the least amount of village points compared to others. At this moment I could go for lynching either one. So I hope to see more posts and reads when I wake up 😛

This thread better not be completely dead when I get back. 😡
 
Why yourself? Even getting cleared as non mafia doesn’t mean you are not something else.
@Sunbodi you decide who you want to investigate and please don’t say it on thread as I talked about yesterday. Better to be unpredictable where you are going to go with your action so non villagers can’t anticipate it. You can of course check WZ; it’s up to you. Just my advice is not to say.
This is why I investigated kata because there was nobody paying attention to kata.


And I got no results!!!
 
I think either I or Alissa will die tonight because I exposed kata and Dubz
 
See quoted above post. So apparently you’re okay lynching someone who made it very clear that they would be busy/gone all day and not here to defend themselves? That’s cool
Whatever post it was that you established that, I did not remember it at the time of my vote
 
Guys let's lynch Dubz. This much push back in the early morning signals wolf.

Dubz is acting like she has 5 votes on her but only 1 and this hostile!!!
 
I panicked because I didn’t have time to actually come up with a real defense. I came on 30 min before lynch close to find I was in the lead. I was at my internship until 10:30 last nit
She was talking about d1
 
I'm going to come back and we better have votes on DUBZ
Screenshot_20200522-123446_Clock.jpg
 
Guys do I get some kind of reward if I pull off a second soccer game?

Let's lynch all the mafia back to back. No room for loss!!! We will get DUBZ.

Dubz TRYING TO KILL OFF ALL OUR PRs
 
Dubz went silent. Wolf chat probably told her to stop targeting two outted PRs
 
Top