What I've said about BU are pretty much known facts, meaning you can quantitate usmle scores, and the general reputation of BU grads is known to be about average among residency program directors. Not to say that average is really bad, but I just think it is ridiculous that BU really pumps a reputation for being "hardcore" in terms of what students experience, when the clinical experience and training isn't as good as is advertised.
I think that there is a certain malignancy associated with attendings in surgery, and in other clerkships, which makes a dramatically subpar educational experience for some. I wouldn't want to say who I know, but I've known some BU students who got slammed in their dean's letter regardless of the "formative comments" section, and it hurt them in the match. While it may not be an outright "you stink" type of comments filled under (tongue in check) constructive criticism, there are ways to imply things and produce a dean's letter which on the surface looks good but hurts students when they apply for the match. You need superlatives like "really shines" and "outstanding clinical skills" not just "satisfactory" and "good", or "not motivated for specialty x" when you are in fact applying for specialty x.
Ouch.
Tell me this, why is it that BU is about average on Step 2, yet they believe that their clinical experience is better than Harvard? This has to be some sort of hoax, or overly aggressively advertising campaign on BU's part.
You've said that BU has the busiest surgery department in the new england area. How many ORs exactly can you be in? If the attendings don't teach, come down "hard" on the students and residents, then what sort of experience is this? You can go do a surgery clerkship at a program which has a fair number of patients, and if you are aggressive and in the OR alot, then you will see a lot.
I saw a ton of surgery patients, OR cases, surgery clinic, everything, on my surgery clerkship, and it wasn't because it was the busiest trauma center in new england.
I don't know why, but some BU students have misrepresented their school on this forum in the past, saying that the school provides an education where you can get stellar step scores and such, and then later on we hear that the first and second year are the same everywhere.
I think most people would take Harvard over BU anyday, especially considering how draconian BU is with their students.
are you a current student at BU? i think i've heard elsewhere about how BU has notoriously mean attendings who do not care for medical students and their futures. i'm not sure if this is true though.