You might be right, but I know a lot of competitive instate applicants who are applying to Utah. My friend last year (instate) had a 525, 3.98 and was applying to Utah because he loves it. I wouldn’t guess that a lot of OOS students would still apply to Utah with those kind of stats because they honestly would probably have a better shot of getting in at Michigan or Vandy (or anywhere else that focuses on high stats) than they would Utah (due to Utah’s heavy in-state bias).
One of my in-state friends has already interviewed at Columbia and I’ve already interviewed at Mayo. Both of us applied and have interviewed at Utah. I don’t say that to boast of myself because frankly, ya’ll don’t know my real identity so it doesn’t matter anyway. The fact of the matter is that many of the students in the instate group are competitive despite us having an easier road to the II at Utah than OOS students. That’s not to say that the OOS pool isn’t crazy awesome—I’m sure they are super competitive. I just think more equal than was initially assumed.