- Joined
- Aug 19, 2013
- Messages
- 59
- Reaction score
- 5
It's not just for me, it's for a lot of those people who have submitted early in the cycle and are interviewing late.
Again, they won't change their process. I've been waiting since August.
It's not just for me, it's for a lot of those people who have submitted early in the cycle and are interviewing late.
Dr. Severin assured us that no matter what time you interview n the cycle, your chances of bring accepted are the same. That's the point of the random review process. They can still accept people and have plenty of spots open for later.
I just want to add that it is in no way a random review cycle and it is very improbable that they make a decision as soon as your application is seen. If so, then why are there so many rejections are the end of the cycle, around March, as seen in previous threads. Is it by chance, year after year, that the last applications reviewed are those that they don't deem as interview worthy? If it were a true random review process, there would be as many rejections in the beginning of the cycle as there are at the end. However, this is not the case. Instead, you see a mass rejection in March. More than likely, they keep some applications on the back burner and when the end of the cycle comes, they let go of those that they might have looked at earlier in the year.
Just my two cents. I don't really see a problem with this process, but I do not believe that it is, in any way, transparent. If you want to see transparency, go to the forum for UA Phoenix Med. An admissions counselor went on throughout the cycle, answering questions, even as far as to divulge the number of interview spots left. UB is a great school and I would be more than happy to gain my medical education at this institution. However, if you look at the facts, it is not a true random review process.....despite what may be said by admissions.
mpcolon, I am not arguing that there are (limited) rejections previous to March. I have seen maybe 2 mentioned thus far in this thread. What I really do not understand is why you feel you need to come to UB's defense on these topics. You are not a current medical, nor to my knowledge were you asked to speak on behalf of their policies. People can dislike the process...and even complain about the process. The cycle is long and can be extremely frustrated. Why must you put down individuals who want to express their frustration at the very tedious time frame UB puts on some applications? This forum is available so people can converse about the process and express the very little control they may have.. If MD please does not like it, let him/her express it without comments on your behalf abut its fairness. We are adults, we what may be fair or unfair. However, we are all allowed to express frustration after 8 months of waiting (assuming since late summer) for one school to review our applications - whether the policy will be changed or not is not relevant.
Glad you have such veneration for your school. Lets hope its reciprocated by an interview.
3.26When are you interviewing?
Does anyone have any advice on preparation for this interview?
both interviews were low stress about 30 minutes each. very conversational, no really tough questions honestly. from what i saw other interviewees also had a good experience. just relax and prepare the same way you done for other interviews. best of luck
You'll be good, you belong in UB 🙂so... do the mass waves of rejections start on march 31st or is there still a waiting period for the official letter after that ?
Does this school accept updates? ( as in recent grades and a first author science publication)
I totally agree with your comments. All medical schools except UB process their applications in the order they were received and then issue interview-invitation, rejection or pre-interview hold. In doing so they reward candidates who have done their part and submitted their applications early. On the other hand UB medical school (in particular Dr. Severin) wants to reward slow and lethargic applicants who don't know how to do their part on time. To me this random review process is a façade to cover up their illogical selection process. It makes no sense that someone who applied in June/July would get no response from UB for 9 months, whereas someone who applied in October with similar credentials would get an interview in November. If Dr. Severin wants to call this process fair, someone needs to define the meaning of 'unfair' to me. (Note: mpcolon please don't respond to my post. Thanks!)I just want to add that it is in no way a random review cycle and it is very improbable that they make a decision as soon as your application is seen. If so, then why are there so many rejections are the end of the cycle, around March, as seen in previous threads. Is it by chance, year after year, that the last applications reviewed are those that they don't deem as interview worthy? If it were a true random review process, there would be as many rejections in the beginning of the cycle as there are at the end. However, this is not the case. Instead, you see a mass rejection in March. More than likely, they keep some applications on the back burner and when the end of the cycle comes, they let go of those that they might have looked at earlier in the year.
Just my two cents. I don't really see a problem with this process, but I do not believe that it is, in any way, transparent. If you want to see transparency, go to the forum for UA Phoenix Med. An admissions counselor went on throughout the cycle, answering questions, even as far as to divulge the number of interview spots left. UB is a great school and I would be more than happy to gain my medical education at this institution. However, if you look at the facts, it is not a true random review process.....despite what may be said by admissions.
Yes, this is exactly what I was told by Mr. Rosso.I believe only once you've been invited to interview.
I would like to hear the logic for rewarding applicants who fail to submit their application early. Also, what data is there to support that those who are slow to turn their applications in would become great doctors?Just because it is a different logic from what you prefer doesn't make it ILlogical. So UB doesn't view how quickly you submit your application as an indicaton of how good a doctor you will become. So what?
It's more illogical in my opinion to complain about an aspect of their application process that was made very clear from the beginning.
I'm still waiting to hear back from UB, btw. So I do understand the anxiety that comes along with this process. But I knew - and was okay with - what I was signing up for.
I would like to hear the logic for rewarding applicants who fail to submit their application early. Also, what data is there to support that those who are slow to turn their applications in would become great doctors?
The problem me and others like me face is that we have a few acceptances from other medical schools and would like to make decision where to go at least a few month in advance. When UB doesn't respond to your application for 9 months, you start considering it as a silent rejection and start planning to attend another school because you need time to arrange housing, financial aid etc.I agree with justwhy. It is *extremely* frustrating to wait but in the end, whether it is done the regular way or the random way, medical schools will only invite applicants they believed are qualified. Whether you were interviewed early or late, Dr. Severin has emphasized that everyone has a shot and nobody is interviewing for waitlist. So if your stats are competitive and Buffalo likes your application, you should hear from them before the interview season is over and your chances are still good for getting an acceptance. Sucks to wait but they were really up front with it from the start.
No one is claiming that they are better, but they would certainly carryout their responsibilities on a timely manner.What data is there to support that those who are fast to turn in their applications are better?
The problem me and others like me face is that we have a few acceptances from other medical schools and would like to make decision where to go at least a few month in advance. When UB doesn't respond to your application for 9 months, you start considering it as a silent rejection and start planning to attend another because you need time to arrange housing, financial aid etc.
No one is claiming that they are better, but they would certainly carryout their responsibilities on a timely manner.
Knowing about it doesn't make the process fair. Since this a forum, just like you I have a right to express my opinion. Good luck to you.That's understandable (I'm in the same boat), but we knew going into this that this was their process and that there was a chance we may not hear back until April. (At least, I knew this was their process, and therefore I don't really care - I know I'll hear back eventually. I find it surprising when people don't know the app process of schools they're applying to...) So, yeah it may not be ideal but it's just something you deal with.
No one is claiming that they are better, but they would certainly carryout their responsibilities on a timely manner.
There is no excuse for sloppy work, those applicants will face the consequence. As far as I know most of the early applicants planned and prepared their application well in advance, such as, taking MCAT, getting LOR, preparing primary and secondary essays, sending their transcripts. This can only be done by well organized individuals. No matter what profession such individual go to, they will succeed.Or rush to turn in sloppy work, as I've seen many fellow applicants do. This 'debate' can be spun in any way you want...
mpcolon I requested you not to respond to my post, but knowing you that was too much to ask. So far I have received 12 interview invitations and the last 4 of them I have declined. I already have 4 acceptances and I am on waiting-list at three other schools. At this late in the admission process do you think I care whether UB invites me for interview or not. The reason I complain about the UB's random process because in my opinion it is unfair and illogical. I know a number of fellow students from Buffalo area who have decided to attend other schools instead of waiting for UB's random process to work for them. Even though you are sure that I will be rejected by UB, I wish you otherwise. Good luck to you. Hope you get your interview invitation soon.Are we really arguing this? LOL...human101 is just bitter because he didn't receive an invitation to interview. Chances are, he'll be rejected. Secondly, I find it cowardly to complain about things behind a computer screen when no one knows your identity. At least with me, people know my identity and can look me up. If I have a complaint, there is no anonymity.
jab1990, who are you to judge others? Being a Buffalo native and UB graduate I have a vested interest in seeing UB med school admits qualified local residents of Buffalo and UB undergrads in a timely fashion so that they don't have to leave the area. We need more of our young residents to stay in the area rather than leave. Hope you understand that.So if you don't like it then don't waste your time here, if you haven't noticed his process isnt fair for the most part. it is what it is. Stop all these damn arguments they are just pathetic at this point. Hey if the random review is unfair, well the 1 week turn around is as fair as it gets..they dont jerk you around for 2-3 months in limbo. You obviously will go to one of the 4 schools that accepted you. gl buddy!
I'm going to chime in to this argument just because I have a strong opinion. I have no issue with the UB process, as an above poster mentioned knowing what we're signing up for. Some get lucky with the draw and some may feel screwed. I'm sure there are reasons and it has worked to their satisfaction. FYI, I am one of those people who applied on day 1 and has yet to be reviewed (apparently).Not everyone seeking acceptance to medical school is straight out of undergrad, with the ability to devote 100% of their time to the application process. In fact, I think that the above discussion underscores a larger issue. Why are some aspiring doctors, individuals striving to enter an altruistic profession, seemingly so narrow-minded? Each applicant is unique, as will be every future patient that you encounter. With diversity comes imperfection. Say your patient is an overweight, 45 year-old male with high blood pressure who just doesn't seem to be following your advice on diet and exercise. Will you employ a similarly judgmental approach with this man, imploring as to how he could possibly be so careless with himself and callously warning of the consequences? Or, will you take a moment to consider the situation from his standpoint and simply ask, "why?". Perhaps he is a stress eater or is depressed, and could benefit from therapy, or maybe he is unsure of how to go about changing his lifestyle, and needs the help of a nutritionist, or, perhaps, your patient has been following your advice but is not losing weight or lowering his blood pressure because of an undiagnosed, potentially serious medical condition. Since you have been accepted into medical school, a major accomplishment in and of itself, I would ask you to never forget the value of perspective–in medicine and in life.
I'm going to chime in to this argument just because I have a strong opinion. I have no issue with the UB process, as an above poster mentioned knowing what we're signing up for. Some get lucky with the draw and some may feel screwed. I'm sure there are reasons and it has worked to their satisfaction. FYI, I am one of those people who applied on day 1 and has yet to be reviewed.
Applying to medical school is not something that should be half-assed, though I sympathize with those who have obstacles in the way. You can talk about "imperfection" and "altruism" all you want, but a big part of being a doctor is professionalism... and a big part of that is timeliness. If one is not able to apply on time, they should suffer consequences.
People should not expect acceptance to medical school if they have a late or sloppy application -- there will be 100 people who had the foresight to understand how to approach the cycle (and enter at the proper time with their stuff together). Not being straight out of undergrad gives one less of an excuse to have a late application.
To end on a nice note... I hope we all hear back in our favor soon!😀
If a complain comes up every two weeks then there must be some validity in it. The 'random review' process is unique to UB med school. No other med school or even other professional schools in UB (management, pharmacy, engineering, law) have such a process. As applicants we don't have any leverage to even complain about it to the admission office. Thus, we can only vent our frustration at this forum. As a med student at UB you may be able at least convey our complain. Sorry if our complains offend you and others. We greatly appreciate the help you and others like you provide to prospective students. Please continue the good work.This complaint comes up every two weeks or so, and makes it hard to stay up to date on this thread.
I sent Mr. Rosso an email inquiring about whether or not that April 1st deadline was true and this is the response:
Hi Michael,
The Screening Committee must be completed by April 1st so we can invite those candidates that the Committee wants to invite for the month of April. Our last interview session is at the end of April.
Our Freshman Medical Class is not completely filled. We currently have 119 candidates in the class of 140, and it does change due to turnover. Candidates who are interviewed in April have as good a chance of being accepted as a candidate interviewed last October. I hope this clarifies things a little. Best regards.
Mr. Rosso
I hope this helps everyone! I know we are all anxious, believe me, every day I check my email 30 times AND I'm on the status check website every hr., so believe me, I get it. I invested everything into UB and I want this too, but I think part of the reason for this frustration and arguing is the panic. We know the list of spots are dwindling and for some of us, this is our last chance to get into medical school this year. But, ladies and gentlemen, it's not over, they have spots, and I say, let's all take them at their word and believe them when they say they'll get to all of us. They'll read all of our applications and there are spots for which we all can interview for!
BTW...It is 8:04 a.m. in Buffalo and still no snow? I thought another Blizzard was coming! LOL
Someone having a different opinion (on random review process) from yours gets branded as "narrow-minded". If this is your open-minded behavior, I rather be called narrow-mindedWhy are some aspiring doctors, individuals striving to enter an altruistic profession, seemingly so narrow-minded?
.
Someone having a different opinion (on random review process) from yours gets branded as "narrow-minded". If this is your open-minded behavior, I rather be called narrow-minded
There is no excuse for sloppy work, those applicants will face the consequence.
If a complain comes up every two weeks then there must be some validity in it.
It is past the point of frustration and is being detrimental to this forum since every post is an argument back and forth between different views. You could vent to your friends instead, as they will be more sympathetic than people here. I think the longer you stay arguing with people, the more bitter you will become.we can only vent our frustration at this forum
starkidbee said: ↑It is not that you have a different opinion.
(There is no excuse for sloppy work, those applicants will face the consequence)
That's pretty brutal. If you can't think of other reasons why people might submit later (professors tardy with LOR, sudden issues, non-trad, full time work, etc.). I hope that you keep your mind open to possibilities when treating patients instead of generalizing so broadly. You are pretty successful in your cycle, so this bitterness towards fellow applicants and the school is surprising. This is a long, complicated, stressful cycle as you know and have been making it very clear here. It takes some stroke of luck to have everything lined up properly by day one.
.