StardeWW Valley - GAME THREAD

[Truenamer]

---

Members do not see this ad.

New WW goals

Just be sketchy all the time and you never get converted. Misyeet rate is higher, but no bussing!

Seriously though, I feel like part of the reason I've been dodging the axe this game is because I've managed to be moderately sketchy and on people's POE's.

Last game I was cherubic Village!True and was immediately eaten for it 😂

 

[WildZoo]

New WW goals

Just be sketchy all the time and you never get converted. Misyeet rate is higher, but no bussing!

Oof.
Now I have to contemplate which is worse. Being misyoten, or post-conversion bussing.

 

[bluestoat]

Oof.
Now I have to contemplate which is worse. Being misyoten, or post-conversion bussing.

If I were converted I'd probably be pretty pissed and have a hard time not softing that I need to be put out of my misery

I think it's because I can see the morality of a wolf as what it is, and the morality of a villager as what it is, but being a double-agent or a turncoat-- that's a big no thanks lol. You'd have to sell out the members of your new pack that you were after in village, and you'd have to start picking out the villagers who put an honest villager in their bloc. No conversion please and thanks.

 

[supershorty]

New WW goals

Just be sketchy all the time and you never get converted. Misyeet rate is higher, but no bussing!

genny pls how am I gonna win most commonly village read if I’m sketchy 🥺

 

[Dinashadow]

NIGHT CLOSED; WRITE-UP & RESULTS PENDING

 

[supershorty]

Night 3




"Animals are very sensitive. They like to be pet every day, and prefer to eat grass outdoors than dry hay. They don't like being outside in the rain, though. happy animals produce higher quality products!"

Boy, was it a busy night at Pierre's general store. The orders were flying in - seeds! Items! Amazing how people will crawl out of the woodwork for a good sale.

She knew all about good sales. She was a sucker for them, and when the opportunity to capitalize on them came up, she couldn't resist. She wasn't the only one. Life didn't seem that different now, other than she walked across the bridge each day to work. It seemed fine to her. Sure, she wasn't supporting the local economy as much as she used to, but that wasn't really a concern that most cows had to begin with.

She was quietly doing her job and minding her own business, when a glimmer of light caught her eye. She cocked her head, watching it, but it didn't appear again, so she shrugged it off and resumed what she was doing - stocking the shelves with only the best vanilla extract.

She snorted a little of it, for quality testing, she claimed. We won't tell if you don't.

Suddenly, the light was back. She looked into it and saw endless fields of vanilla beans and white cheddar Cheetos. They say you'll know paradise when you see it, and she knew she had to go into the light. Nirvana awaited.

Spoiler: Dead is...

@Animal Midwife, White Cow turned Corporate Convert Cow, a vanillager turned cultist.

-->

"I think I'm still a cow. I just produce vanilla milk to be stored within a coconut instead of a carton now."

7 players remain.

1. @potentialsheltervet
6. @genny
7. @WildZoo
11. @Truenamer
13. @Barkley13
14. @SportPonies
16. @bluestoat

Sent for a train ride out of town:
3. @Dana_May_B, Harvey, village jailer
8. @samac, Wizard, village conversion protector
4. @kdswg, Leah, WOLF forager
5. @Zenge142, Strawberry, vanillager
15. @cubsrule4e, Junimo, village universal backup --> village jailer
18. @BobLoblaw78, Blue Chicken, vanillager
2. @Animal Midwife, White Cow, vanillager --> cultist

It is now Day 4. Vote closes at 9pm EST (8pm CST/6pm fantasyland) on Wednesday, 2/9/2022.

There is 1 more day of Summer after today.​

 

[WildZoo]

WHAT

 

[WildZoo]

THERE'S A CULT

 

[bluestoat]

😭😭😭

It was surprising that she wasn't dead yet. She was forming the village core yesterday, too.

But 😭😭😭

 

[WildZoo]

Omg. Omg that must be what samac's role was for.

 

[bluestoat]

THERE'S A CULT

What dis mean

 

[WildZoo]

😭😭😭

It was surprising that she wasn't dead yet. She was forming the village core yesterday, too.

But 😭😭😭

But she wasn't village anymore

 

[WildZoo]

She snorted a little of it, for quality testing, she claimed. We won't tell if you don't.

 

[bluestoat]

But she wasn't village anymore

Ooooooh

We have a 3P converter in play?

 

[WildZoo]

What dis mean

Cult

wiki.mafiascum.net

 

[supershorty]

I giggled a fair amount doing this write up.

 

[bluestoat]

Dubz I'm sorry but your very nature says that you'd love being a cult leader

 

[bluestoat]

Not saying you are one yet, i need to rush out the door, I'm just saying that it seems like a role you'd have a lot of fun with

 

[WildZoo]

Oof if they can recruit nightly that means there's already 3 so they've almost won

 

[WildZoo]

Jeez they would have won today if AM hadn't died

Maybe they can't recruit nightly though

 

[bluestoat]

Jeez they would have won today if AM hadn't died

Maybe they can't recruit nightly though

So... So good guy wolves??

 

[WildZoo]

Dubz I'm sorry but your very nature says that you'd love being a cult leader

Not saying you are one yet, i need to rush out the door, I'm just saying that it seems like a role you'd have a lot of fun with

Oh of course I would, I love being 3p. I'm actually a little sad I'm still village lol

 

[WildZoo]

So... So good guy wolves??

This happened in shorty's noob game too, except wolves killed the cult leader iirc

 

[bluestoat]

Unyeet Barkley

I need to think

 

[supershorty]

This happened in shorty's noob game too, except wolves killed the cult leader iirc

We did, and the village mayor was quite pleased about it.

WOLVES YA DAMN CHAMPS I COULD KISS YA

 

[bluestoat]

Yeet Truenamer

He got that big cult energy

Not committed to this vote

 

[samac]

We did, and the village mayor was quite pleased about it.

******
Stand by the statement.
******

 

[WildZoo]

Yeet Truenamer

He got that big cult energy

Not committed to this vote

You don't think he would have recruited you?

 

[SportPonies]

Yeet Truenamer

He got that big cult energy

Not committed to this vote

is this…. Not a rojo?

 

[bluestoat]

You don't think he would have recruited you?

I wouldn't be surprised if he's a cultist. He can defend himself later (after work)

 

[bluestoat]

is this…. Not a rojo?

...no?

 

[SportPonies]

Jk write ups are important. For some reason I keep not getting notified that they’re posted.

 

[bluestoat]

@SportPonies You are tunneling so hard I'm not sure how to affiliate you anymore

 

[bluestoat]

Jk write ups are important. For some reason I keep not getting notified that they’re posted.

Okay that makes more sense lol nvm

 

[WildZoo]

is this…. Not a rojo?

Sporty pls

I wouldn't be surprised if he's a cultist. He can defend himself later (after work)

Well I was asking you that question

 

[bluestoat]

Sporty pls

Well I was asking you that question

If he were a cult leader I bet he'd convert me, so I don't think he's the leader.

Only argument I could see against him being in a cult (right now) would be if the cultists felt that I would pick up on it. Which is kind of a weak reason to not be suspicious.

 

[Truenamer]

THERE'S A CULT AND AM WAS IN THE CULT BUT SHE WASN'T THE CULT LEADER LKAJD;LFAJDLKF

Okay, mostly I'm just annoyed because I had pulled quotes and written stuff and now it's all pointless garbage. ANYWAY,

If he were a cult leader I bet he'd convert me, so I don't think he's the leader.

Only argument I could see against him being in a cult (right now) would be if the cultists felt that I would pick up on it. Which is kind of a weak reason to not be suspicious.

If I was in the cult or the leader I would have converted you as quickly as possible, because you have a +5 Hat of Knowing How True Thinks. I'm not in the cult. If anything, I'm annoyed at the cult. I would make a great cultist, am I not cool enough for your cult?

Christ, THIS is why AM sounded odd yesterday! I couldn't understand why she wasn't pressing my case harder; it's because she wasn't a villager anymore.

She may have even suspected that Bob was a villager, and not cared, because yeeting him got them one step closer to winning.

 

[Truenamer]

Okay but for the record I'm holding onto my AM reading card because she was a villager... to begin with

 

[bluestoat]

Okay but for the record I'm holding onto my AM reading card because she was a villager... to begin with

Honestly... This might be part of why this whole game feels so "villagey"

You, Genny, and Sporty are my top convert concerns

 

[supershorty]

lol settle down, nooblet, you don't get to claim a reading card until you correctly identify someone as more affiliations than just village.

 

[bluestoat]

Unyeet True Yeet Barkley

I should stay on wolf hunting until I can get home and figure out whether cult or pack is biggest threat, but I think the cult would be bigger now.

 

[supershorty]

lol settle down, nooblet, you don't get to claim a reading card until you correctly identify someone as more affiliations than just village.

That's like Zenge trying to claim he has a 100% read rate on Lawpy when the majority of the times that they played together, Zenge was a wolf and therefore knew Lawpy wasn't. It doesn't count.

 

[bluestoat]

That's like Zenge trying to claim he has a 100% read rate on Lawpy when the majority of the times that they played together, Zenge was a wolf and therefore knew Lawpy wasn't. It doesn't count.

But does N=2 give me Zenge card

Ans: no he's gonna eat me next time he wolfs and I decide D1 he's village

 

[WildZoo]

lol settle down, nooblet, you don't get to claim a reading card until you correctly identify someone as more affiliations than just village.

Damn, you beat me to it

 

[Truenamer]

lol settle down, nooblet, you don't get to claim a reading card until you correctly identify someone as more affiliations than just village.

I can claim all kinds of things, nobody else has to acknowledge them though 😀

Unyeet True Yeet Barkley

I should stay on wolf hunting until I can get home and figure out whether cult or pack is biggest threat, but I think the cult would be bigger now.

Let's math this out.

Okay, the Wolves can't convert. Period. I'm deciding this, because the game is unwinnable if they can, so I'm proceeding with the assumption that they can't. (Also, hey guys, truce? Like, for just a few nights? Can we truce?)

Given the starting size of the game, we reasonably could have had 2 or 3 wolves (based on what I'm reading in forums (glad my boss can't see this)). Because there's a powerful 3P I'm inclined to guess fewer wolves, but I really have no clue and would love advice (except ALL YOUR ADVICE IS TAINTED BECAUSE I'M SURROUNDED BY WOLVES AND CULTISTS). We got one, so there are now 1 or 2 wolves remaining. (And they saved our asses, thank you fell beasts).

Okay, if the Cult Leader can convert every night, there are 1+3-1= 3 Cultists including the Leader.

There are currently 7 players left. That means that worst case scenario there could be 2 villagers left, in which case you're all laughing at this writeup in Wolfchat and Cultchat. Speaking of which, I finally got a PM! With Stoaty (big shock). Going to be really "funny" if we're the last two villagers.

Question 1: Can the Cult Leader convert wolves? We know that there's still one wolf left at least, unless the wolf kill resolved and then the last wolf was converted, but that's a headache. How does the action/ability stack work in this game?

Game scenarios moving forward for everyone's information, from best to worst:

Scenario 1: We yeet the Cult Leader and the wolves eat a Cultist; there is no conversion. 5 Players left on D5, 1-2 Wolves, 1 Cultist, 2-3 Villagers. Village has a narrow chance of winning.

Scenario 2: If there's 1 wolf left, then we could yeet a Cultist and they eat a Cultist, then the Cultists convert the last wolf. D5 there are 2 Cultists and 3 Villagers. We'd have to then exactly pick the cult leader.

Scenario 3: We yeet the last wolf, the cultists convert one of us (assuming 3 Villagers. Cultists win.

Scenarios 4-5: We yeet a villager. Doesn't matter what else happens, either wolves or cultists will inevitably win (especially if there are only 2 villagers left).

 

[SportPonies]

So I guess if there’s a cult, that means VCA is even more worthless than usual.

Please excuse me while I read the wiki* because I have forgotten the technicalities of multiple scum factions.

*in numerous hours, after I leave work

 

[SportPonies]

I want to yeet dubz again.

 

[Truenamer]

I want to yeet dubz again.

I love Dubz but her positive and helpful energy along with voting record mean nothing if she's been a cheerful, wholesome CULT LEADER this entire time 😢

 

[Truenamer]

I honestly have no idea what to do, I'm terrified and feel like I'm surrounded

Like, is it preferable to side with the wolves and try and work with them to hunt out the cult leader? But then the wolves win in most scenarios. If the cult leader dies, do the cultists revert? Do they get a new leader? How does converting wolves work?

The night there was a double kill, did that have something to do with the cult? Why would the cult need a double kill, they're already so powerful!

Maybe they can only convert every other night, and there are only two cultists right now (leader + 1 recruit)?

 

[Truenamer]

I just realized this game has been so weirdly quiet BECAUSE ALL OF YOU WERE LAUGHING IN WOLFCHAT AND CULTCHAT

ADFLAKDF;LAJSDKFJLSA